‘Just got word': AFL shuts down conspiracy theory over rare umpire act
The AFL has clarified a controversial umpiring moment late in Essendon's thrilling win over North Melbourne on Thursday night.
Essendon held off a late Kangaroos charge to claim a 9.11 (65) to 9.8 (62) win, their fourth victory of the season. But it could have been a different story if an umpiring decision went a different way late in the game.
FOX FOOTY, available on Kayo Sports, is the only place to watch every AFL match this Saturday LIVE. Catch all the action in 4K, with no ad-breaks during play. New to Kayo? Get your first month for just $1. Limited-time offer.
With less than 10 minutes remaining in the game and the Kangaroos trailing by just eight points, the ball was deep in North's forward line when the umpire blew the whistle to ball it up in the goalsquare when Jacob Konstanty unnecessarily kicked the ball away.
But the umpire paid a free kick to a North Melbourne player for 'kicking the ball away', which prompted furious Essendon players to point out to the umpire that North's Konstanty was the one who kicked it away.
In rare scenes, the umpire held a finger to his earpiece and changed his mind, saying: 'I've just got word, I just got word' before deciding to ball it up.
Essendon midfielder Will Setterfield pleaded to the umpire: 'That's our free kick.'
Had the umpire paid the free kick to Konstanty, it would have likely resulted in a goal to the Kangaroos, cutting Essendon's lead to two points.
Jack Riewoldt said on Fox Footy: 'Just got word, we can change it, can we?'
Fox Footy reporter Jon Ralph explained the communication had come from one of the other on-field umpires and there was no Big Brother style conspiracy to change the decision.
'There was a mistake made, it just wasn't one made with outside interference,' Ralph said.
'The conspiracy theorists thought maybe when the umpire reversed the free kick, it might have come from the (umpire's) coaches box. They are mic'd up with them but they are not allowed to interfere in the game in any way
'That came from one of the other umpires. All four of the umpires are mic'd up. Konstanty kicks the ball away, the free kick is paid to (North Melbourne's) Finnbar Maley, it's taken off him.
'It should have been a free kick to the Dons as one of those Essendon players Setterfield said. I just needed to clarify it's not from the umpire's coach's box because that would be absolutely out of bounds.'
Seven's AFL reporter Mitch Cleary said: 'There's not some big brother sitting in the stands that can comms in.
'The AFL is adamant that (the clarification) has come from one of the other three field umpires. They got the right decision in the end.'
'That's the first time ever I've seen an umpire change his decision,' Channel 7 commentator Brian Taylor said.
Bombers defender Mason Redman told ABC Radio post game: 'They called a ball up and then Konstanty booted the ball into the stands, they then called it on Hobbsy (Ben Hobbs) and we were like, 'That's not what happened mate'.
'Lucky one of the other umpires communicated to him. I thought we'd get the ball back because I supposed that would make sense as the North player kicked it … I think they sorta half made the right decision.'
Essendon captain Zach Merrett had another superb game, finishing with 35 disposals to help lead his side to a fourth win of the year, keeping in touch with the race for finals.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Perth Now
2 hours ago
- Perth Now
High-flying Magpies won't shift AFL finals focus
Craig McRae's focus on simply qualifying for the AFL finals won't shift despite Collingwood surging six points clear on top of the ladder ahead of their mid-season bye. The Magpies head to a well-earned break with an enviable 11-2 record, having claimed a fifth-straight win in an epic King's Birthday clash with Melbourne. McRae's men could hardly be in a better position in a campaign that started with accusations they were too old and too slow after a first-up thumping from GWS. But the 2023 premiership coach won't be tempted to alter his ambitions heading into the second half of the season. "We're in this phase of qualifying and there's no other thing we're doing at the moment," McRae said after his side's 11.6 (72) to 10.11 (71) victory over Melbourne. "There's no bigger outcome than just getting enough wins to play finals. "We're all in the same (boat) and today was a really good result because the opposition were very, very good." McRae conceded the win over Melbourne wasn't overly pretty after watching his side cough up a 20-point third-quarter lead. The Demons hit the front briefly in the final term, when they finally began to take advantage of their ascendancy at the coalface. Dan McStay's late goal put Collingwood back in front before Dees duo Max Gawn and Koltyn Tholstrup missed chances to snatch the game away in the dying stages. "They're probably in there thinking they let one slip because all the numbers suggest they dominated phases of the game, particularly the contest," McRae said. "The contest was enormous but we found a way to win and that's what we do at the moment." All class, Steele Sidebottom ⭐️#AFLDeesPies AFL (@AFL) June 9, 2025 Collingwood can further press their claims for an important top-two finish with three straight games against bottom-half teams - St Kilda, West Coast and Carlton - on return from the bye. Brayden Maynard (foot) could come back against the Saints, with Jordan De Goey (achilles) and Lachie Schultz (hamstring) also set to play roles in the second half of the season. The biggest flashpoint of Monday's match perhaps came after the final siren, when Demons duo Max Gawn and Steven May clashed. With less than a minute left, Gawn's miscued kick after a mark in the back pocket went straight to Collingwood's Will Hoskin-Elliott to confirm the result. May angrily approached Gawn on the final siren. The captain also made his feelings clear before pushing May away. "Two competitors, frustrated - two leaders (who) have an incredibly strong relationship, obviously disappointed with the outcome," said Melbourne coach Simon Goodwin.
