KMI panel deliver verdict on Rangers vs Hibs ‘ghost goal' and controversial Dundee vs Ross County penalty decision
Referee Nick Walsh was the man at the centre of both incidents with the panel believing VAR should have intervened
VARCE KMI panel deliver verdict on Rangers vs Hibs 'ghost goal' and controversial Dundee vs Ross County penalty decision
A SCOTTISH FA panel has found Rangers' controversial 'ghost goal' against Hibs at Easter Road on the final day of the Scottish Premiership season SHOULD have stood.
The majority of the governing body's Key Match Indicator panel felt that the on-field decision by Nick Walsh was "incorrect" and "VAR should have intervened".
Advertisement
3
The goal was not given because the ball was not deemed to have cross the line
Credit: PA
3
Nico Raskin think he has scored for Rangers
Credit: Willie Vass
3
Dundee's Antonio Portales judged to have handled in the box
Credit: BBC
And the referee was at the centre of more controversy when another one of his calls - a handball in Dundee's match against Ross County, which ultimately relegated St Johnstone - has also been ruled WRONG.
Walsh infuriated Rangers on the final day of the Scottish Premiership season when he failed to give the goal for the visitors to go two up on Hibs before David Gray's men levelled moments later.
Nico Raskin ran through and bundled home from close range under pressure from defender Rocky Bushiri but, despite pictures appearing to show the ball over the line, the goal was not given and VAR did not get involved.
Rangers questioned the effectiveness of VAR in a statement after the game.
Advertisement
And it led to former Gers defender John Brown, who was commentating for the club's official TV channel at the time, to say it was 'corrupt'.
His comments are being investigated by the SFA's compliance officer and a charge could be forthcoming, which the club have said they will defend and described as "excessive, surprising and inconsistent."
A report by the KMI panel released on Friday said: "The panel discussed this decision at length with the majority (4:1) deeming the on-field decision incorrect.
"The majority (4:1) believed that VAR should have intervened and recommended a factual award of the goal.
Advertisement
"One member of the panel highlighted that they didn't think there was conclusive evidence and a VAR intervention should not take place."
They also gave the difficulty of the decision a four - which is described as a 'difficult decision for officials with a high degree of subjectivity or challenging considerations to identify. One that needs deliberation. A 50:50 decision.'
St Johnstone boss Simo Valakari on loving 'crazy' club owners, his Motherwell days and run-in with a Celtic hero
Just a few days before, Walsh made another contentious decision.
His penalty award for handball by Dundee's Antonio Portales enabled Ross County to level from the spot in the 96th minute, which was enough to relegate St Johnstone.
Advertisement
BBC Sportcene's football pundit Michael Stewart called it "a disgrace" and "unforgivable."
On the controversial handball which sunk the Saints, the report found: "The panel discussed this decision at length with the majority (4:1) deeming the on-field decision incorrect.
"The majority (4:1) believed that VAR should have intervened and recommended an OFR and for the referee to cancel the award of the penalty kick.
"One member of the panel highlighted that they thought it was a punishable handball and the penalty award was correct."
Advertisement
They also gave it a difficulty level of a three which is 'a more complex decision... but one that a select group of officials should nonetheless call correctly.'
