EU's failure to propose ways to cut trade with illegal Israeli settlements criticised by nine foreign ministers
The
European Commission's
failure to bring forward proposals to 'discontinue' trade between the
EU
and illegal
Israeli
settlements in Occupied Palestinian Territories has been criticised by Spain, Ireland and seven other member states.
The nine foreign ministers, in a joint letter seen by The Irish Times, take aim at the slow progress in cutting off indirect economic support for Israeli settlements in the
West Bank
and other Palestinian territory.
They say firmer action is needed from the EU in response to findings of the
International Court of Justice
(ICJ) last year, that
Israel's occupation of the West Bank and East Jerusalem was unlawful
.
In their June 16th letter, the ministers say the ICJ opinion put greater obligations on governments to make sure they were not entrenching the illegal settlements through trade links or other ties.
READ MORE
They criticised the commission, the EU's executive arm, which sets trade policy, for not doing enough in response to the court's decision.
'We have not seen a proposal to initiate discussions on how to effectively discontinue trade of goods and services with the illegal settlements,' the letter states.
The nine ministers call for the commission to carry out an 'in-depth analysis' into the implications the ICJ opinion had for other governments' relations with Israel.
The letter was signed by the foreign ministers of Belgium, Spain, Ireland, Finland, Luxembourg, Poland, Portugal, Slovenia and Sweden. It was sent to commission president
Ursula von der Leyen
, EU foreign affairs chief Kaja Kallas and EU trade commissioner Maroš Šefčovič.
'We are committed to respect, and where relevant, implementing the conclusions put forward by the [ICJ] in its advisory opinion on the legal consequences arising from the policies and practices of Israel in the Occupied Palestinian Territory,' the letter says.
[
EU should consider ending visa-free travel for Israeli settlers, academics say
Opens in new window
]
Several governments are to push for Israel to be penalised for its conduct during its 20-month invasion of the
Gaza Strip
, when the 27 EU foreign ministers meet in Brussels on Monday.
A review into whether Israel's war in Gaza has breached human rights commitments it made in a free-trade agreement with the EU will be presented to ministers at the meeting.
Some ministers are expected to call for action to be taken against Israel, to pressure the Israeli government to stop choking off the flow of humanitarian aid into Gaza, where aid agencies continue to warn the civilian population still lacks food, fuel and medicine.
More than 55,000 Palestinians have been killed during Israel's military campaign in Gaza, which began after the deadly
Hamas
attacks of October 7th, 2023.
While a growing number of EU states have been advocating for the EU to take a stronger stance against Israel, others, such as Hungary, Germany and Czechia, have pushed back in support of Israel.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Diplomatic efforts continuing in bid to help Irish citizens in Iran and Israel
Minister for Foreign Affairs Simon Harris has said intensive consular work is ongoing to assist Irish citizens who want to leave Israel and Iran . There is a particular concern about the safety of diplomats in Iran. Ireland is working with other partners about potential routes out. Mr Harris, the Tánaiste, has held talks with the foreign affairs ministers of Saudi Arabia and Jordan over what he termed the 'increasingly dangerous' situation unfolding in the Middle East. Mr Harris spoke by phone to the Saudi foreign minister Prince Faisal bin Farhan and his Jordanian counterpart Ayman Safadi. READ MORE 'We discussed the crisis between Iran and Israel and the urgent need for de-escalation and diplomacy,' Mr Harris said. 'We also agreed on the need to maintain international focus on the deplorable situation in Gaza and the West Bank . I will continue to engage with regional partners in support of a return to stability and peace.' Regarding the safety of Irish citizens in the region, Mr Harris said there were 29 in Iran they were aware of, with about 12 dependants. 'And if they do wish to leave, we are working with other countries in terms of putting safe routes in place,' he said. 'In relation to Israel, there are more Irish citizens in Israel – in and around 200 – and we're working with other European countries in terms of the potential of [their] getting to Egypt or Jordan and being able to take flights from there.' In discussions with the Jordanian and Saudi ministers, he pointed to Iran being set to attend talks in Geneva on Friday, which is seen as crucial for any breakthrough. Ireland will be represented at the meeting by the European Union's High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy, Kaja Kallas. The UK will also be in attendance. Speaking earlier, Mr Harris said: 'It is not possible to overstate the serious moment of danger, not just in Iran and in Israel, but indeed in the broader region and indeed in relation to global security. 'We need Iran and Israel to step back from the brink.' 'I think that is a really important moment to try to get to a position where we can get Iran back to the negotiating table in relation to its nuclear programme.' Mr Harris said the war between Israel and Iran was happening against a backdrop of a humanitarian catastrophe in Gaza. 'The genocide is still continuing in Gaza. It is an extraordinarily dangerous situation, and the ongoing challenge in Gaza is still obviously persisting, and the world can't forget Gaza either,' he said. Separately, Taoiseach Micheál Martin , Mr Harris and most members of the Cabinet will travel to a North-South Ministerial Council in Armagh on Friday to meet First Minister Michelle O'Neill, Deputy First Minister Emma Little-Pengelly and members of the Northern Ireland Executive. It is the first plenary in years when both administrations will have published their programmes for government and it allows for a more substantive agenda than in recent summits. Mr Martin has urged all ministers to engage with Northern counterparts since the new government was formed and he has highlighted the potential of the increased funding of the Shared Island Initiative.
