How will the universe end? A changing understanding of dark energy may provide a new answer
Scientists are homing in on the nature of a mysterious force called dark energy, and nothing short of the fate of the universe hangs in the balance.
The force is enormous — it makes up nearly 70% of the universe. And it is powerful — it is pushing all the stars and galaxies away from each other at an ever faster rate.
And now scientists are getting a little closer to understanding how it behaves. The big question is whether this dark energy is a constant force, which scientists have long thought, or whether the force is weakening, a surprising wrinkle tentatively proposed last year.
Results presented at a meeting of the American Physical Society Wednesday bolster the case that the force is weakening, though scientists are not yet certain and they still haven't worked out what this means for the rest of their understanding of the universe.
The updated findings come from an international research collaboration that is creating a three-dimensional map to see how galaxies have spread and clustered over 11 billion years of the universe's history. Carefully tracking how galaxies move helps scientists learn about the forces that are moving them around.
Called the Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument, the collaboration released its first analysis of 6 million galaxies and quasars last year and has now added more data, bringing the count to nearly 15 million. Their updated results, taken with other measurements — exploding stars, leftover light from the young universe and distortions in galaxy shape — support the idea presented last year that dark energy may be waning.
'It's moving from a really surprising finding to almost a moment where we have to throw out how we've thought about cosmology and start over,' said Bhuvnesh Jain, a cosmologist with the University of Pennsylvania who was not involved with the research.
It's not time to completely rule out the idea that dark energy is constant because the new results are still shy of the gold standard level of statistical proof physics requires. The collaboration aims to map around 50 million galaxies and quasars by the end of its survey in 2026. And other efforts around the globe have an eye on dark energy and aim to release their own data in the coming years, including the European Space Agency's Euclid mission and the Vera C. Rubin Observatory in Chile.
'We want to see several different collaborations having similar measurements' at that gold standard to be sure that dark energy is weakening, said cosmologist Kris Pardo with the University of Southern California who was not involved with the new research.
If dark energy is constant, scientists say our universe may continue to expand forever, growing ever colder, lonelier and still.
If dark energy ebbs with time, which now seems plausible, the universe could one day stop expanding and then eventually collapse on itself in what's called the Big Crunch. It might not seem like the cheeriest fate, but it offers some closure, said cosmologist and study collaborator Mustapha Ishak-Boushaki of the University of Texas at Dallas.
'Now, there is the possibility that everything comes to an end,' he said. 'Would we consider that a good or bad thing? I don't know.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NBC News
17 hours ago
- NBC News
These cosmic monsters are creating the biggest explosions since the big bang
The vast emptiness of space is growing emptier one star at a time. That's because 80 billion lightyears from Earth, three cosmic beasts are devouring stars ten times the size of the sun. In a new study by the University of Hawaii, among others, astronomers scouring through NASA and European Space Agency's data said they had discovered three supermassive black holes. Those behemoths feast on stars of such a size that make the one at the center of the solar system look like a light snack. The explosions those scientists have recorded, which happened when those black holes shredded and sucked up the fabric of those stars, are the largest since the big bang that created the universe. 'What I think is so exciting about this work is that we're pushing the upper bounds of what we understand to be the most energetic environments of the universe,' Anna Payne, a staff scientist at the Space Telescope Science Institute and a co-author of the study, said in the NASA article. Black holes are astronomical objects invisible to the human eye. They have a gravitational pull so strong that they swallow everything, including light. A supermassive black hole is the biggest of all black holes, sitting at the center of galaxies like the one at the heart of the Milky Way slowly sucking planets and all other matter toward it. When a star gets trapped in the pull of a supermassive black hole, it can disintegrate with a spectacular explosion in a cosmic event that scientists in a new study published this week in the journal Science Advances call 'extreme nuclear transient.' 'These events are the only way we can have a spotlight that we can shine on otherwise inactive massive black holes,' University of Hawaii graduate student Jason Hinkle said in a separate NASA article. Hinkle is the lead author of the new study that describes for the first time two such events that took place over the past decade. Two of the three supermassive black holes were detected in 2016 and 2018 by an ESA mission and are documented for the first time in the study. The third, nicknamed 'Barbie' because of its catalog identifier ZTF20abrbeie, was identified in 2020 by a Caltech observatory in California and subsequently documented in 2023. The blasts are so powerful that the only cosmic event larger in magnitude has been the big bang that sparked the dawn of the universe. Unlike in other stellar explosions, though, the way X-ray, optical light and ultraviolet rays dimmed and brightened in these incidents made it clear this event was a 'black hole ripping a star apart,' the NASA article said. NASA says black holes actually brighten during these cosmic events and that brightness lasts for several months. That brightness has given scientists a new way to find more black holes in the early distant universe. When astronomers peer into space, they are looking back in time because the further away they look, the older the light is reaching them — the light reaching Earth from the sun, for example, is eight minutes old. 'We can take these three objects as a blueprint to know what to look for in the future,' Payne said.
