Former Athlete Critiques Judge's Legacy
Tiki Barber didn't mince words when discussing Aaron Judge's place in New York sports lore. The former Giants running back, now a WFAN talk show host, said that in the end, Aaron Judge's MVPs, Home Run records, and mind-blowing numbers won't matter.
Barber said Judge will not be considered an elite Yankee until he wins the World Series.
© John Jones-Imagn Images
'For Aaron Judge to be an elite Yankee, he needs to keep doing what he's doing, maybe win some more MVPs, and most important — because there are 27 that preceded him — he has to win a championship,' Barber said.
Advertisement
Judge, a two-time AL MVP and the Yankees' captain, has been a powerhouse at the plate, boasting a .414 batting average with 11 home runs and 33 RBIs so far this season. However, despite his individual success, the Yankees have not won a World Series since 2009, marking their longest championship drought since the 1980s.
Despite his regular-season dominance, Aaron Judge has struggled in October, batting just .211 with 15 home runs and 74 strikeouts in 54 career playoff games.
Barber contrasted Judge's situation with that of Knicks star Jalen Brunson, who has led the Knicks to playoff victories, including a recent win over the Boston Celtics in the second round of the NBA playoffs.
Brunson's postseason performances have elevated his status among New York athletes.
Advertisement
Ironically, Barber knows this first-hand.
Tiki Barber spent 10 seasons as a running back with the New York Giants, becoming the franchise's all-time leading rusher with 10,449 yards before retiring in 2006. He never won a Super Bowl.
Related: Former Red Sox All-Star Calls Aaron Judge a 'Regular Season Player'
Related: Could the Yankees Trade A Former MVP For Rotation Help?
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Newsweek
28 minutes ago
- Newsweek
Three Realistic Trade Targets for Chicago Cubs to Strike Before Window Closes
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. Chicago Cubs fans have the feeling that this season may turn into the 2016 season all over again. Chicago sits in first place in the NL Central, off to its best start since 2016, when the Cubs eventually won the World Series. Despite the outstanding start, Chicago still has a few holes in its roster that will need to be addressed at the trade deadline. Team president Jed Hoyer has hinted that the Cubs will be focused on pitching help at the trade deadline. If that is indeed the route Chicago's front office takes, here are three potential trade deadline targets. NEW YORK, NY - JUNE 7: Aroldis Chapman #44 of the Boston Red Sox pitches during the ninth inning against the New York Yankees at Yankee Stadium on June 7, 2025 in New York City.... NEW YORK, NY - JUNE 7: Aroldis Chapman #44 of the Boston Red Sox pitches during the ninth inning against the New York Yankees at Yankee Stadium on June 7, 2025 in New York City. The Red Sox won 10-7 MoreAroldis Chapman, Boston Red Sox Chapman was a member of the Cubs' 2016 World Series team and his addition to the backend of the bullpen would be more than welcome. At 37 years old, Chapman's 99.1 mph average fastball velocity ranks in the 98th percentile, making him still one of the game's best late-inning relievers. His 11 saves and 37 strikeouts across 27 1/3 innings pitched is eye-opening and he would give the Cubs a much-needed high velocity left-handed pitcher in the bullpen. Chris Sale, Atlanta Braves Sale is not a name that would've been thought of at the beginning of the season, but he has now become an intriguing option due to the struggles from the Atlanta Braves. After a shaky start to the season, Sale has bounced back and has a 2.79 ERA with 107 strikeouts across 80 2/3 innings pitched. According to Baseball Savant, Sale ranks in the 94th percentile in chase rate at 34.5% and the 92nd percentile in strikeout rate at 31.7%. Chicago's pitching staff has the seventh-fewest number of strikeouts, so the punchout ability and stuff that Sale has would be an excellent addition. Sandy Alcantara, Miami Marlins Prior to the season, Alcantara was expected to be one of the most highly coveted trade targets, but a horrendous first half of the season may have changed that. He is 2-7 with a 7.89 ERA and just 44 strikeouts in 57 innings pitched. What many hoped to be a promising return from injury has very quickly gone sideways. A change of scenery could make all the difference in the world for Alcantara and going from an uncompetitive Marlins team to a World Series contending Cubs team could get him back on track and looking like the pitcher he was two seasons ago when he was awarded the NL Cy Young. More MLB: Preseason Projected World Series Contender in Serious Jeopardy of Missing Postseason
San Francisco Chronicle
an hour ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
Chicago, Connecticut and Dallas are still trying to find their way during early part of WNBA season
Through the first 20% of the WNBA season there are a bunch of teams that have struggled out of the gate. The Chicago Sky, Connecticut Sun and Dallas Wings have combined for five victories so far. The Wings' lone victory came over the Sun while the Sky have beaten the Wings twice. Connecticut has the best two victories in the WNBA so far this season, topping Indiana and Atlanta, but also suffered the second-biggest blowout in league history in a 48-point loss to New York. All three teams have new coaches and are experiencing the learning curve of new systems. The Wings also have been missing No. 1 draft pick Paige Bueckers for their last few games while she dealt first with a concussion and then an illness. She should be back soon. The Sky just suffered their own injury setback, with veteran guard Courtney Vandersloot going down for the season with an ACL tear in her right knee. The injury occurred Saturday night during their game against the Fever. It's a major blow to the Sky, who now need to find a point guard to fill in for Vandersloot. The 36-year-old had returned to Chicago this season after helping New York win its first WNBA championship last year. The Liberty are on the other end of the spectrum, picking up right where they left off after winning the title. New York hasn't lost yet this season and is