Public Inquiry to start into Leeds Bradford Airport night flights
A public inquiry into night-time flying rules at Leeds Bradford Airport's is set to begin later. Ahead of the hearing, BBC Yorkshire's Transport Correspondent Spencer Stokes takes a look at the key issues at stake.
What is the inquiry about?
Chaired by an independent planning inspector, the inquiry will consider the legal meaning of the night-time flying rules at Leeds Bradford Airport (LBA).Currently the airport is permitted 2,920 take offs and landings between 23:00 and 07:00 during the summer.However, campaign group Group for Action on Leeds Bradford Airport (GALBA) say the airport has breached that limit in each of the past three years.But LBA chief executive, Vincent Hodder says the rules, agreed by Leeds City Council in 1994, do not take into account changes to aircraft technology over the past 30 years to reduce noise.
What's the background to the inquiry?
GALBA say LBA has exceeded its night-time flight limits in 2022, 2023, and 2024 - in the most recent year it said the airport operated 820 more flights than permitted.The airport has admitted it did "accidentally" breach the night time regulations in 2022 due to "errors taking place in reporting procedures", but claimed it had not gone over in 2023 and 2024 based on its interpretation of the rules.In a bid to update the 1994 planning consents, LBA applied to Leeds City Council last year for a Certificates of Lawfulness of Existing Use Development (CLEUDs).It said updating the rules would "provide the correct legal interpretation of the existing planning conditions governing the operation of night flights at LBA".However, two CLEUD applications were rejected by the council and the third was left "undecided", prompting LBA to appeal to the government's planning inspectorate.
Where does Leeds City Council stand?
Leeds City Council agreed the original planning consent in 1994 permitting 2,920 night flights, and is responsible for monitoring to make sure LBA does not breach the night time flights cap.It issued a breach of condition notice against LBA for the additional flights in 2022 and accepted the rules were broken again in 2023, but said the public interest for a prosecution had not been met.No action has been taken after the alleged breach in summer 2024.
Has aircraft technology changed?
The European Commission said aircraft have become 75% quieter over the last 30 years, but an increase in the number of flights has resulted in a rise in noise disturbance for a greater number of people.Jet2, who are based at Leeds Bradford Airport, have ordered 146 Airbus A320 Neo aircraft, which the airline said are 50% quieter than their current Boeing 737s.
When will the public inquiry reach a decision?
The Planning Inspector will hear evidence for four days, but it's likely to be several weeks or months before the final decision is announced.GALBA says if LBA is successful at public inquiry "they will continue to fly hundreds more night flights than the original rules intended to allow.".The airport said it would not be going through the "difficult, time-consuming and expensive process if this wasn't important to our customers and the airport".
Listen to highlights from West Yorkshire on BBC Sounds, catch up with the latest episode of Look North.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Reuters
an hour ago
- Reuters
Boeing prepares to resume plane deliveries to China as tariff war eases
SEATTLE, June 6 (Reuters) - A new Boeing (BA.N), opens new tab 737 MAX painted with Xiamen Airlines livery left Seattle on Friday on the first leg of the route used to shuttle jets to the company's delivery center in China, according to flight records on FlightRadar24. The plane was bound for Kailua-Kona, Hawaii, one of the refueling stops Boeing jets make on their way across the Pacific to China. Deliveries to Chinese customers were abruptly halted in early April as the U.S. and China edged toward a trade war. A Boeing spokesperson declined to comment on the jetliner's ultimate destination. Xiamen Airlines and the Chinese government could not immediately be reached for comment. Deliveries to China of new Boeing aircraft stopped in April in response to tariffs imposed by President Donald Trump. However, on May 12, the U.S. and China agreed to roll back the bulk of tariffs for 90 days. Trump said on Friday that U.S. and China representatives would meet June 9 in London to talk about a trade deal. Boeing CEO Kelly Ortberg on May 29 said Chinese airlines would resume taking deliveries of Boeing aircraft in June. At least three 737 MAX jets were repatriated by Boeing to the United States in April from Boeing's Zhoushan completion center near Shanghai, where they had been placed for final work before delivery to Chinese carriers. The first plane to return from China was the same one that left Friday for Hawaii. Boeing has previously said customers in China would not take delivery of new planes due to tariffs, and it was looking to resell potentially dozens of aircraft. Beijing has not commented on why Boeing deliveries stopped, but said Chinese airlines and Boeing had been severely affected by U.S.-imposed tariffs. China represents about 10% of Boeing's commercial backlog and is an important and growing aviation market. Boeing in April said it had planned for 50 jets to go to Chinese carriers during the rest of the year, with 41 in production or pre-built. While Boeing had said other airlines are interested in taking rejected Chinese planes, the planemaker has not sent the planes elsewhere despite aiming to reduce inventory levels.
