‘Grave concerns' in strip search case
A judge presiding over the case of a woman suing the state of NSW over a strip search at a popular music festival has told the court she has 'grave concerns' about the conduct of the defence, who admitted after two years the search was unlawful.
Raya Meredith was made to undress in front of a police officer, lift her breasts, and remove her tampon during a 'humiliating' and terrifying strip search at the Splendour in the Grass music festival in 2018 that police later admitted was illegal.
The then-27-year-old is the lead plaintiff in a class-action lawsuit brought by Slater and Gordon and the Redfern Legal Centre against the state of NSW on behalf of more than 3000 people likely subjected to illegal strip searches from 2016-2022.
Ms Meredith's lawyer, Kylie Nomchong SC argued in her closing statements Tuesday and Wednesday that there was a failure on the part of 'senior echelons' of NSW Police to ensure proper training and supervision given to police doing searches. The state of NSW is being sued over a strip search of a woman. NCA NewsWire / Flavio Brancaleone Credit: News Corp Australia
Julian Sexton SC, who is representing the state of NSW, pushed back on claims by Ms Nomchong about police training and the findings of a report by the Lessons Learned Unit (LLU) following a complaint after a 2013 Mardi Gras afterparty.
Mr Sexton said the report, contrary to submissions by Ms Nomchong, did not represent an 'admission of widespread unlawful use of strip searches' or routine unlawful strip searches and instead only made 'recommendations about best practice'.
He went on to tell the court that out of 172,000 searches in 2016, 3850 were strip searches. Resulting from those searches were only 79 complaints, four of which were sustained, with a further two sustained complaints the following year.
'This demonstrates that there was a decreasing number of complaints sustained. There were only five complaints sustained in the period up until November 2018. That doesn't indicate a widespread use of unlawful searches,' Mr Saxton said.
He made similar claims about the 'very small number' of civil cases.
Justice Dina Yehia said the defence case and state of NSW's admission that Ms Meredith's strip search was illegal were of 'grave concern' during Thursday's hearing.
Justice Yehia told Mr Saxton before the lunch adjournment that 'the conduct of the proceedings in relation to the three iterations of defence that were initially relied upon, that is a matter, I'll be quite honest with you, of grave concern to me.
'All I have is three officers' statements that say either that they don't remember the search at all or both that they don't remember the search nor remember the plaintiff, the lead plaintiff in those circumstances,' she said, referring to Ms Meredith. The closing statements are now in their third day. NewsWire / Luis Enrique Ascui Credit: News Corp Australia
'I'm just not sure how this could ever have proceeded in the way that it did with the initial pleadings.'
Mr Saxton said the admission about the legality of the search was 'more accurate to say it was an admission based on the absence of proof' and police may have based their recollections on 'practice' rather than specific memory.
In response, Justice Yehia said: 'An assertion that the officer's assessment of the plaintiff's demeanour, physical appearance, body language and answers to questions while they spoke outside the tent is very specific.'
Under NSW law, strip searches – which are recognised as being 'highly invasive and humiliating' – are supposed to be undertaken within specific statutory guidelines, including preconditions of 'seriousness and urgency' that they be done.
Ms Nomchong told the court on Tuesday that not a single COPS event log contained why a strip search was necessary, and the general duties officers were 'defective in their understanding of the basis on which strip searches could be carried out'.
'They were not supervised. They were not trained. And, as a direct result, that is why my plaintiff was unlawfully strip searched … along with others who attended the music festival in 2018,' Ms Nomchong said in her more than six-hour statement.
Resuming on Wednesday, Ms Nomchong urged the court to award exemplary damages 'not only to express the court's disapprobation but because of the manifest breaches of the (Law Enforcement Powers and Responsibilities Act) by searching officers'.
