When students say they will never fight for Britain, don't believe them
In 1933, there was a famous Oxford Union debate motion, which was later called the Oxford Pledge: 'That this House will under no circumstances fight for its King and country.'
It passed: 275 people voted for the motion and 153 against it. Hitler's decision-making, Churchill later believed, was affected by the motion. This illustrates what an odious a signal of British decadence and nihilism it sent.
Six years earlier, a motion at Cambridge had been proposed: 'That lasting peace can only be secured by the people of England adopting an uncompromising attitude of pacifism,' which passed by 213 votes to 138.
Churchill's scathing words about the Oxford motion are eerily relevant: 'That abject, squalid, shameless avowal,' he called it. 'It is a very disquieting and disgusting symptom.'
But it soon became apparent that it was youthful talk. When Britain went to war with Germany, almost all eligible Oxford students reported for duty, many losing their lives, a sacrifice still commemorated on VE Day.
This year, more than most, one felt anxious on VE Day, in part due to the doubt over whether it is still the case that cometh the hour, cometh the Lefty student-turned-soldier.
A major survey this year revealed that only 11 per cent of people in their late teens and 20s would fight for their country. Gen Z is anything but tough, valorous or patriotic.
And yet. The aggressive, destructive passivism of the Oxbridge students of a century ago was just the same as it is today, albeit far more literate.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
28 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Ukraine and Europe in limbo after Trump sidelines Zelenskyy at G7
Update: Date: 2025-06-18T07:24:41.000Z Title: 'If we don't help Ukraine further, we should start learning Russian,' Kallas echoes Rutte's warning Content: EU's Kallas continues: On Ukraine, the European Union is doing its part here too, not least because Ukraine is Europe's first line of defence. We know that Russia responds to strength and nothing else. She highlights the importance of the 18th sanction package proposed by the EU, saying that 'every sanction weakens Russia's ability to fight this war.' But she ends on a warning again: We have to do more for Ukraine, for our own security too. To quote my friend Nato secretary general Mark Rutte: if we don't help Ukraine further, we should all start learning Russian. The stronger Ukraine is on the battlefield today, the stronger they will be around the negotiation table when Russia finally is ready to talk. Update: Date: 2025-06-18T07:23:12.000Z Title: Russia 'direct threat' to EU, with 'long term plan for long term aggression', EU's foreign policy chief warns Content: Opening the debate in the European Parliament, the EU's foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas warns: We are living in very dangerous tough times. Russia is already a direct threat to the European Union. Russia is violating our airspace, conducting provocative military manoeuvres near EU borders, targeting our trains and planes, attacking our pipelines, undersea fibre optic cables and electricity grids, assaulting our industry, including companies supporting Ukraine, and is recruiting criminals to carry out sabotage attacks, and it is steadily building up its military forces and expanding its nuclear arsenal. Last year, Russia spent more on defence than the European Union combined. This year, Russia is spending more on defence than its own healthcare, education and social policy combined. This is a long term plan for a long term aggression. You don't spend that much on military if you do not plan to use it. She goes on to call on countries to work towards the new Nato 5% defence spending target as early as they can, adding: Europe's collective economic might is unmatched. I don't believe that there is any threat that we can't overcome if we act together and with our Nato allies. Update: Date: 2025-06-18T07:17:46.000Z Title: Morning opening: Ukraine and Europe left in limbo as attention shifts elsewhere Content: Ukrainian diplomats have been left frustrated – and in some cases embittered – at Donald Trump's refusal to make Ukraine a priority after Volodymyr Zelenskyy flew 5,000 miles to the G7 conference in Canada only for the US president to return home the night before the two leaders were due to meet, the Guardian's diplomatic editor Patrick Wintour reported. The snub came a day after 'one of the most horrific attacks' on the Ukrainian capital, Kyiv, during the three-year war, with the death toll from the Russian strike rising to 21, with more than 130 injured. The move shows a dramatic shift as the world focuses on the escalating conflict between Israel and Iran. But where does it leave Europe and Ukraine? European lawmakers will be this morning discussing the upcoming Nato summit in The Hague, looking at some of these issues. I will bring you the key lines from their discussion. It's Wednesday, 18 June 2025, it's Jakub Krupa here, and this is Europe Live. Good morning.
