Indian restaurant shut down by court order for 'smelling like curry'
The restaurant has been operating for more than 20 years and had tried to do something about the smell
A popular curry house has been forced to close after two decades in business following complaints about it smelling of curry. Cinnamons Restaurant in Wheatley, Oxfordshire, had been operating for over 20 years when a complaint was made to South Oxfordshire District Council about the "curry odours" emanating from the restaurant in 2021.
After environmental health officers visited and upheld the complaint, the Bangladeshi restaurant said they spent around £35,000 for a new extractor fan to combat the odour. However, another complaint was made and the curry house was served an abatement notice, which deemed Cinnamons' new ventilation system to be defective.
Unable to afford the installation cost of a new system, which the restaurant claimed to be in the region of £50,000, Cinnamons was taken to court and forced to pay a £25,000 fine after pleading guilty in October 2024. Despite the funds spent, the council issued a further abatement notice and in May this year, Cinnamons announced that it could not afford the demands and would close in mid-June, making 10 people unemployed.
South Oxfordshire District Council said they have no option but to prosecute "if measures are not introduced to solve the issue and abatement notices are breached" and that Cinnamons "admitted that they could have done more to mitigate the odour". Restaurateur Shirazul Hoque, 32, told PA Real Life: "The village wants the restaurant to stay, otherwise we would have closed before paying the £25,000 fine.
"It's really hard for us and feels absolutely wrong as we love our village... it is hurtful to have our cuisine, which is loved, described as producing obnoxious odours that stink." All our employees have families and the chefs who live above the restaurant will be made homeless – it's a big punch in the gut."
Cinnamons Restaurant has been operating in Wheatley, Oxfordshire, since 2000. Shirazul's uncles took over the business in 2012, and they have been serving Bangladeshi and Indian food there ever since. Many TripAdvisor reviews describe the restaurant as an important part of the community.
"We are so lucky to have this restaurant in our village," one review reads. In 2021, the restaurant won the TripAdvisor Travellers' Choice award, which is given to businesses that consistently earn great reviews from travellers and are ranked within the top 10% in their field on TripAdvisor.
That same year, an odour complaint was made to South Oxfordshire District Council against the restaurant. An officer from the Environmental Health Agency upheld the complaint. After over two decades of service, Shirazul claimed Cinnamons had never received such a complaint but as a result installed a roughly £35,000 ventilation system as demanded.
"We wanted to resolve it because we've been here for 20 years, we love our village and we wanted to do something about it," Shirazul said. A higher specification ventilation model was suggested by a consultant, but the restaurant felt they could not afford the installation cost, estimated to be roughly £50,000, nor the maintenance cost.
Despite the expensive work carried out by a reputable company with over 30 years of experience, Shirazul said, another complaint was lodged with the council. The Environmental Protection Team was sent to the restaurant and the odour was deemed to be unacceptable, and their ventilator defective.
Cinnamons were then asked to rectify the ventilation system. "We weren't able to afford it," Shirazul said. "To be honest, business had not rebounded post-Covid, we'd not been making any profit so we didn't have the money for this."
Since no action was taken, the restaurant was issued with an abatement notice and taken to court. Cinnamons pleaded guilty and accepted a £25,000 fine in October 2024. The issue of ventilation was still deemed unsolved however which left the restaurant facing a further expense estimated by Shirazul to be in the region of £50,000.
On Monday May 19, Cinnamons realised they were unable to continue fighting the battle, telling their 10 employees they were without a job. "It's very hard to share this story because I've spent a lot of my time in the business," Shirazul said.
Asked what other restaurants can learn from his situation, Shirazul said: "Do due diligence in seeing how the council environmental health officers operate and learn the appeal process."
He also says that on Sunday June 15, their last day of trading, the restaurant will be giving out free meals to anyone who comes through. "It's a gesture of thanks for all the support we've received through the difficulties of the last few years," he said.
"It's a way of saying thank you for standing by us."
South Oxfordshire District Council said in a statement: "The council has a legal duty to investigate nuisance complaints about smells from industrial, trade and business premises that could be a statutory nuisance. We always aim to advise and support businesses on how they can resolve issues. However, if measures are not introduced to solve the issue and abatement notices are breached, we have no option but to prosecute.
