Elon Musk says Trump's ‘big, beautiful' tax and spending Bill is a ‘disgusting abomination'

Irish Times

7 days ago

Elon Musk
, the billionaire tech entrepreneur, has opened a new rift with
Donald Trump
by denouncing the
US
president's tax and spending Bill as a 'disgusting abomination'.
Mr Musk's online outburst could embolden fiscally conservative
Republican
senators – some of whom have already spoken out – to defy Mr Trump as they continue crucial negotiations on Capitol Hill over the so-called 'one big, beautiful Bill'.
'I'm sorry, but I just can't stand it any more,' Mr Musk wrote on his X social media platform on Tuesday. 'This massive, outrageous, pork-filled Congressional spending Bill is a disgusting abomination. Shame on those who voted for it: you know you did wrong. You know it.'
Mr Musk, who had
previously voiced criticism of the proposed legislation
, quipping that it could be big or beautiful but not both, added on X: 'It will massively increase the already gigantic budget deficit to $2.5 trillion (!!!) and burden America citizens with crushingly unsustainable debt.'
READ MORE
He continued: 'Congress is making America bankrupt.'
A top donor to Mr Trump during last year's US presidential election campaign,
Mr Musk departed the White House last week
after steering its so-called 'department of government efficiency' (Doge) with the stated mission of slashing fraud and abuse within federal departments. He has argued that the Republican Bill will undermine Doge's work and drive the US further into debt.
On Tuesday, Mr Musk drew immediate support from Thomas Massie, one of only two Republicans who last month voted against the Bill in the House of Representatives. 'He's right,' Mr Massie responded on X.
But there was a rebuke from Mike Johnson, the House speaker, who said he had spoken with Mr Musk by phone on Monday for more than 20 minutes, making the case that the Bill achieved campaign promises while making permanent massive tax and spending cuts.
Mr Johnson told reporters: 'With all due respect, my friend Elon is terribly wrong about the One Big Beautiful Bill. It's a very important first start. Elon is missing it … I just deeply regret he's made this mistake.'
[
Elon Musk wanted to 'move fast and break things' in Washington. The main thing he broke was his reputation
Opens in new window
]
John Thune, the Republican majority leader in the US Senate, was more diplomatic, saying: 'So we have a difference of opinion. He's entitled to that opinion. We're going to proceed full speed ahead.'
Having narrowly passed the House of Representatives, the Bill is now under consideration in the senate, which is aiming to pass a revised version by July 4th. Some Republican fiscal conservatives, such as senators Ron Johnson and Rand Paul, share Mr Musk's concerns about the need for significant spending cuts.
Mr Johnson told CNN: 'We have enough [holdouts] to stop the process until the president gets serious about spending reduction and reducing the deficit.'
Mr Trump has previously dismissed Republican dissenters as 'grandstanders' and urged them to get on-board. His influence proved decisive in quelling a potential rebellion in the house. On Monday he wrote on his Truth Social platform: 'So many false statements are being made about 'THE ONE, BIG, BEAUTIFUL BILL'.'
The White House acknowledged Mr Musk's stance but said it has not changed its position on the Bill. Press secretary Karoline Leavitt told reporters: 'Look, the president already knows where Elon Musk stood on this Bill. It doesn't change the president's opinion: this is one big, beautiful Bill and he is sticking to it.'
The Bill extends Mr Trump's 2017 tax cuts and includes new spending for border security and the military. Republicans aimed to offset these costs with cuts to programmes such as Medicaid, food stamps and green-energy tax credits.
Projections from the Congressional Budget Office and independent analysts indicate that the Bill would add between $2.3 trillion and $5 trillion to the deficit over the next 10 years. White House officials contend that the economic growth generated by tax cuts will offset the increased spending.
Russ Vought, director of the office of management and budget, told CNN: 'This Bill doesn't increase the deficit or hurt the debt. In fact, it lowers it by $1.4 trillion.'
But Democrats have warned that the budget would raise the cost of healthcare for millions of people, and cause millions to lose coverage, to pay for tax cuts for billionaires. A new analysis by Yale University and the University of Pennsylvania found that it could lead to more than 51,000 preventable deaths.
Chuck Schumer, the senate minority leader, said in a floor speech on Tuesday: 'Donald Trump and his so-called 'big, beautiful Bill' is ugly to its very core. Behind the smoke and mirrors lies a cruel and draconian truth: tax breaks for the ultra-wealthy paid for by gutting healthcare for millions of Americans.'
Later, responding to Mr Musk's intervention, Mr Schumer commented on X: 'I didn't think it was imaginable but … I AGREE WITH ELON MUSK.'
Bernie Sanders, an independent senator from Vermont, added in a post: 'Musk is right: this Bill IS a 'disgusting abomination'. We shouldn't give $664 billion in tax breaks to the 1 per cent. We shouldn't throw 13.7 million people off of Medicaid. We shouldn't cut $290 billion from programmes to feed the hungry. Let's defeat this disgusting abomination.' – Guardian
'My Irish friends are awesome' says Elon Musk – who are they?
Listen |
27:30