Ms Nomchong went on to add 'but also because of the … manifest failures on the part of the senior echelons of the NSW Police Force responsible for both general and focus training for conducting strip searches' in the state at the time.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Telegraph
3 hours ago
- Daily Telegraph
Alleged Alameddine gangster Ali Elmoubayed targeted in Merrylands shooting
Don't miss out on the headlines from Police & Courts. Followed categories will be added to My News. Remarkable video footage has emerged of the dramatic chase and arrest of three men accused of shooting up a home linked to an alleged Sydney gangland figure. The shooting happened about 9.20am, with police officers called to the Earl St home in Merrylands in the city's west. Bullets were fired at the house, but nobody was inside at the time. Ali Elmoubayed, an alleged member of the Alameddine enterprise, is linked to the address but dodged the shooting after reportedly leaving beforehand for the Parramatta Magistrates Court to request a change of bail address. A short time later, a burning Porsche was located in Beverley Crescent in Chester Hill, NSW Police said. NSW Polair captures a burning car on the streets of western Sydney. Picture: NSW Police The three men tried to escape in a blue Hyundai. Picture: NSW Police 'The group left Chester Hill in a Hyundai before being arrested on McMahon Rd in Yagoona trying to flee from police on foot,' police said in a statement. 'They remain in police custody.' Footage captured by the NSW Police chopper unit shows the Porsche burning in the street, with black smoke billowing out across the western Sydney suburb. Police officers then track the blue Hyundai as it races through the streets. The three men, aged 20, 22 and 24, abandon the vehicle and try to run away, but are quickly apprehended by officers in the backyards of homes. The shooting has been referred to Taskforce Falcon and crime scenes have been established at both locations. The men abandoned their car and tried to run away on foot. Picture: NSW Police Ali Elmoubayed visited the Parramatta Local Court on Thursday. Picture: NewsWire / Nikki Short The taskforce is being led by State Crime Command with the NSW Crime Commission to investigate and suppress violent crime in the Sydney metropolitan area. Taskforce Falcon Commander Detective Superintendent Jason Box addressed the media in the afternoon and said the shooting had the potential to be fatal. 'There's always the possibility it could be fatal, or someone seriously injured,' he said. He said he expected the men to be charged with firearms offences alongside other possible offences. Superintendent Box added the police had not yet found anything to suggest the three men were 'affiliated or part of an organised crime network'. Originally published as NSW Police chopper footage shows dramatic arrest of three men after alleged Merrylands shooting
Perth Now
7 hours ago
- Perth Now
Former Gold Coast Titans player acquitted in fatal punch trial
A jury has taken only minutes to find former Gold Coast Titans player Oshae Jackson Tuiasau not guilty of unlawfully striking a man who later died following a late-night altercation in Surfers Paradise. The charge stemmed from an incident in the early hours of December 19, 2021, in which 39-year-old Toro George fell and hit his head on a Surfers Paradise street. He died in hospital eight days later. Mr Tuiasau's family and supporters erupted with emotion as the verdict was read, embracing one another through tears. He put his head down and wiped away tears. He was facing a mandatory minimum sentence of 15 years behind bars, with the possibility of life imprisonment, if he had been convicted. The verdict followed nine days of evidence in the Brisbane Supreme Court, almost double the trial's original schedule, after a series of disruptions and heightened courtroom tensions. Barrister Craig Eberhardt KC mounted a forceful defence, frequently challenging the prosecution's case and making persistent submissions to support his client. Mr Tuiasau maintained he acted in self-defence. Camera Icon Oshae Jackson Tuiasau, 30, arriving at the Supreme Court in Brisbane, has been found not guilty to unlawfully striking Toro George, 39, who died in hospital eight days later. NewsWire Credit: News Corp Australia During the trial, Mr Tuiasau told the court he feared for his safety when he struck Mr George during a tense encounter on a Surfers Paradise street. 'He was lunging,' Mr Tuiasau said from the witness box. 'He was pushing towards us … he was angry.' CCTV footage showed shoving between Mr George and other members of the group. Mr Tuiasau, who appeared uninvolved in the physical exchanges, was walking on the far side. Mr George could be seen leaning towards him before Mr Tuiasau suddenly struck him once in the face. Mr George fell backwards, hitting his head on the pavement, and immediately lost consciousness. Several members of Mr George's family turned away or broke down when the footage of the punch was played. Camera Icon Toro George, 39, died on December 27, 2021. Facebook Credit: News Corp Australia Mr Tuiasau told the jury that he acted instinctively. 