NHS nurse ordered to remove ‘antisemitic' video of watermelon launches legal action
A senior NHS nurse who says he was ordered to remove his video with a background showing a fruit bowl containing a watermelon because it could be perceived as antisemitic has launched legal action against his employer.
Ahmad Baker, who is British-Palestinian and works at Whipps Cross hospital, north London, is one of three medical staff claiming Barts Health NHS trust's ban on staff displaying symbols perceived as politically or nationally affiliated is disproportionate and discriminatory. Watermelons became symbols of Palestine amid censorship of the Palestinian flag because of its similar colours.
Barts, which runs five London hospitals, introduced the ban in March in its updated uniform and dress code policy, which extends to items on workstations, laptops and iPads, even if staff are working from home and not seeing patients.
The policy says it is in keeping with the trust's responsibility to be 'completely apolitical and non-biased in our care', but the claimants point to Barts' support for Ukraine.
Baker said: 'As a Palestinian, I should be able to express my identity and solidarity with my people, especially during a humanitarian crisis. Being told that a still-life painting containing a watermelon could be perceived as antisemitic and being threatened with disciplinary action is deeply upsetting.
'I've worked for the NHS for over a decade – this is not the inclusivity I thought we stood for.'
Baker, along with Dr Aarash Saleh, a respiratory consultant at Whipps Cross, and Dr Sara Ali, a haematology registrar who previously worked at the Royal London hospital, claim the policy amounts to indirect discrimination under the Equality Act 2010, disproportionately affecting staff who wish to express pro-Palestinian beliefs, particularly considering events in Gaza.
They also say that it say it unlawfully discriminates against them because of their anti-Zionist views, which were found to be a protected belief under the Equality Act by an employment tribunal last year. Baker has also raised separate claims of direct discrimination and harassment.
Ali said: 'To suggest that expressing support for the Palestinians who are facing one of the most catastrophic humanitarian crises in recent history is somehow threatening, after the trust had rightly expressed support for Ukraine, is not only manifestly discriminatory but is antithetical to the values of universal empathy and compassion that underpin our practice as healthcare workers.'
A letter before action sent on behalf of the healthcare staff by Liana Wood from the law firm Leigh Day also argues that there was 'inappropriate consultation' with a pro-Israel advocacy group, while sidelining internal staff voices.
UK Lawyers for Israel (UKLFI), having complained to the trust about pro-Palestinian symbols worn by staff, published an article on its website about the new policy eight days before it was officially implemented.
Saleh said: 'It's especially troubling that UKLFI publicly announced the policy before the trust itself had communicated it to staff – this raises serious concerns about transparency and whose voices were prioritised in the process.'
Sign up to First Edition
Our morning email breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters
after newsletter promotion
The medics, who are crowdfunding their legal costs on the CrowdJustice platform, are seeking the removal of key provisions of the policy, a declaration from the employment tribunal that discrimination has taken place, and compensation for injury to feelings they have suffered and continue to suffer as a result of the policy.
Wood said: 'Trusts must take care not to impose disproportionate restrictions on expression, especially where those restrictions appear to be targeted at a specific group or belief.'
A spokesperson for Barts said: 'We recognise the distress that global conflict has for our diverse workforce and continue to support their wellbeing as they serve our patients. However, as an NHS organisation our primary responsibility is care for patients.'
