High court judge Roz Mawar praised for sound, solid judgment in denying PMX's immunity bid
TWO prominent lawyers are impressed with the grounds of Kuala Lumpur High Court judge Roz Mawar Rozain in rejecting Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim's bid to suspend the civil lawsuit by his former research assistant Yusoff Rawther who accused him of alleged sexual assault in 2018 at the PKR party office.
Former de facto law minister Datuk Zaid Ibrahim who was at Justice Roz Mawar's court yesterday (June 4) afternoon said he left the venue 'fully satisfied'.
'Her dismissal of Anwar's attempt to delay the hearing of Yusoff's civil claim of sexual assault is 100% correct,' the founder of one of Malaysia's largest legal firms, Zaid Ibrahim & Co, penned on X.
I was in Justice Roz Mawar's court this afternoon, and I left fully satisfied.
Her dismissal of Anwar Ibrahim's attempt to delay the hearing of Yusof's Lawther civil claim of sexual assault is hundred per cent correct
I always find her judgement sound ( except one), and she is…
— Zaid Ibrahim (@zaidibrahim) June 4, 2025
'I always find her judgement sound (except one) and she is undoubtedly one of our best judges.'
In dismissing Anwar's application to refer eight legal questions arising from a civil suit filed by Yusoff to the Federal Court, Justice Roz Mawar ruled that the questions posed by PMX failed to cross the threshold set out in Section 84 of the Courts of Judicature Act 1964.
'None of the articles cited in the Federal Constitution – as argued by the defendant's lawyers – gave rise to any real, substantial and justiciable questions of law that require a determination by the Federal Court,' she deduced.
In rejecting an application by Anwar's lawyer, Alan Wong, for a stay pending appeal on grounds that 'sorry, my hands are tied', Justice Roz Mawar said the trial of Yusoff Rawther's suit will begin at 9am on June 16 as scheduled.
She further ordered PMX to pay RM20,000 in costs to Yusoff.
In summing up, the opposition-slant Zaid now hopes that PMX will not proceed with the application to stay the proceeding which has been set for hearing on June 16 because there are no merits to his application.
'Furthermore, his lawyer had stated in open court that his client was ready to proceed with the trial. Why the need for deferment?' asked the former defence counsel of now incarcerated former premier Datuk Seri Najib Razak.
'As the leader of the Reformasi movement in the country, it does not look good for the PM to be seen as avoiding his accuser in (an) open court. After all, he had said on many occasions (that) the accusations were frivolous and untrue.'
'Beauty with brain'
Commenting on the KL High Court declining his application to refer eight constitutional questions to the Federal Court under Article 128(2) of the Federal Constitution, Anwar reiterated that the matter has never been about seeking personal immunity or escaping legal scrutiny.
'It concerns the integrity of our constitutional system and the need to ensure that high public office is protected from litigation that may be strategically timed, politically motivated or institutionally disruptive,' argued PMX in a statement.
STATEMENT ON HIGH COURT DECISION AND CONSTITUTIONAL REFERENCE
This afternoon, the High Court declined my application to refer 8 constitutional questions to the Federal Court under Article 128(2) of the Federal Constitution.
This matter has never been about seeking personal…
— Anwar Ibrahim (@anwaribrahim) June 4, 2025
'I remain fully committed to the rule of law, the independence of our courts and the dignity of democratic governance. The legal process will continue, and I'll continue to discharge my responsibilities without distraction or compromise.'
Meanwhile human rights activist and lawyer Siti Kasim described Justice Roz Mawar who was appointed as a High Court judge on Nov 12 last year as a 'beauty with brain' after having read her grounds of judgment.
'It's not only that she's pretty and beautiful but she's also very smart … Her decision is solid-molid [sic],' reacted the Orang Asli advocate with a caveat.
'Perhaps Yusoff Rawther will have his day in court, perhaps not because PMX's clever lawyers may appeal and then ask for stay although Justice Roz Mawar has insisted that the case will go on as scheduled on June 16.
'But still, I've strong feeling that the Court of Appeal shall uphold the judgment of Justice Roz Mawar because there's no other way for them to go around it; after all, her explanation is so detailed … Reading a solid judgment coming from a clever judge feels like reading a good book.
