Brazil's outspoken first lady is coming under fire, but she refuses to stop speaking out
SAO PAULO — In early May, an air of triumph filled a dinner in Beijing, where Brazil's President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva celebrated a diplomatic victory: businessmen travelling with him said they had secured billions of dollars in investments as the veteran leader renewed his international prestige standing alongside his Chinese counterpart, Xi Jinping .
But then Brazilian first lady Rosângela da Silva, better known as Janja, raised her hand.
Although no one was expected to speak, da Silva addressed Xi, saying that Chinese social media company TikTok posed a challenge for leftists, claiming its algorithm favors right-wingers. China's president reportedly answered. The exchange was leaked to Brazilian media by the time dessert was served.
Lula's government is grappling with unpopularity that has dented his credentials as the frontrunner for reelection next year. Some analysts, including members of his government, attribute this partly to his wife's perceived overstepping in what was once a ceremonial role.
Janja, a 58-year-old sociologist, has drawn criticism for insulting tech billionaire Elon Musk , mocking the suicide of a pro-Jair Bolsonaro supporter and advising the president on how to use the military during the Jan. 8, 2023 riots in the capital, Brasilia. Still, she insists she will speak out whenever it serves the public interest.
A Datafolha poll released June 12 found that 36% of Brazilians think the first lady's actions hurt the government, while 14% say they are helpful. It was the pollster's first measure of the first lady's approval.
The same poll showed Lula with a 40% job disapproval rating, an 8 percentage point increase from October 2024.
Brazil's presidency said in a statement to The Associated Press on June 20 that da Silva adheres to the solicitor-general's office guidelines, adding that she 'acts as a citizen, combining her public visibility with the experience she has built throughout her professional career in support of relevant social issues and matters of public interest.'
Under guidelines published by the solicitor-general's office, the president's spouse primarily fulfills 'a symbolically representative role on behalf of the president in a social, cultural, ceremonial, political or diplomatic nature.' For many of her critics, this does not grant her the authority to speak as a government representative.
Brazilian media have reported that government ministers, lawmakers and staunch leftist campaigners are privately raising concerns about the first lady being a hindrance more than an asset. These worries have skyrocketed since the incident in China — even as Lula himself has praised his wife for speaking out.
'It looks like Brazil is governed by a couple,' said Beatriz Rey, a political science postdoctoral and research fellow at the University of Lisbon. 'When (the first lady) says there won't be any protocols to silence her, she disrespects our democratic institutions for she has no elected office, no government position. It is not about being a woman or a feminist. It is undue interference.'
Lula's first wife, Maria de Lourdes, died in 1971. His second, Marisa Letícia, died in 2017. Lula, 79, and Janja said they met in 2017 and started seeing each other frequently during the leftist leader's 580 days in jail in the city of Curitiba between 2018 and 2019. They married in 2022.
Many supporters of Lula's Workers' Party partly attribute the criticism against the first lady to misinformation and disinformation. In May, the party launched the 'I am with Janja' social media campaign in her defense. But the week-long effort garnered less than 100,000 views and only a few hundred comments.
'Janja is an asset because she rejuvenates Lula, everyone in the government understands that, even her critics,' a Brazilian government source told the AP. 'No one wants to alienate her. But many important people in Brasilia, friends and allies of Lula, do understand that by overstepping she brings some of her rejection to the president.'
The source, who spoke under condition of anonymity for lack of authorization to speak about the matter publicly, often travels with the president and the first lady.
Adriana Negreiros, a journalist who profiled the first lady for a 2024 podcast titled 'Janja,' said that allies of the president who criticize her do it with extreme caution.
'(Janja) dances, sings, speaks out, appears at official events and meetings with heads of state. She insists on being present and vocal,' Negreiros said. 'There's a lot of sexism and misogyny directed at her, no doubt. But not all criticism is sexist.'
Da Silva said she doesn't go to dinners 'just to accompany' her husband.
'I have common sense. I consider myself an intelligent person. So I know very well what my limits are. I'm fully aware of that,' she told a podcast of daily Folha de S. Paulo.
Da Silva did, however, express remorse during the same podcast for the expletive she used against Musk in 2024, once a close ally of U.S. President Donald Trump .
Many of Lula's adversaries say they want the first lady to remain in the spotlight.
