logo
Blues' top offseason priority? Center options? Match a Joel Hofer offer sheet? Mailbag, part 1

Blues' top offseason priority? Center options? Match a Joel Hofer offer sheet? Mailbag, part 1

New York Times21-05-2025

ST. LOUIS — Considering how aggressive the St. Louis Blues were in making moves in 2024-25, you can picture general manager Doug Armstrong champing at the bit to get his follow-up offseason officially underway.
Not that Armstrong would've sat on his hands if the Blues had missed the playoffs, but as he noted at his end-of-season news conference, the team's performance down the stretch has raised expectations and, he said, 'Now it's how quickly do we move up and continue to expand?'
Advertisement
That certainly gives this offseason more intrigue.
There's always something unexpected when Armstrong is working behind the scenes, and we'll find out what that could be in the coming months.
Of course, fans already have their own ideas for how it should go. In The Athletic's latest call for Blues mailbag questions, subscribers seemed to have bigger ambitions for the possibilities than if St. Louis had missed the postseason for the third straight year.
Let's see just how ambitious — and how realistic — the landscape is, in Part 1.
(Note: Some questions have been lightly edited for length and clarity.)
What do you think Armstrong's two biggest offseason moves will be? And if they happen, do you think they'll make the Blues a legitimate Stanley Cup contender? — Michael B.
For me, the two areas that need to be addressed are center and right-side defense.
Let's start with center, where most of the talk is about the Blues needing a No. 2. I can understand that. It was a pretty good season for Brayden Schenn, who had a lot of chemistry with Dylan Holloway and Jordan Kyrou, but he'll turn 34 in August, and there's no guarantee he won't regress.
But to me, this is more about the overall situation at center. The Blues got 50 points from Schenn and 20 from Oskar Sundqvist, so a combined 70 points from their Nos. 2 and 3 centers. For comparison, the Dallas Stars got 153 points from Matt Duchene (82) and Wyatt Johnston (71). Granted, the Stars are the favorite to win the Stanley Cup this season, but that's a big discrepancy.
So yes, the Blues could serve themselves well by picking up a No. 2 center with more scoring potential. If they did, Schenn could be No. 3, the depth up the middle would be vastly improved, and prospect Dalibor Dvorsky would have more time to develop.
This is where the heightened expectations can change things because, in a perfect world, Schenn could hold down the fort until Dvorsky can be No. 2, assuming he's capable. But with the Blues believing they can be more competitive sooner, they might feel the need to upgrade now and not wait for Dvorsky to be that guy. Either way, they need to find some help at the position this offseason.
Advertisement
Now let's look at the right-side defense.
Can the Blues find a taker for Justin Faulk and a replacement? Faulk is 33 and has two more seasons left on his contract, which has a $6.5 million average annual value. He has a full no-trade clause, but that changes to a modified NTC on July 1, when he'll have a 15-team NTC. The trade protection won't matter, though, if there aren't any takers for a defenseman whose offense has nosedived over the past two seasons.
If there's no trade partner, the Blues might have to keep rolling with Faulk, barring a buyout, which doesn't seem likely.
As for the last part of your question — could they be a Stanley Cup contender if they make these moves? — it depends on who they get. If it's the Florida Panthers' Sam Bennett and Aaron Ekblad, then yeah. But we'll have to see what Armstrong comes up with to know how high it raises the ceiling.
So what's the bigger priority: second-line center for Holloway and Kyrou or a top-four defenseman for Philip Broberg? — Patrick H.
I'd say center depth. That move would have a more dramatic impact on the team's success.
Armstrong mentioned his desire for a 200-foot forward. Any thoughts on who that might be and how that fits into our salary cap? — Chuck B.
Let's operate under two assumptions:
1. The Toronto Maple Leafs' Mitch Marner would be too rich for the Blues' blood at a projected $13 million to $14 million AAV.
2. Center, not wing, is the focus.
If those are the assumptions, then Bennett, a pending UFA, would be attractive. He doesn't bring more offense than Schenn, and his defensive numbers aren't overly impressive, but he plays a hard style and contributes at both ends.
He'll be 29 in June, and the projection for his next contract (if with another team) is seven years at a $7.55 million AAV, according to Evolving-Hockey. That might be too much term for the Blues, but they'd be getting a player who has won recently with the Panthers and would make them more competitive now.
Advertisement
Who could the Blues target as a second-line center, aside from Bennett? — Shawn F.
The Leafs' John Tavares turns 35 in September, so he doesn't fit the Blues' preferred age bracket, but he did have 38 goals and 74 points this season, and going back to what I noted earlier, you're adding depth and giving Dvorsky time to develop.
That said, The Athletic's Pierre LeBrun was at the Maple Leafs' end-of-season news availabilities Tuesday and reported that Tavares, a pending UFA, is 'optimistic' about returning to Toronto. His projected next contract (if with another team) would be a four-year deal with a $7.89 million AAV.
John Tavares says he spoke with Leafs GM Brad Treliving today and he's optimistic that maybe he will be back perhaps. But obviously none of that is for sure at this point.
— Pierre LeBrun (@PierreVLeBrun) May 20, 2025
What about the Colorado Avalanche's Brock Nelson? — Gerald J.