'Anyway, good luck to both Yusoff Rawther and PMX. May the righteous party win the case.' – June 5, 2025
Main image credit: SK Studio/YouTube; Suruhanjaya Pelantikan Kehakiman
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New Straits Times
9 hours ago
- New Straits Times
Penang to review housing discount for Indian Muslims at next exco meeting
GEORGE TOWN: The Penang state government has agreed to review and discuss the five per cent housing discount for first-time Indian Muslim homebuyers at the upcoming state executive council (exco) meeting. State DAP chairman Steven Sim Chee Keong said he had discussed the matter with Chief Minister Chow Kon Yeow. "I acknowledge the public feedback regarding the five per cent discount given to the Indian Muslim community for the purchase of unsold property units (overhang) in Penang. "I have discussed this matter with YAB Chow (Kon Yeow), and he has agreed to bring this issue up for review and discussion at the upcoming exco meeting," he said in a statement. As a party founded on the Federal Constitution, Sim said DAP had always championed justice and the welfare of all Malaysians, regardless of race or religion. "It is important for the Penang state government to continue upholding the principle of social justice and to ensure the rights of every Malaysian to own a home are protected," he added. does not involve units under the Bumiputera quota and does not affect any existing home ownership policies. He said the initiative was part of efforts to expand home ownership opportunities in the open market, particularly for groups with low participation rates, without affecting the rights of other communities.
The Sun
13 hours ago
- The Sun
PM Anwar seeks stronger ASEAN-GCC push to end Gaza atrocities
PUTRAJAYA: Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim has called for stronger cooperation between ASEAN countries and the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) to end Israel's atrocities in Gaza. Speaking to reporters after performing Aidiladha prayers at Masjid Putra here today, Anwar said that regional and international collective efforts are crucial to ending the prolonged conflict and the suffering of the Palestinian people. 'We've conveyed our stance (through a Wisma Putra statement), but this cannot be the effort of just one country. As we saw in recent engagements with Gulf nations, there is a shared consensus. 'So ASEAN, the Gulf states, and a few other countries can come together to provide a clear message and exert strong pressure on the world to put a stop to it (Israel's brutality),' he said. He was responding to the United States' use of its veto power on a United Nations Security Council (UNSC) draft resolution calling for an immediate ceasefire in Gaza and the lifting of restrictions on humanitarian aid.
Borneo Post
13 hours ago
- Borneo Post
PM Anwar seeks stronger Asean-GCC push to end Gaza atrocities
This picture taken from a position near Israel's southern border with the Gaza Strip shows smoke rising over Gaza on July 9, 2024. – AFP photo PUTRAJAYA (June 7): Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim has called for stronger cooperation between Asean countries and the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) to end Israel's atrocities in Gaza. Speaking to reporters after performing Aidiladha prayers at Masjid Putra here today, Anwar said that regional and international collective efforts are crucial to ending the prolonged conflict and the suffering of the Palestinian people. 'We've conveyed our stance (through a Wisma Putra statement), but this cannot be the effort of just one country. As we saw in recent engagements with Gulf nations, there is a shared consensus. 'So Asean, the Gulf states, and a few other countries can come together to provide a clear message and exert strong pressure on the world to put a stop to it (Israel's brutality),' he said. He was responding to the United States' use of its veto power on a United Nations Security Council (UNSC) draft resolution calling for an immediate ceasefire in Gaza and the lifting of restrictions on humanitarian aid. Malaysia has expressed deep regret and disappointment over the repeated failure of the UNSC to adopt a resolution calling for an immediate and lasting ceasefire, as well as the removal of restrictions on humanitarian aid to Gaza. In a statement last Thursday, the Foreign Ministry stressed that the UNSC's repeated failure to act on one of the worst humanitarian tragedies since World War II, due to the use of veto power, is truly regrettable and deeply disappointing. Anwar also said that the continued actions of countries supplying arms to Israel are unacceptable and run counter to the principles of international law. 'It's contradictory when they issue statements of condemnation, yet continue to supply or sell weapons to Israel. Such actions violate the principles of international law and humanitarian norms. 'We strongly condemn (the atrocities) and seek diplomatic avenues to support the Palestinian struggle and help them reclaim their legitimate rights, including in Gaza,' Anwar said. Separately, during Aidiladha phone conversations with leaders of other Muslim nations, including Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan, Iranian President Masoud Pezeshkian and Pakistani Prime Minister Shehbaz Shari, Anwar said each expressed concern over the violence committed by the Zionist regime. 'All of them conveyed a clear stance … and we have agreed to continue consultations to find a resolution to this crisis as soon as possible,' he added. – Bernama anwar ibrahim asean Gaza GCC palestine
