Man's appeal bid over double murder conviction delayed after judge forgets he heard original trial
A man seeking to overturn a double murder conviction must have his appeal reheard after an appeal court judge forgot he oversaw the original trial.
The appeal bid by Jason O'Driscoll over the murders of Anthony Burnett and Joseph Redmond in 2012 was heard for two hours in the
Court of Appeal
before it was pointed out that one of the three appeal court judges had presided over his original trial in 2017.
In December 2017, after a six-week trial, a jury told Mr Justice Patrick McCarthy they could not reach a unanimous or majority verdict in O'Driscoll's case.
O'Driscoll (42) of Richmond Avenue, Fairview, Dublin 3, had pleaded not guilty to murdering Mr Burnett (31) and Mr Redmond (25) in Co Louth on March 7th, 2012.
READ MORE
However, following a retrial, O'Driscoll was sentenced to life imprisonment in October 2018 by Mr Justice Michael White after he was
convicted of the double murder
by the 10-to-two majority verdict of a jury.
Mr Burnett and Mr Redmond had travelled to sell O'Driscoll a stolen car.
They died of gunshot wounds to their heads before petrol was used to set fire to a black Volkswagen Golf containing their bodies.
The two deceased were from Ballybough in the north inner city in Dublin and were described by the State as 'small-time criminals' involved in car theft.
O'Driscoll's appeal against his conviction was heard for more than two hours on Tuesday morning before Mr Justice John Edwards, Mr Justice McCarthy and Ms Justice Isobel Kennedy in the Court of Appeal.
Mr Justice Patrick McCarthy said he had been in the original trial and 'should have remembered'. Photograph: Nick Bradshaw
After breaking for lunch, O'Driscoll's defence barrister told the court that Mr Justice McCarthy had been the judge in O'Driscoll's original 2017 trial.
Seán Guerin SC, O'Driscoll's barrister, said the grounds for O'Driscoll's appeal had been litigated in that trial.
Mr Justice McCarthy said that he had been in the original trial and 'should have remembered'.
Mr Justice Edwards noted that it had been a long time since the original trial.
He said the case would be adjourned for the three-judge court to reconstitute and the appeal to be reheard without Mr Justice McCarthy.
A new appeal date was set for November 13th, 2025.
Mr Justice McCarthy was appointed to the High Court in 2007 and to the Court of Appeal in 2018.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
15 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Maureen Walsh, mother of music manager Louis, remembered as an ‘extraordinary woman' at funeral Mass
Maureen Walsh, the mother of music manager Louis Walsh , was remembered at her funeral Mass as an 'extraordinary' person who left an 'incredible mark' on the lives of many. Figures from the world of music , including Westlife members Shane Filan, Kian Egan and Nicky Byrne , and singers Dana and Michael English, joined the Walsh family in Co Mayo on Thursday to celebrate the 94-year-old's life. English, who was Ms Walsh's favourite country singer, performed a selection of hymns during the Mass at the Church of the Holy Family in Kiltimagh. In a eulogy, one of Ms Walsh's daughter, Sara Keogh, described her mother as an 'extraordinary' woman who left an 'incredible mark' on her eight children. READ MORE 'We had a great upbringing. We wanted for nothing. She pushed us to make the best of ourselves – she didn't do a bad job, I think,' she added. Ms Keogh recalled her mother going to work in the 1970s for the Western Care Association, which provides services to people with intellectual disabilities. 'This gave her a new lease of life,' she told mourners. 'She loved every minute of it. This was where she made some of her best friends in life.' Her son Frank Walsh told mourners his mother was 'a woman of great strength, loyalty and grace'. 'She was hardworking, had great faith and found joy in the simple things,' he said. The simple things she loved included watching GAA matches, set dancing, fancy dress, country music and playing cards games such as 25 and bridge. Chief celebrant Fr Michael Quinn said Ms Walsh's death would be an immense loss for her eight children, 20 grandchildren and three great-grandchildren. He said she was a person of great faith, with a particular devotion to Padre Pio. Among the gifts brought to the altar were Ms Walsh's Rosary beads, a picture of Padre Pio, a Mayo flag, a rolling pin, a family photograph, a transistor radio and a copy of her favourite magazine, Ireland's Own.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Corporate tax receipts drop 30% as Trump's tariffs bite
Corporate tax receipts fell by 30 per cent in May, amounting to a loss of over €1.1 billion when compared to the same month last year, amid signs US tariffs may be denting the profitability of multinationals in Ireland. The latest exchequer returns for May, published by the Department of Finance, indicated that the Government collected just under €2.5 billion in corporate taxes last month, compared to almost €3.6 billion in May last year. The department insisted, however, that 'once-off factors' had boosted receipts in May last year which distorted the year-on-year comparison. Nonetheless with most EU exports currently facing a 10 per cent levy in the US, possibly rising to 50 per cent if negotiations between Brussels and Washington fail, exporting companies here may be predicting lower earnings READ MORE [ Subscriber Only Opinion Ireland cannot base its economic strategy on the 'Taco' theory – Trump Always Chickens Out Opens in new window ] On a cumulative basis, receipts from the business tax were up by €1.1 billion at €7.4 billion but this reflects once-off revenues from the EU court ruling against Apple. When they are removed, corporate tax receipts to the end of May were down 9.4 per cent at €5.7 billion. Minister for Finance Paschal Donohoe said: ' May is one of the more important months for tax revenues, and the steady growth in most tax headings points to an economy that is in a relatively good position." 