logo
Beyond the boardroom: the true weight of directorship

Beyond the boardroom: the true weight of directorship

IOL News26-05-2025

In the evolving architecture of corporate governance, there is often confusion between having a seat at the table and truly discharging the duties that come with it, says the author.
Image: Pixabay
You can sit on a board and still fall short of leadership.
In the evolving architecture of corporate governance, there is often confusion between having a seat at the table and truly discharging the duties that come with it.
Being a director is not ceremonial; it is a fiduciary commitment. One that demands more than occasional attendance and rubber-stamping decisions. It demands diligence, judgement, independence, and above all, accountability. Too often, we invoke the language of 'oversight' or 'strategy' in vague terms. But what does it actually mean to govern well?
South African company law sets the standard with quiet clarity. Directors must act honestly and with the care and skill expected of someone entrusted with protecting the interests of others. They must remain free of conflicts, act in the best interests of the company and make informed decisions. It is not the avoidance of mistakes that protects directors. It is the demonstration of proper conduct and reasonable judgement.
When directors fall short of this, consequences follow. And those consequences are not theoretical.In 2017, the Steinhoff International scandal sent shockwaves through boardrooms across the country. What was once considered a darling of the JSE unravelled into a cautionary tale of unchecked ambition, accounting irregularities and weak board oversight. While much of the public narrative focused on Markus Jooste and the executive team, scrutiny inevitably turned to the board. What did the non-executive directors know? When did they know it? And did they ask the right questions, or any questions at all?
A forensic investigation found failures in financial oversight, with billions in overstated profits and fabricated deals across subsidiaries. The board had approved complex transactions it did not fully understand, and in some cases, did so without full disclosure from management. But here lies the critical point: ignorance is not a defence. Directors are expected to take reasonable steps to remain informed. If a director lacks financial literacy or sectoral knowledge, it is their duty to acquire it, or to probe until they understand. The law does not shield those who look away.
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute
Current Time
0:00
/
Duration
-:-
Loaded :
0%
Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently behind live
LIVE
Remaining Time
-
0:00
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque
Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps
Reset
restore all settings to the default values Done
Close Modal Dialog
End of dialog window.
Advertisement
Next
Stay
Close ✕
Several Steinhoff directors later resigned, reputations tarnished, as the company's value collapsed and lawsuits mounted. Whether or not each individual director was complicit in fraud became secondary. What mattered was whether they had fulfilled their duty of care. And for many, the record showed they had not.
Contrast this with a very different, but equally telling case: Capitec Bank, which in 2018 faced an aggressive short-seller report accusing it of reckless lending and misleading financial statements. The board was thrust into a high-stakes moment. But instead of panicking, Capitec's leadership responded with transparency, data and composure. They engaged the regulator, issued detailed counterstatements and clarified the business model to the public. The regulator's subsequent investigation found no evidence of wrongdoing, vindicating the board's approach. Within weeks, investor confidence began to return.
What set Capitec apart was not luck, but governance. Long before the crisis, the bank had invested in a strong board culture, characterised by diversity in expertise, rigorous processes and shared values. Directors were regularly briefed on emerging risks, encouraged to challenge assumptions and given access to independent advisors. So, when the moment came to exercise judgement under pressure, they were ready. They acted with the care, skill and diligence that governance demands and the law respects.
These two cases reveal a profound truth about directorship: liability hinges not on the decisions themselves, but on how they are made. South African law recognises this. Directors who act in good faith, are free from conflict, are properly informed and act in the best interests of the company remain protected, even if the outcome of their decision proves flawed. This is the essence of the Business Judgment Rule. While the rule rewards rigor rather than results, true rigor demands more than mere rubber-stamping. It offers no blanket immunity, only fairness to those who demonstrate they properly applied their judgement and followed due process.
But herein lies the trap: too many directors confuse consensus with sound judgement, and compliance with conscience. They nod through meetings, approve budgets they haven't read and outsource thinking to consultants or executives. In so doing, they betray not only the company, but also the very purpose of the board.To govern is to care enough to confront. To be curious. To demand clarity. And to accept that duty is not always convenient. It is the director who speaks when others stay silent that earns the law's protection, not the one who watches passively and signs off anyway.
There is no shortage of charters or codes. What we lack, at times, is courage. Courage to ask the uncomfortable questions, to speak when silence is safer, to act when others defer and to hold the line when it would be easier to look away.
As we reflect on what it means to serve on a board, particularly in a climate of mounting public scrutiny, economic pressure and stakeholder activism, it becomes clear that the title 'director' must be reclaimed as a moral imperative, not just a legal obligation. Why? Because when things go wrong, and they often do, the question will not be whether you were in the room. The question will be what you did when you were.In considering the true responsibility of directorship, I offer these questions for reflection:
⦁ Do you understand the company's risks well enough to explain them to a stranger?
⦁ Are you engaging with management critically, or merely observing from a distance?
⦁ Can you evidence how your decisions have been made, and why?
⦁ And, perhaps most importantly, if your decisions were challenged in hindsight, would they reflect good faith and sound judgement?Because directorship is not a shield. It is a spotlight. And it shines brightest when things go dark.
Nqobani Mzizi is a Professional Accountant (SA), Cert. Dir (IoDSA) and an Academic.
Image: Supplied

