MCA, go it alone in GE16
YOURSAY | 'Next polls might see BN being wiped out from history.'
MCA says Zahid missed the point, wants clarity on Madani ties
Zahid assures seats for MCA, MIC in GE16 amid calls to quit BN
ScarletPanda9731: MCA, MIC, and Umno formed the Alliance Party, and eventually, the Alliance Party brought in other parties to form BN. They have stood together to this day. Although MCA and MIC have lost more and more seats in recent years.
In the earlier years, the Alliance Party was the strongest coalition. Now, BN has lost more and more seats. Never forget that the Alliance and BN were in power for decades. Obviously, it lost its way, for it has forgotten what it stood for.
Greed, as usual, took centre stage. The last election for Umno saw its waning popularity. When an open contest was avoided and the top leaders were genuinely worried that they would lose their positions, they suspended or sacked challengers.
Cowards die many times before their deaths. The valiant near tasted of death but once, said William Shakespeare. Sadly, and regrettably, some of the best brains were sidelined.
The top leaders who went to the polls, so confident of winning more seats with the proverbial call, 'Strike while the iron is hot', indeed became very 'hot' themselves when BN lost most seats.
Poor Khairy Jamaluddin, former Umno youth chief, was sidelined and sent to Sungai Buloh to contest. He lost narrowly, despite it being a very new area for him, and very little help was extended to him in the election.
Now, even MCA and MIC leaders are thinking aloud whether the situation is untenable for them to remain in a sinking boat. The next polls might see BN being wiped out from history.
Pakatan Harapan must read and learn history, lest it walk the same path as BN. PKR was founded under 'reformasi' ideals, but it appears that it, too, has forgotten history. Reformasi is moving like a 'turtle on the beach', to quote billionaire Elon Musk, as he saw how the US government machinery works.
The civil service in most nations is like a 'turtle' that moves on the beach. Efficiency is lacking. Red tape seems to be the norm.
LimeHorse5802: I strongly believe MCA should go it alone in the 16th general election (GE16), without aligning with BN. It's increasingly likely that Umno will side with Perikatan Nasional and for good reason - Harapan is losing Malay support at a faster rate than Umno. An alliance between Umno and Harapan will not benefit anyone, least of all MCA.
If MCA remains under Harapan's umbrella, it will be constrained by incumbency policies, likely limited to just two parliamentary seats. Meanwhile, many within DAP may disagree, but the reality is that DAP is currently at one of its weakest points.
Now is the time for MCA to contest as a standalone party, focusing on non-Malay voters, particularly the Chinese electorate. Once you win seats, you can cherry-pick the coalition to form the next government.
Of course, this strategy comes with a caveat: MCA must be prepared for the challenge. Objectively, the party has become more vocal and has gained some credibility, but more is needed. It's time to fully unleash your strengths: activate your vast network of business contacts, leverage your two universities to support the educational needs of the marginalised, and most importantly, mobilise your financial war chest.
WhiteCarp4942: MCA, please contest on your own, don't cling to BN. You are MCA because BN made you so. Now BN has made the other party much, much more MCA than you. So, you are now much, much less MCA than they are.
I voted for the other MCA because they were not MCA previously. Now that they are much, much more MCA than you, I'll vote for the lesser MCA, you, if there is no other option.
I'm not alone. Many hate the greater MCA more than the little MCA. They became the bigger MCA in less than a term. If you still contest under BN, then you are both equally MCA. Don't complain if you are dumped again. You have an opportunity to rejuvenate, don't waste this opportunity.
EmEmKay: While we acknowledge that Umno, MCA, and MIC were instrumental in Malaysia's fight for independence, it's essential to recognise that since the 1990s, these parties have become complacent and disconnected from the needs of the people.
This complacency has led to a culture that condones corruption, exemplified by the silence of BN leaders during the 1MDB scandal. Billions were misappropriated under then-prime minister Najib Razak's watch without any dissent from within the coalition.
On the other hand, the current performance of DAP leaders has been commendable, as they seem more in tune with the citizens' needs and interests. While we cannot forget the historical contributions of MCA and MIC, it is crucial to advocate for accountability and transparency moving forward.
The above is a selection of comments posted by Malaysiakini subscribers. Only paying subscribers can post comments. In the past year, Malaysiakinians have posted over 100,000 comments. Join the Malaysiakini community and help set the news agenda. Subscribe now.