"In the case of Cinnamons Restaurant in Wheatley, the Council's Environmental Protection Team has assessed the odour complaint following our procedures and legislation. An extensive investigation at this site determined a statutory nuisance existed in relation to the kitchen's ventilation systems.
"Cinnamons Cuisine Limited, who run the restaurant, has since failed to follow our recommendations and has breached an environmental abatement notice on several occasions between October 2023 and April 2024. Cinnamons pleaded guilty to four charges ahead of a scheduled three-day court appearance on Wednesday 2 October 2024.
"The District Judge at Oxford Magistrates' Court reviewed the evidence and statements provided by council officers and the company, and taking into consideration the revised guilty plea, the judge ordered that the company pay a total of £25,000 – this includes an £11,000 fine, an award of full costs of £12,000 to South Oxfordshire District Council, alongside a victim surcharge of £2,000.
"As well as pleading guilty to the charges of statutory nuisance laid against them, Cinnamons admitted that they could have done more to mitigate the odour. The council can advise and assist where we can, but ultimately responsibility for fixing the problem sits with the business.
"The business has been provided advice and guidance on steps they can take but to date have failed to follow our recommendations.
"Cinnamons is still the subject of an ongoing legal case, and we will therefore not be in a position to comment any further on this case other than the information provided in the statement above."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Fashion United
35 minutes ago
- Fashion United
From volume to value: Bangladesh's garment strategy amid trade turmoil
Bangladesh's garment industry seeks to shed its low-cost, large quantity image as it aims to capture higher-value business. At Best of Bangladesh, a fair and conference in the heart of Amsterdam, manufacturers and government officials advertised the world's second largest garment producer's transition, hoping to gain more business amid global trade turmoil. Beyond basics It looked like a typical sourcing fair at first glance: Exhibitors waited for buyers in small booths separated by white walls that were lined with garments. Yet, the exhibition floor wasn't hectic. Soft, jazzy music created a lounge feeling amidst the old-world allure of the historic red-brick walls of Amsterdam's former stock exchange. The choice of the elegant venue for 'Best of Bangladesh' at the beginning of April and the talks held at the event sought to convey a feeling of progress. Bangladesh, traditionally focused on basic apparel like knits, shirts, and denim, is currently aiming to level up its textile industry and expand beyond these simpler garments. A textbook example of these ambitions is Centro Ltd, which had its stand right at the entrance to the exhibition. The apparel manufacturer, based in the capital city of Dhaka, was founded in 2006 and started with knitwear and later wovens before expanding its offering to outerwear, activewear and footwear, Sohel Samim, head of design and product development at Centro, said in an interview. The newer categories represent roughly 12 percent of the offering, according to Centro. Bangladesh's textile industry wants to portray the country at its best. Credits: FashionUnited The company generates 70 percent of its 220-million-dollar revenue from Europe, selling ten million garments per month to fashion companies such as River Island, Primark and Peek & Cloppenburg. Centro has sourcing offices in Hong Kong and the UK, operates three factories with 3,000 workers in Bangladesh and sources from 50 partner factories. In Amsterdam, the focus is to showcase newer product categories such as wool coats, leather jackets and sneakers. Centro further highlights that 70 percent of its sourced fabrics are either sustainably produced or recycled, bearing certifications such as Global Organic Textile Standard or Recycled 100. 'Our main aim is to show our strength, not only Centro's, but our Bangladeshi strength,' said Samim, who considers Centro as one of the leading apparel companies from its home country. 'We are representing the Best of Bangladesh.' 100 billion dollar goal The garment sector remains a cornerstone of the South-East Asian country's economy, with exports of 38,5 billion US dollars in 2024 accounting for more than 80 percent of the country's overall exports, data by Bangladesh's Garment Manufacturers and Exporters Association (BGMEA) shows. The industry organisation even announced a goal some years ago to more than double its exports to 100 billion US dollars by 2030. Bangladesh has a long-standing tradition of producing cotton garments, but manufacturing apparel from man-made fibers, such as activewear and outerwear, could help the country achieve its ambitious export targets, said Abdullah Hil Rakib, managing director of Dhaka-based Team Group, during a panel discussion. Garment companies also need to improve their environmental and social governance while tackling inefficiencies with data-driven decision making, for example on the production floor and in their management systems, he added. 