NZ First Bill would ‘write trans people out of' law
A Saturday protest placed human rights concerns of the rainbow community in the spotlight.
Stand Against Transphobia - Fight the Far Right challenged moves to undermine transgender rights.
Organised by International Socialists Otepoti Dunedin and Dunedin Pride, the gathering drew about 300 queer and trans members and supporters.
Speakers responded to a proposed Member's Bill from New Zealand First MP Jenny Marcroft that would define a woman as an adult human biological female and a man as an adult human biological male.
Protest co-ordinator Oscar Bartle said the party's Bill was a blatant attempt to erase trans and non-binary people from law.
''Not only will this result in situations where trans people will be sent to the wrong prisons and other such injustices, it will also serve to legitimise and embolden the transphobic far-right.''
International Socialists Otepoti Dunedin member Neave Ashton said the world had become a much scarier place for trans people in recent years.
''This Bill, if passed, would effectively write trans people out of legal recognition.''
It could mean trans women would be sent to men's prisons where they were up to 13 times more likely to be raped and sexually assaulted.
It might result in ''big, burly trans men with full beards'' being forced to use women's toilets, they said.
''It could also mean that our medication, like puberty blockers and gender-affirming care, could be banned or restricted.''
Local drag performer Ann Arkii, a genderqueer transgender man hoping to receive top surgery later this year, said transitioning had been lifesaving.
''I wouldn't be standing in front of you here today if I was unable to live my life the way that I needed to.
''Who I am as a person is not something that can be defined, debated or legislated by the state.''
Bills like this one were mere distractions from bigger problems such as the cost-of-living crisis, climate change, famine and genocide.
''Trans people will not be erased, not from public life, not from history, not now and not ever. A world without trans people is a world without humanity.''
SAM.HENDERSON @thestar.co.nz
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
11-05-2025
- NZ Herald
Social media restrictions for under-16s: Work to be part of Government's agenda
National's legislation, sponsored by MP Catherine Wedd, will remain in the ballot as the Government does its work. 'I would like to thank Catherine Wedd for her advocacy so far and look forward to seeing how her members' bill can feed into this process,' Luxon said. Luxon said there had been an 'overwhelmingly positive response from mums and dads' that made it 'clear we need to progress options to restrict social media for under-16s'. 'I am concerned by the harm social media can cause young New Zealanders and I believe restricting access for under-16s would help protect our kids from bullying, harmful content and social media addiction,' he said. 'Australia is currently testing a range of options for restricting social media for under-16s, and the United Kingdom, the EU, Canada and states in the US are also exploring the issue. 'As part of her work, Erica will consider how these other jurisdictions are implementing restrictions and what could work in New Zealand, subject to Cabinet approval.' An Act spokesman told the Herald that Sunday's announcement showed why the party had opposed National's bill: 'Much more work is needed, with more options and input from more voices, before we dive headfirst into a ban.' 'Act believes we should instead watch Australia closely as it tries to implement its ban. There will likely be lessons for New Zealand.' The legislation proposed by Wedd on Tuesday would require social media companies to verify if someone is over 16 before allowing them access to their platforms. It reflects a similar move by Australia, which has a ban coming into effect this year. If picked from Parliament's ballot and then passed, the legislation would also introduce financial penalties for platforms that fail to uphold age verification. The law would be reviewed three years after its implementation to assess its effectiveness. When announcing the Member's Bill alongside Wedd on Tuesday, Luxon said he hoped the Government would adopt it, expediting its progress through Parliament. That would require the support of the leaders of Act and NZ First. While NZ First leader Winston Peters agreed the Government should back it, Act's David Seymour said his party opposed it 'because it is not workable'. 'Act is concerned about the practicalities of a ban,' Seymour said. 'For example, requiring all social media users to provide government identification to social media companies would raise privacy issues.' 'The bill's definition of 'social media' more or less includes the entire internet. For example, the bill says social media could be anything that 'allow[s] end-users to link to, or interact with, some or all of the other end users'. Such a poorly drafted definition is unworkable.' He instead called for the education and workforce select committee to hold an inquiry into the issue, which he believed would 'hear all voices to find a workable solution that respects parental responsibility'. The next day, Act MP Parmjeet Parmar wrote to the committee asking it to hear from teachers, principals, technology experts, mental health professionals and parents among others. 