Elections Canada says Quebec recount result ‘final' despite ballot issue
Elections Canada says the result of a recount in the federal riding of Terrebonne is final, despite a misprint that led to one special ballot being returned to sender.
Elections Canada says there was an error on the envelope used to mail a special ballot from Terrebonne, a Quebec riding the Liberals won by a single vote after a recount.
Preliminary results indicated that the Liberals had won the riding, but the seat flipped temporarily to the Bloc Québécois after the results were validated.
After a recount that gave the seat back to the Liberals, however, CBC News reported that a Bloc voter saw her mail-in ballot returned to her.
The agency says an analysis confirmed that part of the return address on the envelope destined for a local Elections Canada office – the last three characters of the postal code – was incorrect.
Story continues below advertisement
Despite the error and questions about the possibility of another recount or a byelection, Elections Canada spokesperson Matthew McKenna said 'the result of the recount is final.'
'The Canada Elections Act does not explicitly provide for the appeal of a judicial recount and Elections Canada is unaware of any appeals brought to a court following a recount,' said McKenna.
2:11
Recount sees Liberals take Quebec riding of Terrebonne by single vote
Elections Canada said this is only case they know of in the recent election of an envelope containing a marked ballot being returned to a voter because of an incorrect address.
Get daily National news
Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day. Sign up for daily National newsletter Sign Up
By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy
McKenna said the returned vote was never part of the recount.
'Any vote that doesn't get to us on time to wherever it's meant to go, whether it's the local office or to our accounting facility in Ottawa, the law basically dictates that it can't be counted,' he said. 'So even if it's something that happens as a result of an error on our part, there's really no mechanism for that to be counted.'
Story continues below advertisement
McKenna said the only thing that could lead to a change in the result is someone officially contesting it.
'Anyone can make an application to a judge to say that they want the results of the election to be reviewed,' he said. 'There's a possibility that that happens … as far as I'm aware, nobody's put forward such an application yet.'
Liberal Tatiana Auguste was initially projected to win the riding by 35 votes after the April 28 election, but on May 1, following the required postelection validation process, Bloc Québécois candidate Nathalie Sinclair-Desgagné, who was first elected in 2021, moved ahead by 44 votes.
The win was returned to Auguste following the judicial recount, with Auguste receiving 23,352 votes and Sinclair-Desgagné receiving 23,351.
0:30
Canada Election 2025: Recount in Terra Nova-The Peninsulas set for Monday
A judicial recount is automatic when the number of votes cast for the candidate with the most votes and the number of votes cast for any other candidate is less than 0.1 per cent of the valid votes cast.
Story continues below advertisement
A validation process is done by the returning officer, who reviews the cumulative addition of votes in a riding from every poll, based on the counts determined at every polling station in the presence of party scrutineers and election officers. It does not recount the ballots, or review ballots that were deemed to be invalid.
A judicial recount looks at all the ballots again, verifying the ones that were initially accepted and reconsidering ballots that were rejected. It takes place in the presence of a judge from a Superior Court in the affected province or territory.
Sinclair-Desgagné wrote on Facebook Monday that she owed it to herself to 'evaluate all the options before us.'
The final result brought the Liberals to 170 seats in the House of Commons, two shy of the 172 needed for a majority government. The Bloc seat count fell to 22.
Other judicial recounts are ongoing in the ridings of Windsor–Tecumseh–Lakeshore, Milton East–Halton Hills South and Terra Nova–The Peninsulas.