Daily Telegraph
5 hours ago
- Daily Telegraph
‘Doesn't want to play for them': Bombshell racism report rocks AFL club
Don't miss out on the headlines from AFL. Followed categories will be added to My News. Adelaide veteran Taylor Walker's racism incident several years ago is playing a role in star trade target Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera refusing to consider joining the Crows, according to veteran journalist Caroline Wilson. However the Saints gun's manager has firmly denied he has ruled out joining the club. In 2021, Walker was handed a six-week suspension and $20,000 fine for racially abusing an Indigenous SANFL player while addressing the Crows reserves players in a non-playing capacity. FOX FOOTY, available on Kayo Sports, is the only place to watch every match of every round in the 2025 Toyota AFL Premiership Season LIVE in 4K, with no ad-breaks during play. New to Kayo? Get your first month for just $1. Limited-time offer. The incident rocked both Walker, who was 'an emotional wreck' in the aftermath, and the team with coach Matthew Nicks emotionally calling it 'completely unacceptable and something that we won't stand for as a football club'. Wanganeen-Milera was drafted by St Kilda later that year and the South Australian, who has emerged as a young superstar halfback, is now weighing up whether to return to his home state or remain at the Saints with lucrative offers looming either way. Will Faulkner has reported Port Adelaide feels well-placed in the race for Wanganeen-Milera due to his close ties with Power players Jason Horne-Francis and Jase Burgoyne, while he also has family links to the club due to his uncle Gavin Wanganeen. Wilson reported on Monday night the 22-year-old will not consider the Crows partially due to the Walker incident, and particularly the way it was discussed on Channel Nine earlier this year. 'I'm making no comment about the club's handling of that incident, because my memory is that Matthew Nicks, the coach, was shattered by that incident, and the club did everything they could to get around Robbie Young (the player abused),' she said on Seven. Tex Walker and Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera. 'But Wanganeen-Milera has clarified that Matthew Nicks was the coach at the time and has indicated that he doesn't want to go to the Adelaide Football Club. 'One thing that happened over Gather Round, and I'm not talking so much about Wanganeen-Milera here, but a lot of his friends and the South Australian Indigenous community, was the Gather Round special that was aired on the Nine Network, hosted by Eddie McGuire.' A clip from the TV show was then aired in which McGuire described the incident as 'tough times' for Walker and framed him as dealing with adversity. Walker hit back at that framing somewhat, saying he 'made a mistake, one that I've got to live with for the rest of my life. But I suppose when you make mistakes, you get a choice, whether you can dwell on it, or you can learn about it.' While Wilson did not want to minimise any work Walker has done to make amends for the incident, and did not blame him for the framing of the interview, she explained there was 'a view from Indigenous leaders across footy that it portrayed Taylor Walker as more of a victim than Robbie Young. 'And it's just a small thing, but it wasn't a small thing to others who were still badly injured by what happened back in 2021. 'And so for a variety of reasons, but specifically Wanganeen-Milera's issues with Taylor Walker and what happened back then, the view from Port Adelaide and others in the footy community is if he does leave, he'll be going to Port Adelaide.' Wanganeen-Milera's manager Ben Williams denied a decision had been reached. In a statement to Nine Adelaide, he said: 'Reports made in the media suggesting that Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera has ruled out joining the Adelaide Crows due to comments made by Taylor Walker in 2021 are false. 'Nasiah is currently considering his future and at this stage, no decisions have been made, and any speculation suggesting otherwise is inaccurate.' Wanganeen-Milera is expected to receive long-term offers nearing $10 million but must be traded if he wants to leave, as he is several years away from reaching free agency. Originally published as 'Doesn't want to play for them': Bombshell racism report rocks AFL club
