Closing arguments take place in Banff stabbing trial
Social Sharing
A B.C. man on trial for murder "took a knife out and used it in a fist fight," prosecutor Kaitlyn Perrin told jurors Monday during closing arguments in the case of a fatal stabbing in Banff in 2022.
John Sproule, 23, admitted to killing the 27-year-old man outside of a Banff bar in September 2022 but has maintained throughout the trial that he acted in self-defence.
"Ryden Brogden's death is tragic," said defence lawyer Cory Wilson. "But tragedy is not evidence of murder."
Closing arguments took place Monday. Wilson asked jurors to acquit his client while Perrin asked the panel to find him guilty of second-degree murder.
On the September long weekend in 2022, Sproule was in Banff with his parents and other members of his family. Sproule and his brother were bar-hopping on the night of the killing.
Brogden, from Priddis, Alta., was with his friend in Banff for the night en route to B.C. for a fishing trip.
The victim and accused had never met before the violent interaction in Banff.
In the early morning hours of Sept. 3, the two pairs were outside the Dancing Sasquatch when Sproule tried to bum a cigarette from Brogden.
A physical altercation ensued.
Sproule testified that he was pushed and sucker punched by Brogden, who told him to "f–k off."
In response, Sproule testified he said, "What the f–k is wrong with you?"
"Johnny Sproule was violently and brutally attacked by Ryden Brogden for absolutely no reason," Wilson told jurors.
'Narrative of lies'
From there, Sproule said, Brogden "ragdolled" him around, punching him repeatedly and then pulled his shirt over his head so he couldn't see.
Sproule said he couldn't get away and pulled out his work knife from his jeans pocket and swung it at Brogden.
The victim suffered 19 stab and slash wounds.
"In the course of a fist fight, Mr. Sproule took out a knife and began using it against his opponent," said Perrin. "This is not a reasonable response given the brief nature of this fight."
A key witness for the Crown, Howard Pearse, testified he heard Sproule threaten to "shank" Brogden.
But even Pearse told a "narrative of lies," argued Wilson.
The Crown conceded that Pearse was "impeached on multiple occasions" but still asked jurors to accept his testimony about the shank threat.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Montreal Gazette
3 hours ago
- Montreal Gazette
Man accused of McGill ghetto murder references synchronicity, quantum physics during testimony
Montreal Crime By François Pelletier continued his very confusing testimony Thursday in the trial where he is accused of stabbing Romane Bonnier to death in the McGill Ghetto in front of several stunned witnesses more than three years ago. Pelletier, 39, is acting as his own lawyer in the case at the Montreal courthouse, where he is charged with first-degree murder. On Wednesday, he made an opening statement to the jury during which he bluntly admitted he killed the 24-year-old woman by stabbing her 26 times. After he delivered the opening statement, he was sworn in and began to testify in his own defence. Without the aid of a lawyer, he set off on what has been a very long monologue. No one is asking Pelletier questions and while he told the jury he wants to explain what happened to Bonnier before they decide his fate, his testimony has been full of asides about things like what songs he was listening to after Bonnier agreed to let him be her roommate and he became obsessed with her. 'Let's just say there are many layers to this reality we are living,' he told the jury at one point. He said he was listening to Radiohead's Creep, Chris Isaak's Wicked Game and a song called Sunspots by Nine Inch Nails. '(Sunspots) is a rather powerful song,' he said, Besides the songs, Pelletier referenced synchronicity and quantum physics and claimed both were involved in his attraction to Bonnier. He also made references to his mental health, which led prosecutor Marianna Ferrero to object twice. Superior Court Justice François Dadour sustained both of the objections, a sign that Pelletier is not supposed to refer to his mental health. On Wednesday, Pelletier told the jury he would have preferred that a psychiatric evaluation on his mental health had been part of the evidence. Ferrero later made another objection when she noted that Pelletier has used the word 'f--k' many times while testifying. The Crown's theory is that, during 2021, Bonnier placed an ad seeking a roommate to share the rent on an apartment she was already living in. Pelletier replied to the ad and Bonnier agreed to let him live with her. They had a brief relationship, but Bonnier eventually put an end to it. Pelletier was unable to accept the breakup and texted Bonnier frequently. The Crown alleges that on Oct. 19, 2021, he staked out her workplace, a store owned by her parents, and followed her after she left before he stabbed her to death. 'She was a sophisticated schemer,' Pelletier said Thursday morning while claiming, as he does often, that Bonnier sometimes dressed in a way to attract him. 'She was dressed to kill. She was dressed to kill me,' Pelletier said during another part of his testimony. 'She was wearing a red dress that I remember to this day.'