—With files from Cassidy McMackon and Morgan Lowrie
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Toronto Star
7 hours ago
- Toronto Star
‘Unjustified and unlawful': Canadian officials react to Trump's threat to double steel, aluminum tariffs
The federal minister tasked with Canada-U. S. trade relations said Ottawa has 'taken note' of U.S. President Donald Trump's latest threat to increase tariffs on steel and aluminum to 50 per cent, but stopped short of announcing any formal retaliatory measures, at least for now. Dominic LeBlanc, the federal minister whose portfolio includes Canada-U. S. trade, said in a statement on the social media platform X Saturday that the government will remain 'resolute in defending our workers and our communities.' 'We can give ourselves far more than the United States can take from us,' he wrote. ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW We can give ourselves far more than the United States can take from us. That's why this Monday, the Prime Minister will meet with Premiers in Saskatoon with one goal - build one Canadian economy out of thirteen, and get big, nation-building projects built faster. (2/3) — Dominic LeBlanc (@DLeBlancNB) May 31, 2025 In a speech in Pennsylvania Friday, Trump said that the increased tariff figures would 'even further secure the steel industry in the United States.' 'Nobody's going to get around that,' Trump said. Industry minister Mélanie Joly, who formerly served as foreign minister, said that Canada is 'fighting' the 'unjustified and unlawful tariffs with our own retaliatory actions, strong domestic support packages, and big moves to diversify our trade.' President Donald Trump says he's going to double the tariff rate on steel to 50 per cent, a dramatic increase that could further push up prices for a metal used to make housing, autos and other goods. (AP Video / May 30, 2025) She added that she plans to meet with steel and aluminum producers and workers over the coming days to 'advance' a plan in response to Trump's pledge. Terry Sheehan, the Liberal MP who represents the steel-dependent riding of Sault Ste. Marie, wrote that the government will 'not back down' in the face of tariffs that 'threaten to further damage the vital relationship between our two countries.' Sault Ste. Marie's mayor, Matthew Shoemaker, said Trump is 'trying to cripple our economy.' Maninder Sidhu, the newly minted minister of international trade, wrote that the government will 'move on terms … strategically, thoughtfully, and without delay.' Sidhu, a Brampton MP first elected in 2019, said that 'trade diversification' is his 'top priority.' ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW 'Canada has what the world needs and we're ready to deliver,' Sidhu wrote. Meanwhile, United Steelworkers, which represents over 220,000 workers in Canada, said that the 50 per cent tariff would 'completely shut us out of the U.S. market' and called on the government to 'move quickly to strengthen domestic demand.' Canada Trump says he will double tariffs on steel and aluminum imports to 50 per cent In March, U.S. President Donald Trump put 25 per cent tariffs on steel and aluminum imports to 'This isn't trade policy — it's a direct attack on Canadian industries and workers,' national director Marty Warren said of the president's recent announcement. 'Thousands of Canadian jobs are on the line and communities that rely on steel and aluminum are being put at risk. Canada needs to respond immediately and decisively to defend workers.' The Canadian Steel Producers Association, a trade group, said in a statement that the government must immediately 'fully reinstate retaliatory steel tariffs to match the American tariffs and to implement as quickly as possible new tariffs at our own borders to stop unfairly traded steel from entering Canada.' In March, Trump put 25 per cent tariffs on steel and aluminum imports to the United States. Trump used Section 232 of the Trade Expansion Act of 1962 to impose steel and aluminum duties and said it will help bring manufacturing back to the United States. Canada is the largest steel supplier to the United States, accounting for nearly 25 per cent of all imports in 2023. About a quarter of all steel used in America is imported. Earlier this week, a three-judge panel at the U.S. Court of International Trade ruled Trump does not have the authority to wield tariffs, a pause that was subsequently lifted by a federal appeals court Thursday. A Leger poll from earlier this month found that nearly 70 per cent of Canadians are in favour of the federal government imposing dollar-for-dollar retaliatory tariffs on U.S. goods. The poll also found that Canadians are reducing the number of U.S. products they're buying in stores as a result of the ongoing trade war. With files from The Canadian Press Politics Headlines Newsletter Get the latest news and unmatched insights in your inbox every evening Error! Sorry, there was an error processing your request. There was a problem with the recaptcha. Please try again. Please enter a valid email address. Sign Up Yes, I'd also like to receive customized content suggestions and promotional messages from the Star. You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply. Politics Headlines Newsletter You're signed up! You'll start getting Politics Headlines in your inbox soon. Want more of the latest from us? Sign up for more at our newsletter page.
