Greenpeace ordered to pay more than $660 million to fossil fuel company over pipeline protests
In a win for the oil and gas pipeline company Energy Transfer, a nine-person North Dakota jury found the environmental group Greenpeace liable for more than $660 million in damages and defamation for the 2016 to 2017
Standing Rock protests
against the Dakota Access Pipeline.
In their lawsuit, Dallas-based Energy Transfer claimed Greenpeace was responsible for defamation, disruption and property damage for the protests that captured national attention in 2016. Greenpeace claimed the lawsuit threatened its freedom of speech.
In a statement, Energy Transfer said, "This win is really for the people of Mandan and throughout North Dakota who had to live through the daily harassment and disruptions caused by the protesters who were funded and trained by Greenpeace. It is also a win for all law-abiding Americans who understand the difference between the right to free speech and breaking the law."
Greenpeace plans to appeal the verdict. "This is the end of a chapter, but not the end of our fight. Energy Transfer knows we don't have $660 million. They want our silence, not our money." Sushma Raman, interim executive director of Greenpeace Inc., told CBS News.
Greenpeace accused Energy Transfer of filing a "SLAPP" lawsuit, short for strategic lawsuits against public participation. SLAPP lawsuits have been criticized as being a method of curtailing free speech and assembly by individuals, organizations or press by threatening lengthy and expensive legal proceedings in court. 35 states have anti-SLAPP laws aimed at preventing these types of lawsuits. North Dakota is not among them.
Energy Transfer previously filed a federal RICO lawsuit against Greenpeace seeking $300 million in damages in 2017, but that case was dismissed by a federal judge. Energy Transfer then filed a lawsuit against Greenpeace in North Dakota state court shortly after. Energy Transfer is valued at over $60 billion and reported $82 billion in revenue in 2024.
"The verdict against Greenpeace not only represents an assault on free speech and protest rights," said Rebecca Brown, president and CEO of the Center for International and Environmental Law, in a statement. "This case is a textbook example of corporate weaponization of the legal system to silence protest and intimidate communities. This misuse of the legal system stifles legitimate dissent and must be seen as a direct threat to environmental justice and democratic freedoms."
In the weeks and months preceding the trial, Greenpeace raised the alarm that the damages sought by Energy Transfer, thought at the time to be in the $300 million range, would be catastrophic to the group, claiming that would amount to 10 times the group's annual U.S. operating budget.
The damages ultimately awarded total roughly $667 million and will be split up among several arms of Greenpeace. Greenpeace USA is on the hook for about $404 million, while Greenpeace Fund Inc. and Greenpeace International must ach pay some $131 million, according to The Associated Press.
The trial took place in Morton County, near the protest site. Greenpeace had requested a change in venue for the trial but was denied.
The 1,172-mile pipeline crosses four states and has been operating since late 2017 despite the controversy and the protest, which stemmed from a pipeline crossing under Lake Oahe near the Standing Rock Sioux Reservation. The
Standing Rock Sioux tribe
called the pipeline a violation of its treaty rights and claimed the pipeline route risked polluting the tribe's primary water source and would damage sacred sites.
The protests at Standing Rock drew thousands of people from around the country who camped outside the pipeline's construction site. Celebrities and prominent figures including now-Trump cabinet members Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. and Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard also visited the camp.
But violence erupted between police, security guards and protestors several times, culminating in
tear gas and water canons
being used against protestors. The camps were cleared in February of 2017. More than 140 people were arrested at the Standing Rock protests.
One of the organizers of the protests was Chase Iron Eyes, an attorney for the Lakota People's Law Project, who was arrested during the demonstrations and charged with felony inciting a riot. Iron Eyes questioned Greenpeace's liability for the protests.
"I never met a single Greenpeace person, a representative, or ever went to a training or anything like that," Iron Eyes told CBS News.
