logo
World's biggest companies have caused $28 trillion in climate damage: Study

World's biggest companies have caused $28 trillion in climate damage: Study

The world's biggest corporations have caused $28 trillion in climate damage, a new study estimates as part of an effort to make it easier for people and governments to hold companies financially accountable, like the tobacco giants have been.
A Dartmouth College research team came up with the estimated pollution caused by 111 companies, with more than half of the total dollar figure coming from 10 fossil fuel providers: Saudi Aramco, Gazprom, Chevron, ExxonMobil, BP, Shell, National Iranian Oil Co., Pemex, Coal India and the British Coal Corporation.
For comparison, $28 trillion is a shade less than the sum of all goods and services produced in the United States last year.
At the top of the list, Saudi Aramco and Gazprom have each caused a bit more than $2 trillion in heat damage over the decades, the team calculated in a study published in Wednesday's journal Nature.
The researchers figured that every 1 per cent of greenhouse gas put into the atmosphere since 1990 has caused $502 billion in damage from heat alone, which doesn't include the costs incurred by other extreme weather such as hurricanes, droughts and floods.
People talk about making polluters pay, and sometimes even take them to court or pass laws meant to rein them in.
The study is an attempt to determine the causal linkages that underlie many of these theories of accountability, said its lead author, Christopher Callahan, who did the work at Dartmouth but is now an Earth systems scientist at Stanford University.
The research firm Zero Carbon Analytics counts 68 lawsuits filed globally about climate change damage, with more than half of them in the United States.
Everybody's asking the same question: What can we actually claim about who has caused this? said Dartmouth climate scientist Justin Mankin, co-author of the study. And that really comes down to a thermodynamic question of can we trace climate hazards and/or their damages back to particular emitters? The answer is yes, Callahan and Mankin said.
The researchers started with known final emissions of the products such as gasoline or electricity from coal-fired power plants produced by the 111 biggest carbon-oriented companies going as far back as 137 years, because that's as far back as any of the companies' emissions data go and carbon dioxide stays in the air for much longer than that. They used 1,000 different computer simulations to translate those emissions into changes for Earth's global average surface temperature by comparing it to a world without that company's emissions.
Using this approach, they determined that pollution from Chevron, for example, has raised the Earth's temperature by .045 degrees Fahrenheit (.025 degrees Celsius).
The researchers also calculated how much each company's pollution contributed to the five hottest days of the year using 80 more computer simulations and then applying a formula that connects extreme heat intensity to changes in economic output.
This system is modeled on the established techniques scientists have been using for more than a decade to attribute extreme weather events, such as the 2021 Pacific Northwest heat wave, to climate change.
Mankin said that in the past, there was an argument of, Who's to say that it's my molecule of CO2 that's contributed to these damages versus any other one? He said his study really laid clear how the veil of plausible deniability doesn't exist anymore scientifically. We can actually trace harms back to major emitters.
Shell declined to comment. Aramco, Gazprom, Chevron, Exxon Mobil and BP did not respond to requests for comment.
All methods they use are quite robust, said Imperial College London climate scientist Friederike Otto, who heads World Weather Attribution, a collection of scientists who try rapid attribution studies to see if specific extreme weather events are worsened by climate change and, if so, by how much. She didn't take part in the study.
It would be good in my view if this approach would be taken up more by different groups. As with event attribution, the more groups do it, the better the science gets and the better we know what makes a difference and what does not, Otto said. So far, no climate liability lawsuit against a major carbon emitter has been successful, but maybe showing how overwhelmingly strong the scientific evidence is can change that, she said.
In the past, damage caused by individual companies were lost in the noise of data, so it couldn't be calculated, Callahan said.
We have now reached a point in the climate crisis where the total damages are so immense that the contributions of a single company's product can amount to tens of billions of dollars a year, said Chris Field, a Stanford University climate scientist who didn't take part in the research.
This is a good exercise and proof of concept, but there are so many other climate variables that the numbers that Callahan and Mankin came up with are probably a vast underestimate of the damage the companies have really caused, said Michael Mann, a University of Pennsylvania climate scientist who wasn't involved in the study.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Datanomics: India's heatwave crisis at boiling point; economic risks mount
Datanomics: India's heatwave crisis at boiling point; economic risks mount

Business Standard

time4 hours ago

  • Business Standard

Datanomics: India's heatwave crisis at boiling point; economic risks mount

The economic toll is rising too. India could see 34 million of the projected 80 million global job losses from heat stress by 2030 Shikha Chaturvedi New Delhi Listen to This Article India is facing one of its worst heatwaves in recent history, with temperatures exceeding 45 degrees Celsius across northern region including Delhi, Lucknow, and parts of Rajasthan. Red alerts, school closures, and health warnings have been issued as the country grapples with extreme conditions following 2024 — the hottest year ever recorded globally. The economic toll is rising too. India could see 34 million of the projected 80 million global job losses from heat stress by 2030. The RBI has warned that up to 4.5 per cent of GDP might be at risk this decade due to lost labour hours

