Former MPP Randy Hillier wins bid to appeal dismissal of COVID-19 lockdown Charter challenge
Social Sharing
Ontario's highest court has ruled that gathering limits during the COVID-19 lockdown in 2021 unjustifiably violated the Charter right to peaceful assembly, and it's allowing former Ottawa-area MPP Randy Hillier to appeal the dismissal of his challenge on the constitutionality of those limits.
In a decision published Monday, Justice Peter Lauwers wrote that peaceful assembly and political protest are "integral to a functioning democracy," and that the effect of shutdown and stay-at-home orders was to "stifle" assemblies protesting those bans.
Hillier was charged with provincial offences under the Reopening Ontario (A Flexible Response to COVID-19) Act for acting as a host or organizer at two protests in eastern Ontario in 2021: in Kemptville on April 8, and in Cornwall on May 1.
After he was charged, Hillier and his lawyers at Charter Advocates Canada — funded by the Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms — challenged the gathering limits. In 2023, Superior Court Justice John Callaghan determined the limits were reasonable and dismissed Hillier's challenge.
Lauwers disagreed with Callaghan's analysis, finding that Callaghan "focused on the law's overwhelming social good in preventing the spread of COVID-19, not on ways in which the fundamental freedom of peaceful assembly might still be accommodated in the delicate task of balancing," among other errors.
'Constitution does not fade from view in times of crisis'
He also noted that Ontario managed to come up with more tailored restrictions on religious gatherings in order to facilitate freedom of religion, but "no such tailoring was performed to facilitate the right to peacefully assemble."
In fact, the evidence showed that the province failed to consider it, Lauwers wrote.
"The pandemic posed significant challenges for Ontario, but the Constitution does not fade from view in times of crisis," his decision reads.
There is no evidence that an exemption to allow peaceful assembly outside would have increased risk, Lauwers found, or that matching the exemption for permitted gatherings like weddings, funerals and religious services would have increased risk. There is also no evidence of increased risk at the outdoor protests Hillier attended.
Court of Appeal Justices Benjamin Zarnett and Renee Pomerance agreed with Lauwers.
Hillier has 10 days to write to the court about what he thinks an appropriate remedy should be, with the province's submissions and any follow-up submissions by Hillier to follow. The parties aren't seeking to be reimbursed for costs.
One of Hillier's lawyers, Chris Fleury, wrote in an emailed statement that he and Hillier are "extremely pleased with the decision" and that "a Canadian Court has finally found that a government went too far in imposing Covid-era gathering restrictions and curtailing civil liberties."
He declined to comment on remedy, as the issue remains before the court.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CTV News
2 hours ago
- CTV News
CTV National News: Canada to hit NATO defence spending target in 2025
Prime Minister Mark Carney says Canada will hit the NATO defence spending target of 2 per cent this fiscal year. Mike Le Couteur on what that means.
Globe and Mail
4 hours ago
- Globe and Mail
Ottawa police probing defacement of National Holocaust Monument as hate crime
The Ottawa Police Service confirmed an act of vandalism on the National Holocaust Monument is being investigated by its hate crime unit. The words 'FEED ME' were found scrawled in red paint across the front of the monument Monday morning. Red paint was splashed on other parts of it as well. Ottawa police said they are treating the incident with the utmost seriousness, noting the impact such crimes have on the community. 'Reporting hate-motivated incidents is an important step in stopping cycles of hatred,' the service said in a statement. There has been an increase in reports of hate crime in Canada in recent years, which police agencies across the country link explicitly to the outbreak of war between Hamas and Israel in October, 2023. Police-reported hate crimes rose 32 per cent in 2023 compared with 2022. There has also been an increase of crimes targeting Jews in Canada, with 900 crimes reported in 2023, compared with 527 the year before. A petition condemning the vandalism in Ottawa was tabled in Parliament Monday by Conservative MP Tamara Kronis, who said 'the government must enforce the law and protect Jewish Canadians from hate, violence and intimidation.' Minister of Canadian Identity and Culture Steven Guilbeault also issued a strong condemnation. 'This monument honours the courage of survivors and the memory of the six million Jews murdered during one of humanity's darkest chapters,' he said. 'Acts of antisemitism, hatred and intolerance are attacks on us all – and they will never be tolerated in Canada.' Gaps in how justice system responds to hate crimes need to be addressed, report finds Deborah Lyons, Canada's Special Envoy on Preserving Holocaust Remembrance and Combating Antisemitism, said she was 'crushed' when she saw that the monument had been vandalized. She said that this was an antisemitic hate crime targeting Jews who have no connection to the Israeli government or its policies in Gaza. 'This is not a way to address the concerns that people have, either about what's happening in the Middle East or certainly about what's happened in our own country with the high spike of antisemitism,' Ms. Lyons said. Ottawa resident Robert Harmer, who lives close to the monument, called the vandalism 'a shame.' 