Instead, Iron Eyes found the ruling to delegitimize the concerns and agency of Native Americans who chose to protest at Standing Rock. "To hold them solely responsible for our fight, this is a tribal nation fight," he said. "I think it's disrespectful to tribal nations, to the Sioux Nation in particular, it was our nation, and our people who stood up."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hamilton Spectator
11 minutes ago
- Hamilton Spectator
Border traffic freefall jeopardizes duty free shop
Mayor, MP joins national call to help border stores survive John Slipp says 'traveller anxiety' is not how the Woodstock business owner wanted to celebrate the 40th anniversary of the Woodstock Duty Free Shop Inc. Canadian reaction to President Donald Trump's annexation threats, chaotic tariff announcements, and increased border scrutiny add up to a dearth of visitors driving by his Woodstock Duty Free Shop en route to the Houlton, Maine border crossing and an uncertain future for his store. 'We have no plans for our anniversary. Given the conditions we are in, there's not much to celebrate at the moment. It's kind of bittersweet. It was a very special time 40 years go when Dad opened the business…. It's sad to see it all come to an end,' Slipp said. No traffic means no business for The Woodstock Duty Free Shop, a dilemma repeated at 32 land border duty free stores across Canada. The Frontier Duty Free Association, a national association of land border duty free shops, conducted a March survey of owners on how long they could remain open under the current climate. Slipp and one-third of the other store owners said three to six months. 'I have been talking to other colleagues at other crossings with stores that are similar in size and have similar concerns… Canadians are not looking to travel to the United States… We are also finding that Americans are experiencing border anxiety as well because of the immigration enforcement in the United States. A lot of Americans don't want to be anywhere near a border,' Slipp said. 'This is not just this border crossing, it's nationwide.' Woodstock Mayor Trina Jones said the Woodstock Duty Free Shop 'offers a critical role' for local tourism, offering visitors a tax-free way to buy Canadian and locally made goods and products that promote Woodstock, New Brunswick, and Canada. 'It's especially important since there is no longer a (provincial) tourist bureau operating at our border location. John Slipp and his staff offer that one last chance for those visiting our area, or passing through, to purchase goods that promote us and boost our economy,' Mayor Jones said in an emailed statement. When the Liberal government announced counter-tariffs on U.S. imports to combat the American tariffs placed on Canadian exports, Prime Minister Mark Carney said the Canadian tariff revenue would help businesses affected by the trade war. Richard Bragdon, Tobique-Mactaquac Conservative MP, said counter-tariffs should support duty free shops. 'Our duty free shops like the one in Woodstock, have taken a big hit over the last several years. They just started to recover coming out of the challenges they faced during COVID, to then be affected by the tariff situation with the United States,' Bragdon said in an emailed statement. 'Funds received through counter-tariffs should be used to support affected industries which includes duty free shops.' Four decades at the border Slipp's father, George, opened the store on June 1, 1985, after the Canadian government announced licensing land border locations for duty free stores to sell goods tax and duty free to travellers leaving the country. John Slipp started working at the family business 31 years ago. 'It's been a good business most of the time. But between COVID and the tariffs, it's a different world here.' Slipp once employed 15 people at the store, which was open seven days a week, selling alcohol and tobacco products, local arts and crafts, local maple syrup, clothing, perfume and other products. The store also offers currency exchange for visitors. Now, the business owner mans the store himself, which is closed on Mondays. Slipp isn't alone. CBC reports that duty-free shops across the country have experienced massive drops in business in recent months. United States Customs and Border Protection data shows travellers entering the United States from Canada dropped almost 850,000 visitors in April. 'These businesses are not in this position because of bad management or poor decisions—this is a crisis not of their making,' said Barbara Barrett, Frontier Duty Free Association (FDFA) executive director, a national organization representing the land border shops. 'From the pandemic border closure to the current impacts of U.S. tariffs and travel disruptions, duty free stores have been disproportionately impacted at every turn. The government has committed to supporting businesses hurt by these challenges, and we are simply asking for targeted, reasonable support to prevent the permanent loss of these local employers. Our ask is modest, but the need is urgent.' Recent FDFA data shows 60 to 80 percent revenue losses at many stores. On June 3, the association joined with mayors from border communities to release an open letter to Prime Minister Carney and Minister François-Philippe Champagne asking the federal government to act now to prevent the permanent closure of Canada's land border duty free stores. 'These are not multinational chains—these are our independently-owned, family-run stores, and in many small border communities, we are the main employer,' said Tania Lee, FDFA president and owner/operator of Bluewater Bridge Duty Free. 'Our stores are an integral part of Canada's tourism fabric and border community economies, sustaining jobs and supporting the towns we call home. Today, many of us are just weeks away from closing our doors for good.' Both federal and provincial politicians have told Slipp they want to help, but he's worried about how long it will take to develop an assistance plan. 'Newly-elected cabinet minsters and members are just trying to find their way… It takes a while to get things approved. We're happy that the talking points are positive.' Slipp said the federal government introduced a lease deferral program when the duty-free stores were weathering the COVID travel ban. Slipp owns the store building, but the land is leased from the Canadian Border Services Agency (CBSA). Allowing duty free store owners to delay lease payments would be helpful. He suggested allowing duty free shops to close temporarily without any penalties and assisting with employees' wages and benefits to keep the business afloat. Slipp is worried the trained employees he had to lay off won't be available to return to work if the slowdown continues. He said using counter-tariff revenues to pay for the assistance makes sense. 'We have reminded the government that was one of their pledges and we would like to participate. The politicians speak positively and provide hope, but it is just taking too long.' 'Local tourism boost' Slipp said that when the federal government created the duty free program, licenses were awarded to local, independent, and private Canadian businesspeople. The shops had to be local stores, not large national corporations or franchises. 'The stores would capture some of the money Canadians would be spending in the United States but also capture American money from Americans returning home buying gifts or souvenirs,' he said. 'The duty-free shops are designed to promote local tourism and capture the money that would otherwise be spent in the United States to support our local economy.' Federal rules require that anything sold at a duty-free shop immediately leaves the country of origin. 'We are an exporter, because everything we sell is exported. We are not allowed to compete with local domestic retailers… Local Woodstock residents cannot come here to purchase goods and return to Canada without paying tax. That wouldn't be fair,' Slipp said. 'Americans visiting our shop have a $200 (U.S.) daily tax exemption. We encourage them to shop here and the local area.' Jones is a member of the Mayor's Border Alliance for Canada. She said border mayors are advocating with the Frontier Duty Free Association for proper federal and provincial support. 'Duty free shops have a unique challenge in that federal regulations prohibit them from selling their products here locally… I would encourage anyone in Woodstock, and all Canadians, who are still choosing to travel to the U.S. to consider stopping at the Woodstock Duty Free Shop on their way to the states to purchase goods to help them get through this tough period,' Jones said. 'We encourage the federal and provincial governments to provide financial assistance to the duty-free shops, similar to the supports provided during the pandemic, to help keep them going during this time.' Error! Sorry, there was an error processing your request. There was a problem with the recaptcha. Please try again. You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy . This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply. Want more of the latest from us? Sign up for more at our newsletter page .
