
Why The Brutalist should win the best picture Oscar
OK, let's get this out of the way: yes, The Brutalist is long. Very long. Backside-numbingly long. Which is as you might expect of a decades-spanning tale of a Holocaust survivor architect's bruising encounter with the American dream. Still, that three-and-a-half hour run time seems to have been presented as Exhibit A in the case against Brady Corbet's film; that it's too grand, too ambitious, too full of itself. It's got a bloody interval, for Christ's sake! Who does this Corbet fella think he is?
Which seems strange, because a lot of what the film has been criticised for is usually seen as an asset. For good or ill, American cinema's high-water marks, from Citizen Kane to The Godfather and beyond, tend to be big, muscular movies that believe they have something profound to say about the country of their making. And The Brutalist certainly has things to say, however you feel about how it goes about saying them: about art and patronage, the US's relationship with Europe, and the relentless churn of capitalism. With so many weighty ideas to pack in, that run time starts to look, if anything, a little stingy.
That such a swing for the fences film could be made at all is all the more impressive. We're in an era of retreat for indie cinema, when many films fail to ever find their way on to the big screen, instead heading straight to streaming and getting lost in the wash of 'content', at a time when horizons have shrunk, along with budgets. The Brutalist's own budget is small too by modern standards, at less than $10m. But within those strictures, Corbet and his team have managed to construct an uncompromising American epic – and somehow turned a profit. It took a fair bit of sacrifice – Corbet and his partner, the film's screenwriter Mona Fastvold, have had to cut their cloth accordingly ('swapping champagne for sparkling wine,' is how he puts it), and the director claims not to have made a penny from his latest film. But that is the cost of making something entirely on your own terms, of sheer creative bloody-mindedness.
It's a characteristic that, as plenty have spotted, is shared by the character at the centre of the film, the fictional Hungarian architect László Tóth, played brilliantly by Adrien Brody. Bauhaus trained, Tóth has built a name for himself in Europe with his austere, clean-lined constructions, but his livelihood – and far more besides – has been disturbed by Hitler's rise. Separated from his wife and niece, he has survived the Holocaust, but arrives in the US without reputation or money, though still feeling the same sting of antisemitism he experienced in Europe. Tóth soon falls into the orbit of Guy Pearce's stiff-jawed industrialist Harrison Lee Van Buren, whose crass son Harry (Joe Alwyn) has recruited him to renovate his father's library as a surprise while he is away on business. At first Van Buren hates Tóth's dramatic update, with its focus on light and space, but attention from the architectural community eventually convinces him of its brilliance. This cycle of adulation and rejection between patron and client will recur throughout the film, sometimes violently.
Soon Van Buren has commissioned Tóth for a grander project: a vast community centre in honour of his late mother. Its construction will span decades, hampered by the changing financial fortunes of its patron as well as Tóth's own flinty perfectionism (only the finest Tuscan marble will do, after all). Complicating things further is the arrival in the film's second half of his wife, Erzsébet (Felicity Jones), fiercely protective of her husband, and clear-eyed about the person he has gotten into bed with.
It's that back half – and one particularly shocking scene that completely unravels the relationship between Tóth and Van Buren– that has most divided critics. Certainly, The Brutalist's big animating moment isn't subtle – but then subtle gestures wouldn't really suit the film. Everything about it, like the movement it takes its name from, is designed to be imposing, from Lol Crawley's stark, wide-angled cinematography to Daniel Blumberg's relentless, abrasive score. But this is also a film intent on holding your attention once it grabs it, directly plotted and propulsively paced. Assisted by the film's much maligned but ultimately palate-cleansing interval, that three-and a half-hours-plus run time sails by.
It helps that the performances are as good as they are. This is an impressive return to leading man prominence for Brody, whose career seemed to have been reduced to that of starry bit-parter – popping up entertainingly in Succession or Wes Anderson's films, but rarely provided with anything to really chew on. That is certainly not the case here: Tóth is both a figure of immense sympathy, but also at times really dislikable – stubborn, resentful, bad-tempered – and Brody is able to bring out his sharp edges. Just as impressive, is Pearce's performance as Van Buren, a character who could so easily slip into booming-voiced, blue-blooded caricature. But his Van Buren also nurses one hell of an inferiority complex, towards the European aesthete who has drifted into his life, one that he tries to overpower with money and American force of character.
That tension, feels timely as both the US and Europe re-evaluate their relationship with each another. It's one of the many reasons why, despite its period setting, The Brutalist feels of the moment. This a film that seeks to awe you into submission with its giant images and ideas. When it comes to this year's best picture, the Academy should think big.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


South Wales Guardian
7 minutes ago
- South Wales Guardian
Brian Wilson: Beach Boys star who surfed the waves to success
Born in California in 1942, he showed early musical talent, teaching harmonies to his younger brothers Dennis and Carl and obsessively studying piano. In 1961, Wilson, his brothers, cousin Mike Love and friend Al Jardine recorded Surfin', a local hit that marked the birth of The Beach Boys. Signed to Capitol Records a year later, the band shaped 1960s American pop with hits such as Surfin' USA, I Get Around and California Girls. The 1966 album Pet Sounds, which included the track God Only Knows, remains a landmark in modern music, influencing generations of artists including Sir Paul McCartney, who called it his favourite record. Sir Elton John, Bruce Springsteen, Smokey Robinson and Carole King were also fans, while The Who's drummer, Keith Moon, fantasised about joining the Beach Boys. The band ranks among the most popular groups of the rock era, with more than 30 singles in the Top 40 and worldwide sales of more than 100 million and they were voted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame in 1988. Originally unfinished in the 1960s, he finally completed and released Smile in 2004 to critical acclaim. Wilson struggled with mental illness and drug addiction, but in later years he toured globally.