Axiom-4: The leak that led to mission delay, how launch windows are decided
Axiom-4: The leak that led to mission delay, how launch windows are decided

Indian Express

time8 hours ago

  • Indian Express

Axiom-4: The leak that led to mission delay, how launch windows are decided

The Axiom-4 mission, which is to carry India's Shubhanshu Shukla and three others to the International Space Station, is facing an uncertain delay now, after its scheduled launch on Wednesday evening India time had to be aborted due to problems in the rocket. The mission was supposed to take off from NASA's Kennedy Space Station in Florida at 5.30 India time on Wednesday. But during tests on Monday, a leak of liquid oxygen (LOx) from the Falcon 9 rocket was detected. SpaceX, the company that produces these rockets, had initially said that it would be able to fix the problem by Tuesday to enable a Wednesday launch. However, on Tuesday night, it was decided to put off the launch to allow for more time to carry out the repairs. 'Standing down from tomorrow's (Wednesday's) Falcon 9 launch of Ax-4 to the space station to allow additional time for SpaceX teams to repair the LOx leak identified during post static fire booster inspections. Once complete — and pending range availability — we will share a new launch date,' SpaceX said in a statement Wednesday morning (late Tuesday evening in the United States). Till Wednesday evening, there was no update on a new launch date and time. What exactly is the leak? Liquid oxygen is a critical component in rocket propulsion as it allows the combustion of the main fuel, highly refined kerosene in this case. Oxygen attains liquid state at very low temperatures, well below -180 degree Celsius. The leak can happen either in the storage chamber of the rocket or in the pipelines that supply the LOx to the rocket's engine. In the best case scenario, a leak reduces the amount of LOx available for enabling combustion of the main fuel. In the worst case, it could trigger a fire or an explosion. 'As part of launch vehicle preparation to validate the performance of booster stage of Falcon 9 launch vehicle, seven second of hot test was carried out on the launch pad (on Monday). It is understood that LOx leakage was detected in the propulsion bay during the test. Based on the discussion on this topic by ISRO team with the experts of Axiom and SpaceX it has been decided to correct the leak and carry out necessary validation test before clearing for the launch. Hence the launch of Axiom-4 slated for 11th June 2025 for sending first Indian Gaganyatri to ISS is postponed,' ISRO chairman V Narayanan, who is in the United States to witness the launch, said in a statement. A reusable rocket Falcon 9 is a partially reusable rocket. Its first stage (booster) returns to the Earth after separating from the mission it has launched, and can be reused after a refurbishment. This is the second trip for the booster being used in the rocket that will launch Ax-4 mission. It had earlier flown on a Starlink mission in April this year. William Gerstenmaier, vice-president of build and flight reliability at SpaceX, had talked about this leak, and some other problems with the rocket, during a pre-launch press conference on Monday evening (Tuesday morning India time). 'We discovered a few things during the static fire that we had to go take a look at. We found a LOx leak that we had previously seen on this booster during its entry on its last mission and discovered that we had not fully repaired the booster during the refurbishment or we didn't actually find a leak and didn't get it corrected. We have now gone out to the launchpad. We are continuing to trouble shoot that. We should get that completed today (Tuesday) and we will have that back in configuration,' Gerstenmaier had said. He had said the team was also working to make the rocket leak-proof. 'We are installing a purge that will essentially mitigate the leak if it still continues if we see it on the launch day. So, we will be fully ready to go fly,' he had said. 'We also discovered an engine 5 thrust vector control problem and we are going to change out the components associated with that. In fact, they are already changed out now and we will be complete with all work this evening and we will be ready to support a launch as early as tomorrow (Wednesday),' he had said. There was no update on the problems from Axiom Space or SpaceX after Wednesday's launch was put off. The mission has another launch window on Thursday, June 12, but with no update forthcoming till Wednesday evening, it was unlikely that the launch would happen immediately. 'This shows the difficulty of getting ready. You can always be prepared, but during the testing, during the dry runs, during the activities with the crew to make sure we are really ready is tremendously important because we always learn something,' Gerstenmaier said on Monday. At the same press conference, Dana Weigel, Manager, International Space Station Program, at NASA, said that there were many more windows of opportunity for the Axiom-4 mission to fly during June and then also in July. 'In terms of launch opportunities, we have these opportunities all the way through June 30th and then after a brief cut-out, we pick up again in the middle of July, in fact in the second week of July. So there are plenty of opportunities actually to fly the vehicle,' Weigel said. Launch windows for rockets are calculated keeping in mind the movements of the celestial bodies involved, the most fuel-efficient path possible with both the starting and the landing points always in motion, and the weather. Apart from Shukla, Axiom-4 is supposed to carry three astronauts, one each from Poland, Hungary and the United States, to the International Space Station, where they are scheduled to perform about 60 experiments, studies and outreach exercises. This is the first time that astronauts of India, Poland or Hungary are going to the International Space Station, a permanent space laboratory that orbits the Earth at a distance of 400 kilometres.