Yahoo
14 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Insurtech Slide targets $2 billion plus valuation in US IPO
(Reuters) -Insurance tech company Slide is aiming for a valuation of up to $2.12 billion in its U.S. initial public offering, joining a lineup of insurance companies that have made impressive stock market debuts in recent weeks. Slide's roadshow launch follows stellar first-time share sales in recent weeks from eToro and Circle , underscoring a revival of investor appetite for market debutants after months of dealmaking paralysis from U.S. policy turbulence. Slide and some of its existing stakeholders are looking to raise up to $340 million by offering 20 million shares priced between $15 and $17 each, the company revealed in a filing on Monday. Insurers are more immune to market downturns, with heightened uncertainty boosting demand for their risk-mitigation offerings. Sectors focused on intellectual property continue to pique investor interest, some analysts have said. While, Apollo-backed Aspen Insurance and Florida-based American Integrity Insurance went public last month, specialty insurer Ategrity is poised to debut later this week. Founded in 2021, Slide offers family and condominium insurance policies in Florida and South Carolina. The company is led by Bruce Lucas, who previously founded and led Heritage Insurance. Filings show 99.5% of Slide's policies are concentrated in Florida, where the company is aiming to grow its footprint in a market from which some insurers are pulling back, due to its history of natural disasters, primarily hurricanes. The company's profit rose 69.1% to $92.5 million for the quarter ended March 31. Combined ratio was at 58.9%, versus 66.7% last year. A ratio below 100% means the insurer earned more in premiums than it paid out in claims. Barclays and Morgan Stanley are the lead underwriters on the listing. The company's shares are expected to start trading on the Nasdaq under the symbol "SLDE". Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
Yahoo
19 minutes ago
- Yahoo
India faces two years of sugar surplus, growers and officials say
By Rajendra Jadhav SATARA, India (Reuters) -India is set to produce surplus sugar for at least two consecutive years, as millions of farmers expand the area under sugarcane cultivation amid ample rainfall, boosting crop yields, growers and industry officials said. The rebound in production would allow the world's second-largest sugar producer to increase exports in 2025/26, they said, after poor rainfall cut sugarcane yields and led to two years of export restrictions. "Sugarcane usually gives us good returns, but sometimes we can't plant it due to a lack of water," said Umesh Jagtap as he planted the crop on a three-acre plot in Maharashtra, a leading sugar producing state in the west. "This year, we had heavy rain in May, and the forecast says more rain is on the way. So we're planning to plant more than usual." Farmers from Maharashtra and neighbouring Karnataka struggle to irrigate their sugarcane crop in May. This year, however, Maharashtra and Karnataka received 1,007% and 234% more rainfall than average, respectively. The rainfall will benefit the crop to be harvested in the 2025/26 season, starting October, and will also support planting for the 2026/27 harvest, said Prakash Naiknavare, managing director of the National Federation of Cooperative Sugar Factories (NFCSF). Sugarcane typically takes 10 to 18 months from planting to harvest. As a result, farmers who began planting this month are expected to harvest their crop during the 2026/27 season. The NFCSF estimates gross sugar production in 2025/26 to rise by nearly a fifth from a year earlier, reaching 35 million metric tons. For the 2024/25 marketing year to September, India's net sugar production is expected to fall below consumption for the first time in eight years. This decline stems from a 2023 drought that hit sugarcane planting and forced India to prohibit sugar exports in 2023/24 and allowing merely 1 million tons in 2024/25. India was the world's No. 2 sugar exporter during the five years to 2022/23, with volumes averaging 6.8 million tons annually. "Looks like production is set to bounce back strongly, so New Delhi will probably have no trouble allowing exports of over 3 million tons in the next season starting October," said a Mumbai-based trader with a global trade house. Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