Western Telegraph
23 minutes ago
- Western Telegraph
Brian Wilson: Beach Boys star who surfed the waves to success
Born in California in 1942, he showed early musical talent, teaching harmonies to his younger brothers Dennis and Carl and obsessively studying piano. In 1961, Wilson, his brothers, cousin Mike Love and friend Al Jardine recorded Surfin', a local hit that marked the birth of The Beach Boys. Signed to Capitol Records a year later, the band shaped 1960s American pop with hits such as Surfin' USA, I Get Around and California Girls. Brian Wilson was a member of The Beach Boys (Ian West/PA) The 1966 album Pet Sounds, which included the track God Only Knows, remains a landmark in modern music, influencing generations of artists including Sir Paul McCartney, who called it his favourite record. Sir Elton John, Bruce Springsteen, Smokey Robinson and Carole King were also fans, while The Who's drummer, Keith Moon, fantasised about joining the Beach Boys. The band ranks among the most popular groups of the rock era, with more than 30 singles in the Top 40 and worldwide sales of more than 100 million and they were voted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame in 1988. Originally unfinished in the 1960s, he finally completed and released Smile in 2004 to critical acclaim. Wilson struggled with mental illness and drug addiction, but in later years he toured globally.


Scottish Sun
26 minutes ago
- Scottish Sun
Jake Paul leaks ‘s***-talking' private messages with Anthony Joshua goading him about being KO'd as trash talk ramps up
Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) JAKE PAUL revealed he is goading Anthony Joshua about being knocked out - as their "s*** talking" ramps up behind the scenes. Paul audaciously called out the two-time heavyweight champion on his podcast earlier this year - vowing to knock Joshua out. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 6 Jake Paul and Anthony Joshua having been goading each other via DMs 6 AJ also shared his phone call with Jake Paul earlier in the year 6 Jake Paul insists they're still friends despite the trash-talk 6 Daniel Dubois KO'd Joshua in September Credit: Getty It did not take long for AJ to quite literally call the prankster-turned-prizefighter's bluff by phoning him up - but Paul countered by suggesting a 2026 fight date. And Paul has now revealed the two are already goading each other privately over social media - as all's fair in love and war. He said: "It was all nice, we've been cordial. He DMd me today like saying "LOL" to one of my training clips and then I sent him a "LOL" of of him getting knocked out. "And so I guess like we're kind of s*** talking, behind the scenes a bit. But I have a lot of love for Anthony Joshua. READ MORE IN BOXING PAUL ON OFFER Jake Paul urges UFC to make 'winner-takes-all' Jones vs Ngannou fight "I think this type of stuff is funny and he's a great guy and I think just a fight between us would be awesome and I do believe I can win." Joshua, 35, is yet to fight since being KO'd by Daniel Dubois, 27, at Wembley in September having undergone elbow surgery in May. Promoter Eddie Hearn revealed AJ hopes to return before the year is over - meanwhile Paul faces ex-middleweight world champ Julio Cesar Chavez Jr on June 28. It comes after he stepped up to heavyweight in November to face Mike Tyson - who controversially made a comeback aged 58. 6 CASINO SPECIAL - BEST CASINO BONUSES FROM £10 DEPOSITS Still over 100 MILLION tuned in to watch Paul's eight-round points win on Netflix - but it came at the cost of piling on TWO STONE. And Paul - who gorged on pasta, steaks and potatoes to bulk up - admitted the heavyweight jump was "brutal". Jake Paul reveals 'hefty' six-man hit-list of opponents for next fight including Anthony Joshua and world champ The 28-year-old added: "It was just too much and my body wasn't made for it and even when I got into the ring I just felt too fat. "So cruiserweight is definitely the perfect weight for me." Paul will come down from 16st 2lb to the 200lb cruiserweight limit of 14st 4lb to face Chavez in California. It followed after Canelo Alvarez, 34, pulled out of a shock deal to fight Paul in Las Vegas on May 3 - instead signing with Saudi Arabia's Turki Alalshikh. Canelo - who beat Chavez on points in 2017 - regained his undisputed super-middleweight titles with victory over William Scull in May. And now he defends the 168lb thrown in a September 13 super-fight against unbeaten American Terence Crawford, 37, as Paul was forced to look elsewhere. But he said: "Chavez and I have been going back and forth for a long time and he's always been a great opponent on the list of someone that I wanted to fight. "And now it made perfect sense to go up against him as a former world champion and just continuing to further my resume and get more time under the lights." Paul also revealed he is in talks to fight current cruiserweight champions Gilberto "Zurdo" Ramirez, 33, and Badou Jack, 41. And with Gervonta Davis, 30, also lined up for an exhibition bout - Paul says he is boxing's most desired man. He joked: I'm like like Megan Fox from Transformers movie like everyone wants me! So there's not enough time to do it all and it could make sense. Look, it might. "It might line up but at the end of the day, there's 100 people that want to fight me. I got Canelo, Gervonta, Anthony Joshua, Badou, Zurdo, Tommy Fury, KSI, the list keeps on going. "It's just about what makes sense and we'll see when the negotiations come but I would for sure entertain a fight with him." 6 Jake Paul faces Julio Cesar Chavez Jr next Credit: Reuters