MSPs hear evidence amid call to make non-fatal strangulation a standalone offence in Scotland
The mother of a student who took her own life after being abused by her boyfriend has branded non-fatal strangulation as the "ultimate act of control" amid calls to make it a standalone offence.
Fiona Drouet's daughter Emily was just 18 years old when she took her own life several days after being choked and slapped by Angus Milligan.
The teenager was studying law at the University of Aberdeen when she died in 2016.
The following year, Milligan received a Community Payback Order (CPO) with unpaid work and supervision after pleading guilty to assault and behaving in a threatening or abusive manner.
Following her daughter's death, Ms Drouet founded EmilyTest - a charity that aims to tackle gender-based violence in universities and colleges - and has lodged a petition to make non-fatal strangulation (NFS) a standalone criminal offence.
NFS laws have already been introduced in England, Wales, and Northern Ireland.
Although it is not a standalone offence in Scotland, there is no gap in the law and it is prosecuted under a range of offences.
Campaigners say that does not go far enough and believe making it a standalone offence would act as a greater deterrent and lead to more accurate data on the number of incidents reported.
Police Scotland and the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service (COPFS) agree that NFS is a "red flag" indicator for domestic homicide, but are concerned that a change could dilute current laws already in place.
In its 2025-26 Programme for Government, the Scottish government pledge to carry out a comprehensive assessment of the law in relation to NFS to determine if further action is required beyond the existing provisions.
Holyrood's Criminal Justice Committee took evidence on NFS on Wednesday.
Ms Drouet told the MSPs the harms of NFS are "significant" and could lead to brain damage, organ failure, and potentially death.
Describing the psychological impact, she said: "It's like a near-death experience.
"And somebody, when they have the oxygen to their brain restricted, they are going to have an automatic response of fighting - literally fighting for their life."
Ms Drouet described NFS as "hugely traumatic".
She added: "It's the ultimate act of control. And you know that whether you live or die is down to that perpetrator."
Ms Drouet highlighted text messages sent by Emily to her friends, which said she feared she was "going to die" when being strangled.
In another message, the teenager wrote: "I am so scared that I think I want to die."
Ms Drouet said: "Members will know that my daughter is no longer with us after being subjected to horrendous abuse.
"And it impacts us all really heavily knowing that she was subjected to these harms and these fears."
Ms Drouet believes NFS is an "exceptionally serious crime that merits a law in itself".
She added: "I'm worried that any other approach minimises the severity and risk of the crime and doesn't give victims, survivors, the justice that they absolutely deserve."
2:56
Police Scotland has raised concerns that dealing with NFS in isolation or presenting it to court as a single incident "could minimise opportunities" to build a case under the Domestic Abuse (Scotland) Act 2018.
The force has suggested implementing a specific aggravating factor in existing offences.
Dr Emma Forbes, the national lead for domestic abuse at COPFS, agreed NFS can lead to "lethal consequences".
In an earlier written submission, she noted: "Scots law currently criminalises non-fatal strangulation and there is not a gap in the law that was present in the other identified jurisdictions to necessitate a standalone offence of non-fatal strangulation.
"Scotland does not need to replicate other jurisdictions in creating a standalone offence to 'keep pace'; rather, it should reflect the fact that other jurisdictions are catching up with the Scottish approach.
"This is not a rationale to stand still and there remains significant work to ensure an effective and robust criminal justice response to non-fatal strangulation."
Dr Forbes agreed that the normalisation of NFS - particularly within sexual relationships - "needs to be addressed".
She said creating a standalone offence would "send a strong message" and achieve greater public awareness "swiftly and effectively", but added: "However, at the same time, it risks a dilution of the currently robust law in Scotland and has the potential to lead to increased reporting but less convictions."
Giving evidence to the Holyrood committee, Dr Forbes said more could be done to raise awareness of NFS and agreed there were "compelling reasons" to create a standalone offence.
