Gaza: UN Agencies Reject Israeli Plan To Use Aid As ‘Bait'
9 May 2025
UN Children's Fund (UNICEF) spokesperson James Elder insisted that the Israeli proposal to create a handful of aid hubs exclusively in the south of the Strip would create an ' impossible choice between displacement and death '.
The plan 'contravenes basic humanitarian principles' and appears designed to 'reinforce control over life-sustaining items as a pressure tactic', he told journalists in Geneva. ' It's dangerous to ask civilians to go into militarized zones to collect rations…humanitarian aid should never be used as a bargaining chip '.
The Gaza Strip has been under a complete aid blockade for more than two months and humanitarians have warned repeatedly that food, water, medicines and fuel have been running out.
Kids and elderly at risk
If the Israeli plan were to happen, Gaza's most vulnerable individuals - the elderly, children with disabilities, the sick and the wounded who cannot travel to designated distribution zones – would face 'horrendous challenges' retrieving aid, the UNICEF spokesperson maintained.
The Israeli aid distribution blueprint presented to UN humanitarians envisages only 60 aid trucks per day entering Gaza - 'one-tenth of what was being delivered during the ceasefire' between Israel and Hamas which held from 19 January to 18 March.
'It's not nearly enough to meet the needs of 1.1 million children, 2.1 million people,' Mr. Elder insisted. 'There is a simple alternative: lift the blockade, let humanitarian aid in, save lives.'
Thousands of trucks in limbo
Stressing the success of the UN-led aid scale up during the ceasefire, humanitarian affairs coordination office spokesperson Jens Laerke urged the Israeli authorities to 'facilitate the aid that we and our partners have available just a few kilometres away' just outside Gaza.
UNRWA, the largest aid provider in the Strip, said that the UN agency has 'over 3,000 trucks of aid' that are stuck outside Gaza.
Juliette Touma, Director of Communications, deplored the fact that such a 'big dollar figure' was going to waste, when the food could be reaching hungry children and when medicine could be used to treat people with chronic diseases.
'The clock is ticking. The gates must reopen, the siege must be lifted as soon as possible,' she insisted, while calling for the release of Israeli hostages and a return to a standard flow of humanitarian supplies.
Inside Gaza, aid teams warn that the situation is desperate. 'Even those [food] lines are now gone because food is running out,' said UNRWA's Ms. Touma.
Nothing left to queue for
In an update on Thursday, OCHA said that more than 80 community kitchens have been forced to shut since late April, owing to the lack of supplies. This number is rising 'by the day', fuelling 'widespread' hunger in Gaza, the UN aid coordination office said.
Rebutting Israeli allegations that aid reaching Gaza has been diverted by militant groups, both Ms. Touma and UN World Health Organization (WHO) spokesperson Dr. Margaret Harris described 'end-to-end' systems put in place to counter this risk.
'Our supplies are reaching the health facilities they're meant to serve,' said Dr. Harris, adding that the UN health agency had not witnessed any aid diversion within the health care system.
'It is not about failure of aid delivery within Gaza. It is about not being allowed to bring it in,' Dr. Harris concluded.
In a further note of caution about the Israeli plan, UNICEF's Mr. Elder insisted that the proposed use of facial recognition as a precondition to access aid ran against all humanitarian principles to 'screen and monitor beneficiaries for intelligence and military purposes'.
He recalled that the ceasefire earlier this year had resulted in a 'huge' improvement in children's nutrition.
'It meant food in the markets, repaired water systems…It meant people could access health care safely. It meant health care facilitators had medicines that they need.'
'Boastful' denials of aid
Fast forward to today and food, water, medicines - 'everything for a child to survive' - is being blocked, Mr. Elder said — 'and in many ways, boastfully blocked'.
The UNICEF spokesperson also expressed concern that the Israeli plan risks separating family members 'while they move back and forth to try and get aid' from the designated locations in a territory that 'lacks any safety' amid ongoing bombardments.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
40 minutes ago
- NZ Herald
NZ joins allies in banning Israeli politicians over Gaza remarks
New Zealand has placed a travel ban on two 'extremist' Israeli politicians over their comments about the war in Gaza. The Government has banned ultra-nationalists Itamar Ben-Gvir, the Israeli security minister, and Bezalel Smotrich, the finance minister, from entering New Zealand in a joint decision with the UK, Australia,
NZ Herald
20 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Gaza-bound aid boat carrying Greta Thunberg reaches Israeli port
A Gaza-bound aid boat reached Israel's Ashdod port on Monday after being intercepted by Israeli forces, preventing the dozen activists on board, including Swedish campaigner Greta Thunberg, from reaching the blockaded Palestinian territory. An AFP photographer said that the Madleen, which organisers said was intercepted in international waters overnight, reached
Scoop
20 hours ago
- Scoop
Guterres Calls For An End To Ocean ‘Plunder' As UN Summit Opens In France