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Omoda C9 review: Powerful hybrid SUV delivers impressive performance and efficiency
Omoda C9 review: Powerful hybrid SUV delivers impressive performance and efficiency

The Citizen

timean hour ago

  • The Citizen

Omoda C9 review: Powerful hybrid SUV delivers impressive performance and efficiency

Blasting onto South African shores with 440kW and 915N.m, the C9 PHEV spearheads Omoda's local new-energy vehicle offensive. CAR Magazine samples the new C9 flagship in Gauteng. First impressions here… Looking for your next new or used vehicle? Find it here with CARmag! Fast facts: Omoda C9 PHEV Price: R999 000 Powertrain: 1.5l, four-cylinder, turbopetrol + electric motors Transmission: three-speed DHT Driven wheels: Four Power: 440kW Torque: 915N.m Top speed: N/a 0-100 km/h: 4.9 seconds* Fuel consumption: 1.4l/100km CO 2 emissions: N/a *Claimed figures What are we driving? Launched alongside the Jaecoo J7 SHS (Super Hybrid System), which we sampled before its official South African launch, we are driving the Omoda C9 PHEV. Positioned as the new flagship in Omoda SA's C9 lineup, the PHEV derivative spearheads the Chinese marque's new-energy vehicle (NEV) offensive. The C9 PHEV (or SHS, the namesake that will replace 'PHEV' to align with the plug-in hybrid Jaecoo's) employs a 1.5l, four-cylinder turbopetrol engine and a quartet of electric motors. The PHEV arrangement produces a total system output of 440kW and 915N.m. Delivered to all four corners via a three-speed dedicated hybrid transmission (DHT), the automaker says these figures allow the C9 PHEV to complete the 0-100km/h sprint in 4.9 seconds. Omoda claims an average fuel consumption of 1.4l/100km when the battery is replenished and a still-impressive 6.9l/100km when the 34.5kWh item is discharged. Capable of accepting up to 70kW at a DC fast charging station, the firm says a 30 to 80% DC charge takes between 20 and 25 minutes. Noteworthy, the PHEV setup offers claimed electric-only driving of up to 150km and a combined operating range of 1 100km. Exclusively available in top-tier, Explore level of specification, the C9 PHEV is generously equipped as standard. The package includes such items as (deep breath) 12.3-inch digital instrumentation and touchscreen infotainment, the latter incorporating Apple CarPlay/Android Auto screen mirroring; 50W wireless smartphone charging; a 12-speaker Sony sound system; dual-zone climate control with rear air-con; electrically adjustable heated/ventilated front pews; heated rear seats, replete with reclining function, and multifunction steering wheel; a surround-view camera array supplemented by fore and aft park distance sensors; and a panoramic sunroof. Safety items include seven airbags, Isofix child-seat anchorages and a bouquet of advanced driver assistance systems. The latter includes adaptive cruise control, blind-spot monitoring, lane-departure warning, lane-change assist and automatic emergency braking, among other features. The cabin is spacious, with fore and aft occupants afforded plenty of head- and kneeroom. Omoda claims a luggage capacity of 660l, which expands to 1 783l when folding down the rear seatbacks. However, it is worth mentioning that the 2.0TGDI 400T AWD derivative, which has the same claimed boot/utility capacity, swallowed 328/1 068l worth of our ISO blocks when evaluated for our December 2024 road test. Related: Review: Jaecoo J7 SHS (PHEV) What are the Omoda C9 PHEV's rivals? The