logo
The Last Musician of Auschwitz review – an exceptionally moving film that will ring in your ears for years

The Last Musician of Auschwitz review – an exceptionally moving film that will ring in your ears for years

Yahoo27-01-2025

Auschwitz was a site of incomparable horror; people arriving at the concentration camp knew it would be hell on earth. So it was a shock to be greeted by a band playing Mozart's Eine Kleine Nachtmusik. Was this some kind of breathtakingly sick joke? A demonstration of German cultural superiority? A suggestion that the camp 'cannot be that bad', as one survivor recalls hoping? Or was it a sign, as another remembers thinking, that the Nazis really were 'crazy'?
The truth was complex and chilling, as Toby Trackman's exceptionally moving and intelligent documentary goes on to explore. The role of music in the Holocaust might initially seem a somewhat marginal topic. Is the fact there were orchestras at Auschwitz really that important in the grand scheme of things? Yes, as it turns out: because by examining the presence of music in the camp, The Last Musician of Auschwitz is able to give voice to a wealth of ideas about the function, value, inherent ambivalence and weaponisation of art and culture.
This documentary is named in honour of 99-year-old cellist Anita Lasker-Wallfisch, the only surviving member of the women's orchestra at Auschwitz. She was sent to the concentration camp as a teenager and, on her first day, was asked by another prisoner about her prewar life. When she said she played the cello, a conductor was summoned immediately. 'Here I was, stark naked, and she was asking me: 'Who did you study with?'' She laughs joylessly. 'It was somehow rather incongruous.'
The absurdity was impossible to ignore. As was the incomprehensible sadism: Lasker-Wallfisch was forced to play as her fellow prisoners were burned alive. While the orchestras were a lifeline for those who qualified, helping them avoid violence, starvation and the gas chambers, they also stripped music itself of meaning and feeling. When Lasker-Wallfisch was made to perform a piece by Schumann for the Auschwitz physician Josef Mengele – infamous for conducting twisted experiments on prisoners – she 'didn't feel anything. I played it as fast as possible and thought: get out.'
Elsewhere, there was something approaching logic. The Nazis wanted to annihilate Jews and other ethnic groups. They were also determined to turn Germany into an economic superpower. Music played into their repugnantly efficient combination of the two. Via the concentration camps, the Nazis had a valuable new resource; the slave labour of imprisoned Jews. In order to drill this free workforce with 'military-like efficiency', explains Guardian columnist Jonathan Freedland in one of his many enlightening contributions, orchestras played marches as the prisoners walked to the factories where they were forced to toil. This film manages to weave in many other nauseating examples of how the Nazis financially optimised Auschwitz, including the selling of shorn hair and off-loading of charred human remains as fertiliser.
In Auschwitz, music became synonymous with heinous acts. Yet it also provided untold comfort. This documentary features many archive interviews from the late 20th century with unidentified Auschwitz survivors; these men and women – elderly, often glamorous, animated yet viscerally haunted – recall singing in groups to provide a flicker of morale and some semblance of identity. We hear of the Roma victims who sang about their experiences in the camps, and the 'bright and optimistic' lullaby secretly written by the Polish composer and prisoner Adam Kopyciński.
Music can make us feel human, but it is no guarantee of humanity. The German identity was tightly bound up with classical music, and German composers were a crucial source of national pride. An appreciation for high art is traditionally associated with civilised behaviour. Yet, observes Lasker-Wallfisch's son Raphael: 'There are many examples of these very cultured people doing the worst atrocities ever known to humankind.' In fact, German ethnocentrism informed their extermination of other cultures. As Freedland points out, the Holocaust didn't only kill millions: when it came to the European Jewry, the genocide decimated an entire cultural world.
The Last Musician of Auschwitz saves its most devastating story for last. We had been following the life of the Jewish writer Ilse Weber, and heard the heartbreaking song she composed for her elder son Hanuš after sending him to England via Kindertransport. Later, Ilse is nursing ill children in the Theresienstadt ghetto, soothing them with lullabies. When she and her younger son are transported to Auschwitz alongside her patients, she is given advice at the gates: tell the children to sing when they enter the gas chamber, then they will die faster and avoid being trampled by the adults attempting to escape.
Any worthwhile documentary about the Holocaust will force you to stare into the abyss; fewer are able to dig into cerebral ideas while unflinchingly documenting the atrocities carried out at the camps. This incredibly impressive programme does not let us forget about Auschwitz's corpse mountains or stench of burning bodies for a second, all the while posing questions about art and humanity that should ring in your ears for years to come.
• The Last Musician of Auschwitz aired on BBC Two and is on iPlayer now.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

