
Gaza: UN Agencies Reject Israeli Plan To Use Aid As ‘Bait'
9 May 2025
UN Children's Fund (UNICEF) spokesperson James Elder insisted that the Israeli proposal to create a handful of aid hubs exclusively in the south of the Strip would create an ' impossible choice between displacement and death '.
The plan 'contravenes basic humanitarian principles' and appears designed to 'reinforce control over life-sustaining items as a pressure tactic', he told journalists in Geneva. ' It's dangerous to ask civilians to go into militarized zones to collect rations…humanitarian aid should never be used as a bargaining chip '.
The Gaza Strip has been under a complete aid blockade for more than two months and humanitarians have warned repeatedly that food, water, medicines and fuel have been running out.
Kids and elderly at risk
If the Israeli plan were to happen, Gaza's most vulnerable individuals - the elderly, children with disabilities, the sick and the wounded who cannot travel to designated distribution zones – would face 'horrendous challenges' retrieving aid, the UNICEF spokesperson maintained.
The Israeli aid distribution blueprint presented to UN humanitarians envisages only 60 aid trucks per day entering Gaza - 'one-tenth of what was being delivered during the ceasefire' between Israel and Hamas which held from 19 January to 18 March.
'It's not nearly enough to meet the needs of 1.1 million children, 2.1 million people,' Mr. Elder insisted. 'There is a simple alternative: lift the blockade, let humanitarian aid in, save lives.'
Thousands of trucks in limbo
Stressing the success of the UN-led aid scale up during the ceasefire, humanitarian affairs coordination office spokesperson Jens Laerke urged the Israeli authorities to 'facilitate the aid that we and our partners have available just a few kilometres away' just outside Gaza.
UNRWA, the largest aid provider in the Strip, said that the UN agency has 'over 3,000 trucks of aid' that are stuck outside Gaza.
Juliette Touma, Director of Communications, deplored the fact that such a 'big dollar figure' was going to waste, when the food could be reaching hungry children and when medicine could be used to treat people with chronic diseases.
'The clock is ticking. The gates must reopen, the siege must be lifted as soon as possible,' she insisted, while calling for the release of Israeli hostages and a return to a standard flow of humanitarian supplies.
Inside Gaza, aid teams warn that the situation is desperate. 'Even those [food] lines are now gone because food is running out,' said UNRWA's Ms. Touma.
Nothing left to queue for
In an update on Thursday, OCHA said that more than 80 community kitchens have been forced to shut since late April, owing to the lack of supplies. This number is rising 'by the day', fuelling 'widespread' hunger in Gaza, the UN aid coordination office said.
Rebutting Israeli allegations that aid reaching Gaza has been diverted by militant groups, both Ms. Touma and UN World Health Organization (WHO) spokesperson Dr. Margaret Harris described 'end-to-end' systems put in place to counter this risk.
'Our supplies are reaching the health facilities they're meant to serve,' said Dr. Harris, adding that the UN health agency had not witnessed any aid diversion within the health care system.
'It is not about failure of aid delivery within Gaza. It is about not being allowed to bring it in,' Dr. Harris concluded.
In a further note of caution about the Israeli plan, UNICEF's Mr. Elder insisted that the proposed use of facial recognition as a precondition to access aid ran against all humanitarian principles to 'screen and monitor beneficiaries for intelligence and military purposes'.
He recalled that the ceasefire earlier this year had resulted in a 'huge' improvement in children's nutrition.
'It meant food in the markets, repaired water systems…It meant people could access health care safely. It meant health care facilitators had medicines that they need.'
'Boastful' denials of aid
Fast forward to today and food, water, medicines - 'everything for a child to survive' - is being blocked, Mr. Elder said — 'and in many ways, boastfully blocked'.
The UNICEF spokesperson also expressed concern that the Israeli plan risks separating family members 'while they move back and forth to try and get aid' from the designated locations in a territory that 'lacks any safety' amid ongoing bombardments.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Scoop
3 hours ago
- Scoop
Foreign Minister Strengthens Relationship With Italy
Foreign Minister Winston Peters has concluded a constructive visit to Italy, marking 75 years of diplomatic relations. Mr Peters and Italy's Foreign Minister Antonio Tajani met in Rome overnight and confirmed the strength of the bilateral relationship that New Zealand and Italy share. 'New Zealand and Italy are long-standing partners,' Mr Peters says. 'We have agreed to work more closely together, in order to expand strategic and trade and economic relations. 'We work closely in Antarctica and have shared interests in supporting the rules-based international order and multilateral system, including cooperation on human rights and UN reform,' Mr Peters says. Mr Peters signed an arts, science and sport arrangement with Minister Tajani, which supports cooperation between New Zealand and Italy in these areas. While in Rome, Mr Peters also met: a range of Italian businesses with investment and commercial interests in New Zealand; and Elizabeth Dibble, the Director-General of the Multinational Forces and Observers (MFO), the international peace monitoring organisation in the Sinai which New Zealand has supported since its inception in 1982. Mr Peters now travels to Jakarta, to attend the annual Indonesia-New Zealand Joint Ministerial Commission meeting.