'Chapter One was about volume, chapter Two is about value,' said Rakib about ways to increase the country's competitiveness as Bangladesh is facing a graduation from its status as 'Least Developed Country' by the United Nations on 24 November 2026. The country enjoys a favorable tariff regime under its current classification, such as duty-free and quota-free access to the EU which will likely end in 2029 after a transition period of three years. Trade turmoil Bangladesh's garment industry has profited from rising production costs in China over the past decade as clothing brands looked for lower-priced alternatives. Many garment industry executives believe that the country might benefit from a likely continuation of trade tensions between China and the US. US President Donald Trump has escalated the trade conflict with China by increasing tariffs on imports from China to the US to 145 percent before reducing them to 30 percent in May. While the reductions will be in place for at least 90 days while negotiations take place, it remains to be seen how the relationship between the two countries will develop as Trump seeks to reduce its trade deficit with China. 'There's hundreds of billions of dollars of business that will have to move out of China,' Pallak Seth, executive vice chairman of PDS Limited said in an interview before the reduction of US-China tariffs in May. The Mumbai-listed sourcing and trading company generates a revenue of more than 1.2 billion dollars by supplying apparel and other consumer products to about 300 retailers and brands worldwide. PDS sources from major apparel manufacturing destinations across the world with 40 percent of volumes coming from Bangladesh. The company's second biggest sourcing market is China but business there is bound for Europe more so than the US, according to Seth. While some of the business from China might move to Central America or Africa, the South Asian country with 'a large capacity and ability to expand fast is Bangladesh', Seth added. 'Bangladesh will be a net beneficiary, not only for apparel, but for general merchandise, home, electronics, pharmaceuticals and many other things.' PDS will continue to invest in Bangladesh, with Seth estimating that the company could source as much as 2.5 billion dollars in goods from the region in the next five years. Looking to Europe The relatively young country is also still in its own trade talks with the US after increased tariffs of 37 percent were put on hold during a 90-day negotiation period. As a sign of goodwill, interim head of government Muhammed Yunus had already pledged to increase imports of products such as soybeans or cotton from the US to Bangladesh. The initial impact of raised tariffs could be felt immediately in the textile sector as some Bangladeshi manufacturers reported halts on orders requested by US buyers. Dhaka-based garment supplier Knit Asia Ltd temporarily halted production on behalf of clients after the announcement of additional US tariffs, said its director Amer Salim in an interview. Now, after the suspension of tariffs, manufacturers are rushing to finish orders destined for the US within the three-month window as uncertainties over the outcome of the negotiations between the two countries remain, he added. The surprise tariffs have also prompted some apparel manufacturers to look for ways to increase their business in Europe. 'I think everyone is de-risking. Everyone's seen that [the US] is not a reliable partner, to be honest,' said Seth, adding that even US focused companies are now looking to increase their share of the European market. The continent has traditionally been their most important export destination. About half of Bangladesh's garments are exported to the European Union and 11.6 percent to the UK, while the US accounted for 18 percent, as figures by trade organization BGMEA show. Most of the woven factories in Bangladesh, producing items like shirts, or jackets, have more customers from North America while manufacturers of knits, such as t-shirts or flat-knit sweaters, generally have more European customers, said Salim. His company generates 40 percent of its revenue from the US but now he is looking to expand in Europe due to risks related to the US market. The big picture Bangladesh's textile sector's future is intertwined with global dynamics, particularly its ability to draw foreign investment during its current political changes. Nobel Laureate Muhammad Yunus is leading an interim government after his long-term predecessor Sheikh Hasina was forced to flee the country amid protests in August. The transformation of Bangladesh is advertised right at the entrance. Credits: FashionUnited The interim government is now using their temporary mandate to push for political and economical reforms before calling for elections, for which no date has yet been set. The government has to boost the flailing economy and improve infrastructure as high inflation and persistent income inequality lead to discontent and unrest in the population. 'We have a generational moonshot to change Bangladesh for the better,' Ashik Chowdhury said in Amsterdam, describing the ambitions of an interim government 'made of technocrats and geeks'. The banker turned government official, has been heading Bangladesh's Investment Development Authority and the Economic Zones Authority for six months. Chowdhury admitted that Bangladesh is not yet a perfect place to do business and that the government tries to improve the investment climate before calling for elections. 