These comments are compiled to reflect the views of Malaysiakini subscribers on matters of public interest. Malaysiakini does not intend to represent these views as fact.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
28 minutes ago
- The Star
China's civil servants banned from dining out in Xi's austerity drive
BEIJING: Some Chinese civil servants have been ordered not to dine out in groups of more than three after deaths linked to excessive alcohol consumption at banquets, according to interviews and social media posts, as Beijing's austerity push ramps up. Revised austerity regulations released in May targeting Communist Party members and public sector workers now bans lavish banquets, "white elephant" infrastructure projects, luxurious car fittings and ornamental plants in work meetings. Analysts say the renewed push is a sign of President Xi Jinping's longstanding preoccupation with anti-corruption and Party discipline, suggesting previous controls were not effective. "The drinking culture among civil servants is indeed quite serious but they haven't found a good solution yet so can only implement a 'one size fits all' policy," said Alfred Wu, associate professor at the National University of Singapore. "While Beijing wants to boost consumption, clean government - which is Xi's fundamental priority - has a price." The measures come after three widely publicised cases of cadre deaths since April linked to excessive drinking at banquets. Dozens of officials have been punished in connection to the deaths in Hunan, Anhui and Henan provinces, where they attempted to conceal details of the banquets and privately compensate the families of the deceased. But new dining guidelines promoted by some localities this week go even further, asking cadres to be wary of social gatherings, not treat bosses or underlings to meals, and avoid "forming small cliques", according to a social media post by a Communist Party body in Anhui province. "When dining with ordinary colleagues, groups of under three are usually fine," read the post, titled 'does it violate regulations to dine with colleagues after work'. "Avoid dining in high-end places, do not constantly meet the same people, do not take the opportunity to form 'small cliques'." The guidance triggered a rare outpouring of complaints on social media from one of the most tightly-controlled groups in China, who increasingly feel that their personal lives are subject to excessive and arbitrary restrictions. "Eating alone is hedonism, eating in a pair is engaging in improper male-female relations, eating in a trio is forming small cliques," read a comment from a user in Hunan province with over 3,500 likes. "Three of us colleagues went out for hotpot at lunch and each of us were punished with a warning," wrote a civil servant in Shandong province. "This is overcorrection, the essence of the guidelines is not wasting public money on lavish banquets but at each level of bureaucracy it gets enforced more harshly," wrote a user in Guangxi region. A civil servant in Sichuan province said her colleagues were ordered to always go straight home after work. Another cadre in Anhui province said her office recently started implementing daily breathalyser tests, while one in Shaanxi province said she was told to get rid of her office plants. Another civil servant in Gansu province was asked to study a list of 20 types of dinner gatherings to avoid, while a state-owned enterprise worker in Wuhan was ordered not to eat lunch with colleagues from other departments or bosses. "Our leader stressed that even if I invite someone in our canteen, spend little and pay the bill, that's not allowed", citing Party discipline, she said. Some cadres in Anhui even reported cold calls from local discipline inspectors asking them to recall the rules from memory or be reported to their supervisors. However, three civil servants in Beijing, rural Guangdong province and Chongqing told Reuters their workplaces did not have excessive implementation. Others told Reuters they welcomed the regulations, as they hated being peer-pressured into drinking with their bosses. The rules supplement the "eight-point regulations", a code of conduct intended to curb rampant corruption in China's vast bureaucracy, which Xi launched soon after taking power in 2012. The number of cadres nationwide punished for violating the 2012 thrift regulations ballooned from 9,292 in February to over 16,500 in April, the latest month for which figures are available. - Reuters
The Star
28 minutes ago
- The Star
Want to file for divorce in China? You might need a booking agent
SINGAPORE: Chinese medical office worker Qin Meng has found a lucrative side-hustle: she wakes up before midnight, fills in her clients' divorce certificate applications on a government website, then hits the confirm button exactly at the top of the hour. Miss it by seconds and the daily slots are "gone in the blink of an eye," says the 30-year-old, who charges 400 yuan (US$56) for her service, bringing relief to couples who have sometimes spent six months trying for a slot. Demographers say the emergence of impromptu agents like Qin, who advertise on Chinese social media, is another sign of how the slowing economy is piling financial stress on married couples and contributing to the breakdown of relationships. The 2024 divorce rate has yet to be announced by the National Bureau of Statistics, but Yi Fuxian, a