'I didn't have time to think,' he said. The court was told that tensions escalated earlier in the night following an allegation that Mr George had inappropriately touched a woman inside Havana RnB Nightclub. The woman was known to Mr Tuiasau. Her brother confronted Mr George inside the club, triggering a series of altercations that spilled out onto the street. One witness testified to hearing Mr Tuiasau say, 'That is what you get,' after the punch; however, he denied making the remark. Mr Tuiasau told the jury he was 'concerned' about Mr George's wellbeing after the incident, but did not initially mention the man's aggression during his police interview because he was in shock. 'My mind was scattered … I was kind of all over the place,' he said. Camera Icon Oshae Tuiasau played for the NRL team the Gold Coast Titans before the – NRL Photos Credit: No Source Mr Tuiasau's barrister, Craig Eberhardt KC, said his client's actions were not unlawful, but in self-defence against 'a drunk and aggressive man who had already sexually assaulted a woman that night'. He said Mr George was intoxicated by alcohol and cocaine and had been belligerent throughout the evening. 'He punched Mr George once in the right cheek,' Mr Eberhardt said. 'It is tragic that he died.' Crown prosecutor Toby Corsbie said it wasn't alleged Mr Tuiasau intended to kill Mr George but that Mr Tuiasau ultimately 'snapped' after a series of events throughout the night. The courtroom was packed throughout the trial with family and supporters of both men. Throughout the trial, jurors, the legal teams, and the judge navigated a series of unexpected incidents. On the first day, one juror left the courthouse during a break to retrieve personal belongings, prompting another to follow, only to become lost and eventually located on a different level of the building. On two other occasions, proceedings began late due to jurors running late, and one juror was later dismissed for personal reasons after appearing to fall asleep during the trial. Camera Icon Former NRL player Oshae Jackson Tuiasau pleaded not guilty to unlawfully striking Toro George, 39, who died in hospital eight days later. NewsWire Credit: News Corp Australia Originally comprising 12 jurors and two alternates, the panel was down to its minimum of 12 by the time closing arguments were delivered. But just as the case was about to wrap up, concerns were raised that a juror may have conducted outside research. The courtroom was closed while the parties held what Justice Frances Williams described as a 'frank' discussion. Tensions were high, with supporters on both sides visibly emotional over the possibility of a mistrial. Family members, some of whom had flown in from overseas and taken time off work and school, were visibly distressed at the prospect of the trial collapsing so close to its conclusion. Ultimately, Justice Williams determined that there had been no wrongdoing, but reminded the jurors that they must not seek external information. The trial was allowed to continue. In a further twist during Mr Corsbie's closing address, the prosecutor offered a second theory about how Mr George may have died, suggesting a combination of factors including the head injury. This sparked immediate objection from the defence, with Justice Williams criticising the prosecution for introducing a new theory not previously raised during the trial and instructed the jury to disregard the prosecutions alternative theory. During Justice Williams's summing up of the trial and giving instructions to the jury, which is usually the final step before they deliberate, Mr Corsbie applied for a mistrial on grounds that they had been treated 'unfairly'. Justice Williams scolded the prosecutor before retiring to consider her decision. Ultimately, she decided to decline the application and resumed her instructions to the jury. The jury took less than five minutes to decide their verdict.
The Advertiser
8 hours ago
- The Advertiser
Bodies found in granny flat: investigation under way into 'suspicious' deaths
Investigators have descended on a leafy, suburban street after two bodies were discovered in a backyard granny flat. The bodies were discovered at 9.30pm on June 11 in the Cannons Parade flat in Forestville on Sydney's Northern Beaches after a friend of the deceased asked police to check on the couple. A man, believed to be aged in his 40s, and a woman, believed to be aged in her 50s, were found at the flat, police said. They are yet to be formally identified. Detective Superintendent John Duncan said the couple hadn't been seen since June 7. They were known to the NSW Police "for minor matters", but the detective superintendent said they had no reported history of domestic violence in NSW. Emergency services forced entry to the flat, as "the premise was secure on police arrival," Detective Superintendent Duncan said. Their cause of death is yet to be established, but the detective superintendent said the bodies suffered lacerations. Three pets - two dogs and a cat - were in the flat with the bodies, police said. The animals were taken to a vet for assessment. "If anybody has any information about any suspicious activity in Cannon's Parade over the last four days, we encourage them to contact either Northern Beaches Police or Crime Stoppers on 1-800-333-000," Detective Superintendent Duncan said. Investigators have established a crime scene, and inquiries under Strike Force Donnybrook have begun into the circumstances surrounding the deaths. Anyone with information about this incident is urged to contact Crime Stoppers: 1800 333 000 or Information is treated in strict confidence. Support is available for those who may be distressed: Phone Lifeline 13 11 14; Men's Referral Service 1300 776 491; 13 Yarn 13 92 76; Kids Helpline 1800 