Flawed data used repeatedly to dismiss claims about 'Asian grooming gangs', Baroness Casey finds
Flawed data has been used repeatedly to dismiss claims about "Asian grooming gangs", Baroness Louise Casey has said in a new report, as she called for a new national inquiry.
The government has accepted her recommendations to introduce compulsory collection of ethnicity and nationality data for all suspects in grooming cases, and for a review of police records to launch new criminal investigations into historic child sexual exploitation cases.
Politics latest:
The crossbench peer has produced an audit of sexual abuse carried out by grooming gangs in England and Wales, after she was asked by the prime minister to review new and existing data, including the ethnicity and demographics of these gangs.
In her report, she has warned authorities that children need to be seen "as children" and called for a tightening of the laws around the age of consent so that any penetrative sexual activity with a child under 16 is classified as rape. This is "to reduce uncertainty which adults can exploit to avoid or reduce the punishments that should be imposed for their crimes", she added.
Baroness Casey said: "Despite the age of consent being 16, we have found too many examples of child sexual exploitation criminal cases being dropped or downgraded from rape to lesser charges where a 13 to 15-year-old had been 'in love with' or 'had consented to' sex with the perpetrator."
The peer has called for a nationwide probe into the exploitation of children by gangs of men.
She has not recommended another over-arching inquiry of the kind conducted by Professor Alexis Jay, and suggests the national probe should be time-limited.
The national inquiry will direct local investigations and hold institutions to account for past failures.
Home Secretary Yvette Cooper said the inquiry's "purpose is to challenge what the audit describes as continued denial, resistance and legal wrangling among local agencies".
On the issue of ethnicity, Baroness Casey said police data was not sufficient to draw conclusions as it had been "shied away from", and is still not recorded for two-thirds of perpetrators.
'Flawed data'
However, having examined local data in three police force areas, she found "disproportionate numbers of men from Asian ethnic backgrounds amongst suspects for group-based child sexual exploitation, as well as in the significant number of perpetrators of Asian ethnicity identified in local reviews and high-profile child sexual exploitation prosecutions across the country, to at least warrant further examination".
She added: "Despite reviews, reports and inquiries raising questions about men from Asian or Pakistani backgrounds grooming and sexually exploiting young white girls, the system has consistently failed to fully acknowledge this or collect accurate data so it can be examined effectively.
"Instead, flawed data is used repeatedly to dismiss claims about 'Asian grooming gangs' as sensationalised, biased or untrue.
"This does a disservice to victims and indeed all law-abiding people in Asian communities and plays into the hands of those who want to exploit it to sow division."
Read more:
The baroness hit out at the failure of policing data and intelligence for having multiple systems which do not communicate with each other.
She also criticised "an ambivalent attitude to adolescent girls both in society and in the culture of many organisations", too often judging them as adults.
'Deep-rooted failure'
Responding to Baroness Casey's review, Ms Yvette Cooper told the House of Commons: "The findings of her audit are damning.
"At its heart, she identifies a deep-rooted failure to treat children as children. A continued failure to protect children and teenage girls from rape, from exploitation, and serious violence.
She added: "Baroness Casey found 'blindness, ignorance, prejudice, defensiveness and even good but misdirected intentions' all played a part in this collective failure."
Ms Cooper said she will take immediate action on all 12 recommendations from the report, adding: "We cannot afford more wasted years repeating the same mistakes or shouting at each other across this House rather than delivering real change."
Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch said: "After months of pressure, the prime minister has finally accepted our calls for a full statutory national inquiry into the grooming gangs.
"We must remember that this is not a victory for politicians, especially the ones like the home secretary, who had to be dragged to this position, or the prime minister. This is a victory for the survivors who have been calling for this for years."
Ms Badenoch added: "The prime minister's handling of this scandal is an extraordinary failure of leadership. His judgement has once again been found wanting.
"Since he became prime minister, he and the home secretary dismissed calls for an inquiry because they did not want to cause a stir.
"They accused those of us demanding justice for the victims of this scandal as, and I quote, 'jumping on a far right bandwagon', a claim the prime minister's official spokesman restated this weekend - shameful."
The government has promised new laws to protect children and support victims so they "stop being blamed for the crimes committed against them".
It is also launching new police operations and a new national inquiry to direct local investigations and hold institutions to account for past failures.