The Irish Sun
3 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Speaking French, Swedish, German… the migrants booted out of EU in asylum crackdown & on small boats to ‘soft touch' UK
MORE than 2,000 migrants are massing in the Jungle camp outside Dunkirk in northern France. And their aim — to cross the Channel and take advantage of 'soft touch' Britain after they were turfed out by the EU countries where they previously lived. 4 Migrants climb walls and cut fences near Dunkirk's Jungle camp Credit: Chris Eades - Commissioned by The Sun 4 While the number of asylum claims across Europe is falling, the figure for the UK is going up 4 Jungle camp residents form a queue behind an aid truck Credit: Chris Eades Shocking new figures have revealed that while the number of And as small boat crossings to Britain are increasing daily, the level of 'irregular' crossings into the EU countries from Africa, the Balkans and Eastern Europe have significantly reduced. When The Sun visited the overcrowded And that is because a huge majority of the migrants waiting to come here have lived in those European countries for years. These are people who have already paid out thousands to Huda plans to apply for asylum in the UK after her original claim in the Netherlands was turned down when she was living in the northern city of Groningen. She told The Sun: 'I don't want to cross the Channel, but what choice do I have? Most read in The Sun "I spent seven years living in Holland and I was happy and settled there. 'Then one day in 2023 they told me to leave. Channel migrants queue for cash in hand jobs as secrets of UK's £260bn illegal economy revealed "They said my asylum claim had been rejected and I would be deported. 'They kicked me out of the refugee camp and I became homeless the same day. 'I was very upset and I still don't know why my asylum claim was turned down. "The people doing the interview did not believe what I said. 'But I know many, many people who had their claims rejected in Holland. "I don't think the Dutch government understands the situation in Somalia. 'I've tried to claim asylum in France, too, but they told me to go back to Holland. 'Now I'm sleeping in 'HUMANITY IN BRITAIN' 'There is more humanity in Britain and I want my children, who are ten and eight, to join me over there.' The decision by EU countries to get tough on immigration — in response to rising public concern — is reflected in the latest figures. In the first quarter of this year, there was a 17.6 per cent fall in asylum claims across the EU, according to the European Commission's statistics service Eurostat. At the same time, there was a 17 per cent rise in asylum claims in the UK, from 93,150 to 109,343, according to the Home Office. EU countries clamping down include the Netherlands, where the Party for Freedom, founded and led by firebrand Elsewhere, the Even centrist European leaders have yanked away the welcome mat at the same time as they are ploughing millions into border security — with significant results. Irregular crossings to the Canary Islands from Morocco, Western Sahara, Mauritania, Senegal and The Gambia in West Africa were down 34 per cent in the first quarter of this year, according to the EU's border security agency Frontex. 4 Somali mum Huda Abdi aims to apply for asylum in UK after being rejected in Holland Credit: Chris Eades Crossings into what is termed the Western Mediterranean — Africa into mainland Spain — were down ten per cent over the same period. The Central Mediterranean crossing point, where migrants take small boats from Tunisia, Egypt, Libya and Algeria to Italy and Malta — has witnessed a three per cent fall compared to last year. Meanwhile, there has been a 30 per cent reduction in crossings along the Eastern Mediterranean migrant route into Greece, Cyprus and Bulgaria, where barbed wire fences have been erected along the border with Turkey. The Western Balkan passage through Albania, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Kosovo, Montenegro, North Macedonia and Serbia has seen a 58 per cent reduction. And crossings from the Eastern land border, from Belarus, Moldova, Ukraine and the Russian Federation, have dropped 37 per cent despite Vladimir Putin pushing migrants in that direction to stoke political unrest. The only border bucking the trend is what Frontex terms 'exits towards the UK', with Channel crossings up five per cent compared to the first three months of last year. Around 50,000 small boat asylum seekers are expected to reach our shores by the end of 2025 — each This is a huge reduction on the 157,651 who reached Italy in 2023, before the Italians paid £85million to Tunisia to boost border security. That figure seems like a bargain compared to the £476million that was given to French border police over three years by the UK Home Office. Aid worker Rob Lawrie has seen at first hand how the migrant wave has turned towards the UK, having spent ten years helping out at camps in northern France. 