Metro
3 days ago
- Metro
Satellite images capture Mount Etna's eruption from space
Hiyah Zaidi Published June 4, 2025 2:55pm Link is copied Comments Tourists were seen running for their lives after Mount Etna erupted on Monday. The Sicilian volcano is Europe's largest and most active stratovolcano, and has recently spewed a giant plume of gas that stretched four miles into the sky. But, just as the volcano erupted, the Copernicus Sentinel-2C satellite was passing by and managed to capture the whole thing in dramatic images (Picture: EU/Copernicus Sentinel-2 / SWNS) On June 2, at around 12pm local time, the volcano erupted following volcanic tremors which began around midnight. The eruption sent a pyroclastic flow - which is a mix of hot rock, ash and gas - down the side of the mountain. The cloud it produced, which was mainly made up of water and sulphur dioxide, headed south west and was so big it plunged the nearby town of Catania into darkness (Picture: European Space Agency) One concern of the eruption was the disruption of air traffic. Dr Stuart Black, geological expert at the University of Reading, said: 'Commercial aircraft typically fly at similar altitudes as where the volcanic material is reaching, so persistent activity could force flight rerouting in the region.' However, the eruption has led to no reported injuries or damage, and barely disrupted flights on or off the island (Picture: European Space Agency) The eruption began with an increase of pressure in the hot gases inside the volcano, according to The Conversation. This led to the partial collapse of part of one of the craters atop Etna on the south eastern edge of the volcano, which led to the pyroclastic flow. However, the lava flowed in three directions, and began to cool down. Pyroclastic flows can be extremely dangerous and can travel at an average of 60 miles per hour, reaching temperatures up to 1,000°C (Picture: European Space Agency) However, the flows did not make it beyond the Valle del Leone (or Lion Valley) which forms a natural containment area. But the volcano has been active recently, with the latest eruption marking the 14th episode since mid-March. The most recent pyroclastic flows with significant reach were recorded on February 10, 2022, October 23, 2021, December 13, 2020 and February 11, 2014, Marco Viccaro, president of Italy's national volcanology association, said on Tuesday (Picture: European Space Agency) Mount Etna reaches around 3,350 meters (11,050 feet) above sea level and is 35 kilometers (22 miles) in diameter. It is the highest Mediterranean island mountain and the most active stratovolcano in the world. It has documented eruptions dating back to 1500 BCE. The largest recorded historical eruption of the volcano occurred in 1669, when a number of big eruptions took place for around four months. It's thought that around fourteen villages and towns were destroyed by the lava flows or by earthquakes, and around 20,000 people were killed by the eruptions (Picture: AP) At the moment, researchers cannot give accurate details on when a volcano is about to blow. However, there are some warning signs, such as earthquakes when the magma pushes its way up to the surface. The magma also makes the ground near a volcano bulge upwards very slightly, by a few millimetres or centimetres, which can be monitored using satellites. However, new research suggests that trees may act as a good early warning detection system, as the magma beneath the surface releases a lot of carbon dioxide, which makes the trees more green – and this can be monitored through satellites (Picture: Getty)
Daily Mail
3 days ago
- Daily Mail
Scientists claim the Big Bang theory is WRONG - as they reveal how the universe really began
For decades, almost every scientist has agreed that the universe began in an enormous explosion known as the Big Bang. But one group of researchers now controversially claims that everything we think about the birth of the cosmos might be wrong. In a radical new research paper, Professor Enrique Gaztanaga, of the University of Portsmouth and his co-authors have proposed a new theory they call the 'Black Hole Universe'. They claim that the universe was formed by a gravitational crunch, forming a massive black hole that then 'bounced' outwards. Professor Gaztanaga claims this theory can explain everything we know about the structure of the universe without the need for any exotic elements such as dark energy. Importantly, the theory also predicts that space should be slightly curved rather than completely flat as the Big Bang model suggests. This is something that current NASA missions such as Euclid may soon be able to confirm, possibly offering a strong hint that the Black Hole Universe theory is correct. However, the Black Hole Universe theory may also have some staggeringly strange consequences for humanity's place in the universe. According to the Big Bang theory, before the universe as we know it came to be, all the matter that currently exists was packed into an infinitely dense point called a 'singularity'. From this point, around 13.8 billion years ago, the universe exploded outwards in an extraordinarily rapid phase of expansion known as cosmic inflation. The shape etched into matter as that initial explosion cooled laid out the patterns that would become stars, galaxies, and even larger structures like galactic superclusters. Since then, as observations from space telescopes like Hubble have shown, the universe has been expanding outwards at