There will also be new ethnicity data and research "so we face up to the facts on exploitation and abuse," the home secretary said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Grooming gangs report author reveals how she found word 'Pakistani' tippexed out of file
Ignoring the ethnicity of grooming gang perpetrators gives racists "more ammunition", the author of a new report has said. Baroness Louise Casey told Sky News' there was a particular issue with some British Asian men that was "abundantly clear" in data analysed from three police forces; West Yorkshire, South Yorkshire and Greater Manchester; which showed a "disproportionately" in child sexual exploitation. Politics latest: But she added: "Just to give some sort of balance, in Greater Manchester I asked for data on child sexual exploitation that took me to Asian heritage. I asked for data on child abuse and that took me to the general population, which is largely white." Baroness Casey said "if we just establish the facts, then you can take the pain out of this". "I think you've got sort of do-gooders that don't really want this to be found because, you know, 'Oh, God, then all the racists are going to be more racist'," she added. "Well, actually, people that are racist are going to use this anyway. All you're doing with the hate mongers and the racists is giving them more ammunition." Asked if people were worried about being seen as racist, the cross-bench peer said she came across direct examples of this in Rotherham - one of the towns at the centre of the grooming gangs scandal. "I was following through on a children's file in archive and found the word 'Pakistani' tippexed out," Baroness Casey said. "I thought whoever did that inadvertently was giving ammunition to the English Defence League that were every week, in and out, campaigning and doing their stuff in that town. "I think the problem is that people are worried about being called racist.... if good people don't grasp difficult things, bad people will, and that's why we have to do it as a society." The government has announced there will be a , as recommended by Baroness Casey's report. The government has also accepted her recommendations to introduce compulsory collection of ethnicity and nationality data for all suspects in grooming cases, and for a review of police records to launch new criminal investigations into historic child sexual exploitation cases. Baroness Casey was asked to produce an audit of sexual abuse carried out by grooming gangs in England and Wales, looking specifically at the issue of ethnicity and the cultural and social drivers for this type of offending. This had never before been done despite multiple local reviews into child sexual exploitation and a known as the Jay Review, which concluded in 2022. The government had previously resisted calls for an inquiry into grooming gangs, after brought the issue back into the spotlight in January, saying it would implement the recommendations of the Jay Review that the Tories didn't. However it changed its position following Baroness Casey's findings. Read more: She found that flawed data has been used repeatedly to dismiss claims about "Asian grooming gangs". Having examined local data in three police force areas, she found "disproportionate numbers of men from Asian ethnic backgrounds" are among suspects for group-based child sexual exploitation, as well as a "significant number of perpetrators of Asian ethnicity" who have been identified in local reviews and child sexual exploitation prosecutions across the country. She said all of this warranted further examination, insisting to Sophy Ridge 👉 Listen to Sky News Daily on your podcast app 👈 Baroness Casey has also called for a tightening of the laws around the age of consent so that any penetrative sexual activity with a child under 16 is classified as rape, which the government has also accepted. She told Sophy Ridge that some perpetrators waited until their victims turned 13 as then it is "much harder to prosecute for rape". She said: "I think we have to be really clear in society that children are children and I don't see the difference between, you know, a four-year-old and a 14-year-old. If somebody is doing to them... what I talk about in my report, it's rape and we need to call it for what it is."