'The ambition is to convert Bangladesh into a global manufacturing hub' like a mini China, connecting West and East, he added. Attracting foreign investment is essential for fulfilling these goals. The government intends to attract such investment through initiatives like green channels, designed as a one-stop-service within the government to help businesses. Another goal is triple port capacity within five years, according to Chowdhury. He also promoted his country as young and dynamic, in line with the message of the event, in front of an audience which also included investors, Dutch government officials and NGO workers. The country's manufacturing industry is still facing transportation bottlenecks and power outages. Rising energy prices worldwide contributed to spiraling inflation and have put a strain on power supply amid slowing economic growth over the past years. Upskilling Foreign investment is also welcomed in the garment sector to create a more complete supply chain. Bangladeshi garment manufacturers are still importing ingredients like certain yarns and fabrics from countries such as China. Investments introducing technology and expertise, such as for producing these ingredients, would allow apparel producers to "offer much better things," said Salim in an interview. His company Knit Asia Ltd works with brands such as Ralph Lauren or Gymshark and generates close to half a billion of US dollars in revenue. The company, which currently employs 23,000 people at its 13 units in Bangladesh, has also heavily invested in newer machinery in the past decade. Previously, producing 10,000 sweaters required 3,000 workers, of which 2,000 operated the manual knitting machines, said Salim. With increasing automation, only 1,100 workers are currently needed to produce the same amount. Despite some remaining simple, manual jobs, the latest machinery doesn't only require less but higher-qualified employees who might even need academic credentials. Salim offers employees continuing education and recruits talent at universities in order to be prepared for the coming digital transformation. 'You need to attract new skills,' he said. 'Things that I cannot do, maybe a talented young kid can do, which I can't even think of right now. So I need to have him or her in my pool.' The technological transition that is already underway also highlights the need for the upskilling of the country's garment industry which is employing more than 4.5 million workers. Workers are losing their jobs because of automation but there are only a few initiatives for workers to get training, said Kalpona Akter, founder of the Bangladesh Centre for Worker Solidarity. They also lack understanding of the industry transition that is happening to realize which greener or sector-specific jobs they could move to and need to be included to participate in the transition, she added during a panel. Due diligence points 'Bangladesh's unique selling point cannot be to produce large quantities at low prices,' said Alexander Kohnstamm, executive director of Fair Wear Foundation during a panel. 'Skilling up your workers and equipping your factories through higher margin business, that is really what needs to be done.' More than 12 years after the collapse of the Rana Plaza building, killing at least 1138 people, NGOs such as Fair Wear agree that working conditions have generally improved in Bangladesh's garment sector. NGOs, textile bosses from Bangladesh and a sustainability manager from Bestseller talk about upskilling and workers' rights. Credits: FashionUnited Almost 90 percent of all the safety hazards identified have been remediated, but there is still a lot that needs to be done in the remaining 10 percent, according to Joris Oldenziel, the executive director of the International Accord. During a panel discussion, he noted that only 60 percent of the 1,600 factories under the Accord have a completely operational certified fire alarm and protection system. The Amsterdam-based organisation is the successor of the Bangladesh Accord, which was set up in 2013 by apparel brands, unions and manufacturers to improve working conditions in the immediate aftermath of the Rana Plaza tragedy. Health and safety conditions have improved significantly over the years but not the wages, said Paul Roeland, an activist from the Clean Clothes Campaign in an interview. The NGO is still supporting demands for a minimum wage of 23.000 Taka (188.42 US dollars) as the last adjustment of the minimum wage wasn't sufficient given the inflation last year. People still have to work overtime, some as much as 80 hours, to sustain themselves, Roeland added. He further demanded that dialogue with workers needs to be included in the minimum wage settings. Workers should also receive better guarantees for freedom of association, said the activist. Another increasing area of concern is the impact of climate change on workers who have become more prone to suffering from floods blocking their way to the work place or the impact of heat stress at work and in the home, added Akter. Next generation The legacy of Rana Plaza and stricter legislation about sustainability and human rights violations in the supply chain have prompted fashion companies to keep a closer eye on their suppliers. Frequent compliance audits have helped to improve working conditions and raise consciousness for more sustainable production methods. However, factories complain about the rise of repetitive audits in a short period of time which put a strain on human and financial resources. 