logo
ABC proposes ‘modest' payout to Lattouf if it loses court battle, despite admitting it added to her psychological pain

ABC proposes ‘modest' payout to Lattouf if it loses court battle, despite admitting it added to her psychological pain

Yahoo28-02-2025

The ABC accepts taking Antoinette Lattouf off air was a contributing factor in the psychological condition that underpins her claim for hurt and distress, the broadcaster has told the federal court.
In closing submissions for the ABC, Ian Neil SC said that in the event the corporation was found to have breached the Fair Work Act, the broadcaster did accept it was a contributing factor to the psychological distress Lattouf now suffers.
Lattouf, who is suing the ABC for unlawful termination, told the court in earlier evidence she suffered from paranoia and sleeplessness since she was removed from air three days into a five-day casual contract in December 2023. She had also become a heavier drinker, she said.
Neil did not submit there should be no compensation, but that there was no evidence the ABC was aware of a pre-existing psychological condition, and any compensation should be 'modest'.
Wrapping up the ABC case, Neil said the evidence showed there were 'many intermingled causes for the exacerbation of her pre-existing psychological condition'.
'One is the psychological condition itself, and the other is all the other things that operate on her mind: the burden of being a poster girl for justice, humanity and a free and fair press; the adverse consequences of attracting attention as an activist for one perspective of a hotly controversial issue.'When asked by Justice Darryl Rangiah if Lattouf, 41, was only caused distress because she had an underlying pre-existing psychological condition, Neil replied: 'Yes, that's the evidence in this case.'
Neil argued that the ABC's view was that Lattouf not sacked but she was 'relieved of the obligation to perform any further work'.
The removal – which was 'designed to protect the ABC' – had nothing to do with discrimination, race or political opinion, he said.
'She was relieved of the obligation to perform any further work. We have the right to do that. There was no express right for Ms Lattouf to actually perform work.
'It's not a case about discrimination, it's not a case about differential treatment,' he said. 'It's not an unfair dismissal case. It's not a case about the fairness of anything that was done in relation … to Ms Lattouf.'
The ABC asked Rangiah not to rely on testimony by Lattouf's line manager, Elizabeth Green. Earlier in the hearing, Green gave evidence that Lattouf was not given a direction not to post on social media about the Israel-Gaza war.
Throughout the hearing, both sides have explored the question: what is the difference between a direction and a suggestion?
Neil said no top ABC managers recall Green telling them that she did not give Lattouf a direction, and they were acting on the assumption she was given a direction not to post.
'She was told, in effect, not to post anything in relation to the conflict in Israel and Gaza during the week she was with the ABC,' he said.
Neil pointed to a text message sent by the chief content officer, Chris Oliver-Taylor, about Lattouf to the managing director, David Anderson. In it, Oliver-Taylor wrote: 'Confirming my view that she has breached our editorial policies whilst in our employment.
'She also failed to follow a direction from her manager not to post anything whilst working with the ABC. As a result of this I have no option but to stand her down.'
The text message was sent to Anderson minutes after a key ABC meeting, when Lattouf's fate was being decided.
Neil said that if Oliver-Taylor had heard Green say during that meeting that she did not give Lattouf a direction, why would he have immediately lied to the managing director in that text.
'What earthly reason would he have for lying, misrepresenting, what he had been told … two minutes before, to his superior,' he said.
Neil said the sole reason for Lattouf's dismissal was the posting of the Human Rights Watch (HRW) post. Lattouf was let go after she shared the post that said Israel had used starvation as a 'weapon of war' in Gaza.
Neil said the post was not the same as the ABC news report on the HRW report.
'This wasn't a like-for-like comparison, the ABC had not reposted the Human Rights Watch story as Ms Lattouf had done,' he said.
'They had done something much more nuanced and balanced than that.'
He said the 'the comparison was never a sound one'.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Greta Thunberg among Gaza-flotilla activists deported from Israel
Greta Thunberg among Gaza-flotilla activists deported from Israel

