Chris Bishop frustrated by 'politicised' Stan Walker Aotearoa Music Awards performance
Paul Goldsmith (left) and Chris Bishop at the 2025 Aotearoa Music Awards in Auckland, on 29 May, 2025.
Photo:
Supplied/ Stijl - James Ensing-Trussell
Senior government Minister Chris Bishop says he was frustrated by the politicisation of Stan Walker's performance at the Aotearoa Music Awards,
when he said "what a load of crap"
.
During Stan Walker's performance of Māori Ki te Ao, performers took to the stage with flags displaying Toitū Te Tiriti, a movement borne out of opposition to the Treaty Principles Bill and other government legislation.
Bishop, who was in attendance, was seen criticising the performance, and has since said he should have kept the comments to himself.
On Tuesday, Bishop told reporters his comments were not directed specifically at Walker.
"I was frustrated and annoyed by the sort of overt politicking around it," he said.
"It's not about Stan Walker, I actually quite like Stan Walker, actually quite liked his performance. It was just the sort of politicisation of it that frustrated me," he said.
Bishop singled out the Toitū Te Tiriti "banners and paraphernalia" as the source of his frustration, not the performance itself.
He said he would not be apologising to Walker.
"It's not clear what I'd be apologising for."
Stan Walker performing at the Aotearoa Music Awards 2025.
Photo:
Emma Cooper
His comments
led to backlash from other performers
, including Don McGlashan, who was seen on video confronting Bishop.
The minister said the irony was he was a "huge" Don McGlashan fan.
"I love the Mutton Birds. But Don McGlashan is a noteworthy non-supporter of the National Party. People might remember the 2008 election, in which he expressed some frustration at 'Anchor Me', which is a great Mutton Birds tune, being used by TVNZ on the election night coverage," Bishop said.
"His political views are quite well-known, but look it is what it is, he's entitled to his views in the same way I'm entitled to mine."
Arts, culture and heritage minister Paul Goldsmith, who was also at the event, brushed off whether the performance was controversial.
"There's always controversy at music awards. It goes without saying," he said.
Māori Crown relations minister Tama Potaka said he disagreed with Bishop's comments, but they were for Bishop to respond to.
"I absolutely love Stan Walker and his commitment to te reo, and the mahi that he does particularly in his engagement with Ratana, the hāhi. I don't agree with minister Bishop's comments, however those are a matter for him to comment on," Potaka said.
Labour's Māori Development spokesperson Willie Jackson said Bishop, as a music fan, should know that music had always been political.
"He should know music better than anyone. Look around the world, people have been doing that for years. Whether it's Bob Marley, Bono, whatever, it's been happening, it's not like something new. He should talk to his Shihad heroes, cos the lead singer there's got pretty good politics too."
Prime Minister Christopher Luxon.
Photo:
RNZ / Marika Khabazi
The Prime Minister told
Morning Report
he was comfortable with Bishop's response
, and had spoken to him over the weekend.
"I just got his side of the story about what he said and it was exactly as reported. He corrected it well before I got to him... he just acknowledged he should have kept his thoughts to himself," Christopher Luxon said.
"The bottom line is your listeners aren't losing a lot of sleep over what a politician sharing his opinion on some music was about."
Labour leader Chris Hipkins said Bishop's behaviour was disappointing, but it was for the Prime Minister to bring his ministers in line.
"You've got to remember when you're a government minister that you're on public display all of the time."