Global News
18 hours ago
- Global News
Lawyer who attacked 80-year-old with knife in Deep Cove pleads guilty
See more sharing options Send this page to someone via email Share this item on Twitter Share this item via WhatsApp Share this item on Facebook A North Vancouver lawyer who attacked an 80-year-old man with a knife in Deep Cove last year has pleaded guilty to multiple charges. Alexander Currie admitted to attacking the senior on May 25, 2024, slashing his motorcycle helmet and narrowly missing causing him serious injury. On Wednesday, he entered guilty pleas to assault with a weapon, uttering threats and mischief. Currie had initially been charged with attempted murder. 0:56 Knife-wielding North Vancouver man facing charges after Deep Cove incident The court heard that he was having a manic episode at the time of the attack. Currie has a history of mental illness, but hadn't suffered an episode in 17 years. Story continues below advertisement The knife attack victim read a statement to the court, describing it as terrifying, after which Currie apologized for the trauma he'd caused. Get breaking National news For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy The Crown and defence made a joint submission to the court, calling for a conditional discharge and citing Currie's lack of a criminal record and his determination to rebuild his life. The judge will hand down the sentence on June 13th. With files from Rumina Daya
Montreal Gazette
a day ago
- Montreal Gazette
‘I killed Romane. I stabbed her 26 times,' says accused in McGill Ghetto murder trial
Montreal Crime By The man on trial for the murder of Romane Bonnier, a woman who was stabbed 26 times in front of several witnesses in the McGill Ghetto, began his defence Wednesday afternoon by bluntly stating that he killed her. 'I killed Romane. I stabbed her 26 times,' François Pelletier, 39, told a jury at the Montreal courthouse. He said his testimony was part of a story called 'the moth and the flame.' Pelletier made the rambling introduction before he was sworn in. 'My objective is to explain what happened,' he said, while telling the jury to expect 'a freestyle rendering.' He also referred to his story as 'a train wreck in four parts.' Superior Court Justice François Dadour reminded the jury that the Crown finished presenting its evidence in the trial last week. The prosecution's theory is that Pelletier met Bonnier after she posted an ad seeking a roommate to share her apartment and they ended up in a brief relationship. It came to a quick end and Bonnier received many text messages from Pelletier demanding that they get back together. The Crown alleges Pelletier then waited outside Bonnier's workplace for a long time and followed her as she headed home before he stabbed her many times on Oct. 19, 2021. The attack was captured by a surveillance camera and the video was shown to the jury. 'It ends insane because (the relationship) started insane,' Pelletier told the jury. He also referenced the popular song Creep by Radiohead, sung from the perspective of an alienated man attracted to a woman he knows he has ultimately no chance with. Pelletier said he believes Bonnier 'had a crush' on him from the moment they met despite the significant differences in age. She was 24 when she was killed. Days after she agreed to let him live in the apartment, Pelletier said, Bonnier put on makeup and did her hair to prepare to go out with friends. A COVID-19 health measure had been lifted, Pelletier said, and Montreal's terrasses were opening up for the first time in a long time. Pelletier said it seemed to him that Bonnier wanted him to see her with makeup and her hair prepared for a night out. 'I knew that she was the most beautiful girl I had ever seen,' Pelletier said. 'That's where it gets special. 'This was something special. It ended the way you saw it (in the surveillance video).' Pelletier also admitted that he ended up being obsessed with Bonnier. 'This girl just occupied all the space in my mind,' he said. 'A psychiatric evaluation would have been interesting to you, but we don't have that right now.' This story was originally published June 4, 2025 at 2:58 PM.
