North Dakota Joins Growing League of States Requiring Age Verification for Porn
Moral panic laws have popped up across the United States in the 2025 legislative season. Recently, North Dakota joined the growing league of states requiring age verification for porn. But critics warn that North Dakota's regulations, which won't go into effect until August 1, are another shining example of First Amendment violations.
Last month, North Dakota Governor Kelly Armstrong (R) signed Senate Bill 2380 and House Bill 1561 which both introduced age verification requirements for websites containing a 'substantial portion' of 'sexual material harmful to a minor on the internet'. These sites must use 'reasonable' methods, like a digitized identification card or having someone submit a government-issued ID. If a website fails to comply with age verification or deletes data, it can be held liable for damages.
What counts as porn is wide under the new regulations. Obviously, actual depictions of sexual intercourse, masturbation, etc, are covered. However, the bill also extends to simulated or animated acts, and it includes depiction of pubic hair, genitals, and the nipple of a female breast, specifically. Beyond that, North Dakota's legislation is aimed at material that 'lacks serious literary, artistic, political, or scientific value' and that which the 'average individual applying contemporary community standards' would consider as appealing to the 'prurient interest'.
According to the Age Verification Providers Association, over twenty states have passed age verification laws to access pornography. Recently, a woman from Kansas used her state's law to sue multiple porn websites after her teenage son watched porn on her old laptop. Of North Dakota's regulations, Rep. Steve Swiontek (R), chief sponsor of HB 1561, said, 'The thought was there should be some requirement and expectations that these adult' entertainment sites who are getting paid for this…that they should be mandated and required to verify age. I think we have a moral obligation for these kids.'
Per the North Dakota Monitor, Swiontek noted that the state's laws are modeled after legislation that Utah passed in 2023. In addition, legislators passed Senate Concurrent Resolution 4017, which requests that the Legislative Management Committee 'consider studying the detrimental impacts of pornography.'
The version of SB 2380 and HB 1561 that North Dakota's legislators passed is toned down from its introduction. Originally, the bill required 'covered manufacturers' (which included device manufacturers and app stores) to 'determine or estimate the age of the primary user upon activation of a device'. At the time, Rose Feliciano, executive director of TechNet, said that the bill's requirements were 'vague, cumbersome, and ineffective.'
The toned down regulations still raise significant First Amendment concerns, though. As NetChoice's director of state and federal affairs, Amy Bos, wrote, 'While states may (and should) protect minors, states lack, as Justice Scalia memorably put it, 'a free-floating power to restrict the ideas to which children may be exposed.'' She added that age verification places barriers on 'constitutionally protected speech' that 'cannot survive judicial review.'
Per Bos, laws in California, Utah, Ohio, Arkansas, and Mississippi 'have recently failed to withstand legal scrutiny.' In addition, Texas' HB 1181, which is similar to North Dakota's new regulations, is now at the center of a Supreme Court case. Bos warned, 'Implementing such a measure in North Dakota would likely meet the same fate and lead to costly legal challenges without providing any real benefit to the state's residents.'
Age verification bills are also a privacy nightmare. Although North Dakota's regulation requires all data collected for age verification to be deleted, companies often hold onto data they shouldn't, and age verification companies still get hacked.
Besides, age verification generally isn't effective at blocking access to content. But as the Electronic Frontier Foundation tracked, these laws have spiraled far beyond 'protecting minors from porn'. For example, states have introduced age verification requirements for skincare, dating apps, and diet pills. EFF cautioned, 'While the intent to protect children makes sense, the unintended consequence is a massive erosion of privacy, security, and free expression online for everyone.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNN
18 minutes ago
- CNN
Mahmoud Khalil's detention for alleged threat to US foreign policy is likely ‘unconstitutionally vague,' federal judge says
The Trump administration's use of an obscure portion of immigration law to detain and attempt to deport pro-Palestinian activist Mahmoud Khalil is likely unconstitutional, according to an order issued Wednesday by a federal judge in New Jersey. Khalil, a recent Columbia University graduate and permanent US resident, is 'likely to win on the merits' of his arguments against the federal government's assertion that he poses a threat to the administration's foreign policy goal of combatting antisemitism, the lengthy order by Judge Michael Farbiarz of the Federal District Court in New Jersey finds. The administration's use of that law appears to be 'unconstitutionally vague as applied' to Khalil, Farbiarz writes. But the judge did not order Khalil's release, finding also that he has not provided sufficient evidence against the administration's other claims that failed to disclose ties with certain organizations when he applied for residency status in the US. Khalil has been in detention since his arrest near Columbia in March. He was among the first in a series of high-profile arrests made by the Trump administration in the name of battling antisemitism, but which has sparked a litany of free-speech concerns. An immigration judge in April ruled Khalil could be deported after the government argued his presence posed 'potentially serious foreign policy consequences.' Khalil's attorneys argue the government's evidence is insufficient and based solely on a letter from Secretary of State Marco Rubio that does not allege criminal activity. They contend Khalil is being targeted for his political speech, a First Amendment violation. The federal judge's new order is sympathetic to that argument. 'The Secretary did not affirmatively determine that the (Khalil's) alleged conduct has impacted U.S. relations with other countries. Indeed, the Secretary's determination says nothing about any country other than America,' Farbiarz writes. The judge also notes that deporting Khalil on those grounds would be 'unprecedented.' Khalil's legal team praised the order and said it will provide the additional information requested by the judge as quickly as possible to 'return (Khalil) to his wife and newborn son.' 'The district court held what we already knew: Secretary Rubio's weaponization of immigration law to punish Mahmoud and others like him is likely unconstitutional,' the legal team said, according to a statement posted by the ACLU, which is helping represent him. Khalil's case is playing out separately in immigration court in Louisiana where he's been in detention. In a lengthy hearing last week, a judge denied a request to terminate Palestinian activist Mahmoud Khalil's deportation proceedings after his attorneys argued that he was arrested illegally and without a warrant over two months ago. CNN's Ruben Correa contributed to this report.