'The more she speaks, the more she holds a microphone, the more she helps the right wing,' said Nikolas Ferreira, one of Brazil's most popular right-wing lawmakers.
Ferreira, a prominent social media figure, claims the role of regulating social media is a matter for Brazil's Congress, not for the first lady to debate with foreign leaders like Xi.
Da Silva is also expected to play as a keen hostess at the BRICS summit in Rio on July 6-7, a role her husband is almost certain not to oppose.
'She will be wherever she wants,' Lula told journalists in March following criticism for sending the first lady as his representative to a nutrition summit in Paris that month.
'She will say what she wants and go wherever she wants.'
____
Follow AP's coverage of Latin America and the Caribbean at https://apnews.com/hub/latin-america
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Forbes
28 minutes ago
- Forbes
Forbes Daily: Elon Musk Ousts Key Tesla Executive Amid Declining Sales
As Tesla grapples with a sales crisis, Elon Musk has fired one of its top executives. Musk removed Omead Afshar, the EV maker's head of operations in North America and Europe, following the news that vehicle sales dropped for the fifth consecutive month in Europe, and analysts expect its worldwide EV deliveries to decline at least 10%. With Musk's role at DOGE and support of President Donald Trump weighing on the brand, the company needs to improve its lineup to compete with growing rivals. Instead, Musk is betting the firm's future on robotaxis, having launched a pilot version of the service in Austin earlier this Powell still has almost a year left in his stint as Federal Reserve Chairman, but President Donald Trump already appears to be closing in on announcing his replacement, as he has attacked Powell for not lowering interest rates. Trump has discussed naming a successor by September or even sooner, the Wall Street Journal reported, even as Powell himself—who was appointed by Trump during his first term—was named only three months before taking over back in 2018. The Senate parliamentarian threw a wrench in the GOP's plans to pass President Donald Trump's 'One Big Beautiful Bill' by July 4, as she ruled Senate Republicans can't fast-track some of the Medicaid cuts included in the House version. Parliamentarian Elizabeth MacDonough, responsible for interpreting Senate rules and procedure, ruled that the changes were outside the scope of fiscal policy, meaning they can't be passed via the reconciliation process that allows for a simple majority vote, rather than the typical 60 votes. MORE: A vote on the Senate's version of the bill could come as early as this week, but before it can head to Trump's desk, both Houses must pass the exact same legislation. And while Dave Camp, former Chairman of the Committee on Ways and Means, noted recently in a webinar for Forbes members that historically, 'the rule of thumb is the House has to accept what the Senate can pass,' thin margins in the House make that Donald Trump's sweeping policy bill includes a major overhaul of student loans, like imposing lifetime borrowing limits and axing most repayment plans, in order to fund tax cuts. The specifics are still in flux, and the parliamentarian also struck down some student loan proposals, but advocates have argued the changes will drive more students to take out private loans. Federal prosecutors want to deport Kilmar Abrego Garcia after he is released from a Tennessee jail and before his trial on human smuggling charges. Attorneys for Abrego Garcia, who was deported to El Salvador due to an 'administrative error' in March before being returned to the U.S., are pushing to return him to his home state of Maryland, but Justice Department prosecutors told a judge that they want him deported to a 'third country.' SPORTS + ENTERTAINMENT John Nacion/Variety via Getty Images After nearly four decades, Anna Wintour will step down as editor-in-chief of Vogue's U.S. edition, though she will continue in her roles as parent company Condé Nast's global chief content officer and as Vogue's global editorial director. Wintour took the reins of U.S. Vogue in 1988, and has been credited for reviving the magazine's appeal in the face of competition, plus she co-chaired the annual Met Gala. DAILY COVER STORY How This Hollywood Producer Turned Brad Pitt Into A $40 Million 'F1' Ad PA Wire/PA Images For the past three years, Apple has been selling F1 as a can't-miss summer blockbuster set in the high-octane world of Formula 1, with the prestige of producer Jerry Bruckheimer, director Joseph Kosinski and star Brad Pitt. But for David Leener, the producer in charge of the movie's product placement, his sales pitch was far simpler—turning one of the world's highest-paid actors into a human billboard. For significant portions of the film, Pitt's character wears fire