551 800; beyondblue 1300 224 636; 1800-RESPECT 1800 737 732. Investigators have descended on a leafy, suburban street after two bodies were discovered in a backyard granny flat. The bodies were discovered at 9.30pm on June 11 in the Cannons Parade flat in Forestville on Sydney's Northern Beaches after a friend of the deceased asked police to check on the couple. A man, believed to be aged in his 40s, and a woman, believed to be aged in her 50s, were found at the flat, police said. They are yet to be formally identified. Detective Superintendent John Duncan said the couple hadn't been seen since June 7. They were known to the NSW Police "for minor matters", but the detective superintendent said they had no reported history of domestic violence in NSW. Emergency services forced entry to the flat, as "the premise was secure on police arrival," Detective Superintendent Duncan said. Their cause of death is yet to be established, but the detective superintendent said the bodies suffered lacerations. Three pets - two dogs and a cat - were in the flat with the bodies, police said. The animals were taken to a vet for assessment. "If anybody has any information about any suspicious activity in Cannon's Parade over the last four days, we encourage them to contact either Northern Beaches Police or Crime Stoppers on 1-800-333-000," Detective Superintendent Duncan said. Investigators have established a crime scene, and inquiries under Strike Force Donnybrook have begun into the circumstances surrounding the deaths. Anyone with information about this incident is urged to contact Crime Stoppers: 1800 333 000 or Information is treated in strict confidence. Support is available for those who may be distressed: Phone Lifeline 13 11 14; Men's Referral Service 1300 776 491; 13 Yarn 13 92 76; Kids Helpline 1800 551 800; beyondblue 1300 224 636; 1800-RESPECT 1800 737 732. Investigators have descended on a leafy, suburban street after two bodies were discovered in a backyard granny flat. The bodies were discovered at 9.30pm on June 11 in the Cannons Parade flat in Forestville on Sydney's Northern Beaches after a friend of the deceased asked police to check on the couple. A man, believed to be aged in his 40s, and a woman, believed to be aged in her 50s, were found at the flat, police said. They are yet to be formally identified. Detective Superintendent John Duncan said the couple hadn't been seen since June 7. They were known to the NSW Police "for minor matters", but the detective superintendent said they had no reported history of domestic violence in NSW. Emergency services forced entry to the flat, as "the premise was secure on police arrival," Detective Superintendent Duncan said. Their cause of death is yet to be established, but the detective superintendent said the bodies suffered lacerations. Three pets - two dogs and a cat - were in the flat with the bodies, police said. The animals were taken to a vet for assessment. "If anybody has any information about any suspicious activity in Cannon's Parade over the last four days, we encourage them to contact either Northern Beaches Police or Crime Stoppers on 1-800-333-000," Detective Superintendent Duncan said. Investigators have established a crime scene, and inquiries under Strike Force Donnybrook have begun into the circumstances surrounding the deaths. Anyone with information about this incident is urged to contact Crime Stoppers: 1800 333 000 or Information is treated in strict confidence. Support is available for those who may be distressed: Phone Lifeline 13 11 14; Men's Referral Service 1300 776 491; 13 Yarn 13 92 76; Kids Helpline 1800 551 800; beyondblue 1300 224 636; 1800-RESPECT 1800 737 732. Investigators have descended on a leafy, suburban street after two bodies were discovered in a backyard granny flat. The bodies were discovered at 9.30pm on June 11 in the Cannons Parade flat in Forestville on Sydney's Northern Beaches after a friend of the deceased asked police to check on the couple. A man, believed to be aged in his 40s, and a woman, believed to be aged in her 50s, were found at the flat, police said. They are yet to be formally identified. Detective Superintendent John Duncan said the couple hadn't been seen since June 7. They were known to the NSW Police "for minor matters", but the detective superintendent said they had no reported history of domestic violence in NSW. Emergency services forced entry to the flat, as "the premise was secure on police arrival," Detective Superintendent Duncan said. Their cause of death is yet to be established, but the detective superintendent said the bodies suffered lacerations. Three pets - two dogs and a cat - were in the flat with the bodies, police said. The animals were taken to a vet for assessment. "If anybody has any information about any suspicious activity in Cannon's Parade over the last four days, we encourage them to contact either Northern Beaches Police or Crime Stoppers on 1-800-333-000," Detective Superintendent Duncan said. Investigators have established a crime scene, and inquiries under Strike Force Donnybrook have begun into the circumstances surrounding the deaths. Anyone with information about this incident is urged to contact Crime Stoppers: 1800 333 000 or Information is treated in strict confidence. Support is available for those who may be distressed: Phone Lifeline 13 11 14; Men's Referral Service 1300 776 491; 13 Yarn 13 92 76; Kids Helpline 1800 551 800; beyondblue 1300 224 636; 1800-RESPECT 1800 737 732.