She added: "This is a public harm, but we have a very strong foundation in our law in Scotland and I would worry about the unintended consequences of a specific offence, not least because it would be more difficult evidentially to prove."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
12 minutes ago
- The Sun
Tragedy as baby found dead at home as cops probe ‘unexplained' death
AN urgent investigation has been launched after a baby died at home yesterday. Police have described the sudden tragedy in Middlesbrough as "unexplained", with detectives now carrying out enquiries. The force has not revealed where exactly the incident took place. A statement by Cleveland Constabulary last night said: "Officers were called to an address in Middlesbrough earlier today, Saturday 7 th June, following the death of a baby. "The death is being treated as unexplained and detectives have been carrying out some enquiries at the address. "Our thoughts are with the family of the deceased child at this sad and difficult time." 1
BBC News
20 minutes ago
- BBC News
Orkney Assassin: Mother haunted by day she confronted killer son
Moira Ross is still haunted, more than three decades later, by the moment she asked her schoolboy son if he had murdered a months earlier, on 2 June 1994, Shamsuddin Mahmood, 26, was killed by a single shot to the head as he served customers in an Indian restaurant in for the first time, she relived the moment she confronted Michael in his bedroom after he was questioned by initially ruled there was not enough evidence to charge the army cadet with a crime committed when he was just 15 years old. Michael left the island the following summer and would go on to get married, have a family and become a decorated Black Watch sniper before he was finally brought to justice thanks to an anonymous in a new documentary, The Orkney Assassin: Murder in the Isles, his parents maintain he is the victim of a miscarriage of the day Michael, then 16, returned home hungry from the police station his mother said he was "just his normal self".She later went upstairs to his room and described what happened next."I said: 'Did you shoot that man?' and he said 'no' and I just can't..."Ms Ross broke down then continued: "I just can't get over the look on his face when I asked him that." As well as the cloud of suspicion over her son, the investigation ended the police career of her husband, was jailed in 1997 after lying about the fact he owned bullets identical to the one used in the murder. The documentary includes moving testimony from a witness who was 13 at the time of the and a local photographer also reflect on the first homicide on the idyllic group of islands for 25 years and agree it continues to divide the community to this day. Ex-Daily Record reporter Bob Dow said: "To be honest this was more than just a murder."This was a cold blooded public execution carried out on one of the most crime-free parts of the UK."This was like Pulp Fiction meets Whisky Galore." The night of the shooting Emma, who was 13 at the time, was in the Mumutaz restaurant in Kirkwall with her at 19:15 she witnessed something that left her recalled: "I was sitting in one of the window seats next to the door and the door opened."Emma thought it was someone coming to collect a added: "They were quite well built and they sort of had a purposeful march on them."I could not see who it was because they had their face covered."Emma admitted her memory of what happened next was "fragmented".She said: "I remember it was a hand gun and there was a pop."It did not make sense at the time what was happening."Then this person turned round and just walked out."In an instant the restaurant had been transformed into a chaotic crime said: "I remember being so relieved to see the police but safe, happy Orkney was gone." Photographer Ken Amer said there was "absolute panic" when he arrived on the black and white images captured stunned staff leaving the restaurant and unfinished meals on the tables, including the one Emma was sitting at with her Amer later realised he had previously photographed the victim while covering a big cheque presentation for The Orcadian at the picture of Mr Mahmood, Emma said: "I remember he had a big smile in real life and he was really friendly and kind."I have never been able to make sense of what happened that night." The investigation Angus Chisholm was a detective inspector for the then Northern Constabulary in Inverness when he was sent from the Highland capital to following morning he tasked local constable, ex-Black Watch soldier Eddy Ross, with the ballistic side of the focus became the 9mm bullet casing of the single shot which passed through Mr Mahmood's head and became embedded in the quickly identified the round as one previously used by the British the inquiry continued a reconstruction of the murder featured on the BBC's Crimewatch unlike most TV appeals, detectives had no description of the gunman, who entered and left the restaurant without uttering a Mahmood's brother, A.K.M Shafiuddin, remembered him as a "kind hearted person" and told the programme he planned to marry his girlfriend, who was