US wildfire data misused following devastating LA wildfires
Following devastating Southern California blazes in January 2025, a post on X claimed US acreage lost to wildfires is decreasing compared with historical data. This is misleading; scientists say records prior to 1983 are unreliable and that climate change in recent years has created conditions for more intense, fast-spreading blazes in the United States.
"Acreage lost to wildfires in the United States fell sharply over a century, despite far more fires deliberately lit. The number of wildfires is not rising, a fake claim based on climate propaganda," a January 27, 2025 post on X by Australian author Peter Clack claims.
In his post, Clack shares a chart -- initially crafted by previously debunked climate-skeptic Anthony Watts -- created by combining official statistics (archived here) currently visible on the US National Interagency Fire Center (NIFC) covering 1983 to the present -- which show an upward trend in US wildfires -- with unofficial data covering a longer timeframe.
Similar narratives have previously circulated on social media, purporting official data has been manipulated to exaggerate observed historical trends. The charts suggest acreage lost peaked around 1930 at levels much higher than in recent years.
Image
A screenshot of an X post taken on February 6, 2025
But the NIFC clearly states on its website: "Prior to 1983, the federal wildland fire agencies did not track official wildfire data using current reporting processes. As a result, there is no official data prior to 1983 posted on this site."
artment of Agriculture Forest Service Research ecologist, Karen Short (archived here), reported on bias and inconsistencies in older statistics in a 2015 paper (archived here).
Millions of acres of intentional burns in the United States used to be included as part of the annual estimates of wildfire activity on unprotected lands, she noted.
In particular, she pointed to prescribed burns that are not currently considered or tracked as wildfires under current criteria but were included in estimates of the acres lost to fire in three southeastern states.
More acres, faster burns
The US Bureau of Land Management also told AFP that the data prior to 1983 is not reliable and said recent datasets point to concerning signs of more intense fire seasons in the country.
Between 1983 and 2004, an average of fewer than 4 million acres burned per year, but in recent decades more than 6 million acres burned annually even though the number of wildfires did not substantially increase, according to the US Bureau of Land Management.
During that period, a slight "reduction in number of fires but increase in acres burned shows a growing trend of larger fires that have become more difficult to suppress," Brian Hires, a spokesman for the agency, told AFP on February 5.
Propagation speed is another key factor in tracking how warming trends impact fire seasons in the US, scientists say (archived here). Fires get supercharged by warming trends as vegetation transitions to more flammable fuels amid weather whiplash -- a growing phenomenon documented in California (archived here).
Numbers predating 1983 "should be treated very carefully and skeptically," Keith Weber, a wildfire researcher at Idaho State University, told AFP on February 4.
"Fire frequency, fire size, and the number of megafires (100,000 acres or more) is trending upward," he explained.
Human-induced warming has led to longer fire seasons, increasing the risks of wildfire including in the western
However, he noted, while climate and weather "can and do play a role, so does decades of past fire suppression (resulting in fuel stockpiles), invasive grasses, and land management practices" that have also contributed to fueling wildfires.
The Palisades and Eaton fires that ravaged Los Angeles County were the most destructive in the history of the second-largest US city, burning some 37,000 acres (150 square kilometers). The blazes killed about 30 people and displaced thousands more, with hundreds of billions of dollars in estimated damage to property and more than 10,000 homes destroyed.
AFP has debunked other misleading claims about the California wildfires.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
France 24
a day ago
- France 24
New T-Rex ancestor discovered in drawers of Mongolian institute
This slender ancestor of the massive Tyrannosaurus Rex was around four metres (13 feet) long and weighed three quarters of a tonne, according to a new study in the journal Nature. "It would have been the size of a very large horse," study co-author Darla Zelenitsky of Canada's University of Calgary told AFP. The fossils were first dug up in southeastern Mongolia in the early 1970s but at the time were identified as belonging to a different tyrannosaur, Alectrosaurus. For half a century, the fossils sat in the drawers at the Institute of Paleontology of the Mongolian Academy of Sciences in the capital Ulaanbaatar. Then PhD student Jared Voris, who was on a trip to Mongolia, started looking through the drawers and noticed something was wrong, Zelenitsky said. It turned out the fossils were well-preserved, partial skeletons of two different individuals of a completely new species. "It is quite possible that discoveries like this are sitting in other museums that just have not been recognised," Zelenitsky added. 'Messy' family history They named the new species Khankhuuluu mongoliensis, which roughly means the dragon prince of Mongolia because it is smaller than the "king" T-Rex. Zelenitsky said the discovery "helped us clarify a lot about the family history of the tyrannosaur group because it was really messy previously". The T-Rex represented the end of the family line. It was the apex predator in North America until 66 million years ago, when an asteroid bigger than Mount Everest slammed into the Gulf of Mexico. Three quarters of life on Earth was wiped out, including all the dinosaurs that did not evolve into birds. Around 20 million years earlier, Khankhuuluu -- or another closely related family member -- is now believed to have migrated from Asia to North America using the land bridge that once connected Siberia and Alaska. This led to tyrannosaurs evolving across North America. Then one of these species is thought to have crossed back over to Asia, where two tyrannosaur subgroups emerged. One was much smaller, weighing under a tonne, and was nicknamed Pinocchio rex for its long snout. The other subgroup was huge and included behemoths like the Tarbosaurus, which was only a little smaller than the T-rex. One of the gigantic dinosaurs then left Asia again for North America, eventually giving rise to the T-Rex, which dominated for just two million years -- until the asteroid struck. © 2025 AFP