Chinese demographer and senior scientist at University of Wisconsin-Madison, expects it to hit 2.6 per 1,000 people, against a low of 2.0 during the Covid-19 pandemic. This compares with the most recent rates of 1.5 in Japan and 1.8 in South Korea. "Poverty destroys marriage," said Yi, warning divorce numbers were inversely correlated with birth rates and could worsen the country's demographic crisis. "China's economic downturn in recent years and the rising youth unemployment rate have reduced the economic capacity of families, exacerbated family conflicts, and thereby increased the divorce rate." While the economy is expanding at about 5% a year, Chinese households have been saving more because of concerns about job security and the impact of a prolonged property crisis. Much of the economic growth has relied on export competitiveness, but Chinese firms, hit by US tariffs, have cut jobs or lowered pay to reduce costs, while millions of fresh university graduates are struggling to find work. The rising financial pressure was thrust into the spotlight last year after a driver rammed his car into a crowd killing 35 people in what was the country's deadliest attack in recent history. The court found that at the time of his offence, the driver was angry with his divorce settlement. He was sentenced to death. Soon after, the bi-monthly Communist Party magazine Qiushi re-published a 2016 speech by President Xi Jinping that argued "harmonious families lead to a stable society." In a further sign that the rebound in divorces is driven by financial strain, demographers point at data showing lower divorce rates in affluent coastal areas and higher ones in poorer inner and northern regions. Zhou Minghui booked her divorce appointment herself on the fifth attempt, after weeks of worry that her ex-husband might change his mind about their separation. Zhou said her motivation for divorce was what she described as her ex's "reckless financial investments". He had lost nearly four million yuan in the stock market in the space of three years, forcing the couple to sell their home, she said. Even then they were only able to repay just over half of the debt he had taken to buy the shares. "When the economy is in a downturn, people shouldn't be so eager to invest or consume,' said 38-year-old Zhou, who works in the education industry in the southern city of Shenzhen. The Covid-era drop in divorce appears increasingly like an anomaly. Demographers say it was the result not only of the shutdown of non-essential public services, but also by the 2021 introduction of a 30-day mandatory cool-off period for couples seeking amicable divorce outside the courts. Couples need to get on the Civil Affairs Department's website twice - before and after that month-long breather - to book appointments to register their divorce. But the demand now far exceeds the available daily slots. The agents, people like Qin, have figured this out and advertise their services for anything from 50 yuan to 999 yuan. Qin has earned 5,000 yuan, nearly half her monthly salary from her day job, since she started the side gig "for fun" in March. She receives multiple daily enquiries and expects to earn much more. "The economy is not great, so there's more pressure at work and more conflicts in marriage," Qin said. "Divorce rates will keep rising." - Reuters
The Star
an hour ago
- The Star
MCA urges govt to clarify data collection practices, not penalise public inquiry
KUALA LUMPUR: The government must respond to public concerns with transparency rather than resort to punitive measures against those who raise legitimate questions, says Datuk Dr Mah Hang Soon. The MCA deputy president was referring to the investigation launched against Pahang MCA Youth chief Wong Siew Mun after she posted a TikTok video on June 7 questioning if the government, via telecommunications companies, is collecting personal mobile data for surveillance purposes. 'This shouldn't be a 'don't ask, don't tell' situation,' Dr Mah said, stressing that Wong's concerns reflect growing unease among Malaysians over the lack of clarity on how personal data is being handled and whether consent is truly respected. He said the issue should be addressed with facts, not fear. 'A healthy, confident government does not punish those who raise questions," said Dr Mah in a statement on Tuesday (June 17). "Democracy means tolerating uncomfortable questions and opposing views,' he added. Also read: MCA will fully support Pahang Youth chief, says Dr Wee Dr Mah said Wong's queries were neither baseless nor conspiratorial, but instead raised valid concerns about data transparency, especially in an age of digital transformation and open data initiatives. He criticised the authorities' frequent use of Section 233 of the Communications and Multimedia Act 1998, originally intended to curb misuse of network services—saying it has become a habitual tool to silence voices of public interest. 'What truly deserves scrutiny is not Wong's video, but whether the government is collecting personal data without consent,' he said. Also read: Dr Wee questions probe against MCA youth leader over mobile data criticism MCA, he stressed, is not advocating for unregulated speech, but for a government that holds itself to a higher standard of openness and accountability. 'If the government has nothing to hide, it can answer the question by not criminalising the inquiry," added Dr Mah