'CRIMINAL NETWORKS' Rob, from Leeds, who hosts the To Catch A Scorpion podcast, told BBC Radio 4's Today programme that the Dunkirk camp is now 'very full', with a 'few thousand' living there. He previously told the same programme: 'The problem is that asylum cases are dropping off massively in Europe in terms of being accepted. 'What we see in the camps of France is different nationalities from African nations — from Afghanistan, Iraq and other nations — they speak either German or Swedish or Belgian and Danish. 'And that's because they've been in those countries for two or three years and eventually had their second or third appeal denied. 'They're not going to go back to Eritrea, or whatever their country was, because of why they left. 'So their only option is now to go down to northern France and once again put their lives into the hands of these organised criminal networks.' Teenager Adau Abraham, from Adau, 18, said: 'It is clear they don't want me here in France. "I tried to claim asylum at the application centre, but they told me I was too late and I would have to come back the next day and try again. 'Then, when I was walking back to the Jungle, the police stopped me and arrested me. I can't afford to waste any more time in Europe so I am going to England to try again Sadia Hassan "They said that as I didn't have any papers, I was illegal in France. "They put me in jail for three hours, which was terrifying. 'They told me they didn't want to see me again, that I had one week to leave France, or else.' Student Ali Yousef, 25, intends to move to Britain after he was kicked out of Germany. He said: 'I was living in Munich for a year or so and everything was good until they told me to leave. 'I had friends there and German people seemed nice, but the authorities do not care about our needs. 'They rejected my claim, even though I have tribal issues in Somalia. "I was deported last year and now I will go to the UK and try again.' Sadia Hassan, 20, from Adale, Somalia, had her asylum claims rejected by two EU countries. Standing with a female friend outside the Auchan store, she said: 'I lived in Holland for two years and they wasted my time. "Then I went to Germany and lived there for three months, but they said no, too. 'I can't afford to waste any more time in Europe so I am going to England to try again. Read more on the Irish Sun 'If they reject me, I don't know what I will do" Unlock even more award-winning articles as The Sun launches brand new membership programme - Sun Club.
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
The Irish Times view on EV sales: acceleration needed
Prices drive car sales. It's a self-evident truth, proven by numerous scrappage schemes, and the 2008 move to an emissions-based motor tax regime. So, a grant of up to €10,000 applied to electric cars would push the volumes towards the critical 16 per cent of vehicle stock, where research shows mass-market adoption is achieved. By the end of last year, Irish EV market adoption stood at 3 per cent. The proposed grant is one of the most eye-catching proposals in the Climate Change Advisory Council's latest annual review on transport. It cogently identifies the key hurdles to EV adoption: cost and charging infrastructure. On the cost side, it suggests a targeted grant scheme of up to €10,000, aimed specifically at lower income households in areas poorly served by public transport. However, the devil would be in the detail. Execution may prove complex, and administratively burdensome. Also, the range of new EVs within the proposed €35,000 price cap remains limited. Still, it reflects the need for innovative thinking. France, for example, offered 50,000 European-built EVs leased at €100 per month to low-income households. The scheme closed in January last year after just six weeks due to the high demand. Initially capped at 25,000 vehicles, subsidised to a maximum of €13,000 each, it had more than 90,000 applications. READ MORE For any consumer who finds an affordable EV option, the next big question is about charging. The report rightly highlights our poor performance compared to EU peers on public charging infrastructure. It identifies key sticking points, such as deploying neighbourhood charging for those without access to off-street parking. The council's review correctly identifies the key obstacles to EV adoption, and a €10,000 grant scheme, targeted at lower-income drivers, would supercharge sales. But without detail, infrastructure and swift Government action, the ambition may stall. Kudos to the council: now it's time for Government to move from recommendations to action.