'There is no sharing of audit results or recognition of other independent programmes that emerge shortly thereafter, as such factories that work with multiple buyers and data undergo multiple audits, each pretty much the same as the other,' said Sohel Sadat, chairman of garment maker Shin Shin Group during a panel. He estimated that his company spends more than 100,000 dollars on audits, certifications and traceability. While there is acknowledgement from brands and NGOs that the overlap of audits should be reduced, no single solution is in sight yet. Facing stricter future sustainable legislation, especially as part of the Green Deal by the EU, the question remains who will foot the bill for a greener future. 'Here we need financial support, policy support and of course our own commitments,' Abdullah Hil Rakib, managing director of Team Group said. Many also hope that attracting higher-margin business will provide more room to pay workers better and to be more responsible to the environment. Therefore, the garment industry also needs to shed its current image. 'We're kind of stuck in this loop where the consumers, the retailers, the buyers are so used to getting inexpensive things from Bangladesh,' said Mustafain Munir, the director of Cyclo Fibers based in Dhaka. 'People should stop having that negative association that because it's made in Bangladesh, it's made with forced labour or bad environmental practices.' 'The practices were not good before,' admits the second-generation textile entrepreneur. But progress has been made in terms of safety, health and the environment, especially in the last ten years. His company in particular is one that is making people rethink their image of garments from Bangladesh. Back in 2009, even before circularity became a buzzword in the fashion industry, he and his father had the foresight to buy a bankrupt Spanish company and to bring its mechanical recycling machine to Bangladesh. After years of research, Cyclo Fibers has achieved a breakthrough, developing an in-house process to manufacture recycled fibers at a lower cost than virgin fibers. Hardly anyone in the fashion industry is currently able to do so. From this perspective, Cyclo offers a pioneering example of the possibilities of the local industry. 'So everything is better, at the same price,' said Munir. 'It's a tough challenge but we're doing it.'
NBC News
2 hours ago
- NBC News
At least 11 people die in a stampede in India as fans celebrate cricket championship
BENGALURU, India — At least 11 people are dead and more than 30 injured after a stampede on Wednesday as crowds tried to enter a cricket stadium in the southern Indian state of Karnataka, authorities said. The crush happened as tens of thousands of cricket fans gathered outside the M. Chinnaswamy Stadium in the city of Bengaluru to celebrate the winners of the Indian Premier League, the world's most popular T20 cricket tournament. Karnataka state's Chief Minister Siddaramaiah, who uses only one name, said the crowd tried to break one of the stadium's gates and enter to take part in celebrations. Eleven people were killed and 33 others were injured, Siddaramaiah said, adding that most of the injured were stable and receiving treatment in hospitals. 'At a time of celebration, this unfortunate event should not have happened. We are saddened by this,' he told reporters. 'No one expected this crowd,' he said.
Wales Online
5 hours ago
- Wales Online
Restaurant forced to close after 25 years because it 'smells of curry'
Restaurant forced to close after 25 years because it 'smells of curry' A much-loved eatery is shutting its doors for good after being taken to court over the strong smell of food wafting from its premises One restaurant in England received complaints about the strong smell of its food (Image: Getty Images ) A beloved curry house has been forced to shut its doors after 25 years due to complaints about the smell of curry. Cinnamons Restaurant in Wheatley, Oxfordshire, received a complaint in 2021 about the "curry odours" coming from the premises, which was upheld by environmental health officers. The restaurant spent £35,000 on a new extractor fan, but after another complaint, they were served an abatement notice, deeming the new ventilation system defective. It was unable to afford the estimated £50,000 for a new system and was taken to court, pleading guilty and paying a £25,000 fine in October 2024. Despite the expenditure, South Oxfordshire District Council issued another abatement notice and last month Cinnamons announced it could no longer afford the demands and would close in mid-June, resulting in 10 job losses. The council stated that prosecution was necessary "if measures are not introduced to solve the issue and abatement notices are breached". Shirazul Hoque, who runs Cinnamons, told PA Real Life: "The village wants the restaurant to stay, otherwise we would have closed before paying the £25,000 fine. It's really hard for us and feels absolutely wrong as we love our village... "It is hurtful to have our cuisine, which is loved, described as producing obnoxious odours that stink." All our employees have families and the chefs who live above the restaurant will be made homeless – it's a big punch in the gut." Article continues below Shirazul