High court overturns B.C. sex assault conviction, clarifies ‘confusion' over evidence
The Supreme Court of Canada is pictured in Ottawa, Monday, June 3, 2024. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick
The Supreme Court of Canada says a British Columbia man convicted of sexual assault in 2022 should get a new trial because social media messages used as evidence against him were admitted to court without a proper hearing.
The court says the ruling confirms that it's not just evidence about a sexual assault complainant's history of sexual activity that's inadmissible at trial without a hearing — but also their history of sexual inactivity.
The ruling released Friday says Dustin Kinamore was 22 when he met the 16-year-old complainant in May 2020, and they exchanged sexualized social media messages that became key pieces of evidence at trial.
The ruling says the messages were introduced by the Crown to show the complainant wasn't interested in a sexual relationship with Kinamore — but the trial judge didn't hold an admissibility hearing, highlighting 'uncertainty' around rules governing evidence about a complainant's sexual history.
The decision says the messages were evidence of sexual inactivity, and confusion about their use in the trial arose because they were introduced by the prosecution rather than the defence.
The court ruled that evidence about a complainant's past sexual inactivity is presumed inadmissible, quashed Kinamore's conviction and ordered a new trial because the messages were used without a hearing to precisely determine relevance.
The ruling says so-called 'sexual history evidence' is presumed inadmissible because it can perpetuate 'myths and stereotypes' about complainants.
'The increasing complexity of sexual offence trials in Canada poses a challenge to our overburdened criminal justice system. One source of complexity lies in the application of the rules that govern evidence of a complainant's sexual history,' Chief Justice Wagner wrote, with the other judges agreeing.
'Although these evidentiary rules are essential to eliminate discriminatory myths and stereotypes from the fact-finding process and safeguard the dignity, privacy, and equality interests of complainants, uncertainty about their scope and procedural requirements has caused unnecessary confusion and disruption.'
This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 13, 2025.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CTV News
20 minutes ago
- CTV News
Man in hospital in serious condition after being burned in downtown fire
Crews responded to a fire in the 700 block of Pelissier Street on Thursday, June 12, 2025. (Source: Auston Kerr) A man has been taken to a hospital in Hamilton after being removed from a downtown Windsor fire on Thursday. Fire crews responded to the fire in the 700 block of Pelissier Street on Thursday for a structure fire. The fire, which was initially on the first floor, spread to the second. The Ontario Fire Marshal was on the scene Thursday evening and was back on Friday for the investigation. The Fire Marshal will lead the investigation moving forward. (With files from AM800's Meagan Delaurier)
CTV News
an hour ago
- CTV News
‘The city has really picked up its game': Edmonton tackling more problem properties, residents seeing results
An example of a home included in the Mature Area Derelict Residential Tax Subclass, which allows the City of Edmonton to triple property taxes for owners of problem properties. (Photo: The City of Edmonton) The City of Edmonton is planning to tackle problem properties in more neighbourhoods this year. The Problem Property Initiative (PPI) will see teams focusing on seven more communities this year – including five south of the river. The initiative was launched in 2023 after a successful pilot the year before. It aims to address issues associated with abandoned or run-down properties in Edmonton, such as fires, criminal complaints, illegal activity and safety concerns. Edmonton Problem Property Initiative Before and after images of a lot cleaned up by the Problem Properties Team, which addresses conditions at seriously neglected private properties posing a public safety hazard. (Photo: The City of Edmonton) Teams work city-wide but have put an additional focus on eight mature central communities — like Alberta Avenue, McCauley and Queen Alexandra – which the city said have higher concentrations of abandoned or derelict properties. Corine Demas, president of the McCauley Community League, has lived there for four years and knows first-hand the impact one of these homes can have on neighbouring residents. 'We had a shooting and a stabbing that first summer we were here,' she said. 'We are thinking, 'What are we doing here?' And it was all because of a problem property across the alley,' she said. 'That house burned down, and the city came in and demolished it and got rid of it and now we have a nice new infill, and we haven't had a problem in our alley since.' Edmonton Problem Property Initiative An Edmonton home that was redeveloped after being cleaned up by Problem Property Initiative teams. (Photo: The City of Edmonton) Allan Bolstad, civics director for the Alberta Avenue Community League, has also seen his share of problems in his neighbourhood. 'It is discouraging if you live right next door,' Bolstad said. 