'These monuments help us remember history – even the painful parts. Defacing something like the Holocaust Monument isn't protest; it's going too far.' Andres Bermudez, a resident and worker from Gemma Property Services involved in the cleanup, said the act was 'disrespectful and harmful.' 'These monuments attract tourists and beautify the city,' he said. 'Vandalism isn't the way to be heard. It's costly to clean up defaced walls, and the money comes from taxpayers.' Lawrence Greenspon, co-chair of the monument committee, spoke of his own family's experience of antisemitism. 'My father is a Holocaust survivor. His sister and his mother and father were all killed. My daughter is named after his sister,' Mr. Greenspon said. 'When somebody defaces the National Holocaust Monument, it is personal and it hurts, and particularly when it is such an act of hatred and antisemitism.' With a report from The Canadian Press
National Post
4 hours ago
- National Post
Canada Post rejects union terms for arbitration as both sides enter bitter stalemate
Canadian Union of Postal Workers (CUPW) President Jan Simpson, second from right, takes part in a Canada Post rally outside of the Prime Minister's Office in Ottawa, on Saturday. Photo by Spencer Colby / Postmedia MONTREAL — A government push to steer Canada Post and the union representing 55,000 mail workers toward common ground hit a big pothole Monday. THIS CONTENT IS RESERVED FOR SUBSCRIBERS Enjoy the latest local, national and international news. Exclusive articles by Conrad Black, Barbara Kay and others. Plus, special edition NP Platformed and First Reading newsletters and virtual events. Unlimited online access to National Post. National Post ePaper, an electronic replica of the print edition to view on any device, share and comment on. Daily puzzles including the New York Times Crossword. Support local journalism. SUBSCRIBE FOR MORE ARTICLES Enjoy the latest local, national and international news. Exclusive articles by Conrad Black, Barbara Kay and others. Plus, special edition NP Platformed and First Reading newsletters and virtual events. Unlimited online access to National Post. National Post ePaper, an electronic replica of the print edition to view on any device, share and comment on. Daily puzzles including the New York Times Crossword. Support local journalism. REGISTER / SIGN IN TO UNLOCK MORE ARTICLES Create an account or sign in to continue with your reading experience. Access articles from across Canada with one account. Share your thoughts and join the conversation in the comments. Enjoy additional articles per month. Get email updates from your favourite authors. THIS ARTICLE IS FREE TO READ REGISTER TO UNLOCK. Create an account or sign in to continue with your reading experience. Access articles from across Canada with one account Share your thoughts and join the conversation in the comments Enjoy additional articles per month Get email updates from your favourite authors As an increasingly acrimonious impasse drags on, Canada Post rejected a framework put forward by the union for a binding arbitration process, which Jobs Minister Patty Hajdu asked the parties to work toward just five days earlier. Canada Post spokeswoman Lisa Liu said the Canadian Union of Postal Workers has effectively refused to take heed of a federally commissioned report that called for major reforms to the 158-year-old institution, including more flexible routes and part-time weekend positions with similar pay rates and benefits. Get a dash of perspective along with the trending news of the day in a very readable format. By signing up you consent to receive the above newsletter from Postmedia Network Inc. Please try again 'The union's refusal to recognize the IIC (industrial inquiry commission) report and its recommendations in their proposed terms of reference for arbitration is unacceptable,' she said in a statement. The Canadian Union of Postal Workers said its goal remains a return to the bargaining table to hammer out a new contract. 'However, Canada Post's actions suggest it does not want to negotiate. It wants to rewrite our agreements — and is seeking to use government interference to further its goals,' the union said in a release Monday. Canada Post questioned that claim, noting that the union has not responded to its latest offer from May 28. The two sides exchanged some information on Thursday and Friday through federal mediators, but have had little contact since, the Crown corporation added. Meanwhile, the union called on members to sign a letter to the minister opposing the prospect of a forced vote on Canada Post's 'final offers.' The letter says that such a move — requested by Canada Post _ would amount to government interference, tip the scales in the employer's favour and potentially sow division in the ranks of employees. 'The issues will remain contentious among some, most or all of the membership, depending upon how the vote goes,' the Sunday missive states, adding that resulting resentment would undermine labour peace. Union president Jan Simpson hinted at possible rifts within the membership last week, saying in an update that 'although tensions are high, let's not forget our fight is with the employer, not one another.' Canada Post's last proposal includes an end to compulsory overtime, signing bonuses of between $500 and $1,000 and cost-of-living payments that are triggered at a lower inflation threshold.
