Second arrest made after Santeria ritual in Hialeah turned into deadly shooting: cops
A second man has been arrested on charges of gunning down another earlier this month, after the pair got together for what police say was supposed to be a Santeria ritual in Hialeah.
Yasmany Matos, 35, was cuffed Tuesday while recovering from a stab wound at Jackson Memorial Hospital. His arrest comes after Milton Cao, 48, was already charged in connection with the same case. Both are charged with second degree murder.
On Feb. 12, Hialeah Police responded to a shooting at a home around 10:15 p.m. When officers arrived, they found a man only identified as Nodar lying unresponsive and covered in blood just outside the front door, according to Matos and Cao's arrest affidavits.
Inside the house, police say they discovered two other injured people: Matos' teenage son, who had cuts on both arms, and Matos, who had been stabbed in the head — with the knife still lodged in place. Cao, who was also at the home, had no injuries and was detained for questioning.
Nodar was subsequently pronounced dead. Matos' son was taken to Nicklaus Children's Hospital, while Matos was transported to Jackson Memorial Ryder Trauma Center for his injuries, according to police.
Two women who were in the house at the time also spoke to police.
Detectives later interviewed Matos' son, who explained that he and his father were at Cao's house because Matos was performing a Santería ritual for him. At some point, an argument broke out between Matos, Cao and Nodar, leading them outside to the parking lot. A short time later, Matos' son heard a gunshot and saw Nodar stumbling back inside, bleeding from his leg, saying he had been shot, police say.
Police say Nodar then went to the bathroom and grabbed a folding knife before coming back and stabbing Matos in the head. Matos' son tried to stop him but was stabbed in both arms in the process.
Despite already being shot and injured — according to police — Nodar then tried to leave the house. As he was walking out, Cao shot him multiple times, killing him.
Police say that Cao told a Sergeant on scene: 'I kill for fun.' Court records show Cao has since pled not guilty.
The next day, detectives obtained security camera footage from a nearby home, which captured the shooting outside.
Around 10:10 p.m., Matos, Cao, and Nodar were seen walking outside together.
Nodar then walked toward a car parked in front of the house, with Matos closely following behind. Suddenly, Matos shoved Nodar aggressively. Nodar, appearing petrified, quickly ran behind the car for cover.
Seconds later, Matos reached into his waistband, pulled out an unknown object and shot Nodar multiple times, police say. Nodar fell to his knees, limped back inside the house and was trailed by Cao and Matos.
Matos remained in the hospital for treatment as of Tuesday, according to his arrest affidavit. Since he has a lawyer, police have not questioned him.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Boston Globe
4 days ago
- Boston Globe
No prison time for campaign worker charged with falsifying nomination papers in R.I. congressional race
In a statement on Monday, Matos said she feels 'pleased to have my name cleared by today's conviction.' Advertisement 'I have supported this investigation at every step in the hopes that the truth would come to light,' Matos said. 'With this case settled, the facts are clear: Holly McClaren committed a serious crime that undermined the sanctity of our state's free and fair elections. I'm grateful to the law enforcement officers who handled this investigation thoroughly and professionally and whose work ultimately led to today's results.' Get Rhode Map A weekday briefing from veteran Rhode Island reporters, focused on the things that matter most in the Ocean State. Enter Email Sign Up McClaren was McClaren worked as a part-time field volunteer gathering signatures for Matos during the 2023 Democratic primary for the First Congressional District seat. A criminal investigation was launched, however, when officials in Jamestown, Newport, and East Providence reported suspect signatures of dead people and others who claimed to have never signed the forms. Advertisement The scandal rocked Matos' campaign. The lieutenant governor ultimately finished fourth in the 11-candidate primary election won by now-Congressman Gabe Amo. Prosecutors alleged McClaren knowingly falsified and submitted nomination papers to the Jamestown and Newport Boards of Canvassers on behalf of Matos between July 11 and 13, 2023. McClaren has John R. Grasso, an attorney representing McClaren, maintained that position on Monday. 'She has always denied that she secured any fraudulent signatures,' Grasso told the Globe. 'The charge was that she signed the documents, attesting to the fact that she personally authenticated those signatures, when, in fact, they were gathered by someone else and then just handed to her in a pile of papers, and she signed them.' Grasso said McClaren, who now lives in Virginia, brought the papers 'to wherever they needed to go, and whoever checked them said, 'You got to sign these.'' 'So she flipped the page over and signed them,' he said. 'That's a case of don't sign a document that you haven't read.' McClaren was one of two people charged with falsifying nomination papers for Matos' campaign: In April 2024, Christopher M. Cotham, of Massachusetts, Court records show the case against Cotham remains pending. Material from previous Globe stories was used in this report. Christopher Gavin can be reached at
