logo
Historymaker Fin Smith was diligent and unstinting in trying to prime misfiring Lions against Argentina

Historymaker Fin Smith was diligent and unstinting in trying to prime misfiring Lions against Argentina

Irish Times5 hours ago

Tom Elliot died four years before Fin Smith was born in 1998, Lion number 380 and Lion number 862, a Scotland prop and an England outhalf. At the Aviva Stadium on Friday the pair claimed a unique milestone as the first grandfather and grandson to represent the touring team.
Elliot did so in the 1955 tour to South Africa under the captaincy of Ireland's Robin Thompson, a squad that drew the series 2-2 with the Springboks, and included one of rugby's great outhalves, Cliff Morgan.
Smith used to run around in his grandfather's old
Lions
gear, dreaming big. On a sultry Dublin night it was realised, bridging a 70-year gap, a poignant moment for his family who attended the game, especially his mother, Judith, as Tom Elliot was her father.
The Lions' jersey is precious in rugby circles, the number 10 shirt represents the pantheon. Barry John in New Zealand (1971), Phil Bennett in South Africa (1974), and a little closer to home, Jack Kyle, Tony Ward, Ollie Campbell, Ronan O'Gara and Johnny Sexton have all donned that shirt in a Test series.
READ MORE
Smith wore it lightly despite a troublesome opening to the game, targeted successfully in the air on a couple of occasions when defending on the wing, and also conceding a penalty that allowed the Pumas to record the first points of the game. A switch to fullback on Argentina ball negated that gambit.
Despite the misadventures, the 22-year-old demonstrated a capacity to shrug off the missteps, remaining composed in his distribution, while hustling superbly on a couple of occasions to shore up defensive lapses, none more laudable that the way he chopped down Joaquin Oviedo that stopped the Argentinian number eight from escaping into the Lions backfield.
Smith offered a ubiquitous presence in the opening 40-minutes, plenty to admire in his kicking, from tee and hand, even if it didn't always come off; a case in point his cross-kick for Jac Morgan brilliantly defended by Ignacio Mendy.
The outhalf's passing was crisp and accurate, at odds with his team-mates as the Lions had two early tries chalked off for knocks-on. It's difficult to put shape on sloppiness, the Lions' handling at times was unsympathetic and fraught, symptomatic of a scratch side lacking composure and, as a result, cohesion.
[
Lions left to rue missed chances as Argentina win in Dublin
]
Smith's influence grew evermore positive, manifest in a basketball-style flick over the top over the top of the onrushing Mendy to get the ball to
Bundee Aki
for the Lions first try. It was no bagatelle to finish for the Irish centre, but without the sharpness of the two Smiths, Marcus and Fin, the chance would not have materialised.
Fin Smith is seen in action as the Lions take on Argentina at the Aviva Stadium on Friday. Photograph: Charles McQuillan/Getty
The Lions outhalf is a doughty competitor and tough to boot, shrugging off a heavy blow to the face that earned his side a penalty, and then a rib-tickling clatter from Argentina wing Rodrigo Isgró as Fin Smith plucked a high ball from the sky.
His relationship with scrumhalf Alex Mitchell, superb in his time on the pitch, provided the Lions with good tempo, but more often than not a predilection for 30/70 offloads cost
Andy Farrell's
side several promising situations in attack.
Yet throughout the travails the outhalf was diligent and unstinting in trying to prime his misfiring team. Trailing 21-10 – Argentina deserved that lead based on their ability to convert on turnover ball – Fin Smith was at the heart of the Lions post interval revival that saw them surge into a 24-21 lead only to be stuck down again an injudicious decision and a turnover upon which the Pumas capitalised superbly.
The Lions couldn't get out of their own way when it came to the mistakes, increasingly ragged, weary and in truth desperate to a point where the outhalf was too often shorn of options in an attacking capacity and as a result resorted to kicking the ball long.
Bruised and afflicted by cramp as the game entered its death rattle, he tried to cajole and marshal his team as they looked to rescue a victory, but that was beyond him and the team. The result, 24-28, will hurt the team and outhalf, but 70-years on Fin Smith may take a little solace from following in the boot prints of his grandfather with the promise of better days ahead.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Dangerous Down almost ready to mark their territory
Dangerous Down almost ready to mark their territory

