Ross accuses Presiding Officer of misleading parliament
Speaking to journalists afterwards, Mr Ross said he was 'very frustrated' by the decision.
'For a member to be expelled from the chamber without being warned at all, I think may be unprecedented,' he said. 'I have been warned in the past, as has John Swinney. I have been warned quite a lot recently, as has John Swinney, for shouting and heckling and others and asking questions, as have many SNP backbenchers and frontbenchers.'
Asked directly if he was questioning the Presiding Officer's neutrality, he replied: 'Yes.'
However, a spokesperson for Ms Johnstone said Mr Ross had been repeatedly warned about his heckling.
READ MORE
On Tuesday, Mr Ross accused Ms Johnstone of refusing to meet him following his ejection the previous week.
He attempted to raise the matter via a point of order, telling her: 'Following your decision to remove me from the chamber last Thursday, I have made several requests to meet with you to discuss this. So far you have refused all requests.'
Ms Johnstone responded that this was 'not a point of order' and instructed him to sit down.
Mr Ross persisted, saying that under parliamentary rules the Presiding Officer 'must act in a neutral manner'.
As the two spoke over each other, Ms Johnstone said: 'I have acted in a neutral manner. I have addressed the point of order on Thursday. I am not continuing to have a dialogue about when I am meeting you in the chamber.'
She added that she had not received a specific request to meet Mr Ross and insisted: 'I treat all members equally.'
Further attempts by Mr Ross to raise points of order were dismissed, with Ms Johnstone saying it was necessary to move on to other business.
"Mr Ross, please sit down. I have acted in a neutral manner."@Douglas4Moray attempts to raise his dismissal from the chamber during last week's #FMQs with Presiding Officer Alison Johnstone. pic.twitter.com/HABSMyI6gI — Holyrood (@HolyroodDaily) June 3, 2025
Later on Tuesday, Mr Ross issued a statement saying: 'This latest exchange has left me with even greater concerns about the approach taken by the Presiding Officer in the chamber.
'If she or her office are going to repeatedly reject requests for a private meeting, then I have no option but to raise this in parliament.
'Given how she responded, I believe that there are further serious questions for her to answer as a matter of urgency.
'Either the Presiding Officer is completely unaware of these requests being turned down on her behalf, or she has misled parliament and should correct the record.'
Last week, the former Tory leader accused Ms Johnstone of constitutional bias, suggesting she treats pro-union parties more harshly than those who supported independence in the 2014 referendum.
The row followed an exchange in which Scottish Conservative leader Russell Findlay challenged the First Minister on the impact of net zero policies on agriculture. In response, Mr Swinney blamed Brexit for harming farmers, prompting Mr Ross to shout: 'Swinney deflecting again.'
Ms Johnstone then paused proceedings: 'Mr Ross, you have persistently refused to abide by our standing orders and I would ask you to leave this chamber. You are excluded for the rest of the day.'
Mr Ross initially refused to leave, forcing proceedings to pause again until he departed.
Ms Johnstone was elected as a Scottish Green MSP in 2021 but surrendered her party membership after becoming Presiding Officer.
On Friday, First Minister John Swinney defended the Presiding Officer, saying she had a difficult job and 'always acts impartially' in upholding the chamber's rules.
At the time, a Scottish Parliament spokesperson said: "The Presiding Officer has warned Mr Ross on repeated occasions recently about his behaviour in the Chamber.