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
42 minutes ago
- RNZ News
Seymour pay changes add more anxiety for ECE sector
Photo: 123rf Early childhood teachers and managers say centres are struggling with teacher shortages, low enrolments and inadequate government funding. Some are alarmed by surprise changes to pay parity - the system for giving centres higher subsidies if they pay qualified teachers the same as kindergarten and school teachers. At Aro Valley Preschool in central Wellington senior teacher Bridget Mickelson-Warmouth said the government's half-a-percent funding increase for next year's subsidies and recent changes to pay parity were making people nervous. "Funding is always a big key for community centres. Because we're not-for-profit, all the money that comes in goes back in to making sure that teachers are well-paid, that we're well-resourced, and that we can maintain low ratios and small groups," she said. "It's quite unnerving to find out what's going to happen within our funding space." Aro Valley Preschool senior teacher Bridget Mickelson-Warmouth says it's "unnerving" thinking about funding for the sector. Photo: RNZ / John Gerritsen Mickelson-Warmouth said community-run centres were especially vulnerable to pay parity changes because they tended to hire experienced, qualified teachers who were paid at the top of the scale. She said last year's decision to cut relief teachers from the scheme had already had a negative effect. "We actually are finding it harder to get relievers as relief teachers either go into permanent work if they can find it or they can leave the sector altogether. We've had some fantastic relievers recently who are currently retraining in other areas and are going out of early childhood due to the inability to get work or the work that they can get is in places that they don't want to be," she said. Some early childhood centre owners have complained that pay parity was hard to afford because the government funding that supported it was inadequate. Despite that, the number of centres opting into the highest tier of the scheme - which obliged them to offer pay-parity rates to the most experienced staff - grew from about 1000 in 2023 to 1484 in March this year. Auckland early childhood centre owner Vince Grgicevich said pay parity was tricky when it was introduced several years ago, but his biggest challenges were competition and parents keeping children home when they worked from home on Mondays and Fridays. Grgicevich said centres tended to have fewer children attending on Mondays and Fridays, which saved parents money but made early childhood centre staffing difficult. "Numbers have improved a little bit but they are still not back up to where we used to sit at 90-95 percent across the board. Our centres sit anywhere between 70 and 80 percent so we're okay, but a centre really needs to be relatively full to make good money," he said. Grgicevich said many centres were not at 70 percent occupancy and those in areas where parents could not afford the fees were struggling. "I know a lot of South Auckland centres really do struggle because you've got to charge a minimum of $300 for a baby and $200 for an over-three and a lot of parents can't even afford that," he said. He said he recently sold a centre because there were too many other centres in the area. Education Ministry figures showed children's participation in early learning increased last year after slumping in 2021-22. Nearly 81 percent of four-year-olds were attending for 10 hours or more a week last year, up from 74 percent in 2023 but still shy of the pre-Covid high of 84 percent. That translated into a percentage-point increase in occupancy to about 78 percent across the education and care sector but in Auckland it was 76 percent. Meanwhile, Grgicevich said he was not expecting any relief from action stemming from last year's review of ECE regulations. "That regulatory stuff, I personally think is a waste of time. We're inherently safe in what we do. There has to be some checks in place and they weren't costing us anything. My annual regulatory budget was low. If I spent two or three thousand dollars a year, that would be it," he said. Kidsfirst Kindergartens is a non-profit organisation with about 64 kindergartens in Canterbury, the West Coast and Central Otago. Its chief executive Sherryll Wilson said kindergarten teachers were state sector employees, so their pay parity with school teachers was negotiated directly with the government, unlike other early childhood teachers. Even so, she said she was worried by the government's changes to pay parity and to early childhood regulations. "It feels like for early childhood we are having the same challenges as what we've had years ago. The pay equity, pay parity, teacher supply. It feels like we never get to the stage where we can future-proof," she said. "It feels like we're just going back in time and having the same arguments all over again." Wilson said enrolments were good across the organisation's kindergartens but there were more centres competing for enrolments. "In the past we might have had three or four really strong ECE services, not all kindergartens, but now we've got 10 services in the same area all trying to capture the same children," she said. Wilson said one of the biggest challenges for the organisation was uncertainty about government funding from year to year was challenging. "For a non-profit organisation like Kidsfirst, our greatest source of revenue is government funding, we're heavily reliant on it and we suffer from the whims of whoever is in power at any given time in terms of the funding we receive," she said. Wilson said the supply of qualified teachers was a problem, especially in the regions, and there was a sense of exhaustion and frustration in the sector.
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
New Lynn stabbing attack: Supermarket visits 'insurmountable obstacle', inquest told