They said the policy aimed to 'uphold political neutrality, creating an inclusive culture at work, and a safe space for patients in their time of need'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Man with a broken wrist spent an hour trying to save hospital doctor friend, 30, after she slipped 30ft to her death from grassy ledge in Snowdonia, inquest hears
A man with a broken wrist spent an hour trying to save his hospital doctor friend after she fell 30ft to her death, an inquest heard today. Dr Charlotte Crook, 31, and her colleague Adam Weatherhogg had been walking in Snowdonia on February 16 when Ms Crook slipped and plunged off a grassy ledge. Senior coroner John Gittins praised the 'amazing efforts' that Mr Weatherhogg made as he carried out chest compressions in a bid to help Dr Crook, of Perry Barr, Birmingham. Her parents described the hills and mountains as their only child's 'happy place.' She had a 'passion for exploration of the great outdoors.' Dr Crook was an experienced walker but died from a head injury last February on Glyder Fach. The Ruthin hearing was told that she had been descending when she slipped. Mr Weatherhogg dialled 999 and tried to reach Dr Crook but also slipped and injured his arm, causing significant pain. Ogwen Valley mountain rescue team said they were descending a scrambling route and rock was greasy. Mr Gittins said: 'I have absolutely no doubt that death would have been instantaneous and Charlie wouldn't have suffered.' The tragedy was a 'conspiracy of all matters at that time, weather, route and loss of footing.' The coroner recorded a conclusion of accidental death. He remarked that Dr Crook was 'incredibly talented.' After the inquest, Clare Crook, her mother, said : 'We are so proud of her. She wanted to be the best she could be, to make a difference and not be forgotten.' Dr Crook was a St John Ambulance volunteer, a member of the Order of St John and also West Midlands Central Accident Resuscitation Emergency (CARE) team, a charitable organisation which responds to serious medical incidents. A tribute from a friend at CARE declared : 'Charlie was an inspiration to all of us at CARE.' She will be remembered at St Paul's Cathedral at a commemoration service for the Order. A University of Birmingham simulation suite to practise medical skills is also due to be dedicated to her memory.
The Sun
an hour ago
- The Sun
BYOMA review: I tried BYOMA's budget-friendly barrier boosting range to fix my skin damage
WHEN you're after a glowing complexion, it's enticing to overuse exfoliants and harsh products to speed up results. Unfortunately, I've fallen victim to this temptation. BUY FROM BOOTS Overloading your skin with potent products can cause damage to your skin barrier, which will leave you with red, irritated skin instead of the perfect summer glow you were aiming for. Luckily, I came across BYOMA. The brand claims that it's 'dedicated to boosting your skin barrier by repairing, restoring and regenerating the skin's structure and barrier function." BYOMA's refreshingly simple product range seemed just what I needed to reduce my skin's sensitivity. Pros Affordable Recyclable packaging Refills available Gentle formulas Science-backed ingredients Suitable for sensitive skin Suitable for teenagers Cons Formulas could be more hydrating Pump mechanism takes too long to work Rating: 7/10 How I tested BYOMA skincare Not one to do things by halves, I decided to ditch my current skincare routine for a week and switch to a simple, four-step routine from BYOMA. The brand recommends starting with a gentle cleanser, followed by a toner or face mist, and finishing off with a serum and a moisturiser. The products included in my streamlined routine (in the order I used them) are the Creamy Jelly Cleanser, Balancing Face Mist, Hydrating Serum, and Moisturising Rich Cream. BYOMA review: Quickfire Q&A What products are available from BYOMA? BYOMA divides its products into skincare and body categories. Think cleansers, toners, moisturisers and SPF for a complete routine. It also has handy kits and bundles that are great for travelling. How much does BYOMA cost? Prices start from £9.99 for its Creamy Jelly Cleanser. What we loved? The majority of the products are affordable. You can recycle most of the packaging, and some products have refills. The formulas avoid unnecessary additives and fragrances, making them great for sensitive or teenage skin, and they are designed to support the skin barrier. What we didn't: The opaque packaging makes it hard to see how much product is left. If you have specific skin concerns like acne or melasma, you may find the products too gentle. BYOMA review: The Nitty Gritty First impressions The neon colours and modern design of these bottles make them look very cool on my vanity. The functionality of the Balancing Face Mist and Moisturising Rich Cream packaging could be improved upon. That being said, all of the products go for under £14, so, in a way, you get what you pay for with the packaging (which is better than losing out on the quality of the formulas). Does it deliver? BYOMA Creamy Jelly Cleanser, £9.99 BUY FROM BOOTS As someone who can be a little heavy-handed with