Toronto Star
7 hours ago
- Toronto Star
Who is Marc-André Blanchard? PM Mark Carney's new chief of staff comes from the worlds of law, diplomacy
As his new government enters its fifth week, Prime Minister Mark Carney continued to build out his inner circle Sunday, naming diplomat and lawyer Marc-André Blanchard as his chief of staff starting in July. In a statement posted to the social media platform X, Carney called Blanchard 'one of Canada's most accomplished builders, legal experts, executives, public servants, and diplomats.' Here's everything you need to know about the prime minister's new top aide. What is Blanchard's educational and professional background? Much like the prime minister he will serve, Blanchard graduated from some of the world's most elite universities; he holds degrees from the London School of Economics, Université de Montréal and Columbia University. ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW A lawyer by trade, Blanchard, 59, spent six years as the chair and CEO of McCarthy Tétrault, a business law firm based in Toronto. He most recently served as the executive vice-president for CDPQ Global, a Quebec-based investment firm. He is still a member of the Quebec bar, according to the body's directory, where his area of law is listed as 'international.' Does he have experience in government? Yes, Blanchard served as Canada's ambassador to the United Nations from 2016 to 2020. The announcement of his ascension to the post received little fanfare at the time, seeing as it was made the same day as David MacNaughton's appointment to be Canada's ambassador to the United States. The UN post has a history of being held by prominent Canadian political figures; former Ontario premier Bob Rae succeeded Blanchard in the job, and Stephen Lewis and longtime Jean Chrétien cabinet minister Allan Rock have also represented Canada at the UN. Federal Politics Former UN ambassador Marc-André Blanchard named chief of staff to Mark Carney Elissa Mendes In addition, Blanchard sat on Canada's North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) Council alongside one-time opposition leader Rona Ambrose and Stephen Harper-era cabinet minister James Moore, among others. How are other public officials and politicians reacting to the news? Lisa Raitt, a three-term Conservative MP who once served as Canada's labour minister, said on X that she is a 'BIG fan of this appointment,' thanking Blanchard for 'coming back once again to serve Canada.' Ambrose, likewise, called the appointment an 'excellent choice.' ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW Meanwhile, former Liberal MP and transport minister Omar Alghabra called it a 'well-deserved appointment,' while longtime Liberal party fixture Penny Collenette said that Blanchard and Carney form 'a powerful duo' that puts Canada 'in supreme hands.' Who else was considered for the role? The Star previously reported that former Trudeau senior adviser Mathieu Bouchard, who also served as chief of staff to the heritage minister, was in conversations for the position. The Globe and Mail reported that Trudeau aide and adviser Gerald Butts declined to take the job after being approached. Who are other notable chiefs of staff? Federal Politics Carney government recognizes 'there's no time to waste' on new housing, Olivia Chow says Mayor Olivia Chow says she is refreshed by the urgency with which the Mark Carney government is tackling the housing crisis. Federal Politics Carney government recognizes 'there's no time to waste' on new housing, Olivia Chow says Mayor Olivia Chow says she is refreshed by the urgency with which the Mark Carney government is tackling the housing crisis. Though perhaps not as glamorous and recognizable as the White House chief of staff in the U.S., a number of notable names have served in the position, including now-Senator Percy Downe and longtime Quebec City mayor Jean Pelletier. Former Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's chief of staff, Katie Telford, for instance, was seen as one of the most important figures in the Liberal government. In describing her influence on the government's strategy and operations, the Star's Susan Delacourt observed in 2023 that no chief of staff had travelled with a prime minister as much as she had during the 10 years she spent in the role. Carney's outgoing chief of staff, Marco Mendicino, served three terms in the House of Commons representing Eglinton-Lawrence and had two different cabinet appointments in the Trudeau government. The Star recently reported that Mendicino is considering a run for mayor of Toronto in next year's mayoral election. With files from The Canadian Press. Politics Headlines Newsletter Get the latest news and unmatched insights in your inbox every evening Error! Sorry, there was an error processing your request. There was a problem with the recaptcha. Please try again. Please enter a valid email address. Sign Up Yes, I'd also like to receive customized content suggestions and promotional messages from the Star. You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply. Politics Headlines Newsletter You're signed up! You'll start getting Politics Headlines in your inbox soon. Want more of the latest from us? Sign up for more at our newsletter page.