A debut novel explores family relationships and cultural displacement

time10 hours ago

A debut novel explores family relationships and cultural displacement

In her debut novel, Misophonia, Dana Vowinckel explores the cultural diaspora through one teenager's summer across Berlin, Jerusalem, and Chicago. It's a coming of age story that balances the narratives of a daughter and her father as well as the fifteen-year-old protagonist's abrupt (and reluctant) reunion with her mother. The book is also a semi-autobiographical trek through parts of Vowinckel's own life. Born in Berlin into an American-Jewish-German family, the author grew up between Chicago and Berlin and her novel manages to capture the sometimes awkward, oftentimes tender, dynamics of a family pulled across continents and histories. Though it explores the travails of teenage girlhood, the book also delves into the nuances of being Jewish and German and the challenges of reconciliation when your goals and feelings collide with world events. 'Language is at the core of the book, not identity,' Vowinckel explained in a recent interview in New York. 'It would be a mistake to read it as purely an identity novel,' she says. Critics have praised the novel for its rich, contrasting ingredients and Vowinckel's ability to narrate the emotions of its teenage protagonist with warmth and clarity. The book won the Mara Cassens Prize, a German literary award given annually for the best German debut novel, and earned Vowinckel the literature prize of the Association of Arts and Culture of the German Economy. It was also shortlisted for the Leipzig Book Fair Prize which celebrates outstanding new publications written in German. The 27-year old Vowinckel, who studied linguistics and literature in Berlin, Toulouse and Cambridge, was in New York to promote the recently published English translation of Misophonia by HarperVia. (The book was translated from its original German by Adrian Nathan West.) Vowinckel's visit included events at Germany's Consulate General of New York - which promotes cultural, intellectual, and artistic exchanges with Germany - and Deutsches Haus at New York University. Misophonia opens in Chicago, with parts set in Berlin and Israel. It follows a teenage protagonist, Margarita, as she travels to her father's birthplace in Israel with the mother who left her when she was a toddler. Margarita shares a special bond with her father, Avi - a doting Israeli who is a cantor at their local synagogue - ever since her mother, Marsha, abandoned the family. Eventually, arrangements are made - without Margarita's knowledge - for her to meet Marsha in Israel before returning to Germany. Blindsided, she wants no part of this overdue reconciliation with a mother she hardly knows. Meanwhile, in Germany, Avi tries to fill the hole left by Margarita's absence with a trip of his own, embarking on a personal journey, both hope-inducing and despairing. Writing the book through the prism of dueling narratives - switching between a teenage girl, and her father - allowed Vowinckel to engage readers in an unusual point-of-view combination, she says. Accounts of Jewish congregational life in Berlin are mixed with detailed descriptions of the awkwardness and lust that go along with living inside a female teenage body. 'Both perspectives were very interesting to me,' Vowinckel told the Chicago Review of Books in May. 'With a 15-year-old, there's early sexuality and kind of being lost in the world, contrasted with the very lonely, quiet life of Avi,' she said. Straddling the two narratives also helped balance the exploration of imperfect family relationships and larger cultural displacement, the author says. 'I think it was very helpful for me to have a protagonist with a very specific job description because that gives you rhythm to the text,' Vowinckel says. 'It made it very easy for me to start this big novel project with this very calm, laconic voice, and then mix it with Margarita.'

Bryce Dallas Howard Says A Director Threw Water At Her
Bryce Dallas Howard Says A Director Threw Water At Her