San Francisco Chronicle
3 hours ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
UK 'shied away' from ethnicity of grooming gangs in child sex abuse inquiries, report finds
LONDON (AP) — The UK government said Monday it will make it mandatory for the police to record the ethnicity and nationality of suspects accused of child sexual abuse and exploitation. The move is part of an attempt to address long-running accusations that authorities have 'shied away' from properly tackling the issue of race when investigating such cases. It comes came after the government announced Saturday that it will hold a national inquiry into organized child sexual abuse, something it has long been pressured to do by opposition politicians. In a statement to Parliament, Home Secretary Yvette Cooper said a recent review of data from three police forces found "clear evidence of over-representation among suspects of Asian and Pakistani heritage men' who prey on often young and vulnerable girls and women. But the review found that ethnicity data was not recorded for two-thirds of perpetrators in what the British press have dubbed 'grooming gang" crimes. 'The appalling lack of data on ethnicity in crime recording alone is a major failing over the last decade or more," said the review, overseen by Louise Casey, an expert on victim's rights and social welfare. 'Questions about ethnicity have been asked but dodged for years.' 'Child sexual exploitation is horrendous whoever commits it, but there have been enough convictions across the country of groups of men from Asian ethnic backgrounds to have warranted closer examination," it added. The review referred to examples of organizations that avoided the topic of race altogether 'for fear of appearing racist or raising community tensions." It said: 'The question of the ethnicity of perpetrators has been a key question for this audit, having been raised in inquiries and reports going back many years. We found that the ethnicity of perpetrators is shied away from and is still not recorded for two-thirds of perpetrators, so we are unable to provide any accurate assessment from the nationally collected data.' Cooper noted that while Casey's review also identified cases in which perpetrators were white, British, European, or other ethnicities, there wasn't enough information to help prevent patterns of crime from being understood and tackled. Britain's justice system has seen multiple cases of underage girls — some as young as 10, and others who were vulnerable because they were in social care or had disabilities — sexually exploited by groups of men in different towns and cities in the 2000s and 2010s. In some of the most high-profile cases to come to trial, the perpetrators were men of Pakistani heritage and the victims were predominantly white girls. The issue has been taken up by right-of-center politicians including Reform UK leader Nigel Farage to link child sexual abuse to immigration. It was more recently stoked by Elon Musk, who took to his X platform earlier this year to condemn Prime Minister Keir Starmer over the issue. Cooper said Monday that as a further step to tackle the issue, laws will be changed so that any adult man who engages in penetrative sex with a child under 16 will face a mandatory rape charge. Officials also said detectives will follow up on more than 800 cold cases involving child sex abuse by grooming gangs. A seven-year inquiry was held under the previous Conservative government, but many of the 20 recommendations it made in 2022 — including compensation for abuse victims — have yet to be implemented.
Hamilton Spectator
4 hours ago
- Hamilton Spectator
UK ‘shied away' from ethnicity of grooming gangs in child sex abuse inquiries, report finds
LONDON (AP) — The UK government said Monday it will make it mandatory for the police to record the ethnicity and nationality of suspects accused of child sexual abuse and exploitation. The move is part of an attempt to address long-running accusations that authorities have 'shied away' from properly tackling the issue of race when investigating such cases. It comes came after the government announced Saturday that it will hold a national inquiry into organized child sexual abuse, something it has long been pressured to do by opposition politicians. In a statement to Parliament, Home Secretary Yvette Cooper said a recent review of data from three police forces found 'clear evidence of over-representation among suspects of Asian and Pakistani heritage men' who prey on often young and vulnerable girls and women. But the review found that ethnicity data was not recorded for two-thirds of perpetrators in what the British press have dubbed 'grooming gang' crimes. 'The appalling lack of data on ethnicity in crime recording alone is a major failing over the last decade or more,' said the review, overseen by Louise Casey, an expert on victim's rights and social welfare. 'Questions about ethnicity have been asked but dodged for years.' 'Child sexual exploitation is horrendous whoever commits it, but there have been enough convictions across the country of groups of men from Asian ethnic backgrounds to have warranted closer examination,' it added. The review referred to examples of organizations that avoided the topic of race altogether 'for fear of appearing racist or raising community tensions.' It said: 'The question of the ethnicity of perpetrators has been a key question for this audit, having been raised in inquiries and reports going back many years. We found that the ethnicity of perpetrators is shied away from and is still not recorded for two-thirds of perpetrators, so we are unable to provide any accurate assessment from the nationally collected data.' Cooper noted that while Casey's review also identified cases in which perpetrators were white, British, European, or other ethnicities, there wasn't enough information to help prevent patterns of crime from being understood and tackled. Britain's justice system has seen multiple cases of underage girls — some as young as 10, and others who were vulnerable because they were in social care or had disabilities — sexually exploited by groups of men in different towns and cities in the 2000s and 2010s. In some of the most high-profile cases to come to trial, the perpetrators were men of Pakistani heritage and the victims were predominantly white girls. The issue has been taken up by right-of-center politicians including Reform UK leader Nigel Farage to link child sexual abuse to immigration . It was more recently stoked by Elon Musk, who took to his X platform earlier this year to condemn Prime Minister Keir Starmer over the issue. Cooper said Monday that as a further step to tackle the issue, laws will be changed so that any adult man who engages in penetrative sex with a child under 16 will face a mandatory rape charge. Officials also said detectives will follow up on more than 800 cold cases involving child sex abuse by grooming gangs. A seven-year inquiry was held under the previous Conservative government, but many of the 20 recommendations it made in 2022 — including compensation for abuse victims — have yet to be implemented. Error! Sorry, there was an error processing your request. There was a problem with the recaptcha. Please try again. You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy . This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply. Want more of the latest from us? Sign up for more at our newsletter page .
