ABC proposes ‘modest' payout to Lattouf if it loses court battle, despite admitting it added to her psychological pain
The ABC accepts taking Antoinette Lattouf off air was a contributing factor in the psychological condition that underpins her claim for hurt and distress, the broadcaster has told the federal court.
In closing submissions for the ABC, Ian Neil SC said that in the event the corporation was found to have breached the Fair Work Act, the broadcaster did accept it was a contributing factor to the psychological distress Lattouf now suffers.
Lattouf, who is suing the ABC for unlawful termination, told the court in earlier evidence she suffered from paranoia and sleeplessness since she was removed from air three days into a five-day casual contract in December 2023. She had also become a heavier drinker, she said.
Neil did not submit there should be no compensation, but that there was no evidence the ABC was aware of a pre-existing psychological condition, and any compensation should be 'modest'.
Wrapping up the ABC case, Neil said the evidence showed there were 'many intermingled causes for the exacerbation of her pre-existing psychological condition'.
'One is the psychological condition itself, and the other is all the other things that operate on her mind: the burden of being a poster girl for justice, humanity and a free and fair press; the adverse consequences of attracting attention as an activist for one perspective of a hotly controversial issue.'When asked by Justice Darryl Rangiah if Lattouf, 41, was only caused distress because she had an underlying pre-existing psychological condition, Neil replied: 'Yes, that's the evidence in this case.'
Neil argued that the ABC's view was that Lattouf not sacked but she was 'relieved of the obligation to perform any further work'.
The removal – which was 'designed to protect the ABC' – had nothing to do with discrimination, race or political opinion, he said.
'She was relieved of the obligation to perform any further work. We have the right to do that. There was no express right for Ms Lattouf to actually perform work.
'It's not a case about discrimination, it's not a case about differential treatment,' he said. 'It's not an unfair dismissal case. It's not a case about the fairness of anything that was done in relation … to Ms Lattouf.'
The ABC asked Rangiah not to rely on testimony by Lattouf's line manager, Elizabeth Green. Earlier in the hearing, Green gave evidence that Lattouf was not given a direction not to post on social media about the Israel-Gaza war.
Throughout the hearing, both sides have explored the question: what is the difference between a direction and a suggestion?
Neil said no top ABC managers recall Green telling them that she did not give Lattouf a direction, and they were acting on the assumption she was given a direction not to post.
'She was told, in effect, not to post anything in relation to the conflict in Israel and Gaza during the week she was with the ABC,' he said.
Neil pointed to a text message sent by the chief content officer, Chris Oliver-Taylor, about Lattouf to the managing director, David Anderson. In it, Oliver-Taylor wrote: 'Confirming my view that she has breached our editorial policies whilst in our employment.
'She also failed to follow a direction from her manager not to post anything whilst working with the ABC. As a result of this I have no option but to stand her down.'
The text message was sent to Anderson minutes after a key ABC meeting, when Lattouf's fate was being decided.
Neil said that if Oliver-Taylor had heard Green say during that meeting that she did not give Lattouf a direction, why would he have immediately lied to the managing director in that text.
'What earthly reason would he have for lying, misrepresenting, what he had been told … two minutes before, to his superior,' he said.
Neil said the sole reason for Lattouf's dismissal was the posting of the Human Rights Watch (HRW) post. Lattouf was let go after she shared the post that said Israel had used starvation as a 'weapon of war' in Gaza.
Neil said the post was not the same as the ABC news report on the HRW report.
'This wasn't a like-for-like comparison, the ABC had not reposted the Human Rights Watch story as Ms Lattouf had done,' he said.
'They had done something much more nuanced and balanced than that.'
He said the 'the comparison was never a sound one'.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

Yahoo
13 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Israeli strikes kill 35 in Gaza, many near an aid site, medics say
CAIRO (Reuters) -Israeli military strikes killed at least 35 Palestinians in the Gaza Strip on Wednesday, most of them at an aid site operated by the U.S-backed Gaza Humanitarian Foundation in central Gaza, local health officials said. Medical officials at Shifa and Al-Quds Hospitals said at least 25 people were killed as they approached the aid site near the former settlement of Netzarim, and dozens were wounded. Ten other people were killed in other Israeli military strikes in Khan Younis in the south of the enclave, they added. The Israeli military had no immediate comment. On Tuesday, when Gaza health officials said 17 people were killed near another GHF aid site in Rafah in southern Gaza, the army said it fired warning shots to distance "suspects" who were approaching the troops and posed a threat. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said on Tuesday there had been "significant progress" in efforts to secure the release of the remaining hostages in Gaza, but that it was "too soon" to raise hopes that a deal would be reached. Despite efforts by the United States, Egypt, and Qatar to restore a ceasefire in Gaza, neither Israel nor Hamas has shown willingness to back down on core demands, with each side blaming the other for the failure to reach a deal. Two Hamas sources told Reuters they did not know about any new ceasefire offers. The war erupted after Hamas-led militants took 251 hostages and killed 1,200 people, most of them civilians, in an October 7, 2023, attack, Israel's single deadliest day. Israel's military campaign has since killed nearly 55,000 Palestinians, most of them civilians, according to health authorities in Gaza, and flattened much of the coastal enclave.