New York Times
24 minutes ago
- New York Times
The young Thunder were ready for this moment
OKLAHOMA CITY — A year ago, the Oklahoma City Thunder were too young for this moment. They were almost historically good in the regular season, but callow enough to not know playoff basketball is essentially a different sport. The changes made to the roster after a second-round loss to the Dallas Mavericks were on the margins but impactful. Out went Josh Giddey. In came Alex Caruso and Isaiah Hartenstein. Beyond that, this core of players, all in their early to mid-20s, had to rely on internal development. Advertisement On Wednesday night, as OKC donned T-shirts proclaiming them Western Conference champions and showered their coach Mark Daigneault with towels on the podium, the realization that they had taken another step in their journey was upon them. A 124-94 series-clinching win over the Minnesota Timberwolves was even easier and more lopsided than the final score suggests. A packed Paycom Center turned into a procession of standing ovations by the end of a dominant first quarter. Oklahoma City advanced to the NBA Finals for the first time since Kevin Durant, Russell Westbrook and James Harden took the 2012 team to the cusp of the Promised Land. Like that 2012 team, this group led by Shai Gilgeous-Alexander, Jalen Williams and Chet Holmgren is young and full of energy, with the promise and hope of many championship runs in its future. Unlike that 2012 team, which was thought to have a fighting chance against LeBron James and the Miami Heat, this group will be a heavy favorite over either the Indiana Pacers or New York Knicks, who are battling it out in the Eastern Conference finals. Either way, this OKC team has validated a 68-win regular season. And despite questions to the contrary in some quarters, they proved they are who they tried to tell us they were all year. 'I thought the mental toughness displayed by the team was great,' Daigneault said. 'With the opportunity to close the series out, it's easy to drift ahead, obviously with a 3-1 lead. But we didn't do that at all. We just played the next possession and did a great job to stack them up.' This is why Daigneault refers to the Thunder as an uncommon group. Oklahoma City's youth is much talked about, but it's a real thing. Gilgeous-Alexander, the West finals MVP, is 26. Collectively, OKC is among the youngest teams in the league. But the group as a whole displays a level of maturity that belies its years. When they suffered their only loss of the series in Saturday's Game 3, the Thunder never panicked. They went about their preparation during the day between Games 3 and 4, played a high-level Game 4 and got the road win they needed. Then their preparation for Game 5 became even more intense. Players including Hartenstein and Lu Dort stayed well beyond shootaround on Wednesday morning, getting extra shots up. Gilgeous-Alexander and Williams gently reminded their teammates that they hadn't accomplished anything. Advertisement Thirteen years ago, Durant and Westbrook advanced to the finals with a Game 6 close-out win over the San Antonio Spurs in front of their home crowd. On Wednesday night, Gilgeous-Alexander's goal was to give his home crowd the same kind of experience. 'What I wanted the most was for the fans to be able to enjoy this,' he said. 'I wanted them to be able to enjoy the moment. I wanted to make sure that, above everything else, I could give them my energy and effort. I wanted the fans to get what they deserve.' That's another reason this group is uncommon. OKC has a roster that's as well-rounded on and off the court as you can reasonably expect in the NBA. The youth and the upside suggest that this is the first championship run of many for the Thunder. The professionalism and the maturity suggest that this group has the mental bandwidth to reach its ceiling. This is a team that, in a seven-game, second-round series win over the Denver Nuggets, faced three must-win situations in Games 4, 5 and 7 and won them all. They overcame two 40-point Nikola Jokić games. Then they overcame being blown out by the Timberwolves in Game 3. A 68-win regular season team became a model of resiliency when it needed to. And that's why Minnesota hardly stood a chance on Wednesday. Oklahoma City surrendered the first three points of the game, courtesy of a Julius Randle 3-pointer on Minnesota's opening possessions. Then the Thunder scored 11 consecutive points, forced a Minnesota timeout and ran away on the scoreboard. Their defense was so good, so dominant and unyielding, that the Timberwolves could hardly get into their offensive sets. They made life miserable for Wolves superstar Anthony Edwards. And unlike Game 4, Edwards' teammates couldn't make shots to stay attached. 