Miami Herald

timean hour ago

  • Miami Herald

Greta Thunberg among Gaza-flotilla activists deported from Israel

June 10 (UPI) -- Swedish activist Greta Thunberg was on a flight to France on Tuesday en route home to Sweden after being deported from Israel a day after the Gaza-bound aid yacht she was on was intercepted by the Israeli military off the coast of Egypt and diverted to Israel. The Israeli Foreign Ministry said the 22-year-old left the country and posted photos on X of her boarding what appeared to be a commercial flight and sitting in an aisle seat with her belt fastened. It had been only around 12 hours since the British-flagged Madleen arrived at the southern Israeli port of Ashdod under Israeli naval escort late Monday. She was accompanied by at least one French citizen who had also voluntarily agreed to be deported, according to French Foreign Minister Jean-Noel Barrot, but in a post on X, he said five other French nationals in the group would be subject to "a forced expulsion process." Barrot said the detained French citizens had consular access. Le Monde reported that European Parliament Member Rima Hassan was among the French contingent detained. The status of the other five people aboard the vessel -- from Germany, the Netherlands, Spain, Turkey and Brazil -- was unclear, but the Foreign Ministry said those who refused to sign deportation documents and leave Israel would be brought before a judicial authority, in accordance with Israeli law, to authorize their deportation. It stressed that all the detainees had met with officials from their respective consulates. Israeli authorities, which have dismissed the mission by the Freedom Flotilla Coalition as a publicity stunt by celebrities, dubbing the effort the "selfie yacht," attempted to sway the activists by showing them a graphic 43-minute video of the Oct. 7, 2023, attacks on the orders of Israeli President Israel Katz. "I instructed the IDF to show the flotilla passengers the video of the horrors of the Oct. 7 massacre when they arrive at the port of Ashdod. It is appropriate that the anti-Semitic Greta and her fellow Hamas supporters see exactly who the Hamas terrorist organization they came to support and for whom they work is, what atrocities they committed against women, the elderly, and children, and against whom Israel is fighting to defend itself," Katz wrote on X. Katz claimed the group refused to continue watching once they found out what it was about. The FFC posted on social media in the early hours of Monday that the Madleen was under siege in international waters off Egypt, "surrounded by quadcopters", being doused with "a white irritant substance," and that its communications systems had been electronically jammed. "The ship was unlawfully boarded, its unarmed civilian crew abducted, and its life-saving cargo -- including baby formula, food and medical supplies -- confiscated," it said in a statement. Israel issued photos of activists being handed sandwiches and water by Israeli military personnel with a caption stating the group were on their way to Israel and "in good spirits, but the Israeli version of events was disputed by Thunberg in a video released by FFC. "If you see this video we have been intercepted and kidnapped in international waters by the Israeli occupational forces or forces that support Israel," she said in the 25 second clip on X in which she also urged her family and friends to lobby the Swedish government to push for their release as soon as possible. The Madleen set sail from Catania on Sicily, loaded with life-saving supplies on June 1 in an effort to break an 80-day blockade on international aid entering Gaza imposed by Israel after it pulled out of a U.S.-brokered cease-fire deal that lasted from January to March. In early May, Thunberg was scheduled to board another FFC vessel, the 1,000-ton Conscience, attempting to sail to Gaza when it was badly damaged in an alleged drone strike off Malta in the western Mediterranean. FFC said the vessel had been en route to Malta to pick up volunteers from at least 21 countries who had traveled to the island to join the mission when it was attacked, among them Thunberg and retired U.S. Army Colonel Mary Ann Wright. In May 2010, nine people involved in a similar mission to Gaza were killed and many others seriously wounded when Israeli forces intercepted the Mavi Marmara, part of a flotilla of six vessels, in international waters. A U.N. Panel of Inquiry ruled that the loss of life and injuries resulting from the use of force by Israeli forces during their takeover of the vessel were unacceptable and that they had provided no satisfactory explanation for any of the nine deaths, all of which were from gunshot wounds. "There was significant mistreatment of passengers by Israeli authorities after the takeover of the vessels had been completed through until their deportation. This included physical mistreatment, harassment and intimidation, unjustified confiscation of belongings and the denial of timely consular assistance." However, the report noted that Israeli Defense Forces personnel were confronted by significant, organized and violent resistance when they boarded the Mavi Marmara, requiring them to defend themselves, and that three soldiers were taken hostage and several others wounded. Copyright 2025 UPI News Corporation. All Rights Reserved.