News24
3 hours ago
- News24
17 killed in Gaza as Palestinians scramble for ‘drop in the ocean' food aid
At least 17 people were killed as they approached an aid site in Gaza. The Israeli military described the roads leading to the sites as military zones. Witnesses said at least 40 trucks carrying flour for UN warehouses were looted. Israeli gunfire killed at least 17 Palestinians and wounded dozens of others as thousands of displaced people approached an aid distribution site of the US-backed Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF) in central Gaza on Tuesday, local health authorities said. Medics said the casualties were rushed at two hospitals, the Al-Awda Hospital in Nuseirat camp in central Gaza, and the Al-Quds in Gaza City, in the north. The Israeli military said they are looking into the incident. Last week it warned Palestinians not to approach routes leading to GHF sites between 18:00 and 06:00 local time, describing these roads as closed military zones. There was no immediate GHF comment on Tuesday's incident. The GHF began distributing food packages in Gaza at the end of May, overseeing a new model of aid distribution which the United Nations says is neither impartial nor neutral. However, many Gazans say they have to walk for hours to reach the sites, meaning they have to start travelling well before dawn if they are to stand any chance of receiving food. While the GHF has said there have been no incidents at its so-called secure distribution sites, Palestinians seeking aid have described disorder and access routes to the sites have been beset by chaos and deadly violence. 'I went there at 2am hoping to get some food, on my way there, I saw people returning empty-handed, they said aid packages have run out in five minutes, this is insane and isn't enough,' said Mohammad Abu Amr, 40, a father of two. 'Dozens of thousands arrive from the central areas and from the northern areas too, some of them walked for over 20km, only to come back home with disappointment,' he told Reuters via a chat app. He said he heard the firing but didn't see what happened. Moiz Salhi/Anadolu via Getty Images Israel allowed limited UN-led operations to resume on 19 May after an 11-week blockade in the enclave of 2.3 million people, where experts have warned a famine looms. The UN has described the aid allowed into Gaza as 'drop in the ocean'. Witnesses said at least 40 trucks carrying flour for UN warehouses were looted by desperate displaced Palestinians as well as thieves near Nabulsi roundabout along the coastal road in Gaza City. AFP reported that the Israeli military said it intercepted a 'projectile' on Tuesday that had entered Israeli airspace from Gaza, where it has fought Palestinian militant group Hamas for more than 20 months. 'Following the sirens that sounded at 10:53am (07:53 GMT) in the area of the Zikim beach, one projectile that crossed from the northern Gaza Strip into Israeli territory was intercepted,' the military said. The war erupted after Hamas-led militants took 251 hostages and killed 1 200 people, most of them civilians, in the 7 October 2023 attack, Israel's single deadliest day. Israel's military campaign has since killed more than 54 000 Palestinians, most of them civilians, according to health authorities in Gaza, and flattened much of the coastal enclave.
Yahoo
3 hours ago
- Yahoo
Olympic legend Mary Lou Retton speaks out for 1st time after DUI arrest
Olympic gymnastics icon Mary Lou Retton is breaking her silence following her DUI arrest in West Virginia last month. In an exclusive statement to ABC News, the 57-year-old said, "I take full responsibility for my actions. What happened was completely unacceptable. I make no excuses." Retton went on to express deep regret and a commitment to growth. "To my family, friends and my fans: I have let you down, and for that I am deeply sorry," she said in the statement. "I am determined to learn and grow from this experience, and I am committed to making positive changes in my life." "I truly appreciate your concern, encouragement and continued support," she added. Retton was stopped in Marion County, West Virginia, on May 17 and charged with one misdemeanor count of "driving under the influence of alcohol, controlled substances, or drugs," according to online court records at the time. She was released later that day after posting a $1,500 bond. On Tuesday, her attorney Edmund J. Rollo issued a statement to ABC News confirming that Retton pleaded no contest to a non-aggravated DUI charge and accepted full responsibility without seeking any special treatment. "Mary Lou Retton appeared in court this afternoon and entered a no contest plea to a non-aggravated DUI charge stemming from a recent incident," the statement read. "Mary Lou accepted full responsibility for her actions and received a standard $100 fine – consistent with sentencing guidelines for first-time, non-aggravated offenses in this jurisdiction." Mary Lou Retton speaks out for 1st time after life-threatening health scare "In keeping with her values, Mary Lou made no request for special treatment and was subject to the same legal process as any other individual. She is grateful for the professionalism of law enforcement and the court system, and she fully respects the outcome," the statement continued. "Mary Lou has expressed a sincere desire to use this experience as a moment for reflection and accountability. She asks for privacy as she moves forward with her personal and professional life." In October 2023, Retton survived what she would later describe as a life-threatening battle with pneumonia, which required nearly two weeks in the intensive care unit. Retton has remained an iconic figure in American sports history. At the 1984 Los Angeles Olympics, she became the first American woman to win the individual all-around gold medal in gymnastics, earning a series of perfect 10s. She also took home two silver medals and two bronze medals, making her the most decorated athlete of those Games, according to her official Olympics biography. In 1997, she was inducted into the International Gymnastics Hall of Fame, and in 2018, she appeared on season 27 of ABC's "Dancing with the Stars." Olympic legend Mary Lou Retton speaks out for 1st time after DUI arrest originally appeared on