Daily Mail
10 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Boeing seals £812m deal to avoid prosecution over 737 Max plane crashes that killed 346 people - as lawyer for victims' families condemns agreement as 'morally repugnant'
Boeing has reached a deal with the US Department of Justice to avoid prosecution over crashes involving a 737 Max plane that killed 346 people. The agreement, outlined in a court filing this week, will see the aerospace giant pay $1.1 billion (£812 million), including a $487.2 million criminal penalty, half of which was already paid in a previous settlement. The move has been blasted by the victims' families' lawyer, Sanjiv Singh, who told the BBC the deal was a 'morally repugnant' escape which allowed the firm to 'sidestep true criminal accountability'. If approved by a federal judge, the deal would protect the firm from a criminal fraud trial. The company previously said it is 'deeply sorry' for their loss, adding that it remains 'committed to honouring their loved one's memories' by pressing ahead with changes to the company. The deal would also see $444.5m in compensation to families of the crash victims. It will also put $455m towards improving its compliance, safety and quality programmes. Boeing would also agree to pay a criminal penalty of $487.2m, although half of that was already paid in 2021. The two Boeing 737 Max crashes, which happened less than five months apart, claimed 346 lives and sparked global outrage. In October 2018, Lion Air flight 610 plunged into the Java Sea shortly after takeoff from Jakarta, in Indonesia killing all 189 people on board. Then, in March 2019, Ethiopian Airlines flight 302 crashed minutes after departing Addis Ababa, resulting in the deaths of 157 passengers and crew. Both disasters were later traced to faulty flight control systems, leading to the worldwide grounding of the 737 Max fleet for nearly two years. Since then, many families of the victims have spent years demanding a full public trial, tougher penalties for Boeing, and the prosecution of senior company executives. In 2021, Boeing avoided criminal prosecution by reaching a deferred prosecution agreement with the US Department of Justice, which included a $243.6 million fine. However, prosecutors later alleged that Boeing had breached the terms of its 2021 deferred prosecution agreement by failing to put in place promised reforms to detect and prevent future violations of federal anti-fraud laws. In response, Boeing agreed last July to plead guilty to a felony fraud charge, potentially avoiding a lengthy and high-profile public trial. It will be the fourth meeting between the DOJ and the families, some of whom are seen here in 2019, of those who died in the two 737 MAX crashes that killed 346 people in 2018 and 2019 But in December, US District Judge Reed O'Connor rejected the plea deal. He raised concerns that government and corporate diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) policies could influence the selection of an independent monitor, the person responsible for overseeing Boeing's compliance, and argued that race might become a factor in the appointment process. A spokesperson for Boeing said: 'Boeing is committed to complying with its obligations under this resolution, which include a substantial additional fine and commitments to further institutional improvements and investments. 'The resolution also provides for substantial additional compensation for the families of those lost in the Lion Air Flight 610 and Ethiopian Airlines Flight 302 accidents. 'We are deeply sorry for their losses, and remain committed to honouring their loved ones' memories by pressing forward with the broad and deep changes to our company that we have made to strengthen our safety system and culture.' MailOnline approached the US Justice Department for comment. The firm maker has also been plagued by other incidents involving its other planes in the US. Last year, a wheel fell off a Boeing 777-200 shortly after takeoff in San Francisco, with the wheel falling after takeoff, crushing cars parked below after it plummeted to the ground. The United Airlines flight 35 left San Francisco Airport on its way to Osaka in Japan and was barely off the runway when the Boeing 777-200's wheel came off. The plane with 235 passengers and 14 crew diverted to Los Angeles Airport after it was alerted to the landing gear failure and safely landed with no further issues and no injuries reported. Just days before this, a 737 engine caught fire mid-flight with a heart-stopping video catching the moment the Boeing jet's engines exploded and burst into flames in the skies above Texas, forcing an emergency landing. The terrifying incident took place just minutes into a United Airlines flight bound for Fort Myers, Florida. Moments later, they were forced to make an emergency landing and return to George H. Bush Intercontinental Houston Airport moments after takeoff. No injuries were reported in the incident.
