Hong Kong ranks 37th overall for journalists' safety in new global index
Hong Kong ranked 37th out of 73 places in safety for journalists according to a new global index, outperforming South Korea and Indonesia but falling below Singapore and other European counterparts.
The Global Index on Journalists' Safety, published on Thursday, also saw the city score better than the United States when it came to the physical safety of reporters, but scored lower in areas measuring digital and psychological well-being.
More than 30,000 journalists across 73 jurisdictions were surveyed between 2021 and 2024 for the joint initiative between the Worlds of Journalism Study research network and the University of Liverpool, in collaboration with Unesco.
Do you have questions about the biggest topics and trends from around the world? Get the answers with SCMP Knowledge, our new platform of curated content with explainers, FAQs, analyses and infographics brought to you by our award-winning team.
Respondents were asked a set of standardised questions about their financial, psychological, physical and digital safety in their operating environments. Additionally, data from the Unesco Observatory of Killed Journalists was used for the index.
In Hong Kong, 289 journalists were surveyed between September and October last year.
Overall, Hong Kong placed 37th in safety for journalists with a score of 79.17 out of 100, surpassing other East Asian jurisdictions, including Thailand (41st), South Korea (47th), Indonesia (49th), and the Philippines (70th).
Nepal and Singapore were the best performing jurisdictions in Asia, at 13th and 17th place respectively, while Taiwan was 36th.
Portugal was the top jurisdiction for journalists' safety overall, while Norway, Germany, Czechia and Spain rounded out the top five.
Russia, mainland China, and most of the countries in Africa were not ranked.
Among the four categories analysed, Hong Kong achieved its highest score in physical safety, ranking 31st with 88.49. The category assessed the number of journalists killed, as well as arrests, detentions, and reporters' concerns for their physical health.
The city outperformed the US, which ranked 48th, where assaults against journalists have significantly increased in recent years.
However, the city scored comparatively worse in areas related to psychological and digital safety.
Regarding psychological safety, which included questions related to threats affecting reporters' mental well-being and actions aimed at delegitimising the profession, Hong Kong fell to 51st place.
In digital safety, which included threats to digital privacy such as surveillance or hacking, the city ranked 53rd.
The Post has contacted the Security Bureau for comment.
Francis Lee Lap-fung, a media scholar from the Chinese University of Hong Kong, said that the city's low score in psychological safety was likely to have stemmed from the recent use of subversion laws and the prosecution of the now-defunct Stand News and Apple Daily.
Lee, who served as the researcher for the city in the index, also noted the timing of the local survey coincided with the release of claims by the Hong Kong Journalists Association last year of an alleged 'systemic' harassment of reporters, their family members and employers.
The undersecretary for security at the time said he was unaware of the claims and reiterated that the city was a place that followed the rule of law.
Lee further suggested that the emergence of alleged online and offline harassment could explain the low ranking of Hong Kong on the digital safety index
He added that Hong Kong journalists were less concerned about their physical safety, and that there had not been any murders of reporters in Hong Kong since the city's return to Chinese sovereignty in 1997.
'Lengthy periods of pre-trial detention had become a 'norm' on cases directly related to national security concerns, but the number of journalists who actually experienced arrest and detention remains very small,' he said. 'Hence Hong Kong fares better on physical safety.'
More from South China Morning Post:
For the latest news from the South China Morning Post download our mobile app. Copyright 2025.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New Straits Times
2 days ago
- New Straits Times
Briton's death: How did backpacker enter construction site, asks Lee
KUALA LUMPUR: The authorities must investigate how a 25-year-old British national managed to trespass onto a construction site before falling into an elevator shaft. Alliance for a Safe Community chairman Tan Sri Lee Lam Thye questioned whether proper safety measures were in place, describing the incident as preventable. "The responsibility falls on the shoulders of the contractors and those managing the work site," he said. "Was there any signage at the site or a barricade? Were there any security personnel present? If they were on duty, they would not have allowed him to go through." He added that the company carrying out construction must conduct an internal investigation to prevent recurrence. Lee, who is also the former chairman of the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health, stressed that construction sites were legally required to have security measures in place to prevent trespassing. A construction work contractor is required to identify the perimeter of a construction site with a suitable sign and fence the area off under regulation 20(2) of the Occupational Safety and Health (Construction Work) (Design and Management) Regulations 2024. Anyone who violates the regulation may be liable to a fine not exceeding RM500,000 or imprisonment for a term not exceeding one year or both. On Thursday, the police confirmed that missing British backpacker Jordan Johnson-Doyle was found dead in an elevator shaft of a partially under-construction condominium in Bangsar here. A post-mortem showed that the cause of death was a chest injury due to a fall from height.