Irish Examiner

time2 hours ago

  • Irish Examiner

Dangerous Down almost ready to mark their territory

THE soon to be dormant, if not extinct, All-Ireland group stages have generally followed the rule of law. Table-toppers generally beat preliminary quarter-final winners - six out of eight times - and the two All-Ireland winners under the system, Dublin and Armagh, have topped their group. In a format not above criticism, the layered reward for where you finish in your group generally holds true. If there is one anomaly, and something that provides hope to a quartet of teams this weekend, it's that in the eight preliminary quarter-finals played, the third-placed team has travelled to the home of their rivals and won on four of seven occasions, while Monaghan also edged out Kildare in neutral Tullamore in 2023 with Newbridge out of action. Last Monday's preliminary quarter-final draw, containing more heavyweights than anticipated, resulted in three lop-sided pairings and one tie that just carries a whiff of, well if not cordite, enough propellant to provide a potentially combustible situation for Galway's All-Ireland hopes. Donegal v Louth, Kerry v Cavan and Dublin v Cork all look like foregone conclusions no matter how it's spun – and maybe the shock will come in amongst those – but Galway travel to Newry to face a Down team that seem best placed to upset the odds. That's true for two reasons. Firstly, Down have made unarguable progress under manager Conor Laverty while Galway, All-Ireland finalists in two of the last three seasons, just haven't settled into this championship since their successful Connacht run – although they will hope that their stirring second-half comeback against Armagh will offer the spark. Sunday in the Marshes will tell us more. Reigning Tailteann Cup champions Down are preparing for their biggest home match since the visit of Mayo in 2019. There have been Ulster clashes since, but nothing to match the level of excitement in the border town this week – or parts of it anyway. Back in 1994, Armagh's pre-season started prior to the All-Ireland final between Down and Dublin meaning that some of their players made the trips to training via a red and black bedecked Newry, seething inside as they passed every good luck flag and piece of bunting. They stayed up for months as Down raised Sam for a fifth time, but 31 years later there hasn't been as much as an Ulster title. Last year's Tailteann Cup was as much about ending a long wait for silverware as the trophy itself. Drive through Newry today and it's the orange and white bunting hanging from lampposts, a hangover from Armagh's All-Ireland triumph 12 months ago. The car flags driving in and out of a city that will always be referred to as 'town' by locals, are Orchard County ones. Except McCoy's Bar on the way to the ground and Páirc Esler itself, Down haven't braved marking their territory – yet. But there is belief, genuine belief, that they are ascending. Results are results but relegation to Division 3 this year was undeserved, subsequent championship displays have reinforced that feeling that they can compete with the best. When Laverty was appointed manager in August 2022, he took on a county in disarray. James McCartan oversaw a winless season beforehand and had been close to stepping down after a serious breach of discipline by players at a training camp in Dublin before being convinced to see the campaign out. 'Players have accepted responsibility and have rectified the situation," Down secretary Sean Óg McAteer told Ulster publication Gaelic Life at the time. Five players, including NFL player Charlie Smyth and current panellist Caolan Mooney, departed the panel before the Tailteann Cup with the latter lashing out at McCartan in an interview with the Smaller Fish podcast. Sources close to the camp suggested that the training block for the Tailteann Cup was the most enjoyable of the year while there was considerable anger that a Mourne legend like McCartan had been treated so poorly. Three seasons on, and of the 20 players who featured in Down's 2022 Tailteann Cup loss to Cavan, McCartan's last game in charge, only Peter Fegan, Ryan Magill, Daniel Guinness, Odhrán Murdock, Pierce Laverty and Patrick McCarthy were on the field against Monaghan last week. McCarthy, Magill and Murdock all won a pair of Ulster U20 crowns under Conor Laverty, Pierce Laverty was a long-time captain and Daniel Guinness has been Down's most consistent player over the last five years. Burren corner-back Fegan comes highly rated. Kilcoo man Laverty has 13 county medals in his pocket – and an All-Ireland too – from playing with the Magpies. He has crafted a Down team that shares so many of their attributes. Physically smaller than many opponents – as Down will be against Galway – they have an extraordinary handle on the basics and operate a running game that is maybe only bettered by Donegal currently. It's not the size of the dog in the fight, after all. He's also managed to rub out one of the black marks that had been hanging over the side – the lack of a marquee forward. On Sunday, barring any unfortunate injury, Pat Havern will move from 0-99 for the season to over the 100-point mark. Shane Walsh may have edged him out in the National League as the two-point king, but Havern is now the current heir to the throne with 21 to Walsh's 18 – although the latter did miss the Connacht championship. Havern, who looked destined to be one of Ulster's top handballers before giving it up at a young age, has previously been accused of not doing it against the top teams. Such notions have been swept away this season, Galway be warned. The men and red and black aren't back just yet, but a visit to the last eight of the All-Ireland for the first time since 2012, and at the expense of one of the favourites for Sam, and that Down bunting will start to be unfurled.