'Act shares the concern that social media is causing harm to young people. But any government response must be grounded in evidence and respect parental responsibility,' she said. Labour leader Chris Hipkins said he was 'broadly supportive' of the bill but felt having consensus within the Government was important. He also wanted to see the details of the actual legislation being proposed. Green Party co-leader Chlöe Swarbrick said she wanted to learn more about the potential ban, acknowledging the bill was simplistic. Act takes on deepfakes Meanwhile, Act MP Laura McClure on Sunday announced she would introduce a Member's Bill she said would restrict the generation and sharing of sexually explicit deepfakes. Deepfakes are digital images and videos created through artificial intelligence (AI) technology that appear to depict real or fictional people or events. They're often made to show world leaders or celebrities saying or doing something they haven't. McClure said they can be made by anyone with 'alarming ease' and 'violate personal autonomy and self-ownership'. 'No-one should have to worry about their digital images being misappropriated and sexualised. This new form of bullying, shaming, and harassment can lead to profound psychological, reputational and emotional harm. 'What started as a problem for public figures and celebrities can now happen to anyone. Teachers and school leaders have told me this technology is already doing real harm to young people in New Zealand, and this abuse risks becoming normalised if we do not act urgently to ensure the law keeps up with technology.' McClure said her legislation built on existing laws around revenge porn and intimate recordings. It would ensure people who produce or share deepfakes without consent face criminal accountability, while victims have pathways to seek redress and the removal of content. 'My bill amends the Crimes Act 1961 and the Harmful Digital Communications Act 2015 to expand the definition of 'intimate visual recording' to explicitly include images or videos that are created, synthesised or altered to depict a person's likeness in intimate contexts without their consent.' She said she'd be writing to the Minister of Justice urging him to adopt it as a Member's Bill.
RNZ News
10-05-2025
- RNZ News
The dictators who work to keep each other in power
This audio is not downloadable due to copyright restrictions. Anne Applebaum is a staff writer for The Atlantic and a Pulitzer-prize winning historian. In her latest book Autocracy, Inc: The Dictators Who Want to Run the World , she examines the power structures currently running the world. Anne says the title 'Autocracy Inc' describes a network of dictatorships who have nothing in common ideologically, but act like an international corporation to help keep each other in control - co-operating financially, militarily, and sharing information to work against democracy. Photo:
Scoop
10-05-2025
- Scoop
Wellington Queer Communities Protest Against NZ First's Anti-Trans Bill
Press Release – Queer Endurance in Defiance Now more than ever, trans communities need support. Join Queer Endurance in Defiance, or your local queer organisation, and help us demonstrate that we will not be defined out of existence. On Saturday 8 May, around 400 protesters rallied with Queer Endurance in Defiance (QED), protesting against a proposed member's bill by NZ First MP Jenny Marcroft, which aims to legally exclude trans people from definitions of 'man' and 'woman.' NZ First leader Winston Peters announced on 22 April that the bill will define a woman as an 'adult human biological female' and a man as an 'adult human biological male.' The wording of the bill reflects that of a recent ruling from Britain's Supreme Court, which similarly excluded trans women from the definition of women. QED activists say both moves seek to facilitate the exclusion of trans people from social services and public life. QED spokesperson Tristan-Cordelia Egarr noted that the government had already indicated moves to restrict access to puberty blockers for trans rangatahi, and erase queer and trans people from Relationships and Sexuality Education in schools. Egarr also noted that 'instead of focusing on the most pressing issues facing New Zealanders – the cost of living crisis, child poverty, the climate crisis, our overburdened healthcare system – Peters and the government are presenting these transparent attempts to distract and divide us by targeting an already marginalised and vulnerable community.' 'Now more than ever, trans communities need support. Join Queer Endurance in Defiance, or your local queer organisation, and help us demonstrate that we will not be defined out of existence. We trans people will continue to exist, and we will continue to resist.'
