
Judge dismisses some counts in suit alleging abuse by SSD teacher, allows others
A federal judge allowed a lawsuit alleging abuse of a disabled student by a Scranton School District special education teacher to proceed on some counts, but dismissed others.
U.S. District Judge Karoline Mehalchick did not rule on the credibility of the suit's allegations concerning teacher Erica Stolan or others named in the civil complaint attorneys Joseph Grady and Todd O'Malley filed in U.S. District Court in February 2024 on behalf of the student and his parents. In addition to Stolan, it named the school district, South Scranton Intermediate School Principal Joseph Lalli, former Principal Daniel Gilroy and district Director of Special Education Ann Genett as defendants.
Among other claims, the plaintiffs allege that the student with multiple disabilities, including autism and attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder, was assaulted by Stolan in her classroom at South Scranton Intermediate School. The complaint specifically alleges that Stolan sprayed liquid in the child's face on Jan. 2, 2023, then, a day later, shoved him out of his chair and directed and encouraged other special education students to forcibly remove him from the classroom.
A behavior support professional witnessed the alleged conduct and reported it to Gilroy in writing, according to the complaint, which notes a ChildLine report originated from the district and district officials removed Stolan from the school on Jan. 4, 2023. But Stolan, now a special education teacher at Charles Sumner Elementary School, was allowed to return to the intermediate school in the spring of 2023, according to the complaint.
The plaintiffs contend Stolan's conduct was 'open, widespread and known' by district staff and administrators and that the district, its officers and employees allowed her abusive behavior to continue 'unabated and unsupervised.'
Attorneys representing the district and other defendants filed a motion to dismiss the lawsuit in April 2024, arguing the 13 separate counts in the plaintiffs' complaint should be dismissed for a variety of reasons. Among other arguments, they contended that Stolan and the other defendants are immune from liability, the court lacks jurisdiction in the case and the plaintiffs aren't entitled to punitive damages.
In their motion, attorneys John Freund, the district's solicitor, and Alyssa Hicks argued the court lacks jurisdiction because the plaintiffs failed to exhaust 'administrative remedies' available under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act. They also argued the plaintiffs didn't specify how the actions of the individual defendants 'demonstrate that they knew their actions violated (the student's) rights' and failed to establish that the student's disability 'was the cause of the denial of benefits.'
In an order late last month, Mehalchick dismissed several of the complaint's 13 counts, some with prejudice and some without, but allowed others to proceed.
For example, the judge denied the defendants' motion to dismiss certain federal claims alleging violations of the Americans with Disabilities Act and Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act, allowing those counts to continue. She also denied a motion to dismiss a separate count alleging violations of rights guaranteed by the 14th Amendment, allowing that claim to proceed while declining during the pleading stage of the civil action to address the defendants' claims of qualified immunity.
It is 'premature' at this point to determine whether Stolan and the other defendants are entitled to qualified immunity, the judge's order notes.
But Mehalchick did dismiss a pair of counts against individual defendants other than Stolan, noting in her order that the plaintiffs failed to allege in the relevant counts 'willful misconduct' by those individuals 'beyond mere deliberate indifference.' She also dismissed the same counts against the school district, finding that the Pennsylvania Political Subdivision Tort Claims Act, which shields government agencies from liability for actions committed by their employees under certain circumstances, bars those counts.
The judge denied a motion to dismiss several counts against Stolan, including counts alleging assault and battery and the intentional infliction of emotional distress.
'Please understand that the judge did not find anyone liable,' Freund said in a recent statement to the newspaper. 'The decision merely means that the plaintiff's complaint stated sufficient allegations for the case to move forward.'
Robert Moran, an attorney for the plaintiffs, also issued a statement addressing the judge's order.
'We are pleased with Judge Mehalchick's thorough and well-reasoned opinion,' he said. 'The facts underlying the allegations should shock every parent, particularly those with children suffering a disability. We look forward to this case proceeding.'
Mehalchick also did not dismiss the plaintiffs' claim for punitive damages in the case, noting such a dismissal would not be appropriate 'at this preliminary stage of litigation.' She also granted the plaintiffs an opportunity to file an amended complaint to potentially cure deficiencies related to claims dismissed without prejudice.