'They are like 15 puppets with one string,' is how Edwards described Oklahoma City's defense. In some ways, OKC's blowout win was predictable. In Game 4, the Thunder were terrific defensively. They forced a bunch of turnovers. They forced Minnesota into a bunch of difficult shots. They harassed the Timberwolves off the dribble and sped up their offense. What made that game close, and allowed Minnesota to score 126 points, was the Wolves' level of shotmaking. It wasn't logical to expect Minnesota to shoot like that again in this series, which meant the Timberwolves would have to run a much cleaner offense than they did in Game 4. Advertisement In Game 5, Minnesota couldn't figure out Oklahoma City's defense, and its role players missed the same open looks they made in Game 4. Oklahoma City is one of the best defensive teams in NBA history. Dort, Caruso, Holmgren and Cason Wallace are some of the best defenders in the league. They pressure full-court on almost every possession, and then deny passing lanes, as well as almost any NBA team in recent memory. To find the last defense that pressured every inch of the court as well as the Thunder, you have to go back to the prime 1990s Chicago Bulls, with Michael Jordan and Scottie Pippen, Dennis Rodman and Ron Harper. OKC's ability to make teams uncomfortable running offense is historic, and Minnesota crumbled under that pressure all series. 'It's great to feel like you didn't leave anything on the table,' Holmgren said. 'And I feel like we did that tonight. We can always be better, and we're going to look and see how we can do better. But, overall, I feel like we were able to come out tonight and play a really good game. Everyone up and down the roster played well. It's definitely a lot easier on the nerves than the close games.' Thirteen years after falling just short of the summit, the Thunder have reached the same spot. Getting back hasn't been easy. Trading for Gilgeous-Alexander was a stroke of luck, because not many saw him becoming an MVP-level player and one of the best players in the world. But through the difficult seasons, and a long rebuild, these Thunder are finally back. Now they will attempt to reach the top of the mountain. (Photo of Shai Gilgeous-Alexander and Luguentz Dort: Zach Beeker / NBAE via Getty Images)
New York Times
29 minutes ago
- New York Times
‘Go by what we see': How 2 rookie tryout players earned offseason shots with Broncos
Sean Payton patrols practice fields and meeting rooms at Denver Broncos headquarters armed with stories that double as teaching tools. If the Broncos are drilling a specific end-of-game situation in practice, Payton will quickly pause the proceedings and pull from a Rolodex of real-world scenarios where the same sequence unfolded. When the Broncos are recruiting undrafted free agents, Payton can hop on the phone and explain how a previous undrafted player at the same position from his coaching past not only made a given team but also became a key contributor. Advertisement 'I think the first time it was a significant subject (was in) '07,'' Payton said earlier this month. '(In New Orleans) we had drafted a running back, I think in the fourth round out of Ohio State, and we had signed a free agent, Pierre Thomas, out of Illinois. We got to training camp, and there was a period of time that Pierre was playing better. … He was playing better enough, where the players and most people knew. So we released the fourth-round pick and kept Pierre.' Next year, Payton will be able to show every player who arrives at rookie minicamp on a tryout basis that they, too, have a path to follow. As the Broncos began OTAs earlier this week, two of the players working out with the group — wide receiver Kyrese White and inside linebacker Jordan Turner — began their journey with the team earlier this month as rookie tryout players. Neither player was selected in last month's draft. They weren't even among the 15 rookies the Broncos signed in the wave of undrafted free agency to follow. They arrived in Denver in early May with nothing guaranteed beyond participation in three days of minicamp practices. But when Payton addressed reporters following the second of those sessions, he hinted there were tryout players who had already earned strong consideration to be added to the actual roster, saying a couple 'have a chance to go to (training) camp with us.' 'Bill (Parcells) was big on that: Go by what we see,' Payton said. By the afternoon on Mother's Day, instead of flying back home as they were previously scheduled to do, White and Turner were finalizing contracts that added them to Denver's roster. Their three-day audition was turning into something more. 'I was so excited when he let me know because it was couple weeks earlier that the draft was going on and then all the free-agent deals were going on, and Kyrese hit me up a couple days afterward saying, 'Coach, I haven't heard from anybody and I don't know what to do,'' said Kyle Cefalo, who worked with White the past two seasons as the wide receivers coach at Utah State. 