a medical wrestled with various theories but inquiries on the island and in the waiter's native Bangladesh drew a Chisholm said: "Nobody had a bad word to say about Shamsuddin." Two months after the murder police finally got a he finished a night shift Ross informed Mr Chisholm that he had discovered a box of the same 9mm bullets used in the murder - in his own father-of-three said he had been given the box - which was still sealed - by ex-marine Jim when Mr Spence was questioned he said he handed over two boxes to PC Ross - one sealed and one half a separate development, a mother and daughter reported they had seen a masked male acting suspiciously in Papdale Woods, a fortnight before the alerted officers when they spotted the same individual going into a baker's in was Michael Ross - the teenage son of PC told the documentary: "Basically from that point in time the finger was pointing towards us."When Michael was interviewed he initially said he did not know anything about the woods and was with two friends on the night of the when officers checked out his alibi it didn't stand up. Michael's mother Moira said: "I was very nervous when they thought Michael was a suspect."He has never been in trouble with the police."He's never been in the Indian restaurant. Ever."In a separate twist, Mr Spence told police he had not mentioned the missing box of bullets as PC Ross had visited him three times and asked him not if he had told his friend to lie about the bullets, Ross said: "No. We had conversations on the street and has he mistaken what I said?"I had no reason to ask him that."Officers obtained a search warrant for the family home and discovered a notebook in Michael's room with swastikas scribbled on 6 December 1994 the 16-year-old was taken from school and interviewed under caution without a Ross, who was at work at the time, said: "We were just in shock, I suppose, because I was sure he would never do anything like that." Mr Chisholm said the teenager was unfazed by the gravity of the added: "He was cool, calm and collected."The senior officer filed a report to the Crown Office but prosecutors decided there was not enough evidence to charge the teenager. Long wait for justice Michael left school in 1995 and joined the Army before being assigned to his father's old regiment, the Black PC Ross was suspended from Northern Constabulary after being charged with perverting the course of justice for asking Mr Spence to lie for 20 May 1997, after a trial in Inverness, he was jailed for three years and his 23-year police career was in who served two years in prison then became an undertaker, said: "With hindsight I should have dumped the box of ammunition and it is much my regret that I did not."But for me ditching it would not have been right, from my way of thinking, so which way do you turn?" Meanwhile, his corporal son was mentioned in dispatches for showing bravery following two improvised explosive attacks in North Babi, in 2006, 12 years after the murder, the cold case took a fresh twist when an anonymous letter was handed in to Kirkwall police author, later identified as local man William Grant, claimed to have seen the killer coming out of a public toilet cubicle on the night of the new evidence was enough to finally arrest Ross and he went on trial at the High Court in Glasgow in May Brian McConnachie KC, who led the prosecution, said he did not anticipate Mr Grant would be "such an unreliable witness". Under cross examination he admitted that he made up some of the things he originally told police. Escape from the dock Leah Seator, editor of The Orcadian, said many people on the island thought Ross would walk on 20 June the jury returned a guilty verdict - only for the moment to be overshadowed by an audacious escape he was about to be led away Ross knocked over a security guard, and jumped out of the pulled open a side door but was eventually stopped in a court McConnachie said: "I have been doing this for 40 years and I have never seen such a dramatic end to a trial."Back in Orkney, Mrs Ross took a devastating call from her said: "I did not believe that he would be sent to prison."When Ross returned to court four months later, amid heightened security, he was sentenced to 25 years plus a further five for his brazen bid to Hardie told the killer he had carried out a "premeditated assassination" motivated by "extreme racist prejudice". Since Ross' conviction his family have urged anyone with new evidence to come forward and in 2018 they appointed campaigning lawyer Aamer years later the former corporal was convicted of his third prison escape attempt after he tried to climb a fence at HMP Shotts in said: "It has not been easy but we have got to try and see if we can get him released a bit earlier."Mr McConnachie said the sad thing about the case was that it became more about the killer than Mr Mahmood, whose life was ended without the verdict, A.K.M Shafiuddin said: "Everybody loved him."We won't get our brother back but at least we have a feeling that justice has been done." The Orkney Assassin: Murder in the Isles will be available on Prime Video in the UK & Ireland on 8 June.