Nelson wouldn't be the worst option. He'll turn 34 in October, so again, he's a bit older. The issue with Nelson is his consistency. The Avs gave up Calum Ritchie, one of their top prospects, to get Nelson in a trade from the New York Islanders, and he had no goals and four assists in their first-round playoff loss to the Stars.
Are any centers available via trade? — Matt S.
This is always a hard type of question to answer because you don't know who's available, but names such as Ryan O'Reilly (Nashville Predators), Shane Pinto (Ottawa Senators), Marco Rossi (Minnesota Wild) and Elias Pettersson (Vancouver Canucks) have been mentioned. With one or two of those players, I doubt their current club would actually trade them, and with others — Pettersson, cough, cough — run!
Any chance the Blues bring in Brad Marchand in the offseason? — Evan R.
I'll leave this one for subscribers in the comment section.
What trade package would you accept for Kyrou? — Jackierosemunro
If I'm trading Kyrou, I want proven offense in return. In the past three seasons, he's tied for 21st in the NHL in goals (104) and tied for 47th in points (210).
Martin Necas is the type of player the Blues would have taken in return for Kyrou before Necas was traded from the Carolina Hurricanes to Colorado in the Mikko Rantanen deal. Necas hasn't come close to matching Kyrou's goal totals, so they would probably want more than someone like him, and I wouldn't blame them.
Say what you want about Kyrou, but if I'm the Blues, I want an equally productive offensive player or someone close and a draft pick(s).
Unpopular opinion: The Blues should be looking to trade Dvorsky, not Kyrou. A trade for a second-line center fits their window better, and it would unlock Kyrou and Holloway. Agree? — Jack M.
Just because you don't trade Kyrou doesn't mean you have to trade Dvorsky. Just like when the Blues drafted Robert Thomas in 2017, they brought in Ryan O'Reilly in 2018 and allowed Thomas to put in the work before he got his time to shine at center.
The Blues have a lot of valuable pieces at forward with Dvorsky, Jake Neighbours, Zack Bolduc, Jimmy Snuggerud, Otto Stenberg, Juraj Pekarcik, Adam Jecho, Aleksanteri Kaskimaki, Jakub Stancl, Ondrej Kos and others. Do you envision Armstrong dealing a few of those pieces for an impact player? — Alexander M.
Perhaps, but outside of Neighbours and Bolduc, I don't know who in that group would yield an impact player at this point. With Snuggerud and Dvorsky still unproven, how good is the player coming back?
Advertisement
Yes, you have to consider moving one or more of them because they can't all play in St. Louis, and at some point, the shine may wear off. But unless a trade for Neighbours or Bolduc is a no-brainer, I'm holding on to this group of players for now because their potential, with the prospects specifically, is worth more to the Blues than what they can get in a deal.
Would you entertain trading for the New Jersey Devils' Simon Nemec or the Los Angeles Kings' Brandt Clarke, even if you had to trade Neighbours or Bolduc? — Todd H.
So now you have to put me on the spot! I really like Neighbours and think he could be a captain one day. I envision him being part of the Blues' success in the future. I really like Bolduc, too. I think he has arguably the best shot on the team (haven't watched enough of Snuggerud yet to see if his will be even better), and likewise, he can be a big part.
But if you can get one of these two young right-shot defensemen — Nemec, 21, the No. 2 pick in 2022, and Clarke, 22, the No. 8 pick in 2021 — you have to do it. I don't know if New Jersey or L.A. would make these deals, but if they would, it would be hard for the Blues to pass up on one of those two defensemen.
Could you provide a prospect depth chart for the Blues defense? Who's next in line for a call-up, and did anyone rise or fall last season? — Tom K.
Blues returners: Broberg, Faulk, Colton Parayko, Cam Fowler, Nick Leddy, Tyler Tucker and Matthew Kessel.
AHL Springfield: Corey Schueneman, Leo Lööf, Michael Buchinger, Lukas Fischer and Marc-Andre Gaudet.
In the system: Adam Jiricek, Theo Lindstein, Colin Ralph, Quinton Burns, Arseni Koromyslov, Matthew Mayich and William McIsaac.
As far as call-ups, Schueneman would likely be No. 1. Regarding any rising stock, probably Fischer, who had a great season with OHL Sarnia. And any fallen stock, Jiricek, just because of the number of games he missed with OHL Brantford due to injury.
Advertisement
Should the team explore trading the rights to Torey Krug to a team that needs to reach the lower threshold of the salary cap? — Ron H.
It's a fair question because if a team is willing to pay Krug's salary, why wouldn't you do it? However, if he's unable to play again, he'll remain on long-term injured reserve (LTIR) and his $6.5 million AAV won't count against the salary cap. Additionally, insurance will help offset his actual cash salary in '25-26 ($6 million), so the situation is not much skin off the Blues' back.
What's your limit on Joel Hofer if someone offer-sheets him? Around $2.2 million? — G.R.
If Hofer is unsigned by July 1 and becomes an RFA, an offer sheet is a possibility, but let's keep the compensation figures in mind when deciding whether to match. Let's use your number of $2.2 million. According to this year's recently released compensation, if Hofer were signed to that salary by another team, the Blues would receive a third-round draft pick. If it's $2.34 million or higher, it's a second-rounder.
I don't believe a second-rounder is worth losing a potential future starter in Hofer, 24, who in 63 starts has a record of 35-22-5 and a .908 save percentage. His progression chart lines up with the final two years of Jordan Binnington's contract, so I'd hang on to Hofer up to any reasonable amount, and I don't think that'll be an issue because, although he has played well, it's not enough of a resume to break the bank.
(Top photo of Torey Krug, Justin Faulk, Sam Bennett and Joel Hofer: Jasen Vinlove / Imagn Images)

