Meta fends off authors' US copyright lawsuit over AI
The judge said the authors had not presented enough evidence that Meta's AI would dilute the market for their work. PHOTO: REUTERS
SAN FRANCISCO - A federal judge ruled on June 25 for Meta Platforms against a group of authors who had argued that its use of their books without permission to train its artificial intelligence system infringed their copyrights.
US District Judge Vince Chhabria, in San Francisco, said in his decision that the authors had not presented enough evidence that Meta's AI would dilute the market for their work to show that the company's conduct was illegal under US copyright law.
Mr Chhabria also said, however, that using copyrighted work without permission to train AI would be unlawful in 'many circumstances', splitting with another federal judge in San Francisco who found on June 23 in a separate lawsuit that Anthropic's AI training made 'fair use' of copyrighted materials.
'This ruling does not stand for the proposition that Meta's use of copyrighted materials to train its language models is lawful,' Mr Chhabria said.
'It stands only for the proposition that these plaintiffs made the wrong arguments and failed to develop a record in support of the right one.'
A spokesperson for the authors' law firm Boies Schiller Flexner said that it disagreed with the judge's decision to rule for Meta despite the 'undisputed record' of the company's 'historically unprecedented pirating of copyrighted works'.
A Meta spokesperson said the company appreciated the decision and called fair use a 'vital legal framework' for building 'transformative' AI technology.
The authors sued Meta in 2023, arguing the company misused pirated versions of their books to train its AI system Llama without permission or compensation.
The lawsuit is one of several copyright cases brought by writers, news outlets and other copyright owners against companies including OpenAI, Microsoft and Anthropic over their AI training.
The legal doctrine of fair use allows the use of copyrighted works without the copyright owner's permission in some circumstances. It is a key defence for the tech companies.
Mr Chhabria's decision is the second in the US to address fair use in the context of generative AI, following US District Judge William Alsup's ruling in the Anthropic case.
AI companies argue their systems make fair use of copyrighted material by studying it to learn to create new, transformative content, and that being forced to pay copyright holders for their work could hamstring the burgeoning AI industry.
Copyright owners say AI companies unlawfully copy their work to generate competing content that threatens their livelihoods. Mr Chhabria expressed sympathy for that argument during a hearing in May, which he reiterated on June 25.
The judge said generative AI had the potential to flood the market with endless images, songs, articles and books using a tiny fraction of the time and creativity that would otherwise be required to create them.
'So by training generative AI models with copyrighted works, companies are creating something that often will dramatically undermine the market for those works, and thus dramatically undermine the incentive for human beings to create things the old-fashioned way,' Mr Chhabria said. REUTERS
Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
39 minutes ago
- Straits Times
Tax-free sales at department stores drop in Japan as foreign tourists curb spending
In the hopes of drawing back foreign customers, department stores are taking targeted measures. PHOTO: REUTERS TOKYO - Visitors to Japan have been key customers for department stores, but now they are tightening the purse strings. Foreign visitors spent about 42.5 billion yen (S$374.4 million) at department stores nationwide in May, down by a massive 40.8 per cent from the same month in 2024, the Japan Department Stores Association announced on June 24. Department stores will try to adapt, such as by offering an app exclusively for overseas customers, but it remains uncertain whether sales will rebound. May 2025 was the third straight month for tax-free sales to fall from 2024. The number of foreign shoppers fell 5.4 per cent year on year, to about 536,000, dropping below the previous year's level for the first time in three years and two months. With sales for luxury brands and other high-priced items sluggish, average purchases per individual dropped by 37.4 per cent, to about 79,000 yen. Foreign visitors are believed to have found shopping in Japan less of a bargain after the recent rise in the yen and price hikes by high-end brands, which were prompted by a surge in raw material costs. Some also argue that Chinese tourists went on fewer shopping sprees due to the slowdown in the Chinese economy. From January to March, visitors to Japan spent about 222,000 yen on average, up 5.2 per cent from the same period in 2024, according to a survey by the Japan Tourism Agency. That suggests that overall consumption by foreign tourists has not declined. However, during that quarter, Chinese visitors spent significantly less on total purchases, with the average dropping by 13.7 per cent to 256,000 yen. 'The decline in the average spending per Chinese customer is particularly noticeable. Inbound tourists are diversifying their spending, and they are changing the types of shopping that they value,' said Mr Yoshiharu Nishisaka, managing director of the department stores association. In the hopes of drawing back foreign customers, department stores are taking targeted measures. Isetan Mitsukoshi Holdings Ltd launched an app for overseas customers in March. At its stores, the company encourages visitors to Japan to sign up for the app, offering discount coupons in return. Takashimaya Co issues VIP membership cards to its top customers at its Singapore store. The cards grant priority treatment when buying tax-free at branches in Japan, a perk meant to encourage them to visit. In April, the Daimaru Umeda department store began stocking plastic models and other items related to the Mobile Suit Gundam anime series. 'Japanese content such as anime is enormously popular overseas, and many customers visit us for these sorts of items,' said an employee from parent company J. Front Retailing Co. 'The real question for department stores is how to get foreign customers to stop in,' said senior researcher Naoko Kuga at the NLI Research Institute. 'They need to have a steady outreach to overseas customers.' THE JAPAN NEWS/ASIA NEWS NETWORK Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
CNA
3 hours ago
- CNA
Meta hires three OpenAI researchers, WSJ reports
Meta Chief Executive Mark Zuckerberg has hired three OpenAI researchers to join his superintelligence efforts, the Wall Street Journal reported on Wednesday, citing people familiar with the matter. The company hired Lucas Beyer, Alexander Kolesnikov and Xiaohua Zhai, who were all working in OpenAI's Zurich office, the report said.
Business Times
4 hours ago
- Business Times
Vietnam PM expects US trade deal before July tariff deadline
[HANOI] Vietnamese Prime Minister Pham Minh Chinh said on Wednesday he expected a trade deal with the United States before the expiration of a pause on 46 per cent reciprocal tariffs on Vietnamese exports in early July. Speaking at the 'Is Asia's Century at Risk?' panel during the ongoing World Economic Forum in Tianjin, in northeastern China, Chinh said Vietnam's government was in frequent communication with the Trump administration on tariffs. 'I hope that you will see that the result will come earlier than two weeks,' Chinh said. 'Vietnam and the US share a deep understanding on tariffs... I hope that all the positive things will come for us.' Vietnam, a major manufacturing hub in Southeast Asia, has held several rounds of negotiations with the US, the latest of which concluded last week. The country seeks to avoid the reinstatement of a 46 per cent tariff rate, initially imposed due to its substantial trade surplus with Washington. Reuters reported that the US submitted a list of trade demands to Hanoi, which Vietnamese officials described as 'tough', and was also pushing Vietnam to reduce the use of Chinese tech in devices that are assembled in the country before being exported to America. Vietnam's trade surplus with the United States climbed to US$12.2 billion in May, marking a nearly 42 per cent increase year-on-year and a 17 per cent rise from April, according to government data. Exports to the US surged 42 per cent from a year earlier to US$13.8 billion, hitting a post-pandemic peak. Under pressure from Washington, Hanoi has intensified efforts to curb illegal trans-shipment, predominantly involving goods from China. Additionally, Vietnam has expressed willingness to reduce non-tariff barriers and expand imports of US goods, including planes, agricultural products and energy, though no formal purchase agreements have been announced. REUTERS