Daily Mail
28 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Salman Rushdie warns people are 'too eager to prohibit speech they disapprove of' as acclaimed author cautions against 'slippery slope' of cancel culture
Salman Rushdie has railed against those who attack free speech as he hit out at those that were 'too eager' to slap down voices they disapprove of. The Satanic Verses author, 77, warned of the 'very slippery slope' of cancel culture and urged to 'trust the audience to be able to make up their own minds'. Sir Salman issued the stark statement last week at the Hay Festival in Wales. In comments reported by The Observer, when asked about free speech, the Indian-born British author declared: 'I'm in favour of it.' And he also posed a question about the Lucy Connolly case, the wife of Conservative councillor Ray Connolly, who was handed a 31-month sentence after admitting posting an online rant about migrants hours after killer Axel Rudakubana murdered three young girls on July 29 last year. 'Here in Britain, we have the Race Relations Act, which makes it against the law to make racist statements. In the United States, there is the power of the First Amendment, which is why American racists are able to openly say what they have to say, and they're not prosecuted. 'The question is: which do you prefer?,' Sir Salman said. The 42-year-old former childminder deleted her post after four hours, but was arrested in August and pleaded guilty to a charge of inciting racial hatred in October. Mrs Connolly deleted her post and blamed it on 'a moment of extreme outrage and emotion' when she was acting on 'false and malicious' information She last month lost her appeal against her sentence, meaning she faces serving another eight months behind bars. It sparked a free speech row with Donald Trump ally and political commentator Charlie Kirk saying he was going to raise Connolly's case with the US Secretary of State Marco Rubio. Sir Salman last month said he was 'over' the horrific knife attack which left him blind in one eye after his attacker was jailed for 25 years. Hadi Matar, 27, was sentenced for attempted murder after he repeatedly stabbed the author on stage during a lecture in New York in 2022. Sir Salman recently told Radio 4's Today programme that he was 'pleased' the man who set out to kill him had received the maximum possible prison sentence. But he wishes to move on from the terrifying ordeal and focus on his new book coming out later this year. He also highlighted the ever increasing role AI is playing in society, and warned authors would be 'screwed' if the technology ever learned how to write a funny book. Speaking at the Hay Festival, he said: 'The machine can absorb a million jokes but it can't make one up, because you only get a version of the million old jokes. Hadi Matar, 27, was sentenced last month to 25 years for attempted murder after he repeatedly stabbed the author on stage during a lecture in New York in 2022 'Unfortunately, however, this thing learns very fast.' The award-winning Midnight's Children writer was left blind in one eye in the knife attack, had damage to his liver and was paralysed in one hand caused by nerve damage to his arm. The event had tight security, with sniffer dogs and bag searches. Once Sir Rushdie entered the stage to an audience of applause, he joked: 'I can't see everyone - but I can hear them.' Although he said he felt 'excellent' he added there 'were bits of me that I'm annoyed about, like not having a right eye. But on the whole, I've been very fortunate and I'm in better shape than maybe I would have expected.' Last year, he published a memoir called Knife about the ordeal, which he said was his way of 'fighting back'. It comes decades after the publication of his novel The Satanic Verses which made him the target of death threats as some Muslims consider blasphemous for its portrayal of the Prophet Muhammad. A short story collection called The Eleventh Hour is set to be released by the author in November.