The plaintiffs are still evaluating whether to file an amended complaint, Moran said.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
5 hours ago
- Yahoo
Kilmar Abrego Garcia, wrongly deported to El Salvador prison, to face federal charges in Nashville
Protesters outside the U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland in Greenbelt rally on April 4, 2025, in support of Kilmar Armando Abrego Garcia, a Maryland father who was deported to El Salvador in an 'administrative error,' calling for him to be returned to the U.S. (Photo by Ariana Figueroa/States Newsroom) Kilmar Abrego Garcia, a Maryland man the Trump Administration conceded had been wrongly deported to a notorious El Salvador prison, has been returned to the United States and is scheduled to be arraigned in a Nashville federal court on Friday. A two-count Tennessee grand jury indictment, issued May 21 and unsealed Friday, alleges Abrego Garcia and unnamed co-conspirators were members of the MS-13 gang and 'knowingly and unlawfully transported thousands of undocumented aliens' for profit between 2016 and 2025. The indictment, filed in the Middle District of Tennessee, accuses Abrego Garcia 'of conspiracy to unlawfully transport illegal aliens for financial gain' and 'unlawful transportation of illegal aliens for financial gain.' The indictment does not name nor charge any alleged co-conspirators. In a separate motion filed Friday, prosecutors seek to keep Garcia in detention, alleging he is a flight risk and a danger to the community. Wrongly deported Maryland man Abrego Garcia returned to U.S. Chris Newman, an attorney representing the Abrego Garcia family said at a virtual press event Friday that he remained skeptical of the federal charges lodged at Abrego Garcia. 'I can tell you that we should all treat whatever charges that are being leveled against him with a high degree of suspicion,' Newman said. 'We should make sure that he gets a fair (trial) in court because he's clearly not getting a fair hearing in the court of public opinion,' he said. Abrego Garcia's deportation served as a flashpoint for the Trump Administration's mass deportations of immigrants without a hearing or ordinary due process rights that give immigrants —– and all U.S. residents —– the right to defend themselves against charges of illegal activities. In April, the Supreme Court ruled the Trump Administration had to 'facilitate' Abrego Garcia's return to the United States. For the next two months, administration officials said Abrego Garcia's return was out of their hands and up to the government of El Salvador. On Friday, in a nationally televised news conference, U.S. Attorney General Pam Bondi thanked Nayib Bukele, that nation's president, for agreeing to Abrego Garcia's release. The criminal charges filed in Nashville are tied to a November 2022 traffic stop by the Tennessee Highway Patrol. Abrego Garcia was driving an SUV with nine Hispanic men when he was pulled over for speeding on Interstate 40 in Putnam County about 80 miles east of Nashville, court records said. He was not charged in the incident. Prosecutors now allege that further investigation revealed the stop involved Abrego Garcia smuggling migrants within the United States illegally. Rob McGuire, who has served as acting U.S. attorney for the Middle District of Tennessee since last year, and lawyers for the Joint Task Force Vulcan —– a unit established specifically to investigate MS-13 gang members —– are listed in court records as prosecutors in the case. ABC News, citing unnamed sources, reported late Friday that the decision to pursue an indictment against Abrego Garcia led to the abrupt resignation of Ben Schrader, former chief of the criminal division for the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Middle District of Tennessee. A spokesperson for the U.S. Attorney's office on Friday referred requests for information about the date and circumstances of Schrader's departure, including a copy of any letter of resignation, to a human resources officer, who did not immediately respond on Friday. Schrader, in a LinkedIn post two weeks ago, announced his resignation from the job he held for 15 years. Schrader wrote 'the only job description I've ever known is to do the right thing, in the right way, for the right reasons.' Schrader did not give a reason for his resignation in his public post and did not respond Friday to a an email sent to his address at Vanderbilt University, where he is listed as holding a teaching post. Kilmar Abrego Garcia indictment
Yahoo
2 days ago
- Yahoo
Pierce County man sentenced in ‘high-volume' drug redistribution tied to prison gangs