make-up and diligently applies SPF (the best anti-ageing tip you could ask for), my cleanser has a lot to remove at the end of the day. I'm very picky with my cleansers, and can't stand it when they leave a residue on my skin. I don't use a cleanser in the morning, so my first time using the Creamy Jelly Cleanser was after a long day at work. The texture of the cleanser is a thick, gel-like consistency, which isn't something I'm used to. As someone with dry skin, I usually opt for cream cleansers, so this was different, and I wasn't sure how well it would work with my skin type. Once I wet my face with warm water and started working the cleanser into my skin, it changed into a light, creamy lather that did a decent job of removing makeup. I went in for a second round because there were still remnants of eye makeup leftover, and this time my skin felt completely clean. One thing that stood out to me when cleansing my face is that this product has a light, slightly chemical scent. This is actually a good thing, however, as it means it hasn't been laced with irritating fragrances that will exacerbate my skin barrier problems. As I have dry skin, some cleansers can leave my skin feeling uncomfortably tight afterwards. As my skin was already feeling like this, I was worried switching up products might make things worse. However, I'm happy to say that's not the case as the cleanser is free from soap, alcohol, and fragrance. The rich hydrating ceramides, liquorice root and green tea extracts cleaned my skin without causing dehydration. BYOMA Balancing Face Mist, £11.99 BUY FROM BOOTS After my face was properly cleansed, the next step in my new routine was the Balancing Face Mist. It took a while for me to get the spray function of this product to start working, and a fair bit of cajoling to get the product to spritz. However, once it started working, I was pleasantly surprised by the refreshing feeling the mist gave my skin. I find most spritzes to be over-fragranced, so the fragrance-free formula was a welcome change of pace. The mist is quite heavy, so it probably wouldn't work well over heavy makeup, but it worked great as a midday refresher on makeup-free days. I used the mist both before I applied serum and moisturiser to ensure my dry skin was getting as much hydration as possible. BYOMA Hydrating Serum, £12.99 BUY FROM BOOTS Squalene isn't a product I've used before, but I've had plenty of friends wax lyrical about its glow-enhancing benefits, which is something this BYOMA serum provides in spades. The serum has a light, milky consistency that feels soothing and silky and leaves my skin with a distinct radiance that lasts throughout the day. I have very dry skin and lean on thick moisturisers to help my skin stay hydrated, but there was one day I forgot to apply moisturiser and could barely tell the difference at the end of the day. The only qualm I have about this product is that, while it is very affordable, if you were to apply the recommended four to six drops daily, I don't think the serum would last very long. BYOMA Moisturising Rich Cream, £14.99 BUY FROM BOOTS The fourth and final step in my barrier boosting regimen was the Moisturising Rich Cream. I had similar issues to the mist with this product and had to spend a bit of time fiddling with the pump to get it to work. My complaints ended there, as I thoroughly enjoyed this moisturiser and can see it becoming a staple in my routine. Perfect for warm weather, this cream is light-yet-hydrating, working with the serum to give me a long-lasting glow. I like to wear medium-coverage foundation to work, and this cream sits wonderfully under makeup, not pilling and also warding off dry patches throughout the day. On evenings when my skin felt particularly dry, I did crave the feeling of a thicker cream, but that might be habit on my end, as my skin felt adequately hydrated throughout the week. After a week of sticking with this gentle, pared-back routine, I can definitely see and feel a difference in my skin. After the test, my skin now feels a lot calmer, and the texture has softened. The few red bumps have cleared up, and my complexion definitely has more of a glow than it did before. While the range was great for the morning, there were a couple of times at night when I was craving products with a thicker consistency that were more hydrating. But my skin is extraordinarily dry, so others might not feel the same. How to tell if you have skin barrier damage? Repairing your skin barrier is about more than the products you use, so we asked Dr Ross Perry, Medical Director of Cosmedics skin clinics, to give us his expertise on how to treat a damaged skin barrier, as well as how you can avoid it happening again. While a damaged skin barrier can look different for different people, Dr Perry says the 'signs of a damaged skin barrier can include sensitivity, breakouts, dryness, redness, lacklustre and dull-looking skin. "When the skin barrier is damaged, it struggles to keep germs, bacteria and irritants away from the skin, leading to a lack of moisture and skin problems'. How do I repair a damaged skin barrier? When you've damaged your skin barrier, it's easy to freak out and worry that the