Fate of Karen Read now in jury's hands as murder trial reaches critical phase
Deliberations are underway in the Karen Read murder trial.
After both sides gave their closing arguments Friday morning, Judge Beverly Cannone spent the early afternoon reading jury instructions before alternates were selected and the remaining jurors were sent to the deliberation room.
Cannone selected Juror No. 5 to be the foreperson. The court clerk randomly pulled Nos. 13, 7, 6, 17, 2, and 8 as alternates.
Read, 45, is accused of slamming her 2021 Lexus SUV into O'Keefe and leaving him to die on the ground in a blizzard on Jan. 29, 2022. Jurors heard more than 30 days of testimony in a trial that began on April 22.
Special prosecutor Hank Brennan wrapped up his closing argument in the murder trial of Karen Read Friday afternoon, telling jurors there is no doubt that she's the one who killed John O'Keefe, her 46-year-old boyfriend, a Boston cop and the adoptive father of his orphaned niece and nephew.
"She was drunk. She hit him. And she left him to die," Brennan said. "It's that simple."
Multiple witnesses testified that they heard her repeating the phrase, "I hit him. I hit him. I hit him," Brennan said. But it was the hard data – not accident reconstruction or witness accounts, that proves his case, he said.
O'Keefe's phone did not move from between the time Read allegedly slammed her 6,000-pound LX 570 in reverse until he was discovered dead on the lawn 5 and a half hours later.
Although Read didn't testify in her own defense, Brennan used her own words against her in the form of multiple televised interviews she sat for.
He alleged that they illustrate that she knowingly left O'Keefe to die after hitting him and where to find the body when she went looking the next morning.
In one, she described O'Keefe as a "weird-shaped lump" and a "buffalo on the prairie," jutting out of the snow.
"John O'Keefe is not a body. John O'Keefe is not a buffalo on a prairie," Brennan said. "He was a person, and he was murdered by Karen Read."
Read's lead defense lawyer Alan Jackson urged jurors to find her not guilty Friday in a closing argument that disputed the prosecution's entire timeline from the night O'Keefe died.
"There was no collision," Jackson told jurors. "There was no collision. There was no collision."
He argued that a sloppy investigation, a lack of physical evidence and witness testimony left a mountain of reasonable doubt in the case. He said the commonwealth's case is "cooked" after an expert analysis of O'Keefe's injuries and called the prosecution's crash reconstruction a "ridiculous blue paint kindergarten project."
The lead homicide detective got fired from the Massachusetts State Police and did not testify at trial.
GET REAL-TIME UPDATES DIRECTLY ON THE TRUE CRIME HUB
WATCH: Karen Read's father addresses media as she prepares for closing arguments
The case is expected to go to jurors later this afternoon after more than 30 days of testimony.
Although Judge Beverly Cannone asked for an earlier start than normal, court kicked off with a sidebar conference that lasted over a half-hour.
Read faces 15 years to life in prison if convicted on the top charge of second-degree murder. If convicted of drunken driving manslaughter, she would face 5 to 20.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBS News
42 minutes ago
- CBS News
Pittsburgh City Council member to introduce bill reducing prostitution to finable offense
Some Pittsburgh City Council members want to reduce the penalties for sex work from jail time to a fine. It's been called the world's oldest profession. And for time immemorial, police have treated it as a crime punishable by jail, a criminal record and stigma. But advocates for sex workers say prostitution is a consensual act that merits only a summons and a fine. "We don't believe that it's helpful to the community or the individual to criminalize sex work at the level of jail time or penalties," said Leigh Kelsey of Pittsburgh Action Against Rape. Proposed bill reduces prostitution to finable offense Under the ordinance to be introduced on Tuesday by Councilmember Barb Warwick, prostitution would remain a crime in Pittsburgh, but reduce it from a misdemeanor with potential jail time to a finable offense. The legislation says the law disproportionately penalizes women in troubled circumstances, and police should focus instead on the people who traffic them and the people who use their services. Former sex worker Theresa Nightengale, the head of the Pittsburgh Coalition for Safer Sex Work, says the workers need help, not jail, and reducing those penalties gives them a better chance at a fresh start. "This is for someone who is having a hard time in their life and doing this survival sex work or someone who is doing this to make money when they're younger or in different phases of their life," Nightengale said. "I just don't want to have them charged with a serious crime, a penalty that makes it so that they potentially can't leave the industry." The bill is co-sponsored by Councilmembers R. Daniel Lavelle, Erika Strassburger and Deb Gross. But other members, including Anthony Coghill, say they have not yet seen it and are concerned that reducing the penalties might encourage prostitution in the city, which police say is most prevalent at massage parlors, some hotels and a section of the North Side. But supporters of the legislation like Pittsburgh Action Against Rape says mostly women are driven to sex work by difficult life circumstances. Gainey voices support for bill In a statement to KDKA, Gainey said the proposal is "consistent with a public health-oriented approach to addressing low-level, non-violent offenses, providing law enforcement with a diversion-based option to use when conditions warrant it." "This will help to remove the fear of incarceration that often prevents sex workers from availing themselves of human services or police assistance when needed," he added. He said he asked the Pittsburgh Public Safety Department and Pittsburgh Bureau of Police to review the proposed ordinance "to ensure that it would align in practice with State law and the procedures for police accreditation." Proponents argue that sex work is dangerous work and reducing the penalties and stigma will make it easier for sex workers to go to the police when they are being trafficked or abused.