Sam Mulroy: 'Families, lives, work and holidays need to count. We're not paid for this thing'
Sam Mulroy: 'Families, lives, work and holidays need to count. We're not paid for this thing'

Irish Examiner

time2 hours ago

  • Irish Examiner

Sam Mulroy: 'Families, lives, work and holidays need to count. We're not paid for this thing'

Sam Mulroy got a message from his clubmate JP Rooney earlier this week. It was a picture of the former Louth player's son playing football in the backyard. Before Louth's victory in last month's Leinster final, which sealed their first senior provincial title in 68 years, it seemed the apple had fallen far from the tree. 'His young lad John was never in love with football until he came and watched Louth playing in a Leinster final a few weeks back,' explained Mulroy at the All-Ireland knockout stages launch. 'It was very nice to see that you're inspiring the next generation of players. 'Louth is a small county with two massive towns and two massive soccer clubs in Dundalk and Drogheda. It's been a battle over the last while, especially with Dundalk's success in recent years in Europe. There's definitely more Louth jerseys floating around on kids these days.' Three years ago, Mulroy appeared on the BBC's The GAA Social podcast and said winning a Leinster title in the next five or six years was a realistic ambition for Louth. He took flak for his comments. To some, it seemed fanciful. Dublin's All-Ireland juggernaut might have been halted the previous year, but they still looked unstoppable in the province. After losing the Leinster finals of 2023 and 2024 to Dublin, Mulroy's prophecy came through. He had stopped just short of saying 'why not?' when asked on that podcast if Louth could win the All-Ireland. Now he's edging closer towards it. 'Last week Meath beat Kerry, and they've beaten Dublin, and there's games, there's results that you wouldn't be calling, maybe last year, that are happening this year,' said Mulroy, top scorer in the championship with 4-34. He believes Gaelic football's new rules have made the game more open. That's not to say he loves every one of them. He doesn't like that the kickout has to go beyond the 40m arc or having to hand the ball to an opposition player after a foul is committed, but what annoys him most is the altering of the rules during the season. 'It's 11 v 11 instead of 15 v 15, there's space to get shots off; players are expressing themselves a little bit more because the game's so fast, and there seems to be a lot more plays happening,' he said. 'Each play doesn't seem to be as important, whereas last year, if you turned the ball over, you could go without the ball for three, four, five minutes.' Louth face Donegal in a preliminary quarter-final on Sunday in Ballybofey. Mulroy knows Donegal manager Jim McGuinness well. McGuinness was involved with Mulroy's club when they won the Louth SFC in 2020 and 2021, the former being the first time Naomh Mairtín claimed the senior title. 'Jim was immense when he was with us, and a gentleman, and always very good with his time,' said Mulroy. 'I've got an awful lot of respect for Jim and what he's done for the game, for Donegal and our club. That was our first ever senior title in the club, so it was very special. I'll never forget that and the help he gave us. 'I was captain in 2021. He was very big on leadership and driving the group on. He would have spoken to me individually. I learned an awful lot. Just on the training pitch, how he spoke to players and got us to bring up our levels - you can see why he's been so successful.' GAA president Jarlath Burns said earlier this month that moving the All-Ireland finals to August from 2027 on would have his support. It would not have the support of Mulroy, who enjoys the split season as it stands. 'It gives a bit more time for those county players to get a little bit of a rest before they go back to the club,' he said. 'Taking into consideration the players' downtime is massively important. If you bring the All-Ireland final back to August and then they're still playing their club finals in November, December, when are they going to stop? That has to be a key consideration for everyone that's making that decision: when do the players get time off? Families and lives and work and holidays need to count. We're not paid for this thing, so I think that definitely has to be the big consideration. 'Even if you got a few more weeks between games… It's not as if you get to go and live your life for a few weeks. You're still training like a professional athlete, you're still in the camp, you're still going away on training weekends. If you push the weeks out, you don't get the time off. It's not as if we're going to be let go and go sun ourselves for a few weeks. 'Prolonging the thing adds more volume of training for players. I know it's tight between games right now, but like, Jesus, I love it. I played last weekend, I get to play again this weekend, I'd rather that than having to go train.' The possibilities for Louth in Monday's draw were all tough. It was Kerry in Killarney, Dublin in Croke Park or Donegal in Ballybofey. They would have been underdogs in the first two, and also will be on Sunday, but it's not outlandish to think they could pull off an upset. 'That's my belief, and I'll definitely be putting that message to the players when we go to training, that we're not going up to Ballybofey for the craic, or to fulfil a fixture, we're in a preliminary quarter-final of the All-Ireland Series,' said Mulroy. 'We played in a quarter-final here (in Croke Park against Donegal) last year, so it's a case of, 'let's try to go better again this year, and try to progress as a team.''