suits, helmets and other apparel adorned with more than a dozen logos for brands, including Mercedes, IWC, Geico, EA Sports and Expensify, each of which also have branding on the fictional APXGP team's car and paid millions for the privilege. Leener, a pioneer of brand integrations in movies for nearly 30 years, says he brought in more sponsor money for F1 than any film in his career—including Top Gun: Maverick , the two National Treasure pictures and several Transformer movies—by far. Forbes estimates Leener's sponsorships for F1 have brought in at least $40 million, a significant part of a production budget that may be as high as $300 million. Leener may be very good at his job, but sponsorship in Formula One and product placement in the F1 movie are fundamentally different propositions. To get your company's logo in on the front wing of an actual F1 car would cost at least $5 million per year, according to The Race Media founder and CEO Andrew Van de Burgt, while title sponsorships range from $30 million at the lowest end to $100 million per year for the most popular teams. WHY IT MATTERS Movie sponsorship is clearly the cheaper of the two options, but in a racing movie those seconds can add up quickly. And, unlike in, say, a Marvel movie, corporate branding is already so deeply ingrained in the culture of F1 that seeing cars and driver apparel covered in logos adds to a movie's authenticity rather than distracting from it. MORE Formula 1's Highest-Paid Drivers 2024 FACTS + COMMENTS Pre-rolled marijuana joints, once considered a beginner's crutch, are now one of the cannabis industry's hottest commodities—driving $3.1 billion in sales in 2024: More than 316 million: The number of pre-rolls that Americans lit up in 2024 15%: The share pre-rolls represent of the entire legal market 80%: The share of cannabis users who consume multiple times daily STRATEGY + SUCCESS Most of us will make difficult career decisions at some point, whether it's to accept a promotion or leave a company. First, dispel the myth that you must be 100% sure about a choice—you can feel good about it even with 80% confidence. In order to reach that point of certainty, try listing the 'known unknowns' you'd like to learn or experience before making the choice, and work through as many of them as possible. VIDEO The moon and Mars will meet this weekend in a rare pairing that will make Mars look like which fruit? A. An apple B. A strawberry C. A cherry D. A pear Check your answer. Thanks for reading! This edition of Forbes Daily was edited by Sarah Whitmire and Chris Dobstaff.
Politico
2 hours ago
- Politico
Cuomo's analogue campaign
Presented by With help from Amira McKee Andrew Cuomo's campaign was built for the bygone cable TV era. Zohran Mamdani lapped him in a TikTok world. POLITICO reports today on the inside story of Cuomo's failed mayoral comeback bid, a campaign that fell flat with Democratic voters clamoring for someone who will address their affordability problems in a deeply expensive city. The former governor launched his bid with a 17-minute video, a sign he was paying little heed to decayed 21st century attention spans with a retro approach. And he relied on a tried-and-true strategy of raising a ton of cash, flooding the airwaves with ads and leaning into a storied political name. None of it worked against a generational talent like Mamdani, a 33-year-old democratic socialist with a scant resume who harnessed voters' abiding concerns over high rents. In contrast to the smiling Mamdani, Cuomo scowled his way through the five boroughs, often in a black Dodge Charger that enabled him to avoid traveling on the creaky mass transit system most New Yorkers use everyday. Cuomo focused on the past — like touting the renovation of LaGuardia Airport under his watch — in appearances that often felt like an aging rocker playing the hits on a farewell tour. 'This definitely felt like a 2025 fully optimized campaign versus a 1988 campaign,' Democratic strategist Trip Yang said. 'Cuomo looked like he was campaigning in black and white. Andrew Cuomo was never that formidable because this wasn't Andrew Cuomo in his prime.' Cuomo spokesperson Rich Azzopardi defended the campaign's approach and the support the ex-governor received. 'We are incredibly proud of the campaign we ran and the broad coalition that we built, including nearly every labor union, our elected endorsers, and everyday working class New Yorkers who supported our vision to get the city back on track,' he said. In the aftermath of his shattering loss, Cuomo's team began assessing and ascribing blame. Five people close to the campaign — granted anonymity to freely discuss what they believe went wrong — pointed to an anemic get-out-the-vote effort, even after data indicated Mamdani was surging with hundreds of thousands of New Yorkers who voted early. Cuomo's field operation relied heavily on labor unions working alongside an allied super PAC. He had paid canvassers, a phone banking program and texting operation. But it was no match for Mamdani's motivated army of volunteers who fanned out across the city to knock on doors and persuade new voters. By the time the ex-governor's team began to discuss a get-out-the-vote operation, it was a month too late, according to one of the five with direct knowledge of the campaign. 