The Star
3 days ago
- The Star
New govt targets ex-president
It's done: Lawmakers passing the Bill to launch special investigations into Yoon's order at the National Assembly in Seoul. — AP The liberal-led legislature overwhelmingly passed Bills to launch special investigations into former president Yoon Suk-yeol's short-lived imposition of martial law in December and criminal allegations against his wife, targeting the ousted conservative a day after his liberal successor took office. The National Assembly also passed a Bill to initiate an independent investigation into the 2023 drowning death of a marine during a search-and-rescue operation for flood victims, an incident the Democratic Party, which holds majority, accuses Yoon's government of covering up. The Bills previously had been vetoed by Yoon during his term and by South Korea's caretaker government after his Dec 14 impeachment. President Lee Jae-myung, a Democrat who won Tuesday's snap election triggered by Yoon's removal from office, is expected to sign the Bills. Many members of the conservative People Power Party refused to participate in the votes, which took place after one of the party's lawmakers accused the liberals of being driven by vendetta. Kim Yong-min, a Democratic Party lawmaker, said the conservatives were effectively defending Yoon's imposition of martial law by repeatedly opposing investigations into it. 'That's why they failed to win public support and were rejected by voters in the presidential election,' he said in a speech. Lee, who drove the legislative efforts to impeach Yoon, pinned his presidential campaign on unity, promising not to target conservatives and calling for an end to political polarisation. Yet Lee has vowed a full investigation into Yoon's martial law imposition and the allegations surrounding his wife, moves that could overshadow the new government and inflame tensions as Yoon faces a high-stakes rebellion trial carrying a possible death sentence. The Seoul Central District Prosecutors' Office has indicted Yoon on charges accusing him of masterminding a rebellion and enacting martial law as an illegal bid to seize the legislature and election offices and arrest political opponents. Liberals have insisted independent investigations into Yoon are essential, saying probes by prosecutors, police and an anti-corruption agency were inadequate and hampered by Yoon's refusal to cooperate. If Lee approves the independent investigations, special prosecutors could request the transfer of relevant cases to expand those investigations or direct public or military prosecutors to continue handling them under their supervision. The Bills calling for independent investigations into Yoon's martial law decree and criminal allegations involving his wife both passed by a vote of 194 to three. Yoon's wife, Kim Keon-hee, also faces multiple corruption allegations, including claims that she received luxury items from a Unification Church official seeking business favours, as well as possible involvement in a stock price manipulation scheme. She is also suspected of interfering with PPP's candidate nominations ahead of legislative elections in April last year. While in office, Yoon repeatedly dismissed calls to investigate his wife, denouncing them as baseless political attacks. — AP
The Sun
3 days ago
- The Sun
Consumer groups lodge EU complaint against Shein
PARIS: Consumer groups lodged a complaint against Shein with the European Commission on Thursday, accusing the Chinese-founded e-commerce platform of using 'deceptive' and illegal techniques that fuel overconsumption. The European Consumer Organisation (BEUC), together with 25 members from 21 countries, alleged that Shein uses so-called 'dark patterns' that 'push consumers into purchasing more than originally intended'. These practices also 'fuel the environmental and societal problems caused by the fast fashion industry', the BEUC said in a statement. The complaint aims to complement the European Commission's own investigation into Shein's practices. The EU regulator warned Shein in late May over a series of practices that infringe the bloc's consumer laws, from fake discount deals to misleading product information. The commission gave Shein a month to reply and offer commitments on addressing the issues found during the probe, which was launched in February. The fast-fashion company could be fined if it does not address EU concerns. Shein said in a statement that 'European consumers would be better served if BEUC agreed to meet with us'. The online retailer, originally from China but now based in Singapore, said it was 'working constructively with national consumer protection authorities and with the European Commission to demonstrate our commitment to complying with EU laws and regulations'.
