City offers to add land to province's plan for Lemay Forest park
The City of Winnipeg will offer 34 acres of land it owns alongside the privately owned Lemay Forest to support a future provincial park.
Mayor Scott Gillingham said the lands will add to the provincial government's controversial plan to expropriate the privately owned urban forest, which the premier previously said would extend to surrounding property.
'This is the city saying to the province (that) we want to be partners, you don't need to expropriate city land. We will offer it to consolidate it all together to create a park,' said Gillingham.
On Friday, city council unanimously approved a proposal to provide the land and be an 'active partner' in creating the park, with a detailed report on steps to do so expected in about six months.
'This really kind of checks a lot of boxes, as it were, in a lot of the goals the city has, the province has… in protecting green spaces,' said Gillingham.
While the mayor suggested offering the land is a 'significant contribution' to the future park, he said the city does not have a current appraisal of the public land's value.
The future of the Lemay Forest has triggered heated debate for more than a year, as many residents sought to preserve its trees. Some also shared concerns that development would disrupt unmarked graves from a former orphanage cemetery on part of the land.
Prior to the expropriation process, Tochal Development Group owned land at the site, where it planned to build a 5,000-bed assisted-living facility. The developer had publicly promised to create a buffer zone around any graves.
When asked if that battle over the land's future affected the city's interest in the land, the mayor spoke only of a goal to protect and enhance green space.
'We have goals of creating more green space and preserving park land. This can be a partnership… which benefits future generations of Winnipeggers and Manitobans,' said Gillingham.
A key planner on the assisted-living proposal questioned the two governments' willingness to create a park, accusing officials of a 'questionable' lack of public consultation since the province announced its expropriation plans last month.
Sent weekly from the heart of Turtle Island, an exploration of Indigenous voices, perspectives and experiences.
'It's moving so quickly for (a) land exchange…. A lot of people are moving very rapidly. Usually, these things take years, if not decades,' said John Wintrup.
Wintrup said it's too soon to confirm if the developer will challenge the expropriation decision in court.
'We're not rolling over, that's for sure. The landowner wants fair-market value for the property…. There (are) various legal options,' he said.
joyanne.pursaga@freepress.mb.ca
X: @joyanne_pursaga
Joyanne PursagaReporter
Joyanne is city hall reporter for the Winnipeg Free Press. A reporter since 2004, she began covering politics exclusively in 2012, writing on city hall and the Manitoba Legislature for the Winnipeg Sun before joining the Free Press in early 2020. Read more about Joyanne.
Every piece of reporting Joyanne produces is reviewed by an editing team before it is posted online or published in print — part of the Free Press's tradition, since 1872, of producing reliable independent journalism. Read more about Free Press's history and mandate, and learn how our newsroom operates.
Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber.
Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Winnipeg Free Press
21 hours ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
The end of a raucous legislature session
Opinion On June 2 at the end of the spring session of the Manitoba legislature, the two main parties issued duelling press releases, each claiming they were listening and responding to the needs and concerns of Manitobans. The NDP government boasted it had delivered 'a strong, ambitious legislative agenda' of 39 bills that would improve health care, remove interprovincial trade barriers, make groceries more affordable, enhance public safety, and act on many other matters. The Progressive Conservative (PC) opposition countered with the claim that several of the more important bills were based on ideas stolen from them. This credit claiming by the parties has become an annual ritual. Over the past five decades, the proceedings of the legislature have increasingly come to resemble a permanent election campaign in which the parties spend more time seeking to score political points against their opponent than using questions of the premier and ministers and debating bills for the constructive purpose of improving public policy. The just-finished session featured too much shouting and name calling across the aisle and several unfortunate episodes of disorderly conduct. It was not, however, the most raucous session that has happened in the modern era of Manitoba politics, which I date from the breakthrough victory of the NDP in 1969. For observers of my generation, it is impossible to forget the French language crisis of 1983-1984 during which then-PC leader Sterling Lyon and his MLAs ferociously fought a NDP government bill entrenching language rights by using prolonged bell-ringing which paralyzed the legislature and brought angry, screaming crowds into building. I recognize that partisan competition provides the motivation and energy which drives the institution. The clash between opposing philosophies and policy perspectives helps to define what actions are in the public interest. Criticism from the opposition is the main way that the government is made to answer and to be held accountable through the media to the electorate. It would be impossible, and wrong, to seek to drive disagreement, emotion and passion entirely out of the proceedings of the legislature. The legislature actually has two modes of operation: most often it is adversarial between the parties, occasionally it demonstrates the capacity for cross-party collaboration. Because media coverage focuses mainly on the partisan clashes in Question Period, many members of the public sees the legislative process as only games-playing by the parties. In my view partisanship has become excessive, unduly negative and personal in content. There is throughout the legislative process too much rude heckling, personal attacks, bullying, inflammatory rhetoric, defensiveness and feigned indignation. Women MLAs are targeted disproportionately. Two episodes in the past session illustrate the problem. On April 22, PC MLA Greg Nesbitt questioned the NDP government about a contract for mental health therapy, suggesting, without providing any evidence, that it may have been for the personal benefit of NDP Finance Minister Adrien Sala. Either this was a cheap ' gotcha' question or Nesbitt had failed to do his homework to learn that the contract was actually for mental health support to landfill searchers. It strained credulity for the PC interim leader Wayne Ewasko to claim that his MLA was simply seeking information. In the shouting match which ensued, the Speaker, Tom Lindsay lost his cool and threatened to toss Nesbitt from the chamber, a threat he apologized for the next day. He also expressed frustration with the lack of decorum and the refusal of MLAs to immediately obey his calls for the heckling to cease. There is only so much the Speaker can do under the rules to maintain civility and to curtail belligerent language. The deeper problem is the culture of the institution which is shaped by many factors, most importantly by the words and actions of the party leaders. This brings me to the second episode which happened in the committee of supply on May 21 when the spending estimates of the executive council (which includes the premier's office) were under review. Proceedings of the meeting can be found on a YouTube stream. Both Premier Wab Kinew and Opposition Leader Obby Khan were in attendance and the meeting turned ugly almost immediately with the two MLAs showing intense dislike and disrespect for one another. A backbench NDP MLA serving as committee chair was hard pressed to maintain order. During Khan's opening statement on economic indicators, he was constantly heckled by Kinew, who at one point described the opposition leader as 'a joke.' Khan responded by bringing up Kinew's encounters with the law as a young adult and described him as a 'toxic, bullying leader' (echoing allegations from a former NDP MLA banished from that caucus). Kinew fought back by accusing Khan of being part of the ethics scandal involving violations of the caretaker convention during the final days of the former Heather Stefanson government. Fostering a more respectful and constructive culture starts with the leaders who must model more responsible behaviour and encourage their MLAs to restrain their outbursts and personal attacks when emotions rise in the chamber and in the committees. Paul G. Thomas is professor emeritus of Political Studies at the University of Manitoba.