'It's an eyesore for one thing, and it's a constant concern that somebody is going to be living in it and causing problems … it just brings down the area.' PPI progress The city said situations at problem properties can be complex and generate an 'extraordinary demand' on services. Different teams are made up of police, firefighters, health officials and city staff, with some focused on securing or working to demolish abandoned homes while others ensure lived-in homes are safe for residents. Since the PPI began, the city said teams have inspected 1,900 properties, rehoused 81 people from unlivable homes – including 37 children – and connected hundreds more with other resources and services. They have also cleaned up 1.6 million pounds of trash and hazardous materials, secured 449 vacant structures and helped get 388 demolished (with 227 of those either redeveloped or in the process). Edmonton Problem Property Initiative The inside of a home inspected by the Residential \Inspection Safety Compliance Team. The team is part of the Problem Property Initiative and take a wrap-around approach to address living situations involving vulnerable Edmontonians. (Photo: The City of Edmonton) Starting last year, the city also started tripling the property taxes for problem property owners, something it said motivates action and earns revenue to deal with derelicts. Of the 202 properties to qualify for a tax hike last year, the city said 54 were demolished, eight were remediated and 48 were sold. Those efforts, the city said, resulted in a 31-per-cent decrease in structure fires in vulnerable neighbourhoods in 2023. Edmonton Fire Rescue Services (EFRS) explained that fires are a major concern at vacant properties, putting firefighters and anyone inside at risk during and after a fire. 'Due to the vacant nature of the property, these fires are often unreported by those accessing the building illegally or go unnoticed by neighbours until the fire has grown and becomes a much larger concern,' EFRS added. Between 2022 and 2024, EFRS increased inspections of unsecured vacant properties from 659 to 2,617. It said teams expect to inspect more than 3,000 this year. Should the current downward trend in fires at these properties continue, EFRS said it expects another 31-per-cent decrease in 2025. Edmonton Problem Property Initiative A home in Edmonton that was demolished and redeveloped following Problem Property Initiatives, including inclusion in the Mature Area Derelict Residential Tax Subclass. (Photo: The City of Edmonton) Both Bolstad and Demas said they have noticed the difference. 'The city has really picked up its game in terms of boarding these places up and securing them, making sure that people aren't able to break into them or camp outside in the yards, and so that's helped a lot,' Bolstead said. 'When the city is able to identify a house that is either derelict and people are getting in … or with people causing problems, when the city helps us with that, it does make a big difference to how we feel, as far as feeling safe,' Demas said. Problem properties can be reported confidentially to the city through an online form or by calling 311. The city asks that residents only report properties with 'significant harmful impact' on the surrounding area, such as properties that pose a risk to tenants or have had a recurring history of serious violations or complaints. For more information on the PPI, visit the City of Edmonton website.
CBC
2 hours ago
- CBC
'He did not deserve this,' says friend of Erixon Kabera after SIU clears officers who killed him
Social Sharing The Special Investigations Unit (SIU) report outlining the events leading to the death of Erixon Kabera answered some questions for his family and friends, but many remain. Two officers who shot and killed Kabera on Nov. 9 won't be criminally charged, the police watchdog said June 6. "On my assessment of the evidence, there are no reasonable grounds to believe that either subject official committed a criminal offence in connection with the complainant's death," said SIU director Joseph Martino in the report. That result is not what the family wanted, said his best friend, Andy Ganza. "[The family is] angry. They're disappointed, they're sad," Ganza told CBC Hamilton. "He did not deserve this at all." A rally for Kabera is taking place on June 19 at Hamilton City Hall, starting at 6 p.m. Ganza will be there, among others who knew him. After reading the report thoroughly, Ganza said he was "shocked" and "disappointed" at the SIU's summary of events and its conclusion. He has a hard time understanding why or how Kabera had a replica hangun, as the SIU reported, and he questions what he sees as a lack of deescalation efforts and the "excessive" shots fired by police. "None of us were there and [the SIU] were not there either, but we knew Erixon, so we have that on our side." The report was published the same day as Kabera's oldest of three children was graduating from high school, Ganza said, and the family had asked the SIU to wait until after to release the report. They had a "huge party" planned to celebrate the teen's achievement, with family visiting from abroad. The celebrations went well, he said, but it was a bittersweet moment. "It felt like a slap in the face," said Ganza. An SIU spokesperson told CBC Hamilton the family had asked to hold the release of the report until June 4, which is why they decided to post the report two days later. "While transparency and timely communication are core to the SIU's mandate, we also recognize the human impact of our work. When appropriate, and without compromising the integrity of the investigation, we do