Mushroom cook's lie to cops: court
Sitting in a police interview room a day after two in-laws had died from death cap mushroom poisoning, Erin Patterson claimed she did not own a dehydrator.
Just under 21 minutes of footage from the August 5, 2023, interview was played for the jury in her triple-murder trial after prosecutors called their final witness of the case.
Detective leading Senior Constable Stephen Eppingstall, a homicide squad detective who led the investigation into the fatal lunch, took to the witness box on Tuesday afternoon.
Constable Eppingstall, who has sat behind prosecutors for the duration of the five week trial, formally charged Ms Patterson on November 2, 2023, the jury was told. Detective Stephen Eppingstall will be the last witness called by the Crown. NewsWire / Diego Fedele Credit: News Corp Australia
Ms Patterson has pleaded not guilty to three counts of murder and one count of attempted murder relating to a deadly beef wellington lunch she hosted with members of her husband Simon Patterson's family on July 29 the same year.
Gail Patterson and her sister Heather Wilkinson both died on August 4, while Gail's husband Don Patterson died the following day.
Heather's husband, Ian Wilkinson, fell critically ill but recovered after spending more than a month and a half in hospital.
Prosecutors allege Ms Patterson deliberately spiked the lunch with death cap mushrooms, while her defence argues it was a tragic accident and she did not intentionally poison anyone. Ms Patterson's husband, Simon Patterson, said he did not attend the lunch. NewsWire / David Geraghty Credit: News Corp Australia
In the interview, held at Wonthaggi Police Station in the afternoon of August 5, Constable Eppingstall tells Ms Patterson police are trying to understand what has made the quartet so ill and, conversely, why she wasn't that sick.
Seated across from the two detectives and wearing a brown jumper, Ms Patterson softly indicates she understands.
'I'm sure you understand too that I've never been in a situation like this before and I have been very, very helpful with the health department during the week because I wanted to help,' she says.
'I do want to know what happened, so I've given them as much information as they've asked for.'
Later in the interview, Constable Eppingstall tells Ms Patterson police have 'got concerns' about the source of the mushrooms used in the lunch.
He asks if she had ever foraged for mushrooms, with Ms Patterson responding; 'never ever'.
Constable Eppingstall questions if she ever 'dehydrates things' and receives a shake of the head in response.
Later still, he asks if Ms Patterson owned a dehydrator.
'No,' she responds.
The officer then tells Ms Patterson they located a manual for a Sunbeam dehydrator in her kitchen when they searched the property earlier the same day.
'I've got manuals of lots of stuff I collected over the years … I just keep them all,' she said.
The detective continues the line of questioning with; 'when did you ever own a dehydrator?'. Ms Patterson told the interviewers she loved her in-laws. Brooke Grebert-Craig. Credit: Supplied
Ms Patterson's reply is not audible, but she then begins to talk about owning a Thermomix.
'When I first got the Thermomix I got really excited about making everything from scratch,' she said.
Earlier in the trial, the jury saw footage of Ms Patterson disposing of a black Sunbeam dehydrator at the Koonwarra transfer station and landfill on August 2.
In his opening address to the jury, her barrister, Colin Mandy SC, told jurors Ms Patterson accepted she lied about owning a dehydrator or ever foraging for mushrooms.
'The defence case is that she panicked because she was overwhelmed by the fact that these four people had become so ill because of the food that she'd served to them,' he said.
'Might someone panic in a situation like that? Is it possible that people might do and say things that are not well thought out and might, in the end, make them look bad?'
Constable Eppingstall will return to the witness box when the hearing resumes at 10.30am on Wednesday.