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Bills RB James Cook present for team's mandatory practice amid contract concerns, AP source says
Bills RB James Cook present for team's mandatory practice amid contract concerns, AP source says

Associated Press

time20 minutes ago

  • Associated Press

Bills RB James Cook present for team's mandatory practice amid contract concerns, AP source says

ORCHARD PARK, N.Y. (AP) — Buffalo Bills running back James Cook put aside his contract concerns — and avoided the potential of being fined — by attending the start of the team's three-day mandatory series of practices on Tuesday, a person with knowledge of the situation told The Associated Press. The person spoke on condition of anonymity because coach Sean McDermott isn't scheduled to address the media until later in the day. The Athletic first reported Cook was present at the team's facility. Cook's attendance comes after he went public with his desire to negotiate a contract extension while entering the fourth and final year of his rookie deal. He was the NFL's co-leader in rushing touchdowns with 16 last year, and skipped Buffalo's six previous spring practices and month-long workout sessions, all of which were voluntary. Cook was selected by Buffalo in the second round of the 2022 draft out of Georgia. His older brother is Dalvin Cook, best known for his six seasons in Minnesota and who spent last year appearing in two games with Dallas. In February, Cook informally began his public negotiation by posting the message '15 mill year' on his Instagram account. A month later, during an appearance on a podcast with former NFLers Shannon Sharpe and Chad Johnson, Cook said, 'Pay me the big bucks,' and adding, 'I want to get what I asked for.' He also made the case for his fellow NFL running backs being underpaid in saying: 'I feel like we deserve to get paid,' and asking, 'How (are) we not valuable?' In April, Cook listed his Buffalo-area home as being for sale. General manager Brandon Beane has on several occasions noted how much he respects and values Cook, while also acknowledging the two sides aren't on the same page in contract talks. In late March, Beane specifically referenced Cook in announcing he was cutting off contract discussions to focus on the draft. 'Just because we don't have James signed today doesn't mean next year we still can't get him done before he gets to free agency,' Beane said. 'We want him to have success. We're rooting for him ... But we are where we are, and there's no hard feelings from us.' Cook proved to be the odd-man out in Beane's offseason binge of signing core players to multiyear contract extensions. The group was made up of quarterback Josh Allen, receiver Khalil Shakir, edge rusher Greg Rousseau, linebacker Terrel Bernard and cornerback Christian Benford. Cook's 16 touchdowns rushing matched a Bills single-season record set by O.J. Simpson, and he also scored two more receiving. He was part of a Bills offense that finished second in the NFL in averaging more than 30 points per outing. After scoring just two touchdowns rushing in each of his first two seasons, Cook's jump in production coincided with Joe Brady's first full season as Buffalo's offensive coordinator, and the team's initiative to have Allen rush less to reduce exposing him to injury. ___ AP NFL:

Sauce Gardner present at Jets minicamp while waiting on new contract: Sources
Sauce Gardner present at Jets minicamp while waiting on new contract: Sources