Yahoo
4 days ago
- Yahoo
Woman at center of Matos signature scandal avoids prison time after changing plea
PROVIDENCE, R.I. (WPRI) — The woman at the center of the signature scandal that derailed Lt. Gov. Sabina Matos' congressional campaign in 2023 was spared prison time after changing her plea to no contest at Providence Superior Court on Monday. Holly McClaren had initially pleaded not guilty last year to two felony counts of violating nomination papers and two misdemeanor counts of giving false documents to an agent, employee or public official last year after she was indicted by a grand jury. On Monday, McClaren changed her plea to nolo contendere, or no contest, meaning she accepts the conviction as though a guilty plea has been entered but does not admit guilt. She was sentenced to three years unsupervised probation without any prison time, and she's allowed to relocate to Virginia. 'She signed papers or signatures that she didn't actually go out and secure,' McClaren's attorney, John Grasso, told reporters outside court. 'She thought that by signing those papers she was just confirming that somebody else had secured those signatures, not realizing that she was attesting to the authenticity of those signatures.' McClaren declined to comment following the hearing. The Matos campaign hired McClaren and her firm in 2023 to collect signatures on behalf of the campaign to get Matos' name on the ballot. It was then revealed several signatures were flagged as potentially fraudulent. Target 12 tracked down several people in Newport, Barrington, East Providence and Cranston who said their names were forged on the paperwork. The scandal launched a criminal investigation and McClaren was subsequently accused of knowingly falsifying nomination papers and submitting them to local canvassing boards. Target 12: 'That's not my signature': Newport residents dispute more Matos nomination papers The scandal caused political damage to Matos, who was widely considered a frontrunner in the race. She ended up finishing fourth in the Democratic primary election, losing to Gabe Amo, who went on to win the general election and holds the seat today. Matos has never been accused of involvement in the scheme. Last month, Matos told 12 News there were moments during the scandal when she thought she would step down from everything, calling it a 'rough time.' 'This whole process was very traumatic and there were moments in which I thought maybe I was going to quit everything and quit the race for congress then have to quit lieutenant governor.' Alexandra Leslie (aleslie@ is a Target 12 investigative reporter covering Providence and more for 12 News. Connect with her on Twitter and on Facebook. Eli Sherman (esherman@ is a Target 12 investigative reporter for 12 News. Connect with him on Twitter and on Facebook. Tim White contributed to this report Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Yahoo
28-05-2025
- Yahoo
Dead chickens placed in odd position on ritzy NYC block — sparking ‘animal sacrifice' claims
The chickens didn't cross the road — but still made it to the other side. Two slaughtered chickens were found on an Upper West Side median in an odd position that has activists worried they were killed in an animal sacrifice ritual. The birds were found Saturday lined up with their feet facing at West 89th Street and Broadway less than a year after similar fowl play three blocks away on Broadway and West 92nd Street, local publication West Side Rag reported. '[It] appears to be animal sacrifice to me,' John Di Leonardo, executive director of Humane Long Island, told The Post. 'It's illegal for live slaughter markets to sell live birds to the public but we know they do it often,' he said. 'From Buddhists releasing live animals in Central Park who die if not recovered to birds tied to trees for Santeria in public parks to Shaktis killing pigs near Gateway National Park – to whatever this is.' Edita Birnkrant, of animal advocacy group NYCLASS, said 'it clearly was done purposely and placed in a visible spot. 'They look healthier than the birds usually look at live markets,' she added. 'The nearest live poultry market is in Harlem so I don't know [if] that's the culprit.' By Tuesday, the birds had been removed but not everyone was uneasy about the birds. 'I'm almost kind of glad,' said Harold Steinblatt, a self-described 'frequent bench-sitter' and longtime Upper West Side resident who said the incident sounded 'cultish.' 'That means it's not just all rich hedge fund managers here,' he said. 'Or maybe it was a disgruntled hedge fund manager who was the culprit.' Chickens are the most common sacrifice in the Santeria Afro-Caribbean religion, according to the BBC. The Supreme Court upheld the right to animal sacrifice on religious grounds in 1993 — but according to New York laws, aggravated cruelty to animals is a felony punishable by up to two years in prison. Evidence of sacrificial killings have been reported across the five boroughs, with chickens, pigs and even rats killed in 'twisted' religious rituals in parkland surrounding Jamaica Bay in Queens. In Upper Manhattan, whole dead chickens and cows, as well as fish and eggs, have been found as offerings on crypts at Old Trinity Cemetery, according to Scouting NY. Thousands of chickens are also killed each year in the Big Apple ahead of Yom Kippur during the ultra-orthodox Jewish ritual of Kaporos, which involves slitting a chicken's throat, per ABC New York.