France 24
2 days ago
- France 24
Mapping Ireland's peatlands to help cut carbon emissions
Ireland is pockmarked with patches of dark brown peat soil that make up at least 20 percent of the land cover, according to Eve Daly, a geophysicist at the University of Galway, who co-led a groundbreaking project on finding peat. "Peatland soils contain comparable amounts of carbon to the likes of rainforests so a more accurate map can lead to better land management decisions and mitigate against greenhouse gas emissions," Daly told AFP. Her research team developed a new mapping approach using gamma radiation measurements to identify for the first time "transition zones" -- typically hidden under forests and grasslands -- where the soil changes from being peat to mineral-based. Daly says the area of soil in Ireland considered "peaty" has increased thanks to a new colour-coded "peat/non-peat" map produced by the researchers. "Improved mapping at higher resolution and locating where hidden organic peat soils are and their extent are key inputs into working out carbon emission factors," she said. Her project co-leader Dave O'Leary told AFP about 80 percent of Ireland had now been mapped out in patches of "peat" brown or "non-peat" green. "Few countries have invested in such an incredible data set, which puts Ireland at the forefront of peatland mapping research," he said. 'New lens' Land use, including farming and peatland draining, is a major source of Ireland's carbon emissions which could see the country failing to meet an EU-agreed climate target to cut emissions by over 50 percent by 2030. A recent report said Ireland risks an EU fine of almost 30 billion euros if it fails to reach the target and recommended the restoring -- and rewetting -- of thousands of hectares of peatlands to help deliver "massive" cuts in emissions. "We need to use more modern technologies or use old technologies with new lenses to try and find these hidden peat soils," Daly said. Ireland's boggy areas are typically located in the middle of the bowl-shaped country which is ringed with hills and low mountains around the coastal areas. Triven Koganti, an agroecology expert at Denmark's Aarhus University, told AFP that five percent of global greenhouse gas emissions came from cultivated peatlands. "Historical agricultural draining of peatlands... or to use them as a fuel source has led to significant greenhouse gas emissions," he said. So "an accurate accounting" of peatland boundaries is needed to achieve "current global initiatives to restore peatlands", he said, adding the Irish research "plays an important role in establishing this". 'Bird's eye' technique The mapping technique -- described as "bird's eye" by Daly -- is based on gamma-ray data measured by a sensor onboard a plane that has been flown low over Ireland for a decade in a state-funded geophysical survey. "All rocks and different amounts of soils give off a certain amount of natural radiation but peat doesn't as it's full of organic material," Daly said. Soils are usually a mixture of broken bits of rock, water and air, but peat soils are distinct from mineral soils as they are formed from decaying plant material, water and air, and contain a very high amount of carbon. When waterlogged, this carbon is stored in the soil but when water is removed, for example via drainage, peat soils then emit carbon dioxide as the decay process restarts, Daly said. The state-funded "Tellus" survey began in 2011 and is expected to be completed later this year.
AFP
4 days ago
- AFP
Nepal 'cloudburst' video is AI generated
"Live video footage of cloudburst in Nepal," reads the Hindi-language caption of a video posted on X on May 25, 2025. It appears to show torrents of water emptying out of a cloud onto already flooded fields. It was shared as monsoon rains in eastern Nepal caused at least one death, according to the Kathmandu Post, as well as widespread flooding and disruptions to transport (archived link). Meteorologists in Nepal said the monsoon clouds had entered the country two weeks ahead of schedule, with the National Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Authority predicting that around two million could be affected by monsoon-related disasters (archived link). Image Screenshot of the false X video, captured on June 6, 2025 The video was also shared among Hindi-speaking users on Facebook and Instagram. "What a terrifying scene... it seems like water gushing out of a dam," reads a comment on one of the posts. Another comment reads: "A very scary scene... May God protect everyone." But Nepalese authorities told AFP that no such weather phenomena had occurred in the country. "Monsoon (season) has begun in Nepal so many areas are receiving rain. But there has been no incident of any cloudburst recently," Dinkar Kayastha, an information officer with the Department of Hydrology and Meteorology, said on June 5. A reverse image search on Google using keyframes from the falsely shared video led to the same footage posted in a YouTube short on May 19 (archived link). The video's includes the hashtag "AI", and the user who posted the video also posted others with the same hashtag that appear to have been AI generated (archived link). Image Screenshot comparison of the falsely shared video (left) and YouTube short posted in May 2025 (right) The director of Purdue University's Machine Learning and Media Forensics Lab, Shu Hu, also told AFP that there are visual inconsistencies in the video which confirm the clip was generated using AI (). "The red roof was absent at the beginning of the video but appeared later," . Image Screenshots of the visual inconsistencies in the falsely shared video AFP has debunked other false claims that utilised AI-generated footage here.
