Not all screen time is equal: Wrestling with a YouTube ban for kids
Early on in my parenting journey a girlfriend sent a post that said, 'To say all screen time is the same is like saying all paper time is the same.' Or like saying that reading this masthead is the same quality of paper time as reading New Idea or opening a utility bill, or reading philosophy or folding origami.
It is obvious how ridiculous that argument is. Surely an 11-year-old reading The Day My Butt Exploded is not the same quality of paper time as reading Harry Potter. It is the same for screen time. Not all screen time is equal.
Psychologists and parenting experts have used analogies galore to explain this to parents, schools and governments. Like the nutritional pyramid, Jocelyn Brewer refers to 'Digital Nutrition' with the 'good screen time' at the bottom, where wholegrains are and the 'sometimes screen time' at the top with lollies and chocolate.
While YouTube does have some educational videos and helpful 'instructionals', it also has a lot of toxic video content. I'm talking about misogynistic content, violent content and young people doing really stupid stuff that our kids then try to replicate, and I mean more stupid than the Mentos in the Diet Coke bottle.
I am sceptical about the social media ban for under-16s, not because I am a great fan of social media for kids, but because I'm not confident it will work. If kids under 16 have figured out how to bypass Lime Bike rentals, you don't think they'll figure out how to use social media?
Loading
But if we are moving forward with a social media ban, and it looks like we are, then there are some things that will make it work. The first is Australian parents getting behind it. Prime Minister Anthony Albanese said the ban was designed so parents could say to their children social media is 'against the law'. That only works if we as parents don't succumb to the wiles of our children. Don't budge if Jonny or Susie are using it. Hold the line.
Currently, YouTube has been exempted from the ban. But the eSafety Commissioner, Julie Inman Grant, wants to change that.
Frankly, it would be farcical to ban social media but allow YouTube for under-16s. While it doesn't have the 'social' elements of other sites, it has the same dangerous content and misinformation. It would be like banning fast food but keeping McDonalds. To say that YouTube is somehow a better use of screen time than other social media apps such as Snapchat, TikTok or Instagram is nuts. So good on Inman Grant for pointing that out.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
an hour ago
- ABC News
Why Albo is under pressure to meet Trump
As the deadline for Donald Trump's so-called reciprocal tariffs looms, Anthony Albanese has reiterated his call that US tariffs on Australia should be "zero." It comes as Penny Wong jets to Washington to meet with her US counterpart, and pressure mounts on the PM to meet with the US President. And 1.5 million Australians are part of the 'sandwich generation', but what does that actually mean? ABC Radio Melbourne mornings host Raf Epstein discusses the impact of the "care squeeze" on Australian families, and what levers governments can pull. Patricia Karvelas and Raf Epstein, ABC Radio Melbourne Mornings Host break it all down on Politics Now. Got a burning question? Got a burning political query? Send a short voice recording to PK and Fran for Question Time at thepartyroom@
Sky News AU
2 hours ago
- Sky News AU
eSafety Commissioner Julie Inman Grant sits on research underpinning demands for YouTube ban under social media laws
The powerful bureaucrat lobbying for Labor to ban kids from YouTube has refused to hand over research she claims underpins her recommendation. eSafety Commissioner Julie Inman Grant recently argued that children should be banned from the video streaming platform in her speech to the National Press Club. Ms Inman Grant claimed she had written to Communications Minister Anika Wells encouraging children be banned from YouTube because of the evidence. 'I don't make determinations or write recommendations to the minister based on whether I keep the public onside, I follow the evidence,' she said last Tuesday. However, can reveal that Ms Inman Grant is refusing to publicly release the full research. Ms Inman Grant and her office have also refused to send the research to YouTube, leaving the streaming platform unable to fact-check or dispute claims which have been sent to the minister. If Ms Inman Grant's lobbying is successful, YouTube will be restricted by sweeping new legislative changes without having an opportunity to provide a counter argument. A decision is expected to be made by Labor in the coming weeks. An eSafety spokesperson claimed that they had 'responded' to stakeholder requests but acknowledged they have not published the full findings from their research. When asked to provide the research in the interest of transparency, the regulator declined, and instead said the findings would be drip fed to the public in 'stages'. 'The data referenced in the Commissioner's National Press Club speech last week represented a subset of a broader study,' the spokesperson said. 'eSafety is publishing the results of this research in stages as part of its Keeping Kids Safe Online series.' The office of the Communication Minister told that Ms Wells was 'carefully considering' the advice and would consult with stakeholders. Ms Inman Grant's lobbying efforts put her at odds with the Albanese government, which previously ruled that YouTube would not be captured by the ban. Prime Minister Anthony Albanese confirmed in November, 2024, that YouTube would be exempted from the ban given its 'education and health support' content. The government's own research at the time found parents believed YouTube was suitable for young people. According to those findings, 85 per cent of children and around 70 per cent of parents considered YouTube appropriate for those aged 15 and under. YouTube, which has previously warned that including the platform in the ban would jeopardise access to children's content, has hit back at Ms Inman Grant's claims. Rachel Lord, Public Policy Manager for YouTube Australia & New Zealand said YouTube's exemption was grounded in extensive research. 'Today's position from the eSafety Commissioner represents inconsistent and contradictory advice,' Ms Lord said on Tuesday. 'We urge the government to follow through on the public commitment it made to ensure young Australians can continue to access enriching content on YouTube.' Children's entertainers, including The Wiggles and Bounce Patrol, have also previously lobbied against YouTube's inclusion in the ban. The beloved children's entertainers argued it would limit safe content for families and harm the future of local kids' programming. The office of the Communications Minister said that Ms Wells' priority was to protect children. 'The minister's top priority is making sure the draft rules fulfil the objective of the act and protect children from the harms of social media,' Ms Wells' spokesperson said. 'The law places the onus on social media platforms – not parents or young people – to take reasonable steps to ensure protections are in place. 'The Albanese government knows our world-leading social media delay will not be a cure-all for the harms experienced by young people online but is an unprecedented step in the right direction.' The social media ban for under 16s will come into effect from December, 2025.