Reuters
a day ago
- Reuters
Boeing rebuilding trust as airline bosses see improved jet quality
NEW DELHI, June 5 (Reuters) - Airline bosses are tentatively voicing greater confidence in Boeing's (BA.N), opens new tab ability to deliver jets at the right quality in a step towards ending years of reputational damage for the embattled planemaker. An annual summit of airline leaders in New Delhi this week struck a more optimistic tone about Boeing's recovery from overlapping safety, regulatory and industrial crises, though executives stressed Boeing still had much work left to do. "What we've seen quarter to quarter is an improvement in safety, an improvement in quality," Seattle-based Alaska Airlines (ALK.N), opens new tab CEO Ben Minicucci told Reuters at the International Air Transport Association's annual meeting. "Are they yet there? No, there's still a lot of work." In January last year, a door missing four bolts blew off a new Alaska Airlines Boeing 737 MAX jet at 16,000 feet. The ripple effect from the incident caused a crisis throughout the aviation industry, hitting suppliers, carriers and passengers. Planemakers often have to run the gauntlet of airline criticism at IATA's annual meeting, where IATA head Willie Walsh last year urged Boeing to learn from errors that fuelled a crisis beginning with fatal crashes of two MAX jets in 2018 and 2019. One of Boeing's most vocal recent critics has been Tim Clark, president of Emirates, the largest customer for big jets like the Boeing 777 and its long-delayed successor the 777X. At his annual sit-down with reporters at the summit this year, Clark spoke more positively about getting "clearer messages" from Boeing's recently appointed leadership. He welcomed a change of style under CEO Kelly Ortberg, revealing he had never met Ortberg's ousted predecessor Dave Calhoun. "It was nice to meet the head of Boeing," he said. Clark, whose airline has 205 of the still uncertified 777X on order, suggested growing confidence from Boeing in private. "When I talk about cautious optimism, in the last few years I had seen none of that" he said. Ortberg, who took the helm last August, has said he will address safety and quality concerns and repair trust with regulators, staff and customers. Boeing customers said the measures are showing some results. While Boeing is still trying to ramp up production, there have been improvements in quality and visibility of deliveries. "There is still further to go but it is definitely an improving story," said Peter Barrett, CEO of lessor SMBC Aviation, a major leasing company and Boeing customer. Few are taking Boeing's recovery solely on trust. Alaska Airlines has sent its own quality inspectors to Boeing's production lines and commissioned a quarterly audit. Alaska's Minicucci said Boeing had put in a "very diligent, deliberate process" to reduce out-of-sequence work, a disruption to normal factory flows blamed in part for the oversight of the missing bolts. He noted that Ortberg, who has moved to Seattle to be closer to the biggest jet plants, and Boeing Commercial Airplanes CEO Stephanie Pope, appointed last March, regularly tour factories. "They're getting out there, they're walking the floor, they're feeling what's going on," Minicucci said. "I think that's different to what happened in the past." Other customers have noted progress, despite a bruising strike last year which halted most of Boeing's jet production. United Airlines (UAL.O), opens new tab CEO Scott Kirby, who took part in a revolt by U.S. airlines that triggered Calhoun's exit after the Alaska incident, said last week Boeing had "turned the corner". Still, few airline chiefs have any illusions about the scale of turnaround needed to restore the status of Boeing factories. "When I was there last year... I thought this is going nowhere at this rate," Clark said, adding he would return this year to see for himself the progress made since then. Boeing declined to comment on specific airline opinions. Nor does the brighter public tone mean airlines will necessarily ease pressure in private as they wait for new jets. But several airline executives at the IATA event acknowledged that Boeing had passed one key test of support at the industry's biggest annual podium, as it slowly stabilises production. "We have got a lot of work still to do (but) there is a lot of positivity from customers on our performance in the first five months of the year," Boeing Senior Vice President of Commercial Sales Brad McMullen said. It now faces a decisive test as regulators review higher output after Boeing hit a temporary ceiling of 38 MAX jets a month. It also seeks certification of models including the 777X. The acting head of the Federal Aviation Administration said on Wednesday higher output would not happen straightaway. Originally due to receive the 777X in 2020, Clark held out little hope of getting the upgraded jet before IATA meets again in June next year. Boeing has said it is now due in 2026. "The important thing is they get it out and it's certified to the rigours of the new Boeing: the new approach to building aircraft, safety of operation and all the quality controls that they were having difficulties with prior to that," Clark said.
