Guernsey deputy chief minister laments island-wide voting system
Guernsey's deputy chief minister has described the current electoral system as "isolating". Voters backed the move to elect politicians from an entire island constituency, rather than the previous district system, at a referendum in 2020. Deputy Heidi Soulsby, who is standing down at the 2025 general election after 13 years in local politics, said she believed the system had cut voters off from politicians. "I don't like this system, you miss one-on-one conversations and that connection with the public," she told the BBC.
"People have to come to you, in a way that's different to the parish system, you were going to them."At the first island-wide general election in 2020, she came second with 12,779 votes, while she topped the polls in the South East in 2012 with 2,061 votes. Soulsby said: "If I wanted to stand, it wouldn't have stopped me, but the thought of going through this really isolating existence wasn't ideal."
A number of candidates and voters have said they would like to see the electoral system reviewed before the 2029 general election. However, defenders of the current system said it led to a record turnout at the 2020 general election.Soulsby said of the previous system: "You were out knocking on doors, walking the streets having one-to-one conversations with people who could be really angry about what you said. "It was great - you found out what the issues were."
A Scrutiny Management Report review of the 2020 election concluded there "remains significant support for the ability to vote for any candidate who stands" and did not recommend making a change to the system of island-wide voting for the 2025 election.Soulsby said it was still hard to defend the current system despite the findings."I feel that sense of isolation of deputies, that lack of connection," she said."You feel more in a bubble."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
11 minutes ago
- BBC News
David Lammy holds Gibraltar talks ahead of potential EU deal
The foreign secretary has visited Gibraltar for talks ahead of a potential post-Brexit deal for the Lammy and Europe Minister Stephen Doughty met Gibraltar's chief minister Fabian Picardo and his cabinet on Wednesday, and the three are now heading to Brussels for discussions with EU and Spanish on rules governing the border of Spain and Gibraltar have been ongoing since Britain left the European Union in 2020, but an agreement has not yet been reached.A Foreign Office source said that a deal was not yet finalised and that a number of sticking points remained. Writing on X, Picardo said it was "time to try to finalise arrangements for lasting, stable relationship between Gibraltar and the EU/Spain which is safe, secure and beneficial".Announcing the new UK-EU deal last month, Sir Keir Starmer and EU Council President António Costa said that the two were "not very far" from concluding a separate deal on which is a British Overseas Territory, is a 2.6 square mile headland to the south of UK has had sovereignty over Gibraltar since 1713, although this is disputed by Spain, who claim the territory as their territory's status and that of its border with Spain has been a key sticking point and has remained unresolved since estimated 15,000 people cross the Gibraltar-Spain border every day for work and leisure. Currently, Gibraltar residents can cross using residence cards without needing to have their passports stamped. Spanish citizens can cross using a government ID there were concerns this would end with the introduction of the EU's Entry/Exit system later this year, causing huge delays at the border. Last month's deal UK-EU deal included confirmation there will be no legal barriers to UK citizens using e-gates, which should mean there won't be a return to passport a separate Gibraltar deal could reportedly make the territory an associate member of the Schengen zone, allowing people to cross freely and see physical border infrastructure opinion in Gibraltar, which has a population of 32,000 according to its government, is in favour of keeping British sovereignty. The most recent referendum, held in 2002, saw almost 99% of voters reject a proposal to share sovereignty with Spain.
BBC News
37 minutes ago
- BBC News
Heathrow Airport expansion 'essential' after busiest May
Heathrow says expansion of the airport is "essential", after experiencing its busiest May on than 7.2 million passengers travelled through its four terminals last month, up 0.4% from a year ago.A Heathrow spokesperson said: "As these record numbers become the norm, it's time to start an honest conversation about the challenges this presents for an already space-constrained yet highly efficient hub."Opponents of the west London airport's expansion say increasing air travel would make it much harder for the UK to meet its climate change commitments. The Mayor of London, Sir Sadiq Khan, opposes a third runway at Heathrow for this reason as well as because of noise and air pollution. Heathrow's spokesperson said: "Heathrow continues to deliver excellent service, but to sustain this performance and meet future demand, expanding capacity will be essential."The airport has previously said it will submit detailed plans for building a third runway to the government in the Rachel Reeves used a speech on growth in January to give her support to the project, which has been repeatedly delayed over several decades because of environmental concerns. Friends of the Earth has previously described the expansion plans as "hugely irresponsible".Alethea Warrington, head of aviation at climate charity Possible, said in January: "This huge increase in emissions won't help our economy, and would just encourage the small group of frequent flyers who take most of the flights."People living in nearby Harmondsworth told the BBC earlier this year that if the expansion plans went ahead, "three-quarters of the village would be demolished" and it would no longer be a "viable community".
BBC News
37 minutes ago
- BBC News
Closure of Natwest in Bridgwater criticised by local MP
An MP has said he is "deeply disappointed" by NatWest's decision to close its bank branch in a Somerset Fox, the Conservative MP for Bridgwater, said the move not only "risks excluding" vulnerable residents but will impact the number of shoppers on the high said over the last five years counter transactions have dropped by nearly 65% in the town as more customers "than ever before" switch to digital Bridgwater branch is due to close on 27 October, along with branches in Midsomer Norton and Portishead. Scott Thomas, who has been banking at NatWest since he was a teenager, said closing the branch was "disgusting"."This bank has been my bank for my whole life - I do my business banking with NatWest, they've always been so helpful and now what am I going to do?," he said."Without NatWest, I wouldn't have been able to set that [business account] up. I'm dyslexic and have ADHD. They sat there with me, done it with me, helped me and now to be told I have to do something online with no help, it's absolutely ridiculous." Madeleine Vann, said the closure was "sad"."It's all computers now and you're not dealing with a human being now, are you?" she said."That's why I've come in [to the bank] today, I wanted to see a human."Another local resident, Mary Cornish said she was "really, really shocked" by the news."I do online banking and that won't change but I like to go into the bank to get money out," she said."Such a shame isn't it. I will really miss it - popping in once a week." Other branches across the West earmarked for closure include Yate, Fishponds, Chippenham, Trowbridge and Fox, said the Bridgwater closure "risks excluding some of our most vulnerable residents"."Especially those who rely on in‑branch support to manage their finances with confidence," he added."It will also be a hit to our town centre, where the loss of regular footfall will add further strain to local high street businesses."He said he is "formally requesting" a meeting with NatWest to ensure they maintain "meaningful human support for those who need it most"."I will be pressing them to consider alternative face-to-face provision to ensure no one is left behind," he said. According to NatWest, nearly three quarters of customers using the Bridgwater branch have chosen to use online banking and the mobile app in the last the number of personal customers using the branch on average each month, was just over 220.A NatWest spokesperson said most of its customers were shifting to its "digital services" because of the "speed and convenience".In a statement, the spokesperson added that branch closures were "disappointing" but it was committed to ensuring the move online was "managed compassionately"."[We] proactively contact branch users who we know may need additional support when a branch closes," the said."And where there's a need we install community pop-ups to help customers become familiar with alternative banking services."