Keep up to date with ALL the latest news and transfers at the Scottish Sun football page
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Reuters
2 hours ago
- Reuters
Sonny Gray improves to 6-1 as Cardinals shut out Rangers
May 31 - Willson Contreras drove in a run and scored one to back the solid pitching of Sonny Gray and two relievers as the St. Louis Cardinals defeated the Texas Rangers 2-0 on Saturday afternoon in the second contest of a three-game interleague series in Arlington, Texas. The Cardinals managed just five hits, but that total was enough to beat Texas, which posted four hits but had only one runner reach third base. St. Louis evened the series after getting shellacked 11-1 on Friday. The Rangers were shut out for the eighth time this season one day after producing their second-highest run total of 2025. Gray (6-1) went seven scoreless innings for St. Louis, scattering four hits and walking one while tying a season high with 10 strikeouts. Phil Maton relieved and worked around a walk in the eighth before Ryan Helsley retired the heart of the Rangers' order in the ninth and struck out two to record his 13th save of the campaign. Gray has won his past three decisions in a stretch of five starts without a loss. Masyn Wynn had two hits -- one of them a double -- to lead the Cardinals' offense. Patrick Corbin (3-4) started and went 5 1/3 innings for the Rangers, giving up two runs on three hits and two walks while striking out three. Corbin has surrendered three runs or less in all 10 of his starts this season but has just one win in his past seven appearances. The Cardinals manufactured the game's first run in the second inning, with Contreras walking, going to second on a wild pitch by Corbin, moving to third on a groundout, and trotting home on a sacrifice fly to deep center field from Nolan Arenado. In the fourth, Contreras doubled home Winn to make it 2-0 after Winn opened the frame with a double into the left field corner. Texas threatened in the fifth as Jake Burger singled and Marcus Semien singled, the latter with two outs. But Gray worked out of the jam by coaxing Kyle Higashioka to fly out. The Rangers had baserunners in the seventh and eighth innings but could not score. --Field Level Media
Scottish Sun
2 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
Top cop's call to toughen up footie banning orders amid surge in violence among teen fans
Police chiefs want easier access and heavier punishments for louts PYRO MANIACS Top cop's call to toughen up footie banning orders amid surge in violence among teen fans Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) TOUGHER footie banning orders are needed to tackle an alarming surge in violence and pyro offences by teenage fans of Scots lower league clubs, a top cop says. Assistant Chief Constable Alan Waddell issued the warning days after yobs brawled in the street before the SPFL Premiership play-off tie between Ross County and Livingston. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 4 01FEB25 Dunfermlines fans at the start. Dunfermline 3 v 1 Raith Rovers , Scottish Championship game played 1/2/2024 at East End Park. 4 Assistant Chief Constable Alan Waddell wants to make it easier for courts to serve tougher punishments on louts 4 Ultras groups down the divisions have marred games with fighting and pyro 4 Partick Thistle keeper ignores a smoke bomb hurled onto the pitch during the clash with Ayr United It followed a series of 'shocking' incidents involving matches in the Championship, League One, League Two — and even at Junior level. ACC Waddell, who heads football policing operations across Scotland, said: 'We are aware of the importance of football to our communities. "But some of the scenes over the last year have been shocking. "There have been pitch incursions and violence recently inside grounds. "And outside them, there have been disturbances leading to concerns and increased reports about fan behaviour. "The challenge with disorder at lower-level matches is that we would not ordinarily have police resources at them. "It means that we have to take officers out of communities to try to deal with this.' Attendances in the Championship, Leagues One and Two rocketed by more than 65 per cent in the last 11 years to a record 985,287 last season. But among the new faces inside grounds are groups keen to replicate the ultras of Celtic's Green Brigade and Rangers' Union Bears. Some have embraced hooliganism — wearing masks and hoods, attacking rival supporters and setting off flares and smoke bombs. Moment Scottish football ultras have megaphone confiscated ACC Waddell is keen to see the yobs being kept away from matches. He told The Scottish Sun on Sunday: 'In England, it's much easier for a football banning order to be issued. "There's an expectation the courts will do that. "However, that's not the same in Scotland. "We are keen to see the legislation being explored further here. "It's in the Scottish Government's plan for the next few years. "We've worked really closely with them. "And we've been inviting sheriffs and procurator fiscals to matches. "We want them to understand the complexities of policing games. "We're trying to get the criminal justice system in a place where we can work together