Live updates: Israel attacks Yemeni port city of Hodeida, key to aid delivery
Live updates: Israel attacks Yemeni port city of Hodeida, key to aid delivery

The Hill

timean hour ago

  • The Hill

Live updates: Israel attacks Yemeni port city of Hodeida, key to aid delivery

Israel's navy attacked docks in Yemen's rebel-held port city of Hodeida on Tuesday, likely damaging facilities that are key to aid shipments to the hungry, war-wracked nation. This is the first time Israeli forces have been involved in attacks against the Iranian-backed Houthi rebels, who have repeatedly launched missiles and drones targeting Israel during its war on Hamas in Gaza. Inside Gaza, Palestinian health officials and witnesses said Israeli forces fired toward crowds making their way to a food distribution point run by an Israeli and U.S.-supported group, killing three people and wounding scores. And Israel deported activists including Greta Thunberg, the Foreign Ministry said, a day after the military seized their Gaza-bound ship protesting Israel's restrictions on aid to the territory. ___ Here's the latest: Activist Greta Thunberg has arrived in France after being deported from Israel. She says the conditions she and other activists faced as they tried to sail to Gaza 'are absolutely nothing compared to what people are going through in Palestine and especially Gaza right now.' Israel seized their boat on Monday. Thunberg says they were well aware of the risks. 'The aim was to get to Gaza and to be able to distribute the aid,' she said in Paris. She said the activists would continue trying to get aid to Gaza, where experts have warned of famine under Israeli restrictions on supplies into the territory of over 2 million people. Israel says it has been informed that the United Kingdom will sanction two of its Cabinet ministers. Foreign Minister Gideon Saar did not provide their names in public remarks. It appears the sanctions will target Itamar Ben-Gvir and Bezalel Smotrich, two far-right champions of Israeli settlements in Palestinian areas. Ben-Gvir and Smotrich both acknowledged the sanctions on social media, and Smotrich confirmed he was a target. Israeli police arrested a 13-year-old, accusing him of taking money to carry out tasks for Iran. A statement from the police and the domestic security agency Shin Bet Tuesday said the teen had been contacted on the messaging app Telegram by 'Iranian elements,' without elaborating. Police say the teen, a resident of Tel Aviv, was asked to take pictures of Israel's missile defense system Iron Dome, a task he did not carry out. They also accuse him of spraying graffiti at the behest of his Telegram contact. The teen was released on house arrest after being questioned, police said. Over recent months, Israel has arrested several people in connection with what it says are attempts by Iran and others to pay Israelis to spy on facilities and officials. The group behind the Gaza-bound ship that Israel seized says that four of its passengers, including Greta Thunberg, have been deported. The remaining eight are being detained while waiting to appear before a judge. They are expected to be deported within days. The Freedom Flotilla Coalition called on the Israeli authorities to release the passengers without deportation. It said their legal team will argue that the ship's interception was unlawful and the detentions arbitrary. Lawyers will also demand that they be allowed to complete their mission to Gaza, the group said in a statement. The Foreign Ministry of Thailand says that the remains of a Thai laborer who was taken hostage by Hamas will be sent back to Thailand on Tuesday. Nattapong Pinta came to Israel to work in agriculture. Israel's government said he was seized during Hamas' Oct. 7, 2023, attack from a kibbutz in southern Israel and killed early in the war. Israel said Saturday it had retrieved his remains in an operation in southern Gaza. Sergio Toribio, a Spanish activist who was on the Gaza-bound ship seized by Israel, arrived in Barcelona Tuesday after being deported. Speaking to reporters upon his arrival, he slammed Israel's interception of the boat. 