With the Mediterranean glittering in the background, UN Secretary-General Antnio Guterres opened the Third United Nations Ocean Conference on Monday, delivering a blunt indictment of humanitys fractured relationship with the sea. ' The ocean is the ultimate shared resource,' he told delegates gathered at the port of Nice. 'But we are failing it.' Oceans, he warned, are absorbing 90 per cent of the excess heat from greenhouse gas emissions and buckling under the strain: overfishing, rising temperatures, plastic pollution, acidification. Coral reefs are dying. Fish stocks are collapsing. Rising seas, he said, could soon 'submerge deltas, destroy crops, and swallow coastlines — threatening many islands' survival.' Call for stewardship More than 50 Heads of State and Government took part in the opening ceremony, including Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva and European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen — a show of political force underscoring the summit's weight. In total, over 120 countries are participating in the five-day gathering, known by the shorthand UNOC3, signaling a growing recognition that ocean health is inseparable from climate stability, food security, and global equity. French President Emmanuel Macron, whose country is co-hosting the summit alongside Costa Rica, followed with a forceful appeal for science, law, and multilateral resolve. 'The abyss is not for sale, any more than Greenland is for sale, any more than Antarctica or the high seas are for sale,' he declared. 'If the Earth is warming, the ocean is boiling.' He insisted the fate of the seas could not be left to markets or opinion. 'The first response is therefore multilateralism,' Mr. Macron said. 'The climate, like biodiversity, is not a matter of opinion; it is a matter of scientifically established facts.' Costa Rican President Rodrigo Chaves Robles took the podium next, thanking Mr. Guterres for elevating the ocean on the global agenda, then shifting to a stark warning. 'The ocean is speaking to us — with bleached coral reefs, with storms, with wounded mangroves,' he said. 'There's no time left for rhetoric. Now is the time to act.' Condemning decades of treating the ocean as an 'infinite pantry and global waste dump,' Mr. Chaves urged a shift from exploitation to stewardship. 'Costa Rica is a small country, but this change has started,' he said. 'We are now declaring peace with the ocean.' Most notably, the Costa Rican leader called for a moratorium on deep-sea mining in international waters until science can adequately assess the risks — a position already backed by 33 countries, he noted. A treaty within reach One of the summit's core objectives is to help bring into force the landmark High Seas Treaty — known as the BBNJ accord — adopted in 2023 to safeguard life in international waters. Sixty ratifications are required for the treaty to become binding international law. Emmanuel Macron announced that this milestone is now within reach. 'In addition to the 50 or so ratifications already submitted here in the last few hours, 15 countries have formally committed to joining them,' he said. 'This means that the political agreement has been reached, which allows us to say that this [Treaty] will be properly implemented.' Whether the legal threshold is crossed this week or shortly after, the French President added, 'it's a win.' High-stakes negotiations in the 'Blue Zone' The tone set by the opening speeches made clear that Nice will be the stage for high-stakes negotiations — on finalising a global treaty on plastic pollution, scaling up ocean finance, and navigating conflicting opinions surrounding seabed mining. Hundreds of new pledges are expected to be announced, building on more than 2,000 voluntary commitments made since the first UN Ocean Conference in 2017. The week-long talks will culminate in the adoption of a political declaration and the unveiling of the Nice Ocean Action Plan, a blueprint aligned with the landmark Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework, a 2022 agreement to protect 30 per cent of marine and terrestrial ecosystems by 2030. 'The deep sea cannot become the Wild West,' António Guterres warned. The summit is being held in a purpose-built venue overlooking Port Lympia, Nice's historic marina, now transformed into the secured diplomatic 'Blue Zone.' On Sunday, a symbolic ceremony led by Li Junhua, head of the UN Department of Economic and Social Affairs and Secretary-General of the conference, saw the French and UN flags raised above the harbor. 'This ceremony marks not only the formal transfer of this historic port into the hands of the United Nations, but also the beginning of a week of shared commitment, responsibility, and hope,' said Mr. Li. Culture, science, and collective memory Before the negotiations began in earnest, Monday's opening turned to ritual and reflection. Polynesian climate activist Ludovic Burns Tuki marked the start of the summit by blowing a pu, a traditional conch shell. 'It's a way to call everyone,' he told UN News after the ceremony. 'I blow with the support of our ancestors.' In Polynesian navigation, the conch is sounded upon arrival at a new island to signal peaceful intent. Mr. Tuki, born in Tahiti to parents from the Tuamotu and Easter Islands, sees the ocean as both boundary and bond. 'We are not only countries,' he said. 'We need to think like a collective system, because this is one ocean, one people, a future for all.' The cultural segment also included a blessing by Tahitian historian Hinano Murphy, a martial arts performance by French taekwondo master Olivier Sicard, a scientific reflection by deep-sea explorer Antje Boetius, and a poetic testimony by Mauritanian filmmaker Abderrahmane Sissako, accompanied by kora musician Wassa Kouyaté. What was lost can return The goals of the Conference are ambitious but clear: to advance the ' 30 by 30 ' pledge, promote sustainable fisheries, decarbonise maritime transport, and unlock new streams of 'blue finance,' including ocean bonds and debt-for-nature swaps to support vulnerable coastal states. In addition to plenary sessions, Monday will feature two high-level action panels: one on conserving and restoring marine ecosystems — including deep-sea habitats — and another on strengthening scientific cooperation, technology exchange, and education to bridge the gap between science and policy. In his opening statement, António Guterres stressed that Sustainable Development Goal 14, on 'Life Below Water', remains the least funded of the 17 UN global goals. 'This must change,' he said. 'We need bold models to unlock private capital.' 'What was lost in a generation,' he concluded, 'can return in a generation. The ocean of our ancestors — teeming with life and diversity — can be more than legend. It can be our legacy.'