SBS Australia
2 hours ago
- SBS Australia
SBS News In Easy English 30 June 2025
Welcome to SBS News In Easy English. I'm Catriona Stirrat. Anthony Albanese says Australia will not increase defence spending next April as part of the national defence strategy, after calls from the US to increase the defence budget. This comes as Foreign Minister Penny Wong heads to the United States for high level discussions with counterpart Marco Rubio ahead of a meeting of Quad leaders. The US has been calling for Australia to lift its defence spending to 3.5 per cent of GDP. The Trump administration also announced this month that it would take a 30-day review of the AUKUS agreement, which will see Australia purchase US nuclear submarines. Mr Albanese says the government is engaging with the US on the matter. "Every opportunity, Australia, raises our points that we have and AUKUS benefits three countries; Australia, the UK and the US. But it does something more than that, as well, it benefits the world, because it makes our region and the world, more secure." Penny Wong is also expected to discuss tariffs during her visit to the US. From July 1 Australians will have greater access to paid parental leave, the minimum wage will go up and millions will see an increase in their Centrelink payments. Australia's lowest-paid workers will receive a pay increase, with the national minimum wage increasing by 3.5 per cent. Millions will also see an increase to Centrelink payments, with a 2.4 per cent increase to help ease the rising cost of living. Australian families will benefit from a more generous paid parental leave scheme, with the amount of government-funded leave increasing from 20 to 22 weeks. Speaking on Nine's Today Show, Finance Minister Katy Gallagher says the expected changes will ease pressure on Australians. "We're not pretending that people aren't still continuing to do it pretty tough, which is why there's a whole range of support that comes in on the first of July. So it is about increasing the minimum wage and increase in super but there's also increases in payments that come from the government. There's increase in PPL, and we're paying super on PPL. There's a whole range of areas where we're providing additional assistance, there's the energy bill rebates come in." Authorities across multiple European countries are urging people to take shelter as wildfires and a punishing heatwave hit the region. Fires broke out in France and Turkiye over the weekend, with this summer's first major heatwave in Europe leaving others on high alert. Ambulances are standing by tourist sites as experts warn that such heatwaves, intensified by climate change, will only get worse. Attending the UN Development Summit in Spain, Nabeeha Kazi says it's very clear that climate action is needed. 'The heat is incredible, no doubt about it. We are navigating it. We´ve been in a lot of indoor places. You know it is unfortunate that climate change is what it is. I don´t think they anticipated it will be this hot this year but we are here for an important mission which is about how we ensure that we are supporting countries that are also affected by climate change.' Nurses in Queensland are threatening industrial action after the state nurses union issued a pay deal ultimatum to the state government. The Queensland Nurses and Midwives' Union is calling for a 13 per cent pay rise over three years, while the state government is offering an 8 per cent rise. While voting to take protected strike action earlier in June, Queensland nurses have not walked off the job since 2022. Union secretary Sarah Beaman says the state health minister has until Tuesday to agree to the union's terms or they will escalate to stage two protected industrial action in early July. Aldrich Potgieter has ended the protracted Rocket Classic, making an 18-foot birdie putt on the fifth playoff hole to outlast Max Greyserman for his first PGA Tour title. He celebrated on Sunday by embracing his caddie and shaking hands with Greyserman and his caddie before giving his father, Heinrich, a hug. The 20-year-old Potgieter is the youngest player on the tour and its biggest hitter, averaging 326-plus yards off the tee. That was SBS News In Easy English. I'm Catriona Stirrat.
