European journalists targeted with Paragon Solutions spyware, say researchers
The hacking mystery roiling the Italian prime minister Giorgia Meloni's rightwing government is deepening after researchers said they found new evidence that two more journalists were targeted using the same military-grade spyware that Italy has admitted to using against activists.
A parliamentary committee overseeing intelligence confirmed earlier this month that Italy used mercenary spyware made by Israel-based Paragon Solutions against two Italian activists.
But the same committee, which launched an investigation into the hacking scandal in March, said it was unable to determine who was behind the targeting of a prominent Italian investigative journalist named Francesco Cancellato, whose news outlet has been critical of the Meloni government.
Now a report by researchers at the Citizen Lab has revealed that a close colleague of Cancellato, Ciro Pellegrino, who is head of the investigative outlet Fanpage.it's Naples bureau, was also targeted by a user of Paragon Solution's spyware, which is called Graphite. The Citizen Lab said a third journalist, who chose to remain anonymous and is described as a 'prominent European journalist', had also been targeted with the spyware.
The news comes as Paragon and the Italian government have been engaged in an acrimonious public spat. Haaretz reported this week that Paragon had offered to assist the Italian government in investigating Cancellato's case. Italy reportedly rejected that offer, however, with the Italian department of security intelligence saying that it raised national security concerns.
Meloni's office did not reply to a request for comment. A debate on the matter, which has prompted outrage among the Italian opposition and MEPs in Brussels, has been scheduled in the European parliament on 16 June.
The Guardian approached Paragon for comment on the latest development. It referred to comments it made to Haaretz, in which it confirmed it cancelled its contract with the Italian government after reports first emerged in February that Cancellato had been targeted. The Guardian first reported that Paragon was terminating its contract with Italy in February.
Like other spyware vendors, Paragon sells its cyberweapon to government clients who are supposed to use it to prevent crime. The company has said it sells its spyware only to democratic countries and that its terms of service forbids agencies to use the spyware against journalists or members of civil society.
The question now remains who is behind the targeting of the two journalists.
John Scott-Railton, a senior researcher at the Citizen Lab, said: 'We found that both journalists phones bore Paragon's unmistakable digital fingerprints. Making matters even more interesting, we found fingerprints matching the same Paragon customer in both cases.'
A report released by the Copasir parliamentary committee found that Italy's domestic and foreign intelligence agencies had contracts with Paragon in 2023 and 2024, and that the hacking software was used with the permission of a prosecutor and in limited circumstances. The committee said the spyware had been used to search for fugitives, investigate alleged terrorism, organised crime, fuel smuggling and counter-espionage efforts.
It said the pro-immigrant human rights activists who were targeted – they included Luca Cassarini and Giuseppe Caccia – had been spied on due to their connection to 'irregular immigration' and not because they were involved in human rights.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Reuters
an hour ago
- Reuters
Killings at European schools fan concern US problem is spreading
ZURICH, June 13 (Reuters) - A spate of school killings in Western Europe has raised pressure on authorities to tackle a problem long seen as a largely U.S. phenomenon, increasing momentum for tougher gun and security laws and more policing of social media. While mass shootings remain far more common in the United States, four of the worst school shootings in Western Europe this century have occurred since 2023 and two - a massacre of 11 people in Austria and another in Sweden - were this year. This week's killings in the Austrian city of Graz sparked calls for tighter gun laws by political leaders, mirroring the response of the Swedish government after the 11 deaths at the Campus Risbergska school in Orebro in February. "Mass shootings, of which school shootings are a part, were overwhelmingly a U.S. problem in the past, but the balance is shifting," said Adam Lankford, a criminologist at the University of Alabama. "The number in Europe and elsewhere is increasing." Part of the rise stems from copycat attacks in Europe often inspired by notorious U.S. rampages such as the 1999 Columbine High School massacre, according to shooters' own comments or their internet search histories, Lankford said. "It's like an export from America. These attackers see other people do it and it has a snowball effect." According to research by Lankford and Jason Silva, shootings carried out by people eager for notoriety were twice as numerous in the United States as in the rest of the world between 2005 and 2010. By 2017-2022, the rest of the world had caught up. Their data also shows that Europe accounts for a bigger share of mass shootings than it used to. It should be easier for European politicians to act against mass shootings than the United States, due to the central role of guns in American culture and identity, Lankford said. The European Union has left gun laws and regulation of social media up to member states. Recent killings have seen a drive by several countries to apply