Lions v Argentina player ratings: Bundee Aki shows his strength, Fin Smith has a shaky start
Lions v Argentina player ratings: Bundee Aki shows his strength, Fin Smith has a shaky start

Irish Times

time4 hours ago

  • Irish Times

Lions v Argentina player ratings: Bundee Aki shows his strength, Fin Smith has a shaky start

Marcus Smith: Scrambled well for a kicked through ball at the end of the first half but wasn't always solid under the high kicks. Caught out of position and didn't read the threat when Santiago Cordero scored his second-half try. 5 Tommy Freeman: Kept busy coming in from the wing and hungry for work from the beginning. Some clever running lines too. Picked it up in the second half and showed what a real live wire he can be at this level. 7 Sione Tuipulotu: Showed his strength going forward for his disallowed try and was always a threat going forward in the carry. Some handling errors and scrappy offloads and an excellent try saving tackle at the end of the first half. 6 Bundee Aki: He was selected for his strength and ability to gain yards in traffic. His first half try was just that as he muscled over with three players around him. Gave way for Elliot Daly in the second half. 6 READ MORE Duhan van der Merwe: He was a mixed bag in the first half, hitting rucks and a great one-handed pass to Tommy Freeman early on. Was an early threat but was turned over going forward for the Albornoz try before half-time. 5 Fin Smith: Shaky start with a few missed high balls but grew into a game that was frantic at times and also disconnected. A busy player but perhaps not as controlling and influential as he would have liked. 5 Alex Mitchell: Provided a good service after box kicking at the beginning which wasn't always profitable. A super one-handed defensive pass to Freeman. Seemed rushed at times moving the ball forward. Replaced after half-time by Williams. 5 Alex Mitchell seemed rushed at times moving the ball forward. Photograph:Ellis Genge: Crushed a few scrums in the first half where the Lions earned three penalties. Good energy too from the loose head prop who trucked some hard yards before giving way to Schoeman after an hour. 6 Luke Cowan-Dickie: Showed great strength for his disallowed try in the first half. Was very active around the park with a few missed lineout throws. Showed good energy while he was on before Ronan Kelleher replaced him early in the second half. 6 Finlay Bealham: Was solid in the scrums and involved around the pitch in a frantic first half. Showed himself to be valuable around the park and in the set piece. Will be pleased with his 59 minutes before Tadhg Furlong came in. 6 Maro Itoje: Quiet enough first half and himself and Cowan Dickie didn't quite get the lineout timing early in the match. Controlled the lineout maul well for the Lions penalty try early in the second half. 5 Tadhg Beirne ran a great line for his try in the first half. Photograph: Billy Stickland/Inpho Tadhg Beirne: Never afraid of the grunt work and ran a great line for his try in the first half, taking the ball from a hard flat pass by replacement Tomos Williams. Great lineout take at the end but Lions just off their game to capitalise. 6 Tom Curry: One of the players that showed from the beginning taking up the ball and hitting back Argentina players. Took a few lineouts too. Turned up on the day but a disjointed overall performance negated some of his work. 7 Jac Morgan: Got involved in everything early in the game and won an important runover in the first half that could have been a try. Probably didn't show as much as he is capable of in a frustrating first half. Replaced by Henry Pollo ck 49 minutes in. 6 Ben Earl: Took early carries and showed visibility throughout the first half. He was one of the more solid Lions performers, taking the ball on and curbing the errors that had frustrated Lions efforts. 7 [ Lions left to rue missed chances as Argentina win in Dublin Opens in new window ] Andy Farrell: Spoke about connections during the week and the difficulty of glueing a team together that had not much time to work out each other's way of playing. That disconnect was on show, especially in a frustrating first half. 6 Replacements: Several players made an impact when they came on including Tomos Williams and Mack Hansen who took the ball on several times. Ultimately they didn't get it over the line with plenty of late possession and territory. 6 Which Ireland players will step up for the summer squad while the Lions are away? Listen | 27:53

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store