May was world's second-hottest on record: EU scientists
May was world's second-hottest on record: EU scientists

India Today

time8 hours ago

  • India Today

May was world's second-hottest on record: EU scientists

People cover themselves for protection against the heat wave on a hot summer day, in Prayagraj. (Photo: PTI) The main cause of climate change is greenhouse gas emissions It comes from burning fossil fuels Last year was the planet's hottest on record The world experienced its second-warmest May since records began this year, a month in which climate change fuelled a record-breaking heatwave in Greenland, scientists said on Wednesday. Last month was Earth's second-warmest May on record - exceeded only by May 2024 - rounding out the northern hemisphere's second-hottest March-May spring on record, the EU's Copernicus Climate Change Service (C3S) said in a monthly bulletin. Global surface temperatures last month averaged 1.4 degrees Celsius higher than in the 1850-1900 pre-industrial period, when humans began burning fossil fuels on an industrial scale, C3S said. That broke a run of extraordinary heat, in which 21 of the last 22 months had an average global temperature exceeding 1.5C above pre-industrial times - although scientists warned this break was unlikely to last. "Whilst this may offer a brief respite for the planet, we do expect the 1.5C threshold to be exceeded again in the near future due to the continued warming of the climate system," said C3S director Carlo Buontempo. Last month was Earth's second-warmest May on record. (Photo: AFP) The main cause of climate change is greenhouse gas emissions from burning fossil fuels. Last year, opens new tab was the planet's hottest on record. A separate study, published by the World Weather Attribution group of climate scientists on Wednesday, found that human-caused climate change made a record-breaking heatwave in Iceland and Greenland last month about 3C hotter than it otherwise would have been - contributing to a huge additional melting of Greenland's ice sheet. "Even cold-climate countries are experiencing unprecedented temperatures," said Sarah Kew, study co-author and researcher at the Royal Netherlands Meteorological Institute. The global threshold of 1.5C is the limit of warming which countries vowed under the Paris climate agreement to try to prevent, to avoid the worst consequences of warming. The world has not yet technically breached that target - which refers to an average global temperature of 1.5C over decades. However, some scientists have said it can no longer realistically be met, and have urged governments to cut CO2 emissions faster, to limit the overshoot and the fuelling of extreme weather. C3S's records go back to 1940, and are cross-checked with global temperature records going back to 1850. The world experienced its second-warmest May since records began this year, a month in which climate change fuelled a record-breaking heatwave in Greenland, scientists said on Wednesday. Last month was Earth's second-warmest May on record - exceeded only by May 2024 - rounding out the northern hemisphere's second-hottest March-May spring on record, the EU's Copernicus Climate Change Service (C3S) said in a monthly bulletin. Global surface temperatures last month averaged 1.4 degrees Celsius higher than in the 1850-1900 pre-industrial period, when humans began burning fossil fuels on an industrial scale, C3S said. That broke a run of extraordinary heat, in which 21 of the last 22 months had an average global temperature exceeding 1.5C above pre-industrial times - although scientists warned this break was unlikely to last. "Whilst this may offer a brief respite for the planet, we do expect the 1.5C threshold to be exceeded again in the near future due to the continued warming of the climate system," said C3S director Carlo Buontempo. Last month was Earth's second-warmest May on record. (Photo: AFP) The main cause of climate change is greenhouse gas emissions from burning fossil fuels. Last year, opens new tab was the planet's hottest on record. A separate study, published by the World Weather Attribution group of climate scientists on Wednesday, found that human-caused climate change made a record-breaking heatwave in Iceland and Greenland last month about 3C hotter than it otherwise would have been - contributing to a huge additional melting of Greenland's ice sheet. "Even cold-climate countries are experiencing unprecedented temperatures," said Sarah Kew, study co-author and researcher at the Royal Netherlands Meteorological Institute. The global threshold of 1.5C is the limit of warming which countries vowed under the Paris climate agreement to try to prevent, to avoid the worst consequences of warming. The world has not yet technically breached that target - which refers to an average global temperature of 1.5C over decades. However, some scientists have said it can no longer realistically be met, and have urged governments to cut CO2 emissions faster, to limit the overshoot and the fuelling of extreme weather. C3S's records go back to 1940, and are cross-checked with global temperature records going back to 1850. Join our WhatsApp Channel

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store