Scoop
4 hours ago
- Scoop
Ongoing Russian Strikes Continue Alarming Civilian Casualty Trend
11 June 2025 The toll includes 1,389 casualties in April (221 killed, 1,168 injured) – the highest monthly total so far this year – followed by 1,019 in May (183 killed, 836 injured). Casualties were reported across 17 out of 24 regions and the city of Kyiv, including areas far from the frontline. The vast majority of attacks (97 per cent) led to civilian casualties occurred in areas under Ukrainian Government control. 'This year has been devastating for civilians across Ukraine, with significantly more deaths and injuries than during the same period in 2024,' said Danielle Bell, Head of the HRMMU – the monitoring mission set up by the UN rights office, OHCHR, at the invitation of the Ukrainian Government. 'The intensification of long-range attacks with missiles and loitering munitions and frequent attacks with short-range drones along the frontline are a deadly combination for civilians.' Weapons and impact Long-range missile and drone attacks caused the largest proportion of civilian casualties – some 28 per cent of casualties during May. On the other hand, short-range drones remained the leading cause in frontline areas. Russian armed forces carried out at least five attacks on port infrastructure in the Odesa region on the Black Sea, resulting in civilian casualties and damage to facilities. One such attack on 23 May killed three men and injured 12 more, including port workers, according to the report. Continuing trends in June The mission noted that long-range attacks have intensified this month. Since 6 June, Russian forces have launched over 1,500 long-range weapons, according to Ukrainian authorities. The HRMMU is in the process of verifying reports that these attacks (or subsequent falling debris) have killed at least 19 civilians and injured 205 others nationwide in just a five-day span. If confirmed, June could match or surpass April and May in total casualties. ' At this pace and scale, further loss of civilian life is not just possible – it is inevitable,' said Ms. Bell.


Scoop
10 hours ago
- Scoop
'Look Busy – The People Are Angry' In The Face Of Genocide – Government Brings Shame On Us All
Press Release – Palestine Solidarity Network Aotearoa The government's decision to sanction Israeli cabinet ministers is a cynical diversionary gesture, according to the Palestine Solidarity Network Aotearoa. New Zealand has joined the UK, Australia, Canada, and Norway in banning the entry of Israel's Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich and National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir. PSNA Co-Chair, Maher Nazzal, says the just announced move is simply to placate New Zealanders angry at the government's complicity with the mass killing of Palestinians and deliberate starvation of Occupied Gaza. 'The New Zealand government statement was quite explicit that the sanctions were 'not designed to sanction the wider Israeli government' of which Ben-Gvir and Smotrich are ministers.' 'The New Zealand government's official statement is laying the blame for Israeli barbarity on just two ministers. Our government is pretending that they alone are responsible for the military violence in the Gaza Strip, and Israel's annexation of Palestinian land, expanding settlements, and forced displacement.' 'All these war crimes are supported and stated by Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and his government. These measures are all being carried out by the Israeli government. These two ministers are quite rabid, but they are not just freelancers or 'bad apples'.' 'Netanyahu himself is wanted for trial on war crimes charges, so why does he escape the travel ban?' Nazzal says Ben-Gvir and Smotrich would never plan to come to New Zealand anyway. 'The last time such an individual visited in 2006 the Auckland District Court issued a warrant for his arrest to face war crime charges.' (That was Israeli General Moshe Ya'alon – the 'Butcher of Qana'. The warrant was quashed by the then Attorney-General Michael Cullen) 'Even if the government sanctioned the entire Israeli cabinet, it would be meaningless.' 'Israel has made Gaza hell on earth for Palestinians, and is making it worse by the hour. We should be cutting trade ties – including military technology, which might be finding its way to Israel, or sending up satellites from Mahia used by Israel to spy on Gaza. 'New Zealand has bilateral agreements with Israel over science and movie-making. They should stop.' 'The government needs to ban Israeli soldiers coming here for genocide holidays, instead of Winston Peters going out of his way to welcome them.' 'And it goes without saying that the Israeli ambassador should be booted out.' Nazzal says the forced starvation in Gaza has reached a crisis point. 'The choice for the international community is stark. Let tens of thousands starve to death in the next few weeks, or impose a no-fly zone over Gaza and provide military protection for UNRWA aid convoys.' 'In that context, by limiting the travel options for two Israeli politicians our government feels like it's conveying a message of 'Look busy – New Zealanders are angry, we must be seen to be doing something, but really, we don't care.'