Ahamed Samsudeen coming out of the New Lynn train station, on the day of the attack on September 3, 2021. Photo: Supplied Content warning: This report contains content some may consider disturbing. The inquest into the LynnMall terror attack will see further analysis of video showing how the assault unfolded, when it resumes on Thursday. Ahamed Samsudeen stabbed five people and injured two others at a Woolworths supermarket in Auckland's New Lynn, before he was shot and killed by police. Survivors at the inquest on Wednesday watched a video of Ahamed Samsudeen pausing to put on a red glove inside the supermarket . He was then seen ripping a knife from its packaging and rushing at his first victim. What happened next scarred survivors physically and emotionally. One survivor, who had name suppression, told the inquest just how much of an impact the attack had on her. "For some, the mere thought of entering a supermarket has become an insurmountable obstacle," she said. "We are no longer the individuals we used to be, and coming to terms with this reality is profoundly difficult." Samsudeen's rampage ended after he was shot 12 times by police. He had been granted refugee status in 2013, was identified by the SIS as a terrorist threat in early 2017, and was under surveillance at the time of the attack on 3 September, 2021. Detective Senior Sergeant Jason McIntosh told the inquest about the moment authorities noticed a change in his social media posting. "Recent content continues to reference Jannah, in brackets 'afterlife', and death, he's referenced literature on lone wolf terrorism" McIntosh said. "Samsudeen has begun to increasingly include his own commentary when posting, which may assist with understanding his mindset going forward." The inquest was shown footage of Samsudeen's previous trip to the supermarket - roughly a month before the attack. He could be seen walking to the knives aisle, appearing to take special notice of the items on the shelves. McIntosh was questioned by police counsel Alysha McClintock over Samsudeen's movements in the time leading up to the attack, as recorded in surveillance logs. "Once it was understood that Mr Samsudeen had visited the New Lynn Countdown previously on the 12th of August, the footage we've just seen, was there subsequently by one of your colleagues, an endeavour to go through the surveillance logs and look at the locations that might have had knifes and or other weapons that Mr Samsudeen had visited," McClintock asked. "Correct, yes" McIntosh replied. The logs revealed Samsudeen made about 119 visits to more than 60 different locations that could have had knives or other weapons. The lawyer representing the interests of Samsudeen's family, Fletcher Pilditch, asked McIntosh about the police surveillance of Samsudeen. "Was it the observations that had been made and recorded by the surveillance team that enabled you after the 3rd of September to then go and identify other places where he had been? "And I don't need to pry into where that information came from, I was just interested in the source of it," Pilditch said. "I do know that we compiled a list post investigation," McIntosh responded. The inquest was expected on Thursday to go through a frame-by-frame analysis of CCTV footage from the attack, as well as hearing technical evidence later in the day.
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Wellington emploment market 'pretty Hunger Games', jobseeker says
Photo: 123RF After about a year of job hunting in Wellington, communications experts Rebecca Thomson and Emily Turner have seen a lot. Sometimes they apply for a job and get no response. Other times, the job remains advertised while interviews are happening. In one case, applying for a three-month contract was to involve a full 45-minute interview, then a coffee chat - but then the advertiser decided not to fill the position. "It feels pretty Hunger Games out there, sort of far more people than jobs, across the board," Thomson said. "It can be like a really bad dating situation," Turner said. "It's like permanently being ghosted from a very bad date, or not even a date because that would be the interview … it's putting your best foot forward, doing some really good chat and banter and thinking it's all going really well, and then nothing." Turner said she had about six interviews for roles, from about 20 applications. "I've got a very clear approach of what I'm applying for, I don't do a sort of scatter gun approach, I apply for roles that I know I've got a clear go at getting." She said she had asked recruiters how many people were applying for senior communications roles and had been told that it could be 80 to 100. Thomson said she had picked up freelance work along the way. "But in terms of full-time employment it's been a year. We're both highly skilled people that have worked on an array of projects and we're not the only ones." The pair have started an informal network for Wellington job hunters, where people can get together to support each other and share tips and information about the employment market. "We set it up to get to be somewhere where people can meet and have a chat in a casual, friendly environment," Thomson said. "It's tough out there and people are mentally finding it tough ." Some people want advice on how to put mortgage payments on hold, how to cover the cost of car registration or body corporate fees without regular income, but other times the network might share details of jobs that might suit other people. Thomson said from the initial meeting with two of them, their next meeting attracted eight. Another meeting was planned for this week and more people were offering their support online. "I've had a few DMs (direct messages) from people saying 'I can't come but this is great'," Thomson said. Gareth Kiernan, chief forecaster at Infometrics, said it was unlikely the Wellington employment market would turn around soon . "There's certainly not any signs that any time soon the pressure from government is going to change on either employment numbers or departmental spending. "Often what we've seen in the past, if we went back to the previous National government from 2008 onwards they had a sinking lid on employment, it was not as tough but reasonably tough, but at the same time they had a bit more room fiscally so there was more consulting work going on. This time the pressure is very much on both sides." Infometrics chief forecaster Gareth Kiernan. Photo: Supplied He said the public sector crackdown was having a flow-on effect on the private sector in Wellington. "It may be after 18 months we're through the worst of it but it's hard to see it turning around and employment picking up any time soon." The annual average unemployment rate in Wellington City was 4.8 percent in the year to March, up from 3.4 percent in the previous 12 months. Kiernan said Wellington had previously had unemployment well below the national average but the gap had closed. Jarrod Kerr, chief economist at Kiwibank, said he thought it could be six months before the Wellington situation improved, "but probably more like a year". "It's the harsh reality of an RBNZ(Reserve Bank)-induced recession and significant cuts in the public sector. We forecast an improvement, which keeps getting delayed, by the end of the year, and we look into 2026 with more confidence." Thomson said anyone who wanted to join the network could find them on LinkedIn. "We wanted to keep it sort of friendly and open - people don't have to join some page to be part of it … it's a space to decompress and have a coffee or tea and chat with some like-minded people." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