a steadily accelerating rate. This so-called 'standard model of cosmology' works well for explaining many big questions such as why galaxies are where they are, but Professor Gaztanaga wasn't satisfied. The problem was that the standard model only works well when scientists make some big assumptions about how the world might work. For example, to explain why the universe is still accelerating scientists have been forced to add mysterious 'dark energy' to the picture - a force that is pushing against gravity but has never been directly observed. So, instead of looking at the expanding universe and trying to work out where it comes from, the researchers looked at what happens when matter collapses in on itself. The Black Hole Universe Theory The Black Hole Universe theory claims that the cosmos did not begin with the Big Bang. The Big Bang theory says the universe exploded outwards from a single, infinitely dense point. The Black Hole Universe suggests that the universe we now see started after a cloud of matter collapsed into a black hole. At a certain point that black hole couldn't compress any more and started to bounce outwards. Our entire universe is inside this black hole, which is nested inside a larger host universe. When large stars collapse in on themselves, they form black holes - objects so dense that not even light can escape their gravitational pull. According to the standard view proposed by Stephen Hawking and British physicist Roger Penrose, when this happens gravity squishes matter down into an infinitely dense point. This would mean that singularities, like the one in the Big Bang theory, are a natural and inevitable part of the universe. However, some scientists now think that the rules of quantum physics mean you can't keep squishing matter together forever. According to quantum physics, you can't pin down a quantum particle to a single point and two particles can't occupy the exact same location. This means that black holes must stop collapsing before gravity squishes matter into a single infinitely dense point. Professor Gaztanaga told MailOnline: 'Infinities may appear in mathematics, but they have no physical meaning. Nature doesn't work with infinite masses or infinite precision.' Therefore, when a cloud of matter like the universe collapses under gravity it will squeeze on itself until it forms a black hole before hitting this limit and bouncing back. What forms out of that bounce is a universe which looks remarkably like our own, suggesting this could be a possible way our universe began. Professor Gaztanaga says this Black Hole Universe Theory is better than the Big Bang because it solves some 'major questions the Big Bang model leaves unanswered'. Most importantly, this theory gives a natural explanation for the two phases of the universe's expansion: the rapid phase of cosmic expansion and the later acceleration we are now observing. According to the researchers' mathematical solutions, both of these phases emerge from the physics of the bounce itself rather than from other factors like dark energy. Professor Gaztanaga says: 'Inflation is simply part of the same dynamical process - the collapse and bounce - so it doesn't need to be added as a separate mechanism.' However, this theory has some fairly wild consequences for our understanding of the universe as a whole. According to the Black Hole Universe, the entire observable universe is inside a black hole nested inside a large parent universe which could, itself, be inside another black hole. Professor Gaztanaga says: 'We don't know for sure, but the theory allows for black holes within black holes - a nested, possibly endless structure. 'The key insight is that our universe may not be the beginning of everything. We are not unique, just part of a larger system. 'It's a continuation of the Copernican principle: Earth is not the centre of the cosmos, our galaxy is not the only one, and our universe may not be either.' Critically, the Black Hole Universe theory makes predictions about the shape of the universe that we should soon be able to test. The researchers say that the 'smoking gun' would be that the structure of the universe should be ever so slightly curved. That would mean the angles in a giant cosmic triangle would add up to slightly less than the 180 degrees that they would make on a flat surface. Soon, with space telescopes such as Euclid or the European Space Agency's upcoming Arrakhis mission scientists will be able to see whether this is true, potentially re-writing our understanding of the universe. The Big Bang Theory is a cosmological model, a theory used to describe the beginning and the evolution of our universe. It says that the universe was in a very hot and dense state before it started to expand 13,7 billion years ago. This theory is based on fundamental observations. In 1920, Hubble observed that the distance between galaxies was increasing everywhere in the universe. This means that galaxies had to be closer to each other in the past. In 1964, Wilson and Penzias discovered the cosmic background radiation, which is a like a fossil of radiation emitted during the beginning of the universe, when it was hot and dense. The cosmic background radiation is observable everywhere in the universe. The composition of the universe - that is, the the number of atoms of different elements - is consistent with the Big Bang Theory. So far, this theory is the only one that can explain why we observe an abundance of primordial elements in the universe.