'Due to his persistent refusal to respect the rules of Parliament, the Member was asked to leave the Chamber. This suspension is for the remainder of the day.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mirror
18 minutes ago
- Daily Mirror
Brits can skip passport queues at major holiday destination from this week
Cabinet Office Minister Nick Thomas Symonds confirmed Keir Starmer's deal with the EU was delivering benefits already - allowing holidaymakers to zip through eGates instead of lengthy passport queues Holidaymakers from the UK can skip lengthy passport queues at a major European holiday destination from today, after Keir Starmer cut a deal with the EU. Faro Airport in Portugal will start the rollout of eGate access to UK arrivals this week, the minister for EU relations has said. Taking a question about steps "to improve relations with the EU", Nick Thomas-Symonds - a minister in the Cabinet Office - told the Commons: "The historic deal that we signed with the EU on May 19 is in our national interests - good for bills, borders and jobs. "It slashes red tape and bureaucracy, boosts British exporters and makes life easier for holidaymakers. "Indeed, I'm delighted to confirm this morning that Faro Airport in Portugal will start the rollout of e-gate access to UK arrivals this week." Starmer described the deal as a "win-win" as he shook hands with the President of the European Commission, Ursula von der Leyen, in London last month. "Britain is back on the world stage," he declared. "[The deal] gives us unprecedented access to the EU market, the best of any country... all while sticking to the red lines in our manifesto." The PM went on to explain the impact of the "new partnership between an independent Britain and our allies in Europe" on voters' daily lives. "Let me set out why it is good for Britain," he said in a speech posted to X. "Today's deal will [...] help British holidaymakers. We're confirming that they will be able to use e-gates when they travel to Europe, ending those huge queues at passport control." Since Brexit, British passport holders have been considered "visa-exempt third-country nationals" and have generally had to queue for manual checks at border control to have their passport stamped. Brits were able to use e-gates at a limited number of airports in Spain and Portugal. However, the EU has now agreed to ease checks on British travellers more universally. The deal states that "there will be no legal barriers to e-gate use for British nationals travelling to and from European Union." It's yet to be confirmed when the rest of the rollout will go ahead. But the EU plans to launch its new Entry/Exit System (EES) in October 2025, replacing the need for non-EU citizens to have their passports stamped. It is thought that more EU airports will allow UK passengers to use the e-gates after the new system comes into effect. The system will require travellers to have their fingerprints scanned and a photograph taken so they can be registered to a database. Their data will then be stored for three years. Those who do not provide a fingerprint scan and photo will be denied entry. Some EU airports will still require additional checks and Brits may not be able to use e-gates here. Brits will also still be subject to the '90-day rule', whereby eligible non-EU citizens can spend 90 days in any 180-day period in the EU without a visa. Travel records will be digitised under the new EES to enforce this rule and increase border security. The 'landmark deal' is also expected to "lower food prices at checkouts", improve UK defence and put "more money in people's pockets," according to Starmer. Von der Leyen described it as "a historic moment [...] opening a new chapter in our unique relationship."
The Independent
25 minutes ago
- The Independent
Anti-Brexit newspaper changes name to reflect ‘reality' of global politics
The New European, a 'Remainer' magazine launched in response to the Brexit referendum, is being renamed to reflect the changing picture of global politics. The rebrand to The New World is a nod to the 'the global unravelling' which started with Britain leaving the EU but is now being seen worldwide in countries such as the US, according to founder and editor in chief Matt Kelly. 'The New European was conceived as a pop-up provocation; a defiant middle finger to the rising tide of right wing populism that brought us Brexit,' said Mr Kelly. 'Nine years later, the world and The New European has changed dramatically. This is a reflection of that new reality. 'We know there is enormous appetite for our style of journalism - vibrant, constructive, witty and full of ideas and great reads that make sense of this extraordinary moment in world politics and culture.' The New European, which has published more than 400 editions, had 35,000 paying subscribers and claim revenues have trebled since the business moved independent three years ago. Tony Blair's former spin doctor Alastair Campbell, who is editor-at-large of The New European newspaper, said themes that underpinned Brexit are playing out around the world, including a political shift to the right in many nations. 'We're always going to be very passionately anti-Brexit, very pro internationalism, liberal democracy,' said Mr Campbell. 'When we started the paper, you could never have predicted [where we are]. Just to look at United States alone. You wouldn't have predicted that Ukraine and Russia were going to be fighting a war on the edge of Europe. Lots has happened - it's a reflection of that.' Mr Campbell said he will 'never resile from the view that Brexit is the biggest act of self harm that we've inflicted upon ourselves', but added: 'I'm hoping this will be the next chapter of a story that we're going to keep telling, which is that liberal democracy is the way forward, that nationalism is not the answer to the challenges that we face, that populism is doomed to fail, and there's a better way that involves people with an optimistic, internationalist outlook.' New contributing editors slated to join The New World include Sonia Sodha, formerly of The Observer, The Revenge of Power author Moises Naim and Tom Baldwin, Keir Starmer's biographer and former senior advisor to Labour.