Buzz Feed

time18 hours ago

  • Buzz Feed

Bryce Dallas Howard Says A Director Threw Water At Her

I'm sure you know Bryce Dallas Howard. You probably know that the Jurassic World star is also the daughter of award-winning director Ron Howard (A Beautiful Mind, The Da Vinci Code). In an interview with The Sunday Times, Bryce explained an alleged exchange she had with Danish director Lars von Trier where he tried to use her father's job against her. Bryce starred in the 2005 drama Manderlay, a direct sequel to Dogville (2003). Bryce had replaced Nicole Kidman as Grace Margaret Mulligan from the first movie. She said the moment she arrived at the set for Manderlay in Norway, Lars allegedly spoke negatively of her dad in an attempt to upset her. "He started insulting me: 'Your father's a terrible film-maker,'" she remembered. "I went, 'Lars, what are you trying to see?' and he said, 'Your angry face. I don't know what it looks like.'" Bryce claimed that Lars then threw a glass of water in her face. "So I threw a glass of water in his face. He goes, 'Why did you do that?' and got up and left." She said she was actually unfazed and actually entertained by the interaction. "That was my introduction to the Lars von Trier experience, but it wasn't like I went to my room and cried or anything. I was sort of delighted by it." Lars is a director with a reputation for his erratic behavior and even faced several allegations several years back for his behavior on set. In 2017, Icelandic singer-songwriter Björk posted about her treatment by a Danish director. When the media connected the dots that Björk starred as Selma Ježková in Lars von Trier's 2000 musical psychological tragedy Dancer in the Dark, Lars came forward and denied the accusations. Björk posted another statement in the midst of #MeToo social movement, doubling down her claims while still remaining not to directly name the director. Björk wrote, "After each take the director ran up to me and wrapped his arms around me for a long time in front of all crew or alone and stroked me sometimes for minutes against my wishes," Björk wrote. "While filming in Sweden, he threatened to climb from his room's balcony over to mine in the middle of the night with a clear sexual intention, while his wife was in the room next door." In November 2017, the Guardian reported that Zentropa, the film studio co-founded by Lars and former CEO Peter Aalbæk Jensen, faced several allegations of "sexual harassment, degradation and bullying," per several Danish news publications. While Lars wasn't named in these allegations, Peter resigned from his CEO position as the accusations poured in. Read the entire interview with The Times here. We reached out to Lars's people for comment, and we'll let you know if we hear back.

Hearts Melt at What Dog Does Every Afternoon When He Sees the School Bus
Hearts Melt at What Dog Does Every Afternoon When He Sees the School Bus

Newsweek

timea day ago

  • Newsweek

Hearts Melt at What Dog Does Every Afternoon When He Sees the School Bus

Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. A dog has developed the most heartwarming daily habit whenever he catches sight of a yellow school bus outside the family home. Every day around the same time, Thor watches and waits. He knows exactly what to look out for and, considering he's a dog, has a pretty good idea of when to expect it. "We brought Thor home in November of 2023," Deanna Rogers told Newsweek. The mom, who lives with her husband and two young sons in Cape May Court House, New Jersey, said that, before Thor, they had a very specific idea in mind for what kind of dog they wanted. "We specifically wanted a German shepherd because they're known for their loyalty to their family," Rogers said. "Because we live on a very busy main road, we wanted a dog who wouldn't be so willing to run off." In a busy household that also includes two rescue ponies, a pair of goats and some chickens, Thor plays an important role in keeping the peace and appears to thrive in it. "He could spend all day outside, just keeping an eye on the farm animals and watching our boys play," Rogers said. "His favorite thing to do is definitely very long walks and car rides! He is insanely smart and protective without coming across as intimidating. When it comes down to it, he's a big baby." Thor's intelligence shouldn't come as a shock. Stanley Coren, author of The Intelligence of Dogs and professor emeritus at the University of British Columbia's Department of Psychology, ranks the breed among the most intelligent. "According to my research, the seven dog breeds with the highest working and obedience intelligence, starting with the brightest are: Border collie, poodle, German shepherd, golden retriever, Doberman pinscher, Shetland sheepdog and Labrador retriever," Coren told Newsweek. However, Thor appears especially smart, if a video posted to Rogers' TikTok, @deannarogers_, is anything to go by. It' is a compilation of the heartwarming daily habit Thor has picked up when Rogers' kids come home from school. "Thor started really becoming aware of the boys' school routine this year," Rogers said. "In the afternoon, he would start watching out the window around the time he knew they came home, anticipating the big yellow school bus to arrive out front of our house." One day, Thor opted to take things one step further. "He just decided to go greet the boys at the foot of the bus steps," Rogers said. Things quickly escalated from there in the sweetest way imaginable. "After that, some of the kids would call his name and he would go right onto the bus, take a lap down the aisle and head off," Rogers said. "It became a regular occurrence." Thor's antics have made him a firm favorite with everyone at her sons' school. "Not only do our kids love seeing Thor greet them at the bus, all of the other kids and the bus driver love it, too," Rogers said. Now Thor's adorable escapades have gone viral, with the compilation clip posted to Rogers' TikTok, showing his regular visits to the bus, going viral with more than 23,000 views and counting. "He loves your son so much!! Good doggy," one viewer wrote, with a second commenting: "Oh my God this is the cutest, dogs deserve the world." A third meanwhile admitted they were "crying on the toilet" watching the footage. The response has blown Rogers away but, given how much she knows and loves Thor, it is not a surprise to see others feeling the same. "When I shared the video, I knew people would feel the love that our dog has for our children and it would make people smile," Rogers said. "Dogs are just the best, but our Thor is really up there with the best of the best." It looks like quite a few New Jersey school kids would agree.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store