'Our turnout model targeted key districts and constituencies and we met those turnout goals — and got more votes than Eric Adams did four years ago,' Azzopardi said. 'However, Mamdani ran a campaign that managed to expand the electorate in such a way that no turnout model or poll was able to capture, while the rest of the field collapsed. As the governor said, the city is in crisis and these are serious times — we'll be looking at the final numbers and weighing our options on next steps.' — Nick Reisman and Sally Goldenberg HAPPY FRIDAY: Got news? Send it our way: Jeff Coltin, Emily Ngo and Nick Reisman. WHERE'S KATHY? In Albany and Franklin County appearing on North Country Public Radio and convening with local leaders impacted by federal policies. WHERE'S ERIC? Public schedule not available as of 10 p.m. Thursday. QUOTE OF THE DAY: 'I vote in Albany.' — Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand, when asked on WNYC about endorsing Mamdani and whether she would support Adams or Cuomo instead. ABOVE THE FOLD PIVOT TO THE GENERAL: Mamdani's team knows he's got a fight ahead of him. His aides and allies are girding for a costly battle in November against opponents bankrolled by a fired-up business class desperate to stop him from taking over the epicenter of world finance. Mamdani's campaign, as well as outside groups backing him in New York's mayoral election, said they are preparing to drop millions to counter those efforts, while also tapping into an asymmetric strategy to capture voters' attention through social media and a door-knocking volunteer army. 'My gut is that we're going to have to raise a lot more than we did and we're going to have to spend a lot more than we did in the primary,' said Regina Monge, chair of a pro-Mamdani super PAC. 'Corporate special interests and billionaires might want to throw down for Eric Adams. They might want to support Cuomo on his line. I don't know what folks' plans are, but I want to make sure that we're ready.' Mamdani has more perceived vulnerabilities than recent Democratic mayoral nominees. So one of the biggest tasks in front of him is uniting the fractured party after a divisive primary. He and his team have been working the phones, talking to elected officials and community leaders in New York and around the country — including Jewish leaders who opposed him in the primary. John Samuelsen, leader of the Transport Workers Union International, believes Mamdani is on the path to winning over more supporters. He said his union of subway and bus drivers still has some concerns about Mamdani when it comes to policing the subways, but he expects even those that backed Cuomo in the primary will shift their support. 'I do think you're going to see the trade unions coalesce around him,' he said. 'They viewed Cuomo as the sure win, like the favorite at the Kentucky Derby,' he added. 'Zohran has got to be the overwhelming favorite to win. And there are pragmatic unions who will enter a political relationship with him now.' Read more from POLITICO's Holly Otterbein and Jeff Coltin on how Mamdani is prepping for the general — and how the opposition campaign is still forming. CITY HALL: THE LATEST DSA-PANSION: The New York City chapter of the Democratic Socialists of America keeps expanding, as its standard-bearer Mamdani, the presumptive Democratic nominee for mayor, prepares for the general election. About 260 new members have joined since Primary Day on Tuesday, a chapter spokesperson told Playbook on Thursday. That's on top of the nearly 3,000 new members the chapter gained over the course of Mamdani's candidacy. The local DSA says it mobilized about 45,000 volunteers to door-knock for Mamdani this primary. — Emily Ngo POWER TO THE PEOPLE?: An evangelist for a massive publicly owned renewable energy build-out is poised to lead the nation's largest city — one that's heavily reliant on fossil fuels. Mamdani focused much of his campaign on affordability issues like providing free buses, freezing rents and creating city-run grocery stores. But he has a history of advocacy on climate issues as well, POLITICO Pro reports. 