new-energy C9's PHEV rivals come in the shape of the (SA-built) BMW X3 30e xDrive, which we sampled at the local launch in 2025, and Volvo XC60 T8 Recharge, priced from R1 260 000 and R1 314 000, respectively. As a reminder, the plug-in hybrid X3's petrol-electric powertrain comprises a 140kW/310N.m, 2l, four-cylinder turbopetrol and 135kW/250N.m electric motor for a combined system output of 220kW and 450N.m. The X3 30e's average fuel consumption and electric-only operating range are a claimed 1.1l/100km and 90km. BMW quotes a 0-100km/h sprint time of 6.2 seconds and 215km/h top speed for its new-generation new-energy X3. The Volvo XC60 T8 Recharge's 233kW/400N.m, 2l, four-cylinder super- and turbocharged petrol internal combustion engine is assisted by a 107kW/309N.m electric motor. The Gothenburg-based brand's midsize plug-in hybrid SUV produces peak power and torque outputs of 340kW and 709N.m for a claimed 0-100km/h sprint time of 4.8 seconds, making it one-tenth of a second quicker to the three-figure marker than the car driven here, and 180km/h top speed. Related: Review: BMW X3 30e xDrive What is the Omoda C9 PHEV like to drive? Stepping inside (via standard-fitment keyless entry), the C9 PHEV's Nappa leather-upholstered cabin is a comfortable place sit. Perceived interior build quality is good and contributes to the Omoda's impressive levels of NVH suppression. The C9 PHEV is a comfortable drive, with its suspension setup soaking up most road imperfections with aplomb. The steering is generally direct. However, the calibration of the setup would benefit from more weight as it feels a touch too light and void of feedback at low-speed manoeuvring and when pushing on. Noteworthy, the C9 PHEV doesn't seem to suffer from the throttle calibration issues we've previously experienced in several other Chinese vehicles. The drivetrain delivers power to all four corners in a smooth fashion. A brief stop at Gerotek allowed us to test this C9's straight-line performance. Admittedly, this is not what the C9 PHEV was built for. Yet, considering its performance SUV-matching outputs and claimed 0-100km/h sprint time, we were keen to test just how it performs in the acceleration stakes. The powertrain exhibited some latency off the line and, as impressive as the C9 PHEV's outputs are on paper, it curiously didn't quite feel like there's 440kW/915N.m on hand. However, the Omoda is plenty quick and overtaking on the motorway is fuss-free. Related: Review: Omoda C9 AWD Explore Verdict Featuring a solidly constructed, capacious and tech-laden cabin, easy-to-drive characteristics, road-holding manners and admirable fuel economy, the C9 PHEV ticks a lot of boxes. Though, from first impressions, it doesn't feel as powerful as the outputs on its spec sheet would suggest. However, that's not what it was built for; it was made to offer the driver and occupants an exceptionally comfortable driving experience. And the Omoda majors in this. Browse thousands of new and used vehicles here with CARmag! The post Review: Omoda C9 PHEV appeared first on CAR Magazine. Breaking news at your fingertips… Follow Caxton Network News on Facebook and join our WhatsApp channel. Nuus wat saakmaak. Volg Caxton Netwerk-nuus op Facebook en sluit aan by ons WhatsApp-kanaal.

Donald Trump to dump his Tesla after Elon Musk row?
Donald Trump to dump his Tesla after Elon Musk row?

The South African

timean hour ago

  • The South African

Donald Trump to dump his Tesla after Elon Musk row?