tougher rules. In Sweden, the government agreed to tighten the vetting process for people applying for gun licences and to clamp down on some semi-automatic weapons following the Orebro killings. Incidents of violence and threatening behaviour in junior high and high schools rose over 150% between 2003 and 2023, according to a report by Sweden's Work Environment Authority. In Finland, where a 12-year-old shot dead a fellow pupil and badly wounded two others in 2024, schools practice barricading doors and hiding from shooters. The government has also proposed stricter punishments for carrying guns in public. Following a deadly December knife attack at a Zagreb primary school, Croatia's government tightened access to schools and mandated they must have security guards. Germany has gradually imposed tighter controls on gun ownership since school massacres in 2002 and 2009, and last year introduced a ban on switchblades and on carrying knives at public events following a series of knife attacks. Tightening gun ownership was the only way politicians could show they were taking the issue seriously, said Dirk Baier, a criminologist at the Zurich University of Applied Sciences. "There will certainly be resistance to this, from hunters, sport shooters, or other lobby groups," he said. "However, I think the arguments for tightening the laws will outweigh the arguments against." Gun laws have also been a hot political topic in the Czech Republic since a student shot dead 14 people at the Charles University in Prague in December 2023. The country made it obligatory for gun sellers to report suspicious purchases and requires doctors to check whether people diagnosed with psychological problems hold gun permits. Britain is holding a public inquiry into an attack in Southport where three young girls were stabbed to death last year. UK drama "Adolescence", a story about a schoolboy accused of murder, explores concerns about toxic online culture. Meanwhile in France, President Emmanuel Macron this month pressed for EU regulation to ban social media for children under 15 following a fatal school stabbing. What motivated the Austrian school gunman is still under investigation. Police said he was socially withdrawn and passionate about online shooting games. Most such shootings are carried out by young men, and criminologist Lankford said there was a global phenomenon of perpetrators seeking notoriety that eluded them in real life, driven in part by social media. "Even if the shooters expect to die, some are excited about leaving behind a legacy." Austria has relatively liberal gun laws, and President Alexander Van der Bellen said after the attack the legislation deserved closer scrutiny. Broad support in Austria for tightening gun ownership laws looked probable, although a general ban on private weapons seems unlikely, said political scientist Peter Filzmaier.
The Sun
an hour ago
- The Sun
French cops with riot shields FINALLY launch bid to stop overloaded migrant boat… only to retreat & watch it sail away
Ed Southgate in Gravelines Julia Atherley Sam Creed Published: Invalid Date, HEAVY handed French police finally went into the sea to try to stop migrants getting onto a dinghy - but the small boats were still left dangerously overcrowded after the officers retreated. Riot officers dramatically threatened migrants with batons and pepper sprayed them in waist-high water during shocking scenes at Gravelines beach - near Dunkirk - in the early hours of this morning. 12 12 Harrowing babies ' cries and screams rang out from the water as their parents carrying them refused to leave. Smugglers were caught off-guard when the French authorities, who have famously kept to dry land, started wading into the cold water. But 15 minutes later, riot cops were called back out of the water and watched on as the same group of migrants boarded the waiting dinghy. The Sun watched as Smugglers and migrants initially tried to fight back against the police, shouting at them, pushing them and splashing water at them. Then they tried moving along the coast, rather than towards land, to escape the cops and wait for the small boat, and the group slowly dispersed into smaller groups with cops pursuing them. Families began shouting at each other to come back when some moved towards the shore. The dinghy had arrived already with some migrants on, confirming theories that smugglers are now operating boats like a bus route picking people up at various spots. Tear gas grenades were thrown on land as the second group ran around, with smoke completely covering the miles-long beach in scenes comparable to a war zone. This is believed to be one of the first times French police have ever gone into the water. They have repeatedly refused to get their feet wet, claiming it is dangerous and legally complex. New maritime rules allowing cops to intervene at sea have not come into force yet. It has created accusations of officers just wanting to "put on a show" after being exposed in the press, while continuing to fail to stop any dinghies. The first group entered Gravelines beach from the sand dunes at around 4.50am. They walked with pace along the beach before eventually running towards the sea with a very large number of young children and babies. People smugglers were yelling at them, directing them what to do and where to go while no police were on the beach. Parents adjusted their childrens' life jackets as the group of around 50 migrants stood at the edge of the sea. One dad's one-year-old son was crying as he asked for help adjusting the baby's ill-fitting life jacket, which heartbreakingly appeared to be choking him. The dad said he was terrified for his baby ahead of the journey, but insisted they were fleeing war and needed to go to Britain. 