Glasgow Times
25 minutes ago
- Glasgow Times
Billy McAllister who exposed Lyons family slams police
Billy McAllister, a former SNP councillor, first raised the alarm in 2000, claiming the Lyons family had infiltrated a publicly funded community centre in Milton, Glasgow. According to the Daily Record, he alleged their control of the Chirnsyde Community Initiative, which received over £1.4 million in taxpayer funding, was a front for organised crime and laid the groundwork for a bloody feud with the rival Daniel crime clan. (Image: Newsquest) READ MORE: Property fire 'linked' to ongoing gangland feud Despite his repeated warnings, authorities failed to act until the 2006 murder of Michael Lyons, who was shot dead in a Glasgow garage by members of the Daniel gang. It was only after this killing that Glasgow City Council shut down the centre and removed the Lyons family. Speaking to the Daily Record, McAllister said: "It's shocking that two young men have lost their lives, but what is more shocking is the fact that the assignation was in a public bar where members of the public were going about their lawful business, having a good night out and their lives where put in danger. "Surely, given all the intelligence and information they (the police) have on these criminals, how was this allowed to happen? "It was wrong for the police and politicians to ignore us. "If they had done an early intervention, then maybe a lot of people might still be living. "Now, 25 years later, the feud is still ongoing and they (the police) are losing the war." READ MORE: Two Scottish men die in shooting at bar in Malaga Spain His remarks come after the Glasgow Times reported the recent murders of Ross Monaghan and Eddie Lyons Jr., both shot dead on May 11 at Monaghan's Bar in Fuengirola, Spain. The Glasgow Times reported that the gunman fled in a waiting vehicle, and Spanish police continue to investigate. Police Scotland has confirmed it is assisting Spanish authorities but has not deployed officers to Spain. Eddie Lyons Jnr and Ross Monaghan(Image: Spindrift) READ MORE: Graphic footage emerges of Ross Monaghan gangland shooting McAllister, who was elected in 2006 after campaigning to remove the Lyons gang from Chirnsyde, said the roots of the feud lie in drug trafficking and the battle for control over north Glasgow. He also claimed that both Monaghan and Lyons Jr. were members of the so-called 'Club Boys,' a group of young criminals associated with the community centre during its operation. Billy added: "The origins of the feud were all drug-related, and control of that market. "The Lyons, along with the Daniel's were determined to control the north of the city at that time. "They always hated each other, going back to when they were petty criminals. "We kept on complaining, but they just ignored it, but lo and behold, it all came out at the end." He continued: "A top policeman told me that the police and politicians had left the cancer of serious and organised crime too long without addressing the problem head-on. "That's why criminality is a growth industry, the risks are very low of getting caught. "The Lyons could have been taken out when they were petty criminals, but they have been allowed to go undetected and look where we are now." The Glasgow Times reported that Police Scotland issued a statement, reiterated that there is no current intelligence linking the Spanish shootings to ongoing gang violence in Scotland under investigation through Operation Portaledge. READ MORE: Police Scotland issue statement after fatal shooting in Spain A spokesperson said: "The investigation into the fatal shootings in Fuengirola is being carried out by Spanish police. "Police Scotland is supporting Spanish police where requested; however, at this time, we have no officers deployed within Spain. "There is currently no intelligence to suggest the deaths of these two men in Spain are linked to the recent criminal attacks in Scotland being investigated as part of Operation Portaledge. "Any misinformation or speculation linking the events in Spain is not helpful to the ongoing investigations in either country. "There is also nothing to suggest that the shooting in Fuengirola was planned from within Scotland."