The trial continues.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Perth Now
30 minutes ago
- Perth Now
Unprovoked attack lands officers in hospital
Two Gold Coast police officers had to be hospitalised after an ATV ramming on Sunday morning. Gold Coast Acting Chief Superintendent Peter Miles said the officers were conducting patrols in an ATV in Kingsholme when they were targeted. Body worn camera footage shows white Isuzu MUX ramming into the ATV of two police officers, who were later sent to the hospital for their injuries. Credit: Gold Coast Bulletin The officers' attention was drawn to a vehicle parked on the side of the road, which they thought looked a bit suspicious while driving towards the vehicle. 'A male and a female, alighted from a nearby area, got into that vehicle, and then deliberately rammed that ATV. 'The force of the collision was enough to push the ATV into the path of another vehicle, a third vehicle that was driving nearby.' Gold Coast Police Acting Chief Superintendent Peter Miles said the incident was 'a selfish act'. Alex Treacy Credit: News Corp Australia The pair were taken to Pindara Hospital for treatment, have been discharged and will remain off work to recover from the whiplash caused by the incident. Police are looking for the offending vehicle, a white Isuzu MUX with a wraparound bullbar, a black snorkel on the driver's side, and black mag wheels. The number plates have been revealed to be fake after police checks, and it is unclear at this stage whether they were stolen or cloned. Chief Superintendent Miles said that they don't know who the offenders are, and if they 'haven't got returned to prison warrants'. 'They've got real reasons to want to be away from police and get away,' he said. 'They didn't hang around to see if those officers were severely injured or not – it's all about them, it's a selfish act. 'They're willing to do this to police, ram police cars, they'll ram anyone. Anyone who's in their way is a problem for them, and that certainly is concerning as well.' Body worn camera footage captures the offending vehicle ramming into the police ATV on Sunday. Credit: Gold Coast Bulletin The police ATV, which was worth $25,000, was written off in the crash with the intention to be replaced to continue patrols in the bushland isolated areas. Chief Superintendent Miles is appealing in Kingsholme area between 11am and 12pm on Sunday with any CCTV and dashcam footage to come forward. 'These officers were just out there doing their job, being proactive, keeping their community safe, and this is what happens, they end up spending the afternoon in hospital,' he said. 'There used to be that fine line where police weren't targeted as much as members of the public, not anymore. It's just a sad indictment of where we are with some members of the community, and that's why we're very keen to get them (offenders) into the watch-house.'
Perth Now
2 hours ago
- Perth Now
‘Endearing' messages read in MP's trial
A political staffer who alleges Kiama MP Gareth Ward sexually abused him has told a court that he spent months 'looking over his shoulder' after the alleged assault despite sending him 'endearing' messages. Mr Ward, 43, is facing a four-week criminal trial in the Downing Centre District Court over allegations he sexually abused two young men. The NSW independent MP was charged in March 2022 with three counts of assault with act of indecency, an alternative charge of common assault against an 18-year-old man at Meroo Meadow in 2013, and intercourse without consent against a 24-year-old man in Potts Point in 2015. He has pleaded not guilty to each of the five charges. Mr Ward arrived in court on Monday for the second week of the criminal trial before Judge Kara Shead SC. The first complainant, a man who was aged 24 at the time of the alleged assault, again took the stand to give evidence in a cross-examination by defence solicitor David Campbell SC. State member for Kiama Gareth Ward is facing a four-week criminal trial in the Downing Centre District Court. NewsWire / John Appleyard Credit: News Corp Australia Mr Campbell asked the man, who cannot be named for legal reasons, about an RSVP to a party in 2016. The man said he 'did not recall' either sending an RSVP or even attending the party. However, Mr Campbell put to the man that it would be 'extraordinary' for him not to remember attending such an event, given how he previously told the court that he felt 'uncomfortable' towards Mr Ward at the time. 'Until today I haven't recalled attending,' the man replied, noting it was almost 10 years ago. The man's memory again came under question when Mr Campbell asked him about further communications with Mr Ward in the months following the alleged assault. A series of Facebook messages were read out in court between the complainant and Mr Ward. In the messages, the man refers to Mr Ward as 'love', along with a smiley face, and asks him how his night was. Mr Campbell said the term 'love' was 'an expression of endearment', which he suggested was not the sort of dialogue one would use when feeling 'uncomfortable'. The man replied that he often referred to others, as well as colleagues, as 'love' or 'dear' and perhaps he was 'overcompensating' at the time. During the time of the messages in the months following the alleged assault the man told the court that he felt a 'little uncomfortable'. 