'I'm running for mayor to make the city more affordable and to take on the existential crisis of our time — climate change,' Mamdani said during a March candidate forum on climate. One of Mamdani's signature legislative priorities — although he wasn't the prime sponsor of the bill — was pushing for the New York Power Authority to build out new renewable energy generation. He's one of only two lawmakers who actively participated in Con Edison's last rate case and recently slammed the utility for seeking another bill hike. Mamdani also opposed a new gas plant in his district that was blocked by Gov. Kathy Hochul and sponsored an unsuccessful measure to ban new fossil fuel power plants. For climate advocates who backed him, the Queens assemblymember's victory is a refreshing antidote to the trend of Democrats de-prioritizing climate investments in favor of near-term affordability concerns. 'Our horizons have opened exponentially — and I'm really excited for the future for the first time, maybe, in my entire life,' said Daniel Goulden, the strategy co-chair of the New York City Democratic Socialists of America's Ecosocialists Working Group. — Marie J. French More from the city: — Negotiations on this year's city budget are coming down to the wire — with several sticking points remaining. (Daily News) — Cuomo's sexual harassment accusers called on state Comptroller Tom DiNapoli to cut off the former governor's taxpayer-fueled legal defense fund. (New York Post) — Harlem's One45 development got key clearance from the City Council after years of setbacks (THE CITY) NEW FROM PLANET ALBANY MAMDANI'S NEW YORK: Sent first to POLITICO Pro subscribers, Mamdani's desire to hike taxes on the richest New Yorkers has a receptive audience in the state Legislature. Six Democratic state lawmakers, speaking with POLITICO Pro following Mamdani's upset victory, said they would be open to his tax hike platform. Their support is key in a statehouse where mayoral proposals often go to die. Any income tax hike impacting New York City residents must be given approval in Albany, where Democrats control both legislative chambers. 'This is a message from a candidate proposing policies that people want,' said state Sen. Gustavo Rivera. 'That's not radical, it's not crazy. One of them is making sure we can afford this, is making sure we tax the wealthy a little bit more.' Moderate lawmakers from outside the city, including Hudson Valley state Sen. James Skoufis, were open to a tax hike. 'I'm perfectly comfortable with modest, targeted increases on millionaire's personal income tax rates so long as some of the revenue is dedicated to relief for middle- and working-class New Yorkers,' he said. Support from state lawmakers for a tax hike on the wealthiest earners will add ballast to Mamdani's push if he becomes New York City mayor, offering a counterweight to Gov. Kathy Hochul's opposition, which she reiterated Thursday. The governor and Mamdani, though, have a mutual interest in driving down the cost of living. 'I have been finding ways to reduce the cost of living in New York,' she said, ticking off support for more child care, housing and education services. — Nick Reisman More from Albany: — New York lawmakers say they are playing 'wac-a-mole' with so-called forever chemicals. (Times Union) — Assemblymember Jessica González-Rojas is considering a run for state Sen. Jessica Ramos' seat. (City & State) — Hochul sidestepped political questions raised by Mamdani becoming the likely mayoral nominee. (Gothamist) KEEPING UP WITH THE DELEGATION DEFENDING MAMDANI: Mamdani faced an ugly call Thursday for his denaturalization and deportation from Tennessee Republican Rep. Andy Ogles, who wrote to Attorney General Pam Bondi and disparaged the presumptive mayoral nominee as 'little muhammad.' But among Mamdani's defenders was one of his greatest critics in New York's Democratic House delegation: Rep. Ritchie Torres. 'It is no secret that I have profound disagreements with Zohran Mamdani,' wrote the Bronx Democrat. 'But every Democrat — and every decent person — should speak out with moral clarity against the despicable Islamophobic attacks that have been directed at him.' Torres, who endorsed Cuomo, is one of Israel's fiercest defenders, while Mamdani is one of its harshest critics. Mamdani, who was born in Uganda to Indian parents, is Muslim and a naturalized citizen. He faced a call for his deportation earlier in the primary from Republican City Council Member Vickie Paladino. 'This is what Trump and his sycophants have wrought,' Mamdani had responded then of the bigotry. — Emily Ngo AGREED ON AFFORDABILITY: New York House Democrats who acknowledged Mamdani as their party's pick for New York City mayor found something in his platform they could get onboard with, even as most shied from endorsing him: affordability. They commended him for focusing his campaign on cost of living, a nod to the challenges that animated voters in last year's presidential election. 