our best to show sensitivity during what are often very painful and emotional times for those involved," the spokesperson said. Kabera's death sparked outrage in Hamilton and beyond, including in the Rwandan community in Canada, of which Kabera was part. Family and friends have been demanding answers since he was killed. "The report not only failed to deliver justice — it further insulted our community and deepened our pain," Rwandan Canadian Healing Centre (RCHC) Executive Director Kizito Musabimana said in a post on social media. Kabera was an advisor to the RCHC board. "We are still mourning. We are still seeking answers. And above all, we are still demanding justice," Musabimana wrote. Kabera had 'no reason' to own a replica gun: friend One of the biggest questions Ganza has is over the detail in the SIU report that Kabera was holding a replica gun the day police shot him in his apartment. He had held it up and walked toward police, the report said. Ganza was supposed to meet with Kabera that night, Nov. 9, to hang out but was running late. The pair was texting just 20 minutes before everything unfolded, he said, with nothing out of the ordinary. Kabera also spoke with other friends that afternoon, he said. "He was fine. He was happy as usual," Ganza said. According to the SIU, police were called in the afternoon to the floor where Kabera lived on Main Street W. when a resident reported a man had been knocking on their door and appeared to be holding a handgun. Kabera would walk in and out of his apartment, according to the report, and approach the door of the resident's apartment where he would knock, turn the handle and ask to be let in. Officers found Kabera in the hallway when they arrived and called out to him. He entered his apartment and locked the door, but then came out again, holding "what appeared to be a handgun in his right hand at waist level, pointed at the floor," according to the report. The SIU said the object was not a real gun, but did appear like one. Kabera then pointed the replica firearm at the officers and walked towards them, the SIU said. The officers responded with immediate gunfire, according to the report. Ganza said he and the family don't believe Kabera owned the replica, and everything that happened after does not line up with what he knew about his friend. "He would not even remotely do something that reckless, right? He's a 43-year-old man," he said about Kabera pointing the replica firearm at police. Ganza said Kabera had plans for his future, including a move to Montreal. "It just doesn't make any sense whatsoever." Officers shot at Kabera 24 times, 8 bullets hit him After Kabera pointed the replica at police, a female officer fired eight rounds while moving backward before falling to the floor, according to the report. Kabera kept walking forward. That's when the other officer, a male, shot six to eight more rounds, to which Kabera "remained unfazed." The male officer then tripped and fell as well, according to the SIU. The female officer, "who had lost her firearm when she fell," fired her Taser at Kabera, which did not affect him, and he continued to advance on the officers. The male officer fired seven to eight more shots moments later, after replacing his magazine, and that's when Kabera "collapsed and landed on his back." Up to 24 shots were fired at Kabera, with eight striking him, according to the SIU. Ganza said it was "excessive" and "way too much." And though he knows police have a "very difficult job, they should have had the training for a situation like this," he said. Martino, the SIU director, said in the report the officers believed they had to fire their weapons at Kabera to protect themselves and because he was holding a gun. "A further retreat or withdrawal might have been available to the officers, but neither was viable given the speed at which events unfolded and the presence of fifth-floor residents, whose safety would have been imperiled," the director wrote. The female officer involved declined to be interviewed by the SIU, as is her legal right, but did release her notes, Martino noted. The other officer was interviewed, but didn't release his notes. The SIU also interviewed several witnesses, reviewed 911 calls, police radio recordings, forensic and physical evidence and a coroner's report. Family believes there's more to the story To Ganza's and the family's knowledge, Kabera did not have any mental health or substance abuse issues, nor did he have any ongoing problems with neighbours. "He was a happy-go-lucky guy," he said. Ganza had been to Kabera's apartment less than a week prior to his killing, and said everything looked normal and tidy, unlike after the events of Nov. 9. "The apartment looked like it was ransacked," he said, adding that things were misplaced, broken or missing. Ganza said he thinks there's more to the story painted by the SIU, which does not mention officers going into Kabera's apartment. It is unclear what or who did the damage, which Ganza said he saw himself after the shooting. Hamilton police spokesperson Jackie Penman told CBC Hamilton in an email the service will now conduct their own investigation, "as required by legislation." A report will be submitted to the Hamilton police board within 90 days and published on the board's website after review. A Coroner's inquest will also take place, she said, "which will review this incident in detail." Ganza said the family and their lawyer, Julian Falconer, are exploring the options they have.