A Pierce County man described as a 'high-volume' drug redistributor for the leader of a drug distribution ring tied to white supremacist prison gangs was sentenced Friday in U.S. District Court in Tacoma. Gregory Beers, 32, of Edgewood, received a total of 12.5 years in prison from U.S. District Court Judge David G. Estudillo. 'This is a very serious crime,' said at sentencing, according to a news release from the Acting U.S. Attorney's Office. 'It involved thousands and thousands of fentanyl pills, which wreak havoc on our community. There are people literally dying from these drugs and it leaves a wake of destruction for those who survive.' According to federal prosecutors, Beers was a high-volume drug redistributor for Jesse James Bailey, the leader of one of three branches of the drug distribution organizations tied to two Aryan prison gangs. On March 22, 2023, law enforcement made two dozen arrests on federal charges. Law enforcement seized 177 firearms, more than 10 kilos of methamphetamine, 11 kilos of fentanyl pills and more than a kilo of fentanyl powder, three kilos of heroin, and over $330,000 in cash from 18 locations in Washington and Arizona. 'Earlier in the investigation, law enforcement seized 830,000 fentanyl pills, 5.5 pounds of fentanyl powder, 223 pounds of methamphetamine, 3.5 pounds of heroin, 5 pounds of cocaine, $388,000 in cash, and 48 firearms,' the release noted. Prosecutors say Beers fled his residence on March 23, leaving behind drugs, cash, body armor and firearms. Law enforcement said that the residence contained heroin, fentanyl, methamphetamine and detailed drug ledgers. Police also found guns as well as bullet-proof vests in two of the bedrooms, digital scales, ammunition and nearly $5,000 in cash. Inside Beers' Mercedes, agents found more weapons and ammunition, as well as two Kevlar ballistic vests, and small bags of heroin and fentanyl powder. The trunk held another handgun and a bag of bullets, law enforcement said. Beers was arrested on April 11, 2023, after being found living in an RV parked at a Tacoma home and dealing narcotics, according to prosecutors. 'Even after seeing that his co-conspirators were arrested and knowing that he too was sought by police, Gregory Beers continued his drug trafficking, arming himself with guns,' Acting U.S. Attorney Teal Luthy Miller said in a statement. 'He was arrested with two firearms, $7,000 in cash and some $36,000 worth of jewelry that he would wear around his neck — all proceeds of drug trafficking.' Last June, Beers pleaded guilty to conspiracy to distribute controlled substances and possessing a firearm in furtherance of a drug trafficking crime. In asking the court for the 12.5-year prison term, prosecutors noted that Beers was blatant about his drug dealing. 'Beers flaunted his drug trafficking and illegal firearm possession, sending videos of his firearms and drug proceeds to (Department of Corrections) inmates,' prosecutors wrote to the court. 'All of this was done for the purpose of his own personal enrichment, including his purchase of expensive jewelry.' According to Friday's release, three connected drug rings in the case were identified over an 18-month wiretap investigation. The three distribution rings were working together as the Aryan Family/Omerta Drug Trafficking Organization, the release stated, one of which was led by Beers' co-defendant Jesse Bailey. Bailey has pleaded guilty and is scheduled for sentencing on July 2, the release added.

Yahoo
2 days ago
- Yahoo
U.S. Customs Border Protection officer charged with possessing child porn
A U.S. Customs and Border Protection officer was charged with knowingly possessing one or more items that contained visual depictions of a minor engaging in sexually explicit conduct, acting U.S. Attorney Joseph H. Thompson said Friday. Anthony John Crowley 52, of Minnetonka, Minn., made his first appearance in U.S. District Court on Friday, authorities said. 'In recent months, we have seen a rash of agents, officers, and public officials engaging in crimes against children,' Thompson said in a news release. 'Let there be no misunderstanding: the U.S. Attorney's Office has zero tolerance for people in positions of trust and authority who abuse children. Zero.' A special agent with Homeland Security, Timothy Ryan Gregg, 51, of Eagan, was charged Monday in U.S. District Court with producing child sexual abuse material after federal authorities say images and videos of the two engaged in sexual activity were found on her cellphone on May 29. 'When those who take an oath to uphold the law become the ones who break it in the most egregious way, it erodes the public's faith in our institutions,' said Special Agent in Charge Alvin M. Winston Sr. of FBI Minneapolis. 'We are seeing a troubling pattern — multiple arrests in recent months involving individuals in positions of authority charged with exploiting children. Let one thing be clear: position and power will not shield you from accountability. If you harm a child, the FBI and our law enforcement partners will find you. And no matter who you are, we will bring you to justice.' Crowley was ordered Friday to remain in custody pending further proceedings. Man once convicted in Minnesota of supporting al-Qaida is now charged in Canada for alleged threats Jury finds Milwaukee man guilty of killing and dismembering 19-year-old woman 'We feel relief': Derrick Thompson found guilty in Minneapolis crash that killed five young women Man charged with hate crime in Boulder attack on 'Zionist people' appears in federal court Minneapolis man sentenced for stabbing, hanging St. Paul woman's dog after argument