'It is unforgivable, it is a violation of our rights. It is a pirate attack in international waters.' he said. He continued: 'We weren't doing anything wrong, we were just carrying provisions as a symbolic gesture.' Spanish media described Toribio as a 49-year-old ship mechanic. The Israeli military says it intercepted a projectile fired from the northern Gaza Strip that set off air raid sirens in nearby Israeli communities. There were no reports of casualties or damage. Rocket fire from Gaza has grown rare as Israel's 20-month military campaign has depleted the military capabilities of Hamas, which fired thousands of rockets during the Oct. 7, 2023, attack that ignited the war. Palestinian health officials and witnesses say Israeli forces fired toward crowds making their way to a food distribution point in the Gaza Strip early Tuesday, killing three people. The Israeli military did not immediately respond to a request for comment. The Awda Hospital in central Gaza, which received the casualties, said two men and a child were killed and at least 130 were wounded. The Associated Press spoke to two witnesses who said Israeli forces fired toward the crowds at around 2 a.m. hundreds of meters (yards) from the aid site. Experts and humanitarian aid workers say Israel's blockade and military campaign have pushed Gaza to the brink of famine. Around 130 people have been killed in a number of shootings near aid sites run by a new Israeli and U.S.-backed organization. The Israeli military has acknowledged firing warning shots on previous occasions at people who it says approached its forces in a suspicious manner. The Gaza Humanitarian Foundation, which runs the sites, says there has been no violence in or around the distribution points themselves. But it has warned people to stay on designated access routes and paused delivery last week while it held talks with the military on improving safety. French Foreign Minister Jean-Noel Barrot said Tuesday that one of the detained French activists who was on a Gaza-bound ship intercepted by Israel signed an expulsion order and will leave Israel on Tuesday for France. The other five refused and will await court decisions in the coming days. In a separate post on X, Barrot said the five will face a 'forced expulsion.' All six received consular visits overnight around 3 a.m., he said, as did the other activists aboard the ship. The French detainees were transferred overnight to a detention center in the Israeli city of Ramle, he said, and may receive another consular visit there. Activist Greta Thunberg is being deported from Israel, Israel's Foreign Ministry said Tuesday, after the Gaza-bound ship she was on was seized by the Israeli military. In a post on X, the Foreign Ministry shared a photo of Thunberg on a plane, saying that she was headed for France. Thunberg was one of 12 passengers on board the Madleen, a boat carrying aid destined for people in war-torn Gaza. The activists said they were protesting the ongoing war and the humanitarian crisis in Gaza. Israel says such ships violate its naval blockade of Gaza.