New York Times

time31 minutes ago

  • New York Times

Sauce Gardner present at Jets minicamp while waiting on new contract: Sources

Sauce Gardner is present at the start of the New York Jets' mandatory OTAs, according to league sources. While stars like T.J. Watt (Pittsburgh), Trey Hendrickson (Cincinnati) and Terry McLaurin (Washington) are expected to be absent for the start of minicamps, Gardner and Garrett Wilson, both still on their rookie contracts though now eligible for extensions, continue to show up as the Jets enjoy what has so far been a drama-free spring. Advertisement Both Gardner and Wilson have stated publicly that they want to be Jets 'for life' — while both are also seeking contracts that would make them among the highest-paid at their positions. As for Gardner, specifically: He wants to be the highest-paid cornerback in the NFL, which would place him around $30 million per season. He certainly has a case to get it considering he was an All-Pro in each of his first two seasons. He was solid in 2024 too, even if it could be argued it was a down season by his standards. Gardner, who turns 25 in August, is a crucial piece of the Jets' new-look defense with head coach Aaron Glenn and defensive coordinator Steve Wilks, one that should deploy more man coverage than it did under Robert Saleh. It should also feature Gardner lining up across the other team's best wide receiver most of the time. As for Wilson: He's less likely to pursue a contract as the highest-paid receiver. That would reach Ja'Marr Chase and Justin Jefferson territory, and he's not quite in their class yet. However, he's produced at a remarkable level through three seasons despite turmoil at quarterback and offensive coordinator. Wilson, who turns 25 in July, recorded three straight 1,000-yard seasons and is in line to get the ball a lot in 2025 while playing his college quarterback (Justin Fields) and in an offense without a clearly defined second option in the passing game. Wilson's frustration was a topic of conversation as the Jets bumbled their way to a five-win season last year. If the franchise continued to struggle, he might have looked to move from the organization. But Wilson has been a fan of the Jets' offseason moves — both in terms of coaching and quarterback — and a couple weeks ago stated his desire to be here long-term. It hasn't hurt that he's shown up for every offseason workout and OTA practice. Gardner missed at least one voluntary practice but has mostly been present this offseason too. Advertisement 'I want to be a part of something special,' Wilson said a couple weeks ago during OTAs. 'I don't think that a whole bunch of individuals makes something special. As a group aspect, this is a group thing and I wanted to get in and know my teammates. I want to get in to know my coaches, even. This is a new staff. Learn the material that they're putting out and not be the guy that's behind when this thing is mandatory (in minicamp in June), right? There's a way you go about business when you love what you do.'

One year from World Cup opener, FIFA leaves questions unanswered on tickets and security
One year from World Cup opener, FIFA leaves questions unanswered on tickets and security

Associated Press

time41 minutes ago

  • Associated Press

One year from World Cup opener, FIFA leaves questions unanswered on tickets and security