Montreal Gazette
9 hours ago
- Montreal Gazette
Pablo Rodriguez on defensive as Liberals seek way to win back votes in regions
By RIVIÈRE-DU-LOUP — Despite criticism from one of his competitors, Pablo Rodriguez says it would be perfectly legitimate for the next leader of the Quebec Liberals to represent a riding on the island of Montreal. 'What's most important is to have Quebec in your heart, to have the regions in your heart,' Rodriguez said at a news conference. 'It's as if there is something bad in coming from Montreal. 'I grew up in Sherbrooke. What's important is I will be the premier of all Quebecers.' The question of where Rodriguez would run roared to life Sunday during the sixth and final debate before the June 14 election of a new Quebec Liberal Party leader, a replacement for Dominique Anglade. The theme of the debate was the regions. Virtually shut out in ridings off the island of Montreal in the 2022 general election, the party desperately needs to win back francophone voters outside Montreal if it stands any chance of winning the next general election in 2026. It was former Liberal MNA Karl Blackburn, campaigning he is the man to rebuild the Liberals in the regions, who raised the issue of the leader's pedigree in a particularly intense moment of the debate before 150 Liberals gathered at the Hôtel Lévesque here. He told the crowd that in 2022 the Coalition Avenir Québec (CAQ) formed a government with 90 MNAs and only two were from Montreal. 'It shows you can form a government without Montreal, but you can't form a government without the regions of Quebec,' Blackburn said, adding in his mind the ballot box question in this race is who is best equipped to win those votes back. 'Unfortunately, voting for Pablo is to again abandon the landscape of the regions of Quebec and the economy,' Blackburn fired across the stage. At another point of the debate, Blackburn challenged Rodriquez to say where he would run. Blackburn noted he and the three other candidates have pledged to run for seats in the regions: him in Roberval, Charles Milliard in Orford, Marc Bélanger in the Outaouais, and Mario Roy in the Beauce. Rodriguez, who represented the Montreal riding of Honoré-Mercier when he was an MP and is leading the candidates in the polls, has not said where he would run should he become leader. Rodriguez has indicated he is mulling over either running in the Eastern Townships or in Montreal. He has said win or lose the leadership, he will be a candidate for the Liberals in 2026. At his own encounter with the media later, Blackburn did not back down. 'He did not even accept to say where he will run,' Blackburn said. 'For me, Pablo is a double zero. I don't need to find a region to say I come from. I am from Saguenay—Lac-St-Jean. The regions of Quebec have always been my playground. 'It was a great opportunity for him (Rodriguez) to say he will run in the regions.' The other candidates, however, were cautious about wading into the feud, which was not the first one between Rodriguez and Blackburn. 'It was not an anti-Montreal debate,' said Charles Milliard, a pharmacist and former president of the Fédération des chambres de commerce du Québec who lives in North Hatley. 'I sense a certain slippage in this debate; to the effect that if you once lived in Montreal you can't show your face in public.' As for Rodriguez possibly running in Montreal, Milliard said: 'Who am I to judge that? He will make his own decision. We're going to need 125 candidates, I'm going to need 124 amazing candidates and I would be very pleased to have him on my team.' Bélanger, an international trade lawyer, had an answer at the ready. 'Voting Marc Bélanger, that's a good choice for the regions,' he told reporters. Bélanger added 'people can run where they want,' but he has the knowledge of both Montreal and the regions. He is from Matane. The debate was just about the final pitch for votes from the candidates as the clock ticks down to election day. During the debate, all five said they are the best equipped to defeat the CAQ and block a comeback by the Parti Québécois, which leads in the polls. But candidate Roy, a 31-year-old economist and farmer from the Beauce who is barely registering in the polls, announced off the top of the debate he would not be rallying or working with the winning candidate no matter who comes out on top because he disagrees with all their positions. Roy also revealed to the crowd he put up $40,000 required to run in the race and now has to fundraise from Liberals to pay it back. To date, his campaign has raised $3,600. If he fails, Roy will be found in violation of the province's electoral laws and barred from seeking public office. 'It's do or die,' Roy said. 'If I am not elected, the party is finished. If I am not elected, the PQ will take power and my province is finished. It's do or die. If I am not elected the PQ and (Donald) Trump have a free hand. My country is finished.' Now that the debates are done, it will soon be time for the Liberals to start voting for their new leader. The process kicks off June 9 and runs to June 14. They can do it by phone, internet or in person at the site of the leadership convention June 14 at the Quebec City convention centre. While all members of the party have a vote, the party is using a weighting formula by riding and by age group. Under this formula, each of Quebec's 125 ridings are allocated 3,000 points. One thousand of those points are in the hands of youth members (25 years old and under). The total number of points awarded is 375,000. To win, a candidate has to obtain a majority of those points, or 187,501. If no candidate obtains a majority in the first round of voting, a second is held between the two candidates with the most votes. At the deadline to become a member to be eligible to vote, the party had 20,495 members. The candidates have one more chance to address Liberals: in speeches the day of the election at the convention. This story was originally published June 1, 2025 at 6:25 PM.