Israel deports activist Greta Thunberg after military seized Gaza Freedom Flotilla ship
Israel deports activist Greta Thunberg after military seized Gaza Freedom Flotilla ship

CBS News

time2 hours ago

  • CBS News

Israel deports activist Greta Thunberg after military seized Gaza Freedom Flotilla ship

Jerusalem — Israel deported activist Greta Thunberg on Tuesday, the country's Foreign Ministry said, a day after the Gaza-bound ship she was on with 11 other people was seized by the Israeli military. Thunberg left on a flight to France and was then headed to her home country of Sweden, the Foreign Ministry said in a post on X. It posted a photo of Thunberg, a climate activist who shuns air travel, seated on a plane. Thunberg was one of 12 passengers on the Madleen, a ship carrying aid to Gaza with a mission to protest Israel's ongoing war there and shed light on the humanitarian crisis in the Palestinian territory, according to the organizers, the Freedom Flotilla Coalition. Israeli naval forces seized the boat without incident early Monday about 125 miles off of Gaza's coast, according to the coalition, which, along with rights groups, condemned Israel's actions as a violation of international law. Israel rejects that charge because it says such ships intend to breach what it argues is its military's lawful naval blockade of Gaza. The boat, accompanied by Israel's navy, arrived in the Israeli port of Ashdod Monday evening, according to the Foreign Ministry. Swedish campaigner Greta Thunberg talks to journalists upon her arrival at Roissy-Charles de Gaulle Airport in Paris, France, after she was deported by Israel following her detention by Israeli forces, along with other activists who were aboard a Gaza-bound aid boat, June 10, 2025. HUGO MATHY/AFP/Getty The Freedom Flotilla Coalition said three activists, including Thunberg, had been deported along with a journalist. It said it had encouraged some of the group to do this so they could speak freely about their experiences. Eight other passengers refused deportation and were being held in detention before their case is to be heard by Israeli authorities. Adalah, a legal rights group in Israel representing the activists, said the eight were expected to be brought before a court later Tuesday. "Their detention is unlawful, politically motivated and a direct violation of international law," the coalition said in a statement. It called for the remaining passengers to be released without deportation and said their lawyers would demand that they be allowed to complete their journey to Gaza. Sabine Haddad, a spokeswoman for Israel's Interior Ministry, said the activists who were being deported Tuesday had waived their right to appear before a judge. Those who did not will face one and will be held for 96 hours before being deported, she said. Rima Hassan, a French member of the European Parliament who is of Palestinian descent, was also among the passengers on board the Madleen. She has previously been barred from entering Israel because of her opposition to Israeli policies toward the Palestinians. It was not clear whether she was being immediately deported or detained. French Foreign Minister Jean-Noel Barrot said Tuesday that one of the detained French activists signed an expulsion order and will leave Israel on Tuesday for France. The other five refused. He said all the activists received consular visits. Sergio Toribio, a Spanish activist who was deported, slammed Israel's actions after he arrived in Barcelona. Spanish activist Sergio Toribio arrives in Barcelona, Spain, from Tel-Aviv, at El Prat de Llobregat airport, June 10, 2025, after being deported by Israeli authorities. Kike Rincon/Europa Press/Getty "It is unforgivable, it is a violation of our rights. It is a pirate attack in international waters," Toribio told reporters. On Monday, Adalah, the rights group, said that Israel had "no legal authority" to take over the ship, because the group said it was in international waters and it was headed not to Israel but to the "territorial waters of the state of Palestine." "The arrest of the unarmed activists, who operated in a civilian manner to provide humanitarian aid, amounts to a serious breach of international law," Adalah said in a statement. Amnesty International said Israel was flouting international law with the naval raid and called on the country to release the activists immediately and unconditionally. Israel said its actions were consistent with international law. Israel viewed the ship as a publicity stunt, calling it the "selfie yacht." Israeli officials said that the flotilla was bringing "meager" aid with what amounted to less than a truckload of goods. The Flotilla has made it clear that its repeated attempts to reach the Palestinian territory by sea with vessels carrying aid and activists are aimed as much at raising awareness of the Israeli blockade as they are about getting any food into the enclave. Israel and Egypt have imposed varying degrees of a blockade on Gaza since Hamas seized power from rival Palestinian forces in 2007. Israel says the blockade is needed to prevent Hamas from importing arms, while critics say it amounts to collective punishment of Gaza's Palestinian population. Palestinians carry cans filled with water in Khan Younis, southern Gaza, June 8, 2025. Abed Rahim Khatib/Anadolu/Getty During the 20-month-long war in Gaza sparked by the Hamas-led Oct. 7, 2023, terrorist attack, Israel has restricted and sometimes blocked all aid into the territory, including food, fuel and medicine. Experts say that policy has pushed Gaza toward famine. Israel says Hamas siphons off the aid to bolster its rule. The Oct. 7 Hamas-led terrorist attack killed around 1,200 people, mostly civilians, in southern Israel, and saw 251 others taken hostage into Gaza, most of whom have since been released in ceasefire agreements or other deals. Hamas is still holding 55 hostages, but only about 20 are still believed to be alive. Israel's military campaign has killed more than 54,000 Palestinians, according to the Hamas-run Gaza Ministry of Health, which doesn't distinguish between civilians and combatants but has said that women and children make up most of the dead. The war has destroyed vast areas of Gaza and displaced around 90% of the territory's population, with many people being forced to flee multiple times. The entire population is almost completely dependent on international aid.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store