Toronto Star
a day ago
- Toronto Star
Anishinabek Nation chief says he briefed OPP on protests against fast-track bills
OTTAWA - A regional chief for Anishinabek Nation says he briefed Ontario Provincial Police Thursday on what to expect when First Nations take to the streets to protest provincial and federal legislation aimed at fast-tracking major projects. Scott McLeod said he was invited by an Indigenous relations coordinator to brief officers at the OPP's Orillia headquarters on why First Nations oppose the legislation and why they see the bills as a violation of treaties with the Crown.
Winnipeg Free Press
a day ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Biz leaders thankful for tax deferrals, ask for more help amid wildfire losses
Business leaders have praised Manitoba for offering sales and payroll tax deferrals to those affected by wildfires. 'That's fantastic,' said Kory Eastman, president of the Flin Flon and District Chamber of Commerce, which has 100 members in the evacuated northern city and neighbouring Saskatchewan communities of Creighton and Denare Beach. 'Any kind of assistance is positive.' He expressed gratitude to Premier Wab Kinew for showing up Thursday to witness the damage caused by a massive blaze and talk to firefighters. MIKAELA MACKENZIE / FREE PRESS FILES On Thursday, Finance Minister Adrien Sala announced optional deferrals of the retail sales tax and payroll tax to help businesses affected by the unprecedented emergency that has forced 21,000 Manitobans to flee 27 communities. On Thursday, Finance Minister Adrien Sala announced optional deferrals of the retail sales tax and payroll tax to help businesses affected by the unprecedented emergency that has forced 21,000 Manitobans to flee 27 communities. 'We haven't seen any matching communication from the Saskatchewan side,' said Eastman who is staying in Edmonton. 'It'd be nice to see that as well,' said the chamber president, who is manager of the Flin Flon Credit Union. 'We've been able to re-establish services working remotely which been has been a challenge but obviously you know we're there for our members and for our customers.' He said he appreciated Premier Wab Kinew flying to Flin Flon on Thursday to see firsthand the empty streets and businesses shuttered by the wildfire. 'He got to kind of see what's happening on the ground there.' Eastman said he hopes Kinew's visit might prompt more provincial support for businesses. 'Maybe with a little more understanding, we'll see even more movement and support from the government, but I can't complain. They've been good so far with our area, I believe,' he said. 'Comparing to the other side of the border, (Saskatchewan Premier) Scott Moe has not been been there, and Denare Beach was devastated as a community, losing 300 properties,' said Eastman, noting Moe sent provincial officials to view the fire-ravaged community. He said he spoke to the Manitoba Chambers of Commerce Friday about its discussion with the government for supports for members that are under evacuation. 'Tax holidays are not something they often can give out, but we're pleased with any kind of progress, and still we'll hopefully keep the communication open,' Eastman said. A spokesman for the Canadian Federation of Independent Business said the tax deferrals are 'helpful first steps' to deal with evacuations, lost revenue and supply delays. Seasonal businesses and those in northern and rural communities will need more help as the wildfire situation unfolds, spokesman Tyler Slobogian said Friday. The CFIB wrote to the finance minister June 2 in which it asked him to consider emergency grants, broader tax flexibility, and expanding Disaster Financial Assistance eligibility for small businesses. It hasn't received a response, the spokesman said. They're also hoping for an extension or expansion of similar sales and payroll tax deferrals available from February till July that were announced by the province in March in response to U.S. tariffs, he said. Monday Mornings The latest local business news and a lookahead to the coming week. 'CFIB members are being squeezed by rising input costs, supply chain instability, and additional labour challenges,' Slobogian said. 'Additional relief such as financial support for impacted industries, or permanent targeted tax reductions, would help offset these costs,' he said. 'The dual pressure of wildfire disruption and trade uncertainty is putting serious strain on Manitoba's small business community. Confidence has taken a large hit.' The CFIB's 'business barometer' shows a 6.5-point drop in Manitoba's long-term outlook, which is now the lowest in Canada, Slobogian said. 'This marks a new low, even beneath the confidence levels we saw during the worst of the COVID-19 pandemic.' Carol SandersLegislature reporter Carol Sanders is a reporter at the Free Press legislature bureau. The former general assignment reporter and copy editor joined the paper in 1997. Read more about Carol. Every piece of reporting Carol produces is reviewed by an editing team before it is posted online or published in print — part of the Free Press's tradition, since 1872, of producing reliable independent journalism. Read more about Free Press's history and mandate, and learn how our newsroom operates. Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber. Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