'The most notable feature of the May exchequer returns was in respect of corporation tax, which saw a marked year-on-year drop,' he said. 'While this reflects once-off factors last year, it nonetheless highlights the degree of concentration in the corporate tax base, wherein a small number of multinational firms can significantly impact on the overall tax yield,' Mr Donohoe said. 'In a context of unprecedented uncertainty in the international economic landscape, this serves as a timely reminder of Ireland's exposure to changes in the global trading environment, and of the vital importance of adhering to a sensible and sustainable budgetary strategy,' he said. Overall the latest exchequer data show the Government collected €38.2 billion in tax revenue during the first five months of the year. This was up nearly €3 billion or 8.5 per cent on the same period last year aided by positive increases in income tax and VAT. Income tax receipts, the Government's largest tax channel, generated €14.5 billion, €630 million more than last year, reflecting the State's strong labour market. Separate figures, published on Thursday, put the headline rate of unemployment near a historic low of 4 per cent. VAT receipts for the year so far were also up by €600 million at €11.4 billion. The sales tax reflects consumer activity. On the spending side, total gross voted expenditure for the five-month period amounted to just under €42 billion, up by €3.1 billion (8.1 per cent) on last year and €37 million (0.1 per cent) behind profile. At a headline level, an exchequer surplus of €4 billion was recorded compared to a surplus of €0.8 billion last year, an improvement of €3.2 billion. Excluding the once-off receipts arising from the Apple tax case, the underlying surplus was €0.7 billion.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Suspended solicitor's appeal over professional misconduct finding to be heard in July
A date has been fixed next month for an appeal by suspended solicitor Declan O'Callaghan over findings of professional misconduct in connection with his handling of a land deal in Co Mayo. On Friday, the president of the High Court, Mr Justice David Barniville, set a provisional hearing date of July 23rd for the appeal. Barrister Michael Mullooly, for Mr O'Callaghan, said he expected it to run for two days and Mr O'Callaghan would be among his side's witnesses. Barrister Ruadhán Ó Ciaráin, for Nirvanna, the concrete products manufacturer that brought the complaint against Mr O'Callaghan over the 2007 land deal to the Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal, said it is expected to call two witnesses at most. READ MORE Last month, Mr Justice Barniville rejected a challenge by Mr O'Callaghan over the procedures adopted by the tribunal in reaching its findings last year of professional misconduct over the 2007 deal. On Friday, he made an order requiring Mr O'Callaghan to pay Nirvanna's costs in opposing that application. The rejection of Mr O'Callaghan's judicial review-type challenge cleared the way for the hearing of his full appeal. If he loses that appeal, the High Court will then consider whether or not to grant an application by the Law Society to strike him off. The society has agreed with the tribunal recommendation that Mr O'Callaghan be struck off, but the final decision on whether or not to grant a strike-off order must be made by the High Court president. The three-member tribunal last summer found Mr O'Callaghan guilty of four counts of professional misconduct over his handling of the 2007 land deal involving Nirvanna, a company of Co Mayo businessman Tom Fleming. [ Declan O'Callaghan: No end in sight as saga of suspended solicitor continues Opens in new window ] Now aged 80, Mr Fleming claimed Nirvanna never received €250,000 for selling the land to a now-deceased businessman. Mr O'Callaghan denied the sum was owed, and disputed the transaction was for 'sale' of the lands. The tribunal upheld the Nirvanna complaint, finding professional misconduct on grounds Mr O'Callaghan breached his duty of care to the company, provided inadequate professional services, and purported to act for vendor and purchaser in a transaction where there was 'a clear conflict of interest'. In recommending strike-off, it had regard to two findings of professional misconduct previously made by it in 1990 and 2019 against Mr O'Callaghan. He has been suspended as a solicitor since 2018 arising from a separate Law Society investigation into matters at his now-defunct practice Kilrane O'Callaghan & Co, which was based in Ballaghaderreen, Co Roscommon. The suspension was imposed pending a tribunal hearing of the society's application for an inquiry into matters arising from its investigation. Concerns raised in an independent solicitor's report for that investigation included that Mr O'Callaghan withdrew substantial fees from the estate of a bereaved child.
