Trans athlete in political storm earns, and shares, first place in event

Time of India

2 days ago

Tired of too many ads?
Remove Ads
Tired of too many ads?
Remove Ads
Tired of too many ads?
Remove Ads
The California athlete at the center of a searing political debate over transgender girls competing in girls' sports went home a winner Saturday in what is arguably the most competitive state track and field meet in the nation. AB Hernandez , a junior from Jurupa Valley High School in Riverside County , shared first place in the high jump and triple jump, and also shared second in the long jump. Her spot on the awards podium was a sign of how complicated her participation in the competition had become.With President Donald Trump threatening to cut federal funding to the state if the trans girl competed, the event organizer changed the rules just days before the event in hopes of allaying concerns about the fairness of allowing Hernandez to compete. The athlete who finished behind Hernandez would be elevated to share her placement.The first awards came after the long jump, and that moment of recognition did not turn out to be awkward or contentious, as some people had feared.The two girls -- Hernandez and Brooke White of River City High School -- joked around like any teenage girls would, giving each other an enthusiastic double-handed high-five before they squeezed onto one step of the podium together. Then after both received medals, they put their arms around each other, held their medals out from their chests and smiled for photos.Hernandez and the event's winner -- Loren Webster of Wilson High School -- both had leaped more than a foot farther than anyone else in the event. For Webster, it was a back-to-back state title in the event before she heads off to compete at the University of Oregon For Hernandez, it was the celebration she had waited for after a week of enduring an intense spotlight. Two years ago, two trans girls had qualified for the state meet but withdrew because they were afraid for their safety. The online harassment had grown ominous.In an emailed statement from the group TransFamily Support Services , which is representing Hernandez's family, her mother, Nereyda Hernandez, wrote that her child has been attacked for "simply being who they are."She wrote that her daughter's competitors showed her respect and sportsmanship, but recently adults -- "some even in positions of power, who should be protectors of our youth" -- were the ones harassing her.Hernandez's performances drew interest far beyond the stadium in Clovis , a city near Fresno. Her participation, allowed under a 2013 state law that said students could compete in the category consistent with their gender identity, has fueled a searing political debate.Gov. Gavin Newsom of California, a Democrat, earlier this year called it "deeply unfair" that trans girls compete in girls' events.On Saturday, hours before the meet, Steve Hilton, a Republican candidate for governor, also weighed in on the issue, holding a campaign stop just outside the stadium.Flanked by activists holding up signs that read "Save Girls Sports" and joined by the mayor pro tem of Clovis, Diane Pearce, Hilton called out Newsom for not adequately addressing the issue of trans girls competing in girls' sports."Every time he's asked about that, he just says, 'Oh, it's too difficult and there's nothing we can do,'" Hilton said, adding that there is, in fact, something that he could do: repeal the law that allows trans girls to play. He said he would press for that.At the meet, some coaches inside the stadium acknowledged the complexity of the situation and were sympathetic to the trans athlete's place in the middle of a national debate.Martial Yapo, an assistant track coach at Santa Margarita High School , said the teenager has forced him to contemplate what he would do if he were to coach a trans athlete facing added scrutiny."I don't have the answer, but I'm going through the same process as many other people," Yapo said. "But being a decent human is more important."Bryn Williams, an assistant sprint coach at the school, which had athletes competing Saturday, said the new measures about final placement seemed reasonable given that the issue arose such a short time before the event."I think it is the definition of a compromise -- trying to meet in the middle over something knowing that not everyone is going to be 100% happy with the decision that was made," she said.What put Hernandez at the center of the issue's spotlight was that she was good at her sport. She had gone into the meet as one of the favorites in the long jump and triple jump, worrying some coaches and competitors that she would win those events and displace girls who would have won state titles if she had not competed.The points she scored would matter, too, because schools were vying for a team title and the higher an athlete places, the more points she earns for her team.With those concerns looming, the California Interscholastic Federation, the entity that organizes the state meet, crafted the last-minute compromise to try to keep the competition fair without excluding athletes.Once Saturday's finals began, people outside the stadium chanted through bullhorns, "No boys in girls' sports," and some people high up in the stands shouted the same thing during Hernandez's first event, the long jump. But before she took off down the runway, cheers drowned out the chanting, with several people shouting, "Go, girl!"She stepped over the takeoff line during her first attempt, a foul. Before her next jump, the announcer got on the loudspeaker to say that the event was pausing to allow the hecklers in the stands to quiet down. He said everyone should respect the competitors.All the while, none of the athletes seemed bothered: At one point Hernandez stood under a tent as she awaited her next jump, sharing a laugh with a couple of fellow competitors as the chants from outside the stadium carried on.She and Webster exchanged the lead a few times before Webster finished on top, with a jump of 21 feet, 1/4 inch, ahead of Hernandez's 20 feet, 8-3/4 inches. In the triple jump, Hernandez's jump was 42 feet, 2-3/4 inches -- nearly 2 feet longer than the next girl's jump.In the high jump, Hernandez cleared 5 feet, 7 inches, with no missed attempts, while two other competitors -- Lelani Laruelle and Jillene Wetteland -- also cleared the height, but each with one failed attempt.The three of them climbed to the top step of podium together. A lone voice shouted from the crowd, "That's a boy!" but the girls appeared to ignore it, or did not hear it, and they continued to smile for the cameras.This article originally appeared in The New York Times.