damage will last forever, but Dr Perry says, 'The good news is that you can repair the skin barrier'. But how do you go about doing so? Dr Perry advises, 'First of all, look at your lifestyle, are you eating a balanced diet, using SPF and drinking plenty of water? "Look at your alcohol intake and keep it to a minimum, and make sure you're getting enough sleep at night and exercising regularly, as all of these will affect the skin's barrier." "If you're suffering from dry, itchy skin, it might be time to change your moisturiser to a slightly thicker one'. On top of lifestyle changes, Dr Perry says genetics play a part too, but there's little you can do on that front. In terms of products to incorporate into your skincare regime, Dr Perry advises, 'Look for products containing ceramides, free fatty acids, natural moisturising factors and niacinamide. "Also, water-retaining ingredients such as hyaluronic acid, glycerin and panthenol will support your skin's ability to retain moisture'. How long does it take to repair a damaged skin barrier? Dr Perry advises that while recovery will vary for everyone, hopefully it shouldn't take too long. 'Everyone's skin is different, and it's all dependent on how much damage we're looking at. "A severe acne flare-up isn't going to go away overnight and needs time to heal. "Rashes, dry patches, and dull-looking skin will recover much quicker, after two to three weeks'. To help your skin as much as possible, Dr Perry says 'go back to basics with skincare, which includes a gentle face cleanser, an antioxidant-rich serum, followed by a barrier-rich moisturiser and broad spectrum SPF'. Can a damaged skin barrier cause acne? Barrier damage isn't the first thing people think of when treating acne, but Dr Perry says it can be a contributor. 'Once the skin barrier is damaged, it makes the skin more susceptible to allowing more germs and dirt to penetrate'. What kind of products should I be avoiding if I have a damaged skin barrier? Many of the most popular skincare products on the market can wreak havoc on your skin barrier if used incorrectly. Dr Perry says, 'Cleansers containing ingredients such as sodium lauryl sulfate or any kind of detergent or soap can damage the skin's barrier by stripping the skin of its natural oils." The other kinds of products you should avoid are 'strong retinols and chemical exfoliators, which can cause the skin to be more sensitive and dry." "You need to be focusing on mild, gentle, fragrance-free products'. 'You will notice when your skin has healed. Acne will clear up, inflammation reduced, moisture restored and sensitivity will be minimal. "Skin will regain its glow and look fresher in appearance'.
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
Warning issued to parents over giving young children slushie drinks
Parents have been warned to avoid giving children under the age of seven slushie drinks which contain glycerol. While the iced drinks may be popular as temperatures increase, the Food Standards Agency (FSA) said they may have adverse effects on young children in its latest warning for parents, carers and business vendors. Consumed at high levels, glycerol can cause very low blood sugar levels and unconsciousness. The FSA endorsed new advice on Wednesday urging parents to manage glycerol intake in young children over the longer term. FSA chair Professor Susan Jebb warned that in warm weather, children may be more likely to consume the slushie drinks containing glycerol and warned parents and carers to remain aware of the risk. She said: 'As a precaution, the FSA is recommending that children under seven do not consume slush ice drinks containing glycerol. With our counterparts in Scotland, we will be talking to parent groups and charities to provide updated guidance that is useful and applicable across the UK. 'We expect industry to share data on the quantity of glycerol in their products to inform our future work. Meanwhile, there are immediate actions they can take that can help protect children and reduce the risk from these products. For example, retailers should limit cup sizes and should not offer free refill promotions to children under 10.' The drinks can contain glycerol as a sugar substitute to prevent them from freezing solid. Businesses are advised to only add glycerol at the minimum quantity technically necessary to achieve the slush effect. Glycerol is found in higher qualities in these beverages than in other foods. The FSA's latest risk assessment incorporated information from recent glycerol intoxication incidents, assessing the impact of one serving of a slush ice drink (350ml with 50,000 mg/l glycerol) on children with a lower-than-average bodyweight for their age. It said the up-to-date assessment takes a more precautionary approach than the initial one, conducted in 2023, which was based on average bodyweight. As children's weights vary, bodyweight has been converted alongside age to provide more practical advice to parents and children. The watchdog's updated advice applies to ready-to-drink slush drinks with glycerol in pouches, as well as home kits containing glycerol slush concentrates. Information should be available on the label, it said.
