St. Paul City Council deadlocks around Ryan Cos. plan to add one-story buildings along Ford Parkway
A developer's efforts to add a series of single-story buildings along the outer edges of the Highland Bridge development have been rebuffed by a tie vote of the St. Paul City Council.
The Ryan Cos. recently sought zoning variances to add four