NEW YORK (AP) — A year from the largest World Cup ever, there has been no announcement on general ticket sales, prices for most seats, location of a draw or security arrangements as FIFA has mostly avoided disclosing details of an event set for 16 stadiums across the United States, Mexico and Canada. There is uncertainty about whether fans from some nations will be welcome — 11 of the venues are located in the U.S., where all matches will be played from the quarterfinals on. Security is a concern, too. At the last major soccer tournament in the U.S., the 2024 Copa America final at Miami Gardens, Florida, started 82 minutes late after spectators breached security gates. 'That was certainly a reminder and a wake-up call if anybody needed it that those types of things are going to be used in terms of the ultimate assessment of whether this World Cup is successful,' said former U.S. defender Alexi Lalas, now Fox's lead soccer analyst. U.S. President Donald Trump's travel ban on citizens from 12 nations exempted athletes, coaches, staff and relatives while not mentioning fans. Vice President JD Vance made what could be interpreted as a warning on May 6. 'Of course everybody is welcome to come and see this incredible event. I know we'll have visitors probably from close to 100 countries. We want them to come. We want them to celebrate. We want them to watch the game,' he said. 'But when the time is up they'll have to go home. Otherwise they'll have to talk to Secretary Noem,' he added, speaking alongside Secretary of Homeland Security Kristi Noem. Back in U.S. for first time in 32 years The 1994 World Cup sparked the launch of Major League Soccer with 12 teams in 1996, and $50 million in World Cup profits seeded the U.S. Soccer Foundation, tasked with developing the sport's growth. MLS now has 30 teams, plays in 22 soccer specific stadiums and has club academies to grow the sport and improve talent. Next year's tournament will include 104 games, up from 64 from 1998 through 2022, and the 11 U.S. stadiums are all NFL homes with lucrative luxury suites and club seating. It also will be the first World Cup run by FIFA without a local organizing committee. 'The legacy initiative of 2026 is around how we ensure that soccer is everywhere in this county,' U.S. Soccer Federation CEO JT Batson said. 'How do we ensure that every American can walk, ride their bike or take public transit to a safe place to play soccer? How do we make it to where every school in America has soccer accessible to their students? And how do we make it to wherever every American can truly see themselves in the game?' Interest in soccer has vastly increased in the U.S., with England's Premier League averaging 510,000 viewers per match window on NBC's networks last season and the European Champions League final drawing more than 2 million viewers in each of the past five years on CBS. However, CBS broadcast just 26 of 189 Champions League matches on TV in 2024-25 and streamed the rest. MLS drew about 12.2 million fans last year, second to 14.7 million in 2023-24 for the Premier League's 20 teams, but MLS has largely disappeared from broadcast TV since starting a 10-year contract with Apple TV+ in 2023. Apple spokesman Sam Citron said the company does not release viewer figures. In a fractured television landscape, different deals were negotiated by FIFA, UEFA, MLS, the NWSL, the USSF and the five major European leagues. 'You basically have over 2,800 game windows per season aired in the United States and so that requires distribution largely on streaming platforms like Paramount+ or ESPN+, but it's difficult for new fan adoption and it makes reach kind of challenging,' said Gerry Cardinale, managing partner of RedBird Capital Partners, which holds controlling interests in AC Milan and Toulouse and owns a non-controlling stake of Fenway Sports Group, parent of Liverpool. 'Kids today are getting weaned on Premier League football and Serie A football, and when you watch that as a product, it's hard for MLS to compete.' 1994 World Cup set attendance record The 1994 World Cup, a 24-nation tournament, drew a record 3.58 million fans for 52 matches. Ticket prices ranged from $25-$75 for most first round games and $180-$475 for the final at the Rose Bowl in Pasadena, California. FIFA, which has about 800 people working at an office in Coral Gables, Florida, says it will announce information on general tickets in the third quarter. It wouldn't say whether prices will be fixed or variable. Hospitality packages are available on FIFA's website through On Location. For the eight matches at MetLife Stadium in East Rutherford, New Jersey, including the final on July 19, prices range from $25,800 to $73,200 per person. Variable ticket pricing possible FIFA appears to be using variable pricing for this year's Club World Cup, played at 12 U.S. stadiums from June 14 to July 13, and some prices repeatedly have been slashed. Marriott Bonvoy, a U.S. Soccer Federation partner, has been offering free tickets to some of its elite members. Asked about Club World Cup ticket sales and team base camp arrangements, Manolo Zubiria, the World Cup's chief tournament officer, hung up four minutes and five questions into a telephone interview with The Associated Press. Brendan O'Connell, the publicist who arranged the interview, wrote in an email to the AP: 'The guest was not prepared for those questions.' FIFA's media relations staff would not make FIFA president Gianni Infantino available to discuss the tournament. Ahead of the 1994 World Cup, FIFA announced in May 1992 the draw would take place at Las Vegas on Dec. 18 or 19, 1993. FIFA has not revealed plans for this year's draw but appears to be planning for Las Vegas on Dec. 5. Regular ticket sales began in February 1993 for the U.S. soccer family and general first- and second-round sales started that June. Fans submitted lottery applications in October 1993 for games from the quarterfinals on. Teams could train away from World Cup cities While not detailing ticketing plans for next year's tournament, FIFA is spreading it beyond the host cites and lists about 60 possible base camps for teams to use, paired with hotels. Some are fancy — The Greenbrier Resort in White Sulphur Springs, West Virginia — and some more Spartan — the Courtyard by Marriott Mesa at Wrigleyville West in Arizona. Thousands of arrangements must be coordinated. Major League Baseball is drawing up its schedule to ensure that the four teams whose ballparks share parking lots with World Cup stadiums — in Arlington, Texas; Kansas City, Missouri; Philadelphia; and Seattle — won't play home games on the dates of tournament matches. Boris Gartner, CEO of La Liga North America, a joint venture of the Spanish soccer league and Relevent Sports, said the 2026 World Cup should be viewed as just another step in the sport's long-term growth in the United States. 'If you have a clear understanding of the market and the audience, a clear understanding of the value that these properties bring to media companies, and you mix content with a commercial strategy, with the right media distribution strategy, this is something that will continue to grow over the next two decades,' he said. 'If more people are watching the NWSL, more people are going to be interested in soccer that could potentially end up watching a Bundesliga game or La Liga game.' ___ AP soccer:

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store