to address these issues.' Last Monday, more than 20 ultras linked to Ross County and Livingston threw punches and attacked each other with poles and makeshift weapons in Dingwall, Easter Ross. Kenan Widdows, 24, of nearby Invergordon, was caught up in the chaos. He said: 'Boys from both sides were really lucky nobody was hurt considering weapons were used and bottles were thrown.' Earlier this month a cop required medical attention after being injured when Ayr United and Partick Thistle fans scrapped before their play-off clash. During the match at Somerset Park four young fans were hurt by pyros and home goalie Josh Clarke, 20, was shoved by a Jags supporter who'd ran onto the pitch. Greenock Morton revealed they'd hit seven fans with two-year bans following trouble at several games. Club chiefs said they were left with 'no choice but to take action'. Flares were hurled onto the pitch at Partick Thistle, narrowly missing kids, and a lad of 13 was attacked outside. Security was stepped up at Ton's Cappielow Park ground, with stewards checking for flares and smoke bombs. Four fans, three of them just 13, were nabbed in February by cops for having pyros at the Raith v Dunfermline league clash at Stark's Park. Ultras also let off smoke devices at Falkirk v Dunfermline in March. League One's bottom side Dumbarton barred all unaccompanied kids after ultras set off flares inside and outside their stadium during a game against Montrose, leaving some spectators needing medical attention. League Two side Spartans launched a 'School for Ultras' after kids said they wanted to get together to write songs and paint banners. But it had to be axed over fears they would be targeted by rivals. Even Junior football was affected. Masked hooligans were caught on CCTV hurling fireworks into a petrol station shop after being ejected from Newmains United Community FC's West of Scotland First Division clash with Carluke Rovers. Scots courts have issued more than 150 football banning orders to fans of lower league sides since 2012. But last night Stuart Murphy, chief exec of the Scottish Football Supporters Association, warned the chaos could lead to diehard fans opting to stay away. He said: 'Long-standing season ticket holders at clubs are thinking twice about renewing due to the behaviour of some people. These supporters are the lifeblood of our clubs but this is especially true for many teams in the lower divisions. But they are sick of illegal pyro use inside and outside grounds. It seems the game is secondary for some ultras. Nobody should need to worry about their kids or grandkids being burned by flares or being beaten up at a football match.' Kennie Young, assistant secretary of the Scottish Junior Football Association, said: 'Kids are just copying what they see fans of the biggest teams do on the telly. Clubs need to engage with them and tell them pyro is unacceptable, give them their own section and teach them responsibilities.' An SPFL spokesman said: 'We have repeatedly stated that pyrotechnics are illegal and unsafe and have no place at our matches. We wholeheartedly support the increased use of football banning orders for unacceptable behaviour.'
Scotsman
2 hours ago
- Scotsman
Brisbane, with a shot of Scotch
Brisbane's Story Bridge, named after Scottish pioneer, John Douglas Story, one of the 19th-century founders of the city which stands on the lands of First Nations peoples, the Turrbal and Yuggera. | Tom Adair Names, bridges, streets and districts all bear testament to the Scottish founding fathers of this forward-looking city. Sign up to our daily newsletter – Regular news stories and round-ups from around Scotland direct to your inbox Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... Welcome to Brizzie! The Queensland capital where the future looks Olympic. What you see here is what you get- which means informal, direct, relaxed. In seven years' time the world will log on, sit back and bask as Brisbane plays host to the Games of 2032. It'll be some party. Right now I'm here in pursuit of a Story - the Story Bridge, named after a Scot - and its Adventure Climb - not to mention the Scottish legacy (still found in district names like Morningside, Balmoral, Kelvin Grove, MacGregor, Robertson) and street names such as Armstrong Street or Edinburgh Castle Road. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad From my lofty room in the Crystalbrook Vincent, a modern art hotel overlooking the tortuous twists of the Brisbane River, at 6am, I see far below the Rivercat ferries like tiny toys, carving arcs from bank to bank while along the serpentine strip of Riverwalk runners and joggers, power-walkers, cyclists, a purposeful existential stream of human endeavour is up and running - evading death or speeding towards it. The city's dream to host the Olympics is now a reality, and Brisbane's latest fame-grab is - to quote the man responsible for bringing those games to life - 'to make Brisbane recognised by the world as a Tier-One city.' No small aspiration. The Crystalbrook Vincent sits under the bridge in the cultural riverside hub now known as Howard Smith Wharves - a re-purposed zone of recreational and performance spaces, new restaurants and a micro-brewery. I recall it as almost moribund and derelict on my last visit. Back then, 14 years ago, Brisbane seemed somehow adolescent in its swagger. Today it possesses the grown-up resolve to live out its dream. The Story Bridge Adventure climb takes sight-seers along the spans of the bridge, high above the River | Tom Adair And I'm here to live mine - to climb the imposing Story Bridge, named after Scottish pioneer, John Douglas Story, one of the 19th-century founders of this city which stands on the lands of First Nations peoples, the Turrbal and Yuggera. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The bridge is heritage listed, spanning the twisting restless river from Kangaroo Point to Fortitude Valley, (casting its shadow each afternoon across my bedroom), it stands 243 feet above the river and is the longest cantilever bridge anywhere in Australia. More to the point, the Adventure Bridge Climb, second only to BridgeClimb Sydney, promises windswept, 'stunning views… and the thrill of history'. I'm sold. Latched to the rail as we ascend, (health and safety to the fore), zipped into our jump suits, five rookie climbers, (two clinging newly-wed Americans, two Japanese, myself and climb-leader, Sam, from Devon, attempt the first-ascent of the day, Sam spraying facts about the history of settlement: the Scots, the Irish, the English, while directing us to cast our gaze towards the silhouette of the skyline's chrome and glass totems. Kelsi and Justin, (as newly-weds ought), are holding tight, not looking down. Reader - we survived. Tom Adair at the top of the Story Bridge, Brisbane. | Tom Adair I head to Tai Tai for lunch, in the vibrant riverside 'Cultural Quarter', (the Gallery of Modern Art, Brisbane Museum), where I dine al fresco beside the 'Brown Snake', (the locals' nickname for the river), enjoying a flavour burst of South East Asian soup and spicy pork. My server, (Malaysian), calls himself Stewart, while manager, Ian, is a Robertson from Dunfermline boasting a granny from Portree. 'I'm well assimilated,' he grins, pointing out the pontoon where I catch the Citycat, (a free ferry ride), to my digs on the other side. The winding river grants Brisbane a grandeur unmatched by Australia's other state capitals. Graced at intervals by gardens of oleander, jacaranda, figs, and swathes of sub-tropical bush it invites recreation. Bisbaners love it for the man-made striking Streets Beach - a simulated tropical paradise with palm trees, a blue lagoon, white sandy beaches and chill-out vibe. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad While the river feels open, the city hoards secrets within its high rise. I seek to unlock them with Local Sauce Tours, whose city guide, Saskia, mentions her bagpipe playing granddad as she strides me into the looming smoked glass labyrinth of buildings, finding gems from a century past: St Stephen's Cathedral, and older still, the great domed Customs House, floodlit at night, and the super opulent Regent Theatre, ornately magnificent. Round two corners lies City Hall in King George's Square, a public space where citizens rally in times of crisis and celebration. Its dominant statue - the Petrie Tableau - lauds the importance of the city's founding family. The Presbyterian, Andrew Petrie settled in 1842. He nurtured relations with the Turrbal, and became the first mayor of the settlement which had been named for Thomas Brisbane, the New South Wales Governor, originally from Largs. The Petrie Tableau Statue in King George's Square, Brisbane. | Tom Adair Inside City Hall, the most prized exhibit is the 'Largs Door' removed from the entrance to Thomas Brisbane's Ayrshire home and presented in 1958 by the Provost of Largs to the city of Brisbane. The Largs Door | Tom Adair By way of contrast, Saskia leads me to the ultra-modernist 'Star', a sky-piercing casino that Andrew Petrie might have considered a den of iniquity. 'Smells of America,' I tell her, unimpressed. 'Time for a drink,' she says, 'I'm buying.' And thus we repair to Frogs Hollow Saloon. The drinks list is mighty - a who's who of all the world's great distilleries. Alas, since we're each 'on duty' we order soft drinks - to toast Andrew Petrie and Thomas Brisbane, the men, the place, and the Scots who followed. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad That night I indulge in fancy dining at the swish but relaxed SK Steak and Oyster, where beef is grilled to juicy perfection and wine sings in harmony. Milton, my promised date next morning, would have hated it. And besides, I was pretty sure he'd be sleeping already - he goes to bed early and kips like a log 20 hours a day. We meet by arrangement after breakfast at Lone Pines Sanctuary up river. It houses, crocodile, platypus, dingoes, snakes and roo. But mostly Koala - and Milton's the poster boy. Milton the koala, who sleeps 20 hours a day at the Lone Pines animal sanctuary, Brisbane. | Tom Adair While I stroke his back and shoulders he simply blanks me, munching juicy eucalyptus. A passing water dragon hustles us. Milton's indifferent. Another fistful appears in his paw. Caillin, his keeper says he's 'a very good boy indeed,' adding 'he's bit me only once.' I notice the water dragon take cover. 'Mosquitoes love him' she adds. On cue he begins to scratch.