Hoque, right, and his uncle had fought a lengthy court battle over the smell complaint (Image: Collect/PA Real Life ) Cinnamons has been a staple in Wheatley since 2000. The business was taken over by Shirazul's uncles in 2012, and they've been serving up Bangladeshi and Indian food ever since, reports the Mirror. Numerous TripAdvisor reviews highlight the restaurant as a vital part of the community. One happy punter commented on the site: "We are so lucky to have this restaurant in our village." In 2021, the restaurant was honoured with the TripAdvisor Travellers' Choice award, a recognition given to businesses that consistently receive high reviews from travellers and rank within the top 10% in their field on the site. However, in the same year, an odour complaint was lodged against the restaurant with South Oxfordshire District Council. An officer from the Environmental Health Agency validated the complaint. After more than two decades of service, Shirazul stated that Cinnamons had never faced such a complaint before but complied by installing a £35,000 ventilation system as required. He said: "We wanted to resolve it because we've been here for 20 years, we love our village and we wanted to do something about it." A higher specification ventilation model was suggested by a consultant, but the restaurant felt they could neither afford the installation cost – estimated to be roughly £50,000 – nor the maintenance cost. Despite substantial work being carried out by a reputable firm with over 30 years of experience, another complaint was made to the council, according to Shirazul. The Environmental Protection Team found the odour unacceptable, and the ventilator defective upon investigating the restaurant. Cinnamons was then instructed to fix their ventilation system. "We weren't able to afford it," Shirazul explained. "To be honest, business had not rebounded post-Covid. We'd not been making any profit so we didn't have the money for this." The restaurant's new £35,000 ventilation system was not enough to satisfy council officials (Image: Collect/PA Real Life ) As no solution was forthcoming, the establishment found itself on the wrong side of an abatement notice, leading to court action. In October 2024, Cinnamons entered a guilty plea and was handed a £25,000 fine. Despite this, the problems with ventilation persisted, presenting an additional financial hurdle that Shirazul estimated could cost around £50,000. Then on May 19, came the heartbreaking decision at Cinnamons – the struggle was too much to bear, resulting in ten employees being informed they no longer had their roles. "It's very hard to share this story because I've spent a lot of my time in the business," Shirazul admitted. The restaurateur imparted some wisdom to fellow business owners: "Do due diligence in seeing how the council environmental health officers operate and learn the appeal process." Shirazul shared that on their final day of business, June 15, the restaurant will provide complimentary meals to visitors as a token of appreciation. He said: "It's a gesture of thanks for all the support we've received through the difficulties of the last few year. It's a way of saying thank you for standing by us." South Oxfordshire District Council explained its position with the statement: "The council has a legal duty to investigate nuisance complaints about smells from industrial, trade and business premises that could be a statutory nuisance. We always aim to advise and support businesses on how they can resolve issues. However, if measures are not introduced to solve the issue and abatement notices are breached, we have no option but to prosecute. The restaurant has received plenty of praise since it opened in 2000 (Image: Collect/PA Real Life ) "In the case of Cinnamons Restaurant in Wheatley, the Council's Environmental Protection Team has assessed the odour complaint following our procedures and legislation. An extensive investigation at this site determined a statutory nuisance existed in relation to the kitchen's ventilation systems." It added? "Cinnamons Cuisine Limited, who run the restaurant, has since failed to follow our recommendations and has breached an environmental abatement notice on several occasions between October 2023 and April 2024. Cinnamons pleaded guilty to four charges ahead of a scheduled three-day court appearance on Wednesday 2 October 2024. Article continues below "The District Judge at Oxford Magistrates' Court reviewed the evidence and statements provided by council officers and the company, and taking into consideration the revised guilty plea, the judge ordered that the company pay a total of £25,000 – this includes an £11,000 fine, an award of full costs of £12,000 to South Oxfordshire District Council, alongside a victim surcharge of £2,000. "As well as pleading guilty to the charges of statutory nuisance laid against them, Cinnamons admitted that they could have done more to mitigate the odour. The council can advise and assist where we can, but ultimately responsibility for fixing the problem sits with the business. "The business has been provided advice and guidance on steps they can take but to date have failed to follow our recommendations. Cinnamons is still the subject of an ongoing legal case, and we will therefore not be in a position to comment any further on this case other than the information provided in the statement above."