12 12 12 12 People smugglers were shouting at the group and aggressively threw sand at the onlooking media. They stayed at the edge of the water until around 5.15am, when around 40 police officers finally emerged from the sand dunes and began marching the three quarters of a mile towards the sea. The migrants were then instructed by smugglers to enter the cold water, which they believed would give them protection against the officers who famously have never been in the sea. At least six riot officers marched into the sea towards the group of migrants and aggressively banged their riot shield with batons as they shouted at the group to go back. It led to a stand-off, with the group refusing to budge. One officer then lunged towards the group and pushed them with his shield, causing them to almost fall. The officers then continued to push them as screams were heard from the group, and they then used pepper spray against them. Parents, carrying their children on their shoulders or in their arms, were among those remaining firm in the water. Other sporadic moments of jostling and pushing between police and migrants continued during the 15 minute standoff. But the police were then called back as tear gas grenades were thrown on the sand as a second group appeared on the beach. It meant the migrants a dinghy could approach the group that the cops had failed to remove from the sea. The Sun then watched as they struggled to get on the already-overcrowded dinghy. Children were hoisted up as adults struggled in the sea. Meanwhile on the beach, hundreds more migrants were running around in a cat and mouse game with the police as they also tried to get to a second boat that was further down the coast. Officers threw a line of tear gas grenades to try to stop them from getting near to the sea. But migrants still managed to get to that boat. Smugglers appear to always bring more migrants than can fit on the boat, to make sure they are as full as possible. It meant there was a large group that were left on the beach after the boats had gone. But this was because there was no more room on the boats, not because the police had stopped them. It comes after The Sun watched on Wednesday morning as police stood idly by on land while migrants almost drowned trying to get onto a boat. But around two hours later today, some miles east in Dunkirk, another group of migrants boarded a small boat as officers continued to look on from the shore. 12 12 12 12
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
Private schools lose High Court battle against Starmer's VAT raid on fees
It comes after six families last year launched a legal challenge against the government's controversial tax raid, which imposes 20 per cent VAT on private schools, claiming it is discriminatory against certain children, such as those with special education needs (SEN). Supported by the Independent Schools Council (ISC), which represents 1,400 independent schools, the families sought a declaration of incompatibility under section 4 of the Human Rights Act, claiming the new tax is incompatible with the European Convention on Human Rights. But Dame Victoria Sharp, Lord Justice Newey and Mr Justice Chamberlain said in a 94-page decision that while the legislation does interfere with some of the group's human rights, there was a 'broad margin of discretion in deciding how to balance the interests of those adversely affected by the policy against the interests of others who may gain from public provision funded by the money it will raise'. During a hearing in April, Lord David Pannick KC, representing one group of children and their parents, said that the needs of some children currently in private schools could not be met by state schools. The High Court was told that, as well as religious beliefs and SEN, some children are privately educated because of a need for a single-sex environment because of previous abuse, or because they are only temporarily in the UK and need to be educated in line with their home national curriculum. But Sir James Eadie KC, representing the Treasury, HMRC and the Department for Education, said abolishing the VAT exemption for private school fees was a prominent feature of Labour's manifesto at the last general election. While the legal challenge would not have been able to halt the VAT policy or reverse it even if successful, it would have been a major blow to ministers and piled pressure on them to consider further exemptions. The government has estimated the tax raid will raise £1.7bn per year by 2029-30, money which ministers said would be used to fund 6,500 new teachers for state schools. So far, private school pupil numbers have fallen by more than 11,000 in England following the tax hike, DfE data showed. In January 2025, there were around 582,500 pupils at English private schools, down from 593,500 at the same point last year. When the policy was introduced, Treasury impact assessments estimated that private school fees would increase by around 10 per cent as a result of the introduction of VAT, But in May, ISC figures showed that fees have increased by 22.6 per cent in the past year, with parents now paying out more than £22,000 a year on average. The Treasury predicts that 35,000 pupils would move into UK state schools 'in the long-term steady state'. A further 2,000 children would leave private schools, the department estimated, consisting of international pupils who do not move into the UK state system or domestic pupils who move into homeschooling. The ISC has been contacted for comment.