one of two undefeated teams along with WNBA Finals runner-up Minnesota. Power poll rankings New York led the way as the No. 1 team in the power poll again this week. Minnesota was still right behind in second. The national voting panel chose Seattle third, Phoenix fourth and Atlanta fifth. Indiana was sixth with Las Vegas seventh. Golden State, Washington and Los Angeles were the next three. Chicago, Connecticut and Dallas rounded out the poll. Calling it a career Allie Quigley announced in The Players Tribune on Tuesday that she's officially retiring after not playing since 2021. Quigley, who played in the WNBA for 14 seasons after getting drafted by Seattle in 2008, was a four-time 3-point champion at All-Star weekend. Player of the week Napheesa Collier of Minnesota earned Player of the Week honors for the third time this season. The Lynx forward averaged 23 points, 10.5 rebounds and 4.5 assists to help the team win both its game and stay undefeated. Other players receiving consideration were Kelsey Mitchell of Indiana, Satou Sabally of Phoenix, Breanna Stewart of New York and Gabby Williams of Seattle. Game of the week New York at Indiana, Saturday. The Eastern Conference representative in the Commissioner's Cup could come down to this game. The two teams met earlier in the season and the Liberty had to rally for the victory. It also could mark the return of star Indiana guard Caitlin Clark, who has been sidelined with a left quad strain the last few weeks. ___
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
NBA trade rumors: The latest on the Knicks coaching search, Kevin Durant and Giannis Antetokounmpo
Sure, the NBA Finals are in full swing, but fans of the 28 other NBA teams have one thing on their minds: the offseason. Known for big trades and drama, the NBA offseason has found ways to dominate the sports news cycle in times when basketball should be the last thing on anyone's mind. This offseason promises to be similar. Future Hall of Famers like Kevin Durant and Giannis Antetokounmpo are expected to be available on the trade market, and one of the league's premier franchises — the New York Knicks — are searching for a new coach. Advertisement Where do all those stories stand with the Finals underway? Yahoo Sports has you covered with all the biggest NBA rumors below. Knicks, Jason Kidd still in limbo The Knicks may have narrowed down their coaching search to their top candidate, but there's a problem: He's already taken. The Knicks are reportedly interested in Dallas Mavericks coach Jason Kidd, but New York has yet to ask the Mavericks for permission to talk to the coach. The Knicks like the idea for a few reasons, per Marc Stein. The franchise is familiar with Kidd after he spent the final year of his playing career with the Knicks. The team also believes Kidd could handle the media pressure and spotlight that comes with being in New York. Kidd also has familiarity with Knicks star Jalen Brunson. Advertisement But in order to hire Kidd, the team needs to formally ask the Mavericks to speak with the coach. It's unclear whether the Knicks will do that. Some in the Mavericks' organization believe the Knicks will not ask the team for permission to speak to Kidd, per Stein. It's possible that's because the Knicks believe they will get shut down by the Mavericks, forcing them to look elsewhere for a new head coach. The team finds itself in a strange spot after the surprising firing of Tom Thibodeau last week. Thibodeau posted a .565 winning percentage in five seasons with the Knicks and just took the team to the Eastern Conference finals. Given the strong personalities in the Knicks' front office, the team could have multiple ideas on how to replace Thibodeau, per Stein, so losing out on Kidd might not be a huge barrier for the franchise. Kevin Durant to the Knicks? The Knicks could have an easy time bringing in a new coach, especially if the club acquires Phoenix Suns star Kevin Durant. The Suns are expected to deal Durant after the team struggled despite bringing in elite talent last offseason. Advertisement While a number of teams — including the Houston Rockets, Miami Heat and San Antonio Spurs — have been mentioned as suitors for Durant, the Knicks continue to be one of the teams consistently mentioned in rumors for the superstar. ESPN's Shams Charania mentioned New York as a suitor for Durant in April, and his colleague, ESPN's Brian Windhorst, brought up that possibility Tuesday. The Suns may have struggled last season, but it wasn't due to Durant. The 36-year-old showed little sign of decline, averaging 26.6 points and six rebounds over 62 games in Phoenix. That should make Durant a popular trade target for a number of teams. It certainly sounds like the Knicks want to remain in that mix. Giannis Antetokounmpo could stay put in Milwaukee. (Photo by) (Justin Casterline via Getty Images) Giannis Antetokounmpo won't be traded? There is apparently no trade market for Milwaukee Bucks star Giannis Antetokounmpo right now, per Windhorst. Advertisement Antetokounmpo has not asked the team for a trade, and the Bucks reportedly aren't looking to deal their star. Given how quickly the NBA offseason shifts, that could change. The Bucks have plenty of incentive to deal their superstar now. Milwaukee was once again eliminated early in the playoffs, and the Bucks are in rough shape following Damian Lillard's injury and the team's lack of control over its future first-round picks. Antetokounmpo should bring in quite the haul if he gets dealt. The 30-year-old averaged 30.4 points and 11.9 rebounds for Milwaukee last season, and is under contract through the 2027-28 NBA season. Expect a lot of NBA offseason action soon While rumors are quiet at the moment, things could pick up relatively soon. Windhorst teased the NBA offseason could move faster than normal during an appearance on "First Take" on Tuesday. Advertisement Windhorst mentioned Charania has "cleared his calendar" ahead of the 2025 NBA Draft, which will take place June 25. Windhorst teased, "You're gonna get your action very soon." That action should come once the NBA Finals conclude. If the series goes a full seven games, that would happen June 22, just days before the NBA Draft. It could make for a hectic draft season.