'His campaign galvanized young voters and centered the fight for a more affordable city for all,' posted Rep. Greg Meeks, who had endorsed Cuomo, congratulating his fellow Queens lawmaker on his Primary Night performance. Rep. Adriano Espaillat, who also endorsed Cuomo, said that 'affordability continues to be the leading issue across NYC for the families who call our city home.' Reps. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, Nydia Velázquez and Jerry Nadler have endorsed Mamdani, calling for Democratic unity ahead of the November election. 'The radical socialist policies?' Velázquez asked on X, responding to criticism from GOP Rep. Mike Lawler. 'Making a New York City that everyone can afford.' — Emily Ngo More from Congress: — Many Democratic lawmakers and officials in Washington either denounced Mamdani or notably declined to rally around him. (Axios) — The White House is forging ahead with its demand that Congress pass its sweeping megabill by July 4. (POLITICO) — Senate Republicans are dealt a major blow on Medicaid cuts in the GOP megabill. (POLITICO) NEW YORK STATE OF MIND — ICE detainees are being held at a notorious Brooklyn jail with Diddy, Luigi Mangione, feds confirm. (Gothamist) — The MTA's 4 percent hike in fares and tolls could be delayed next year. (Newsday) — A video showed U.S. Attorney John Sarcone's encounter with a knife wielding man in downtown Albany. (Times Union) SOCIAL DATA IN MEMORIAM: Former Rep. Carolyn McCarthy, whose personal tragedy propelled her to launch a nearly two-decade congressional career as one of the nation's leading voices for gun control, died Wednesday of natural causes at her home in Fort Myers, Florida. She was 81. (Newsday) HAPPY BIRTHDAY: State Sen. Jessica Ramos (4-0) … Teresa Gonzalez of BSJ … Adam Chen of AG Letitia James' office … Edward Cerna of NYC Council Member Alexa Avilés' office … Carlos Beato of Pitta Bishop & Del Giorno … Trudy Mason … The New School's James Parrott … Nick Rizzo … Terri Smith-Caronia … Tony Fratto … Reuters' David Shepardson … NYT's Krista Mahr and Lisa Friedman … CNN's Carrie Stevenson … Charles Bronfman (94) … George Malkin … Paul Roveda … Scott Livingston … (WAS THURSDAY): Mikhail Khodorkovsky ... Toby Stavisky ... Elizabeth Pipko ... Irving H. Picard ... Austin Grossman ... Robert E. Levin Missed Thursday's New York Playbook PM? We forgive you. Read it here.
USA Today
2 hours ago
- USA Today
Is America's billionaire boom good for government, democracy? Tell us.
The two most conspicuous examples of the growth in billionaires' power are President Trump and Elon Musk, whom Trump brought in to slash government. We want to know how you feel about the power shift. Billionaires are having a day. The White House is a good example of this happy time for the wealthiest among us, since it is the residence (once more) of our first billionaire president, Donald Trump. It was there that he was joined briefly by the richest man in the world, Elon Musk, who slashed his way through much of the federal government, then exited to go tend to rockets, electric cars and other ventures. But not to worry. Left behind are five billionaires brought into office by Trump, the most of any administration. Those magnates spent hundreds of millions of dollars to reelect Trump and to throw him an inaugural party. Opinion: What's an oligarchy? With Trump's 'Big, Beautiful' bill, we're living in one. As a national phenomenon, the number of billionaires has grown from one in the 1920s (industrialist Henry Ford) to more than 900. Since the start of the 21st century, that group's wealth has expanded nine times, aided by Trump's 2017 tax cuts. For the country's lower half of earners, the expansion was double, mostly due to stimulus checks. I say all this to set up the question for you: What do we think of this conspicuous power of America's billionaires? Is the growing power of billionaires a good thing? Is it something to fear, as President Joe Biden warned on his way out the door, saying there is a growing oligarchy that "threatens our entire democracy, our basic rights and freedoms, and a fair shot for everyone to get ahead"? Or are these exceptional people whom we should celebrate? They are, after all, the group that brought us Starlink, a satellite system that kept Ukraine afloat in its war against Russia. And Amazon. (Boy, I like not going to the store to buy that thingy to fix my dryer. And I get it the next day!) Opinion: You're not really mad at the Bezos, Sánchez luxury Venice wedding. You're just poor. We want to know what you think. Take our poll below, or send us an email with the subject line "Forum billionaires" to forum@ We'll publish a collection of responses from all sides of the conversation in our next installment of the Opinion Forum. Do you want to take part in our next Forum? Join the conversation by emailing forum@ You can also follow us on X, formerly Twitter, @usatodayopinion and sign up for our Opinion newsletter to stay updated on future Forum posts.