'He got one minicamp invite and that was it. It wasn't even like he decided to go to the Broncos. It was his only option.' Advertisement White was hard to miss during the practice open to reporters, and not just because his big hair flowing under his helmet and the No. 43 he wore made him look like Troy Polamalu. White did a little bit of everything last season at Utah State, where he finished with 44 catches and 526 yards while also returning kicks and developing into one of the team's best perimeter blockers despite his 5-foot-10, 185-pound frame. He shuffled through all of those roles with aplomb during his tryout with the Broncos. It wasn't the first time White had willed himself onto a team. He was a walk-on at Utah and, after entering the transfer portal in 2023, also had to earn his way into a deep wide receivers room at Utah State that featured Jalen Royals, a fourth-round pick of the Kansas City Chiefs. 'The one thing I told scouts was, 'If someone gives him a chance and brings him in, you're going to have a tough time getting rid of him,'' Cefalo said. 'He's going to be smart and he's going to work really hard. He's going to be great on special teams. He's a great athlete and he's going to make plays. That's the message I gave. I didn't oversell or undersell Kyrese to anybody. I was just like, 'If you bring him in, you're going to have a tough time cutting him.' Sure enough, that's what happened with the Broncos. Clearly, he made a great impression in a few days.' The impression Turner made on the Broncos started well before he arrived for minicamp. In the days leading up to the draft, he had conversations with Broncos linebackers coach Jeff Schmedding. He had another connection on the staff in Jim Leonhard, Denver's defensive pass game coordinator. Before transferring to Michigan State for his final college season in 2024, Turner had played two seasons at Wisconsin for Leonhard, who was the team's defensive coordinator and later its interim head coach during that time. 'Just from a relationship standpoint, Jordan was having all these different touch points,' said Turner's agent, Jackson Magnini. ' … Jordan had made the comment to me, even before the draft ended, 'I don't want to go anywhere else, even if there are other opportunities. This is where I want to be.'' Despite the Broncos' significant interest in Turner, they signed two other players at his position during undrafted free agency: JB Brown of Kansas and Karene Reid of Utah. The flurry of post-draft activity can be a chaotic time for teams and players alike, like college recruiting on hyperdrive. Teams don't know how many spots they'll have to offer at a given position until players start deciding where they want to sign. The inside linebacker spot in Denver, which should feature ample offseason practice time as veterans Dre Greenlaw and Alex Singleton finish injury rehab, quickly became a popular destination for players with options. Advertisement Still, the Broncos quickly made it clear their opinion on Turner hadn't changed. They still wanted to see him in rookie minicamp. Turner, unlike White, had a chance to go to other camps. Denver remained his target despite the sting of not being drafted or initially signed by the Broncos. 'Once he got out there, his mindset, which I give him a lot of credit for, was, 'I'm not leaving here,'' Magnini said. Turner impressed the coaching staff with a quick grasp of the playbook. He made a similarly quick transition when he transferred to Michigan State, finishing his final season with 66 tackles (11 for loss), three sacks and two interceptions. The 6-foot-1, 228-pound linebacker made enough of an impression at minicamp for the Broncos to add him to an inside linebacker group that now has four undrafted free agents, including last year's post-draft signee at the spot, Levelle Bailey. It also helped White and Turner that they had extensive special teams experience in college. New special teams coordinator Darren Rizzi will have a strong voice in shaping the end of Denver's roster. The Broncos were the only team to select a punter in last month's draft (sixth-rounder Jeremy Crawshaw) and other picks, like fourth-round outside linebacker Que Robinson, were made with early special teams impact in mind. The team's two newest rookies will need to make themselves valuable in that phase of the game to extend their stays further. The path to the 53-man roster by September will be a narrow one for White and Turner to navigate. They will continue to battle undrafted free agents at their positions this offseason — White was the fourth wide receiver the Broncos signed after the draft — to say nothing of the veterans already entrenched at those respective spots. Cuts can come any day in the offseason. To make room for the tryout standouts, after all, the Broncos had to cut two other players after minicamp, undrafted rookies Kendall Bohler and Christian Dowell, to stay within the 90-man roster limit. White and Turner know nothing is given from here. But they are here as the offseason rolls forward. For now, that's all that matters. 'I give them the same message each year,' Payton said of rookie minicamp participants. ''(How) you arrive, that's part of us procuring the talent, but once you arrive here, how you arrived here isn't important to us. You're here.'' (Top photo of Kyrese White: Jamie Sabau / Imagn Images)