Donald Trump may offload a Tesla he said he bought earlier this year in a show of support for Elon Musk, a White House official said, following a blazing row between the US president and his billionaire former advisor. The red electric vehicle, which retails for around $80 000, was still in a parking lot on the White House grounds last Friday, an AFP reporter said, a day after the very public meltdown between Trump and the South Africa-born tech tycoon. 'He's thinking about it, yes,' a senior White House official told AFP when asked if the Republican would sell or give away the Tesla. Tesla stocks had tanked more than 14 percent amid the row, losing some $100 billion of the company's market value. Trump, who does not drive as a president, said he was buying the Tesla in March to boost support for his mega-donor, whose brand – and bottom line – has been hit hard by public outrage over his role in slashing US government jobs. At a choreographed publicity stunt that turned the White House into a pop-up Tesla showroom, Trump praised the EV as a 'great product' and lashed out on social media at 'Radical Left' attacks against the world's richest person and his company. Trump's Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt and another senior aide posed in the car as recently as last week, in a photograph posted on Musk's social media network X. 'Taking President Trump's Tesla out for a ride,' Trump's communications advisor Margo Martin posted. But the shiny red vehicle has now become an awkward symbol of the fiery political divorce between Trump, 78, and former Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) chief Musk, 53. Trump said he was 'very disappointed' by Musk and threatened to end his government contracts after his ex-aide criticised the president's flagship budget and policy mega-bill as an 'abomination.' Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1 Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news. By Garrin Lambley © Agence France-Presse

FNB empowers South Africans with new financial literacy platform
FNB empowers South Africans with new financial literacy platform

The Citizen

time2 hours ago

  • The Citizen

FNB empowers South Africans with new financial literacy platform

Website teaches key topics including money management, debt, and more. FNB recently announced the launch of its new online financial education hub, in a bid to ramp up its consumer education efforts and improve financial literacy outcomes among South African communities. The website, which is open to all South Africans regardless of which financial institution they bank with, features free registration and access to micro learning modules, articles, videos, and other content formats to empower users with financial education. The bank also notes that those who register for financial education on Fincents will be able to download content to allow for learning offline. 'According to the FSCA Financial Literacy Baseline Survey, 48% of South African adults struggle with basic financial literacy. And, with women and underserved communities bearing the brunt of this knowledge gap, we view it as critical for us to open up our capabilities and expertise to empower South Africans from all walks of life with potentially life-changing financial knowledge,' says FNB's Personal Segment CEO, Lytania Johnson. FNB's data shows that consumers tend to have specific and apparent financial education needs, such as access to content that relies less on complicated financial language and terminology. Our data shows that South Africans have general fear and anxiety when it comes to the topic of personal finances. Moreover, consumer education data also shows that financial information is not always easily retained by individuals after a single interaction. As a result, to enhance knowledge retention, education efforts need to be centred on addressing these challenges in an appropriate and easily digestible manager. 'With this in mind, we have tailored the content and information available on the Fincents website to meet these requirements by offering users core financial education support. Our team tapped into its experience working in communities across the country and partnered with digital content experts to craft an interactive learning platform that allows users to learn through storytelling, quizzes, and contextual content,' says Dhashni Naidoo who is a programme manager at FNB Consumer Education. Fincents takes users through five content pillars and 13 combined themes ranging from topics such as budgeting, saving, identifying financial scams to managing debt, and retirement planning. 'Ultimately, our aim in this knowledge transfer exercise is not only to improve financial literacy levels but also to positively and sustainably influence attitudes and perceptions about the importance of personal finances,' continues Johnson. Over the years, FNB's Consumer Education unit has invested in community workshops, radio outreach, and social media content. The bank reaches over 70 000 consumers annually through its workshops, which are long format, interactive learning experiences. Additionally, FNB has extensive coverage on community, regional and vernacular radio stations, providing content in seven South African languages. 'What's exciting about Fincents is the fact that it will allow us to empower as many South Africans as possible with accessible and interactive multimedia learning tools – something that we haven't yet done as a bank, until now,' adds Naidoo. With the bank set on establishing Fincents as a trusted and well-used source of financial education among a broad cross-section of the population, it also intends to provide content in various South African languages and sustainably improve financial literacy levels among users. In fact, this first phase of the website is just one of the steps FNB is taking to ensure it further develops its existing consumer education efforts. Over time, the bank plans to enhance the website's features and expand content areas to meet the growing financial literacy needs of consumers. 'We're actively exploring including content around additional subject areas like homeownership, vehicle finance, cryptocurrency, and more. We also plan to include specialised content tailored to niche audiences, such as educators (for use in the classroom) and parents (for age-appropriate financial conversations with their children).' Naidoo continues. Financial literacy is not only critical on an individual level, says Johnson, adding: 'It's also critical for families, communities, and the broader economy. And, by opening the platform up to all South Africans, FNB hopes to be able to play a critical role in improving the quality of financial inclusion, increasing financial wellness and financial stability among vulnerable members of our communities, and empowering them to secure their financial futures.'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store