CBS News
an hour ago
- CBS News
1 shot, 1 stabbed along Fulton Avenue in Arden-Arcade
One person was shot and another was stabbed in the Arden-Arcade area Monday afternoon, the Sacramento County Sheriff's Office said. It happened along Fulton Avenue between Marconi and El Camino avenues. Around 4 p.m., the sheriff's office said officials were applying tourniquets while paramedics were responding to the scene. CBS Sacramento has a crew headed to the scene. This is a developing story. Check back here for updates.
Washington Post
an hour ago
- Washington Post
Army Ranger convicted of rape, multiple sex assault charges
An Army Ranger who was arrested after a two-year investigation sparked by a Facebook group of women who said he sexually assaulted them was convicted Monday of two rape charges and more than a dozen other assault counts by a military jury, and will face sentencing Tuesday by a judge who could impose up to life in prison without parole. Maj. Jonathan Batt, 40, listened to 15 women testify against him during his three-week trial at Fort Meade in Maryland, then took the witness stand and provided detailed explanations for why, in his view, all the sexual encounters were consensual. 'I am not a rapist,' Batt told the jury of three colonels and five lieutenant colonels, who heard closing arguments June 16, then deliberated for three days in the week since. The jury of six men and two women convicted Batt of 20 charges involving eight women, and acquitted him of 18 counts involving seven women. Each rape charge carries a maximum sentence of life without parole, and each sexual assault count has a 30-year maximum term. The jury foreman declined to comment after the verdict. Batt chose to have military Judge Adam S. Kazin sentence him rather than the jury. The judge will hear testimony Tuesday morning before imposing sentence. 'There's a mix of emotions,' said Ryan Guilds, a lawyer representing nine of the women who testified. 'Disappointment for those who didn't get the justice they deserved, validation for many of them, that they were believed. … Though today was a good day, it doesn't change the incredible amount of harm suffered by these victims.' The total number of charges Batt faced was steadily reduced after he was initially arrested last October on 77 counts, including 14 rape and 16 aggravated assault charges. Prosecutors from the Army's Office of Special Trial Counsel said five of the initial 20 accusers withdrew from the case, and a number of other charges were dismissed or combined with other counts. In the end, the jury considered six rape charges, two aggravated assault by strangulation charges, 10 sexual assault and 16 assault and battery charges among 38 total counts. Batt, a West Point graduate who then entered Ranger School, rose to major and was in line for a promotion to lieutenant colonel before his arrest. He had been assigned to an artificial intelligence division of the Army in Arlington, Virginia, where he also lived. He kept a boat on the Potomac, the 'Batt Boat,' on which some of the incidents originated. He has a young daughter and testified he got married last month. Prosecutors said Batt met the women through online dating apps, through friends or through work. All of the women agreed to dates, but many said they did not agree to sex, particularly on the first date. From 2020 to 2023, 'Major Batt preyed upon and attacked 15 different women when they were vulnerable, isolated and defenseless,' Army Lt. Col. Gregory A. Vetere said in his closing argument. He cited the testimony of a woman who had fended off one physical advance by Batt, told him she wasn't interested in sex, then in a later encounter was forced to have sex at night on the Potomac River while they were on a Jet Ski. Prosecutors also said Batt strangled three women into unconsciousness during sex, without their consent. 'They felt the life force being driven out of them,' Vetere said. 'It is clear that the accused, in their testimony, was having sex with their unconscious bodies. That is rape, for which consent is not even a defense. An unconscious person cannot consent.' Other women said they were tied with ropes against their will or forced to have sex after they said no. Two lawyers and an Army soldier were among the 15 women who testified against Batt. Some of the women met after one of Batt's girlfriends posted on the Facebook group, 'Are We Dating the Same Guy?' Batt's lawyer, Nathan Freeburg, said the subsequent discussions among the women constituted 'witness contamination,' in which witnesses are exposed to prejudicial information before they testify. Freeburg noted in his closing argument that Batt testified for nearly an entire day. 'He looked you in the eye and told you the truth. We've done all an innocent person can do. We've shouted from the rooftops, he is innocent.' Freeburg pointed out that many of the women had subsequent encounters with Batt after claiming he sexually assaulted them. 'I always have fun with you guys,' one woman texted Batt after engaging in a video-recorded threesome, Freeburg reminded the jury. The video itself was shown to the jury, though prosecutors claimed it was edited by Batt to remove the criminal element of the encounter. Another woman sent more than 100 messages to Batt after she was allegedly attacked. 'That's not someone who got assaulted,' Freeburg told the jury. 'None of this makes sense.' Batt maintained that nearly all of his actions were consensual and not unusual. 'There's always a conversation about what the other party wants,' he told the jury. Prosecutors summoned an expert on how victims of violence respond to their attackers. She testified that many victims of interpersonal violence often maintain ties with their assailants. The jury was given instructions on multiple counts that evidence of sexual interactions with Batt 'should be considered as to whether she [the accuser] consented to the charged act.' The women in Batt's trial gave varying explanations of why they continued to see Batt after he allegedly assaulted them. One of them, a lawyer, said she was shocked when Batt had sex with her after she specifically told him no, a warning Batt admitted to on the stand, and more shocked when he placed his hands around her neck, nearly rendering her unconscious. But she said she discussed the choking with him, and returned for a second encounter. She testified that the strangling lasted longer the second time, but still she returned for a third time, with no strangling, before ending the relationship. 'Just trying to give him the benefit of the doubt,' the woman testified. 'He seemed like a nice guy.' The jury acquitted Batt of sexual assault but convicted him of aggravated assault by strangulation in the counts related to the woman. The woman who first contacted police, in the summer of 2021, told a story even Freeburg acknowledged was 'horrific,' of being partially bound, strangled and raped after recently undergoing surgery as part of her transgender conversion. She said she had not told Batt that she was transgender. But after undergoing a sexual assault exam at Inova Fairfax Medical Campus, meeting with a detective and starting therapy, she told police she didn't want to prosecute Batt. She then saw him a second time and agreed to be bound again. She said she met with him to hear him apologize in person for their first encounter. A year later, when the woman saw the Facebook group, she returned to the Alexandria police and said she wanted to prosecute. She had spoken to others who had posted in the group, some of whom then also cooperated with police and testified at the trial. The investigation restarted in August 2022 and was later joined by the Army Criminal Investigation Division, culminating in Batt's arrest. Batt was convicted of rape and assault and battery for his first interaction with the woman, and also rape of a second woman. The jury acquitted Batt of four rape counts involving other women but convicted him of a lesser charge of assault in each case. Though Freeburg claimed that the women's interactions before trial constituted contamination, prosecutor Capt. Stephanie Ryder said eight of the 15 women who testified had never seen the Facebook group. Ryder said three of the women testified that Batt had strangled them into unconsciousness. Six women were bitten, struck or slapped by Batt, Ryder said. 'These women have done everything they can to stand up for themselves,' Ryder told the jury. 'Major Batt is a sadist and he is sexually obsessed. He took whatever he wanted whenever he wanted.' 'Navigating the criminal justice system can be extremely daunting,' said Adrian R. Perry, director of victim services for Attorney General Jason Miyares (R) of Virginia, where many of the victims reside, 'and not having victim advocacy support often amplifies the fears and anxieties victims experience after reporting what happened to them.'