News.com.au
8 hours ago
- News.com.au
‘Doesn't want to play for them': Bombshell racism report rocks AFL club
Adelaide veteran Taylor Walker's racism incident several years ago is playing a role in star trade target Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera refusing to consider joining the Crows, according to veteran journalist Caroline Wilson. However the Saints gun's manager has firmly denied he has ruled out joining the club. In 2021, Walker was handed a six-week suspension and $20,000 fine for racially abusing an Indigenous SANFL player while addressing the Crows reserves players in a non-playing capacity. FOX FOOTY, available on Kayo Sports, is the only place to watch every match of every round in the 2025 Toyota AFL Premiership Season LIVE in 4K, with no ad-breaks during play. New to Kayo? Get your first month for just $1. Limited-time offer. The incident rocked both Walker, who was 'an emotional wreck' in the aftermath, and the team with coach Matthew Nicks emotionally calling it 'completely unacceptable and something that we won't stand for as a football club'. Wanganeen-Milera was drafted by St Kilda later that year and the South Australian, who has emerged as a young superstar halfback, is now weighing up whether to return to his home state or remain at the Saints with lucrative offers looming either way. Will Faulkner has reported Port Adelaide feels well-placed in the race for Wanganeen-Milera due to his close ties with Power players Jason Horne-Francis and Jase Burgoyne, while he also has family links to the club due to his uncle Gavin Wanganeen. Wilson reported on Monday night the 22-year-old will not consider the Crows partially due to the Walker incident, and particularly the way it was discussed on Channel Nine earlier this year. 'I'm making no comment about the club's handling of that incident, because my memory is that Matthew Nicks, the coach, was shattered by that incident, and the club did everything they could to get around Robbie Young (the player abused),' she said on Seven. 'But Wanganeen-Milera has clarified that Matthew Nicks was the coach at the time and has indicated that he doesn't want to go to the Adelaide Football Club. 'One thing that happened over Gather Round, and I'm not talking so much about Wanganeen-Milera here, but a lot of his friends and the South Australian Indigenous community, was the Gather Round special that was aired on the Nine Network, hosted by Eddie McGuire.' A clip from the TV show was then aired in which McGuire described the incident as 'tough times' for Walker and framed him as dealing with adversity. Walker hit back at that framing somewhat, saying he 'made a mistake, one that I've got to live with for the rest of my life. But I suppose when you make mistakes, you get a choice, whether you can dwell on it, or you can learn about it.' While Wilson did not want to minimise any work Walker has done to make amends for the incident, and did not blame him for the framing of the interview, she explained there was 'a view from Indigenous leaders across footy that it portrayed Taylor Walker as more of a victim than Robbie Young. 'And it's just a small thing, but it wasn't a small thing to others who were still badly injured by what happened back in 2021. 'And so for a variety of reasons, but specifically Wanganeen-Milera's issues with Taylor Walker and what happened back then, the view from Port Adelaide and others in the footy community is if he does leave, he'll be going to Port Adelaide.' Wanganeen-Milera's manager Ben Williams denied a decision had been reached. In a statement to Nine Adelaide, he said: 'Reports made in the media suggesting that Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera has ruled out joining the Adelaide Crows due to comments made by Taylor Walker in 2021 are false. 'Nasiah is currently considering his future and at this stage, no decisions have been made, and any speculation suggesting otherwise is inaccurate.' Wanganeen-Milera is expected to receive long-term offers nearing $10 million but must be traded if he wants to leave, as he is several years away from reaching free agency.