'What do you mean by that?' Mr Campbell asked. 'Having to be alert made me uncomfortable … when you're looking over your shoulder, you often felt uncomfortable,' the man replied. The cross-examination is expected to continue on Monday afternoon. The man had earlier told the court that he attended an event on the night of the alleged assault at NSW Parliament House in 2015 before heading back to Mr Ward's apartment. Messages between Mr Ward and a complainant were read out in court on Monday. NewsWire / John Appleyard Credit: News Corp Australia The man said he had drunk 'three or four glasses of white wine' at the event and was trying to organise a cab ride home when he ran into Mr Ward. The pair had a brief conversation before Mr Ward allegedly invited the man to his office at Parliament House where he poured the staffer another wine. The man told Mr Ward that he had to leave as he lived 'a long way away', to which the MP offered the 24-year-old to stay at his place that night, the court was told. The pair allegedly walked to Mr Ward's apartment in Potts Point, and along the way Mr Ward continued telling the man about 'how bright' his future was, the court was told. Back at Mr Ward's apartment, the MP poured the man another drink before allegedly attempting to kiss him on his balcony, to which the political staffer pushed him away and said 'no'. Mr Ward leaned in again a short time later and kissed the man before the 24-year-old said he wanted to go to bed, the court was told. The Crown alleges the man was shown to his room by Mr Ward, who had allegedly stripped down to his boxers. Mr Ward allegedly put an arm over the man and his hands on the man's buttocks before he was told to stop. Without warning, it's alleged Mr Ward digitally penetrated him before allegedly kissing his neck and masturbating. The two maintained a professional relationship for some time after the alleged events, the court was told. The man made a formal statement years later to police, and Mr Ward was formally charged in March 2022. In her opening address last week, Crown prosecutor Monika Knowles alleged that Mr Ward indecently assaulted another man, who had just turned 18, at his home on the South Coast in February 2013. Beginning his political career in 2011, Mr Ward was a councillor on the Shoalhaven Council before becoming the Liberal member for Kiama in 2011, a seat he has held since. The trial continues. mental health support
Perth Now
4 hours ago
- Perth Now
Prisoner on the run after shock escape
A prisoner is on the run after a shock escape by tractor from a correctional facility in Far North Queensland. Michael Graeme Rennie, 43, is serving a six year, three month sentence for various offences including serious assault, motor vehicle offences, theft and burglary offences and drugs and weapons offences, at Low Custody Correctional Centre. He was conducting his work duties on a correctional farm on Sunday when he escaped. Michael Graeme Rennie has absconded from Lotus Glen Low Custody Correctional Centre on Monday, allegedly when conducting his work duties. Queensland Police Credit: NewsWire Rennie was last seen driving a Red Massey Tractor with an attached bucket. The correctional facility offers programs in the fields of both farming and industry, to equip inmates with skills in preparation for their release. The Queensland Police have warned the public to not approach him if seen and to immediately contact authorities. Rennie was last seen driving a Red Massey Tractor at Low Custody Farm, before his escape. Queensland Police Credit: NewsWire Rennie is described having fair hair and complexion with blue eyes, with a light build standing at 174cm and weighing 56kg. He also has a number of body markings, with the upper half as follows: a gun tattoo on his left shoulder, a dragon and skull on his right shoulder, with a screamer on his top shoulder blade, a clown with a gun on his left ribs, the letters 'SMP', a gargoyle, a demon holding a skull with horn and 3 names on his left arm, multiple dog bites and scars on his left arm, and on his right arm, a Celtic design, skull clown, full sleeve on forearm and knuckle dusters. The lower half of his body includes a knee to ankle brick wall, panther, anarchy sign, skull, 4 headstones, clown face and 8 ball on his left leg, a Celtic sleeve on his outside right calf, a star on his right foot, and a joker with crown on the side of his right knee. Anyone with information is urged to contact Policelink through the online suspicious activity form which operates 24 hours per day or call 131 444. Anonymous reporting of any information can also be done at Crime Stoppers by calling 1800 333 000.