Reuters
an hour ago
- Reuters
Israel launches airlift to bring home stranded citizens after Iran strike
TEL AVIV, June 18 (Reuters) - Israel began flying home citizens stranded abroad on Wednesday, launching a phased airlift operation after the country's surprise military strike on Iran left tens of thousands of Israelis stuck overseas. The first rescue flight, operated by national carrier El Al ( opens new tab, touched down at Ben Gurion Airport early Wednesday morning, bringing home passengers from Larnaca, Cyprus. Worldwide, Israel's transport ministry estimates that more than 50,000 stranded Israelis are trying to come home. El Al has said repatriation flights are already scheduled from Athens, Rome, Milan and Paris. Smaller rivals Arkia and Israir ( opens new tab are also taking part in the operation. "We are preparing for the airlift to bring all Israelis home," Transportation Minister Miri Regev told the captain of the arriving El Al flight before it landed, according to a statement released by the Israeli Aviation Authority. "We are very emotional about receiving the first rescue flight as part of 'Safe Return'. Land safely," she added. Tel Aviv's airport has been closed to passenger traffic since Israel launched its attack on Friday. The Airports Authority reinforced staffing on Wednesday to ensure the arriving passengers exited the airport quickly. They were shuttled to their parked vehicles or transported via train and bus to city centres nationwide. The operation is being carried out in stages, based on risk levels and security assessments, with an emphasis on the safety of passengers, flight crews, and aircraft, a spokesperson for the airports authority said. Relatives were advised to avoid travelling to airports for security reasons. Iran has fired more than 400 ballistic missiles at Israel since Friday, a large number of them targeting the Tel Aviv area. At least 24 people have died so far in the strikes. There are still be no passenger flights leaving Israel, meaning up to 40,000 tourists are stranded in the country. El Al has cancelled all scheduled flights through to June 23. Large numbers of Israelis seeking to get home have converged on Cyprus, the European Union member state closest to Israel. Flights from the coastal city of Larnaca to Tel Aviv take 50 minutes. Nine flights were expected to depart Cyprus Wednesday for Haifa, and four for Tel Aviv, carrying about 1,000 people, sources in Cypriot airport operator Hermes said. Cruise operator Mano Maritime, whose "Crown Iris" ship carries 2,000 passengers, has said it will make two crossings from Cyprus to Israel's Mediterranean port city of Haifa. Earlier on Wednesday, a cruise ship arrived in Cyprus carrying 1,500 participants to a Jewish heritage programme who had left Israel on Tuesday.
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
PM considers Nato visit; Optus agrees to $100m fine; and dating's 6ft fixation
Good afternoon. Anthony Albanese is considering a snap visit to Europe to meet Donald Trump, days after their first meeting at the G7 in Canada was cancelled amid the escalating Israel-Iran conflict. Albanese said he could join a gathering of Nato leaders in The Hague next week, a move that is incumbent on a face-to-face meeting with the US president being locked in. Meanwhile, the prime minister said he had accepted the EU's offer of high-level negotiations on a new defence and security pact. Albanese said Australia's partnership with the EU will focus on areas including defence industries, cybersecurity and counter-terrorism. It is not legally binding and would not include troop deployment, but is designed to strengthen cooperation on global security challenges. The EU already has similar deals in place with countries including Japan, South Korea and the UK. Ban on gay and bisexual men donating blood and plasma in Australia to be scrapped Four teenagers charged over alleged six-hour gang-rape of girl in Sydney Jim Chalmers says media's 'rule-in rule-out game' on tax reform has 'cancerous effect' on policy debates Malfunctions, overreactions and a steep learning curve: wargaming a Chinese attack on Taiwan Trans people can obtain US passport that aligns with their gender identity, judge rules What is rat lungworm disease and why are cases rising in dogs in Australia? Leaked footage and prison logs reveal Aung San Suu Kyi's life in detention A volcano in eastern Indonesia has erupted, forcing the cancellation of dozens of flights to and from Bali. Mount Lewotobi Laki-Laki spewed an ash cloud 10km high into the air, the country's volcanology agency said. Indonesian officials raised volcano alerts to their highest level after the eruption, but so far there have been no reported damages or casualties. The volcano erupted several times in November, killing nine people and forcing mass evacuations. 'She's not on trial for lying. This is not a court … of moral judgment.' – Colin Mandy SC Erin Patterson's defence barrister has continued his closing remarks to the jury in the Victorian woman's triple murder trial, telling the court there was 'no venom' in her relationship with her estranged husband and his parents, and that there was 'no evidence' to suggest any disagreements presented to the jury were more than 'a minor thing'. Catch up on all the day's developments. Optus has agreed to pay a $100m penalty after conceding it engaged in 'inexcusable' misconduct when it sold phones and contracts to hundreds of customers who could not afford them, did not want them, or didn't even have coverage to use them. The negotiated penalty, if approved by a federal court judge, came after court action taken against Optus by the consumer regulator. If imposed, it would be the largest ever for the telco sector. Sign up to Afternoon Update Our Australian afternoon update breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters after newsletter promotion The shorter man's search for love: 'One woman cried when I told her how tall I am' Tinder is trialling a height filter, following in the footsteps of some other popular apps. What is behind the '6ft fixation' in dating – and could it be scuppering the chance of true connection? Today's starter word is: HEST. You have five goes to get the longest word including the starter word. Play Wordiply. Enjoying the Afternoon Update? Then you'll love our Morning Mail newsletter. Sign up here to start the day with a curated breakdown of the key stories you need to know, and complete your daily news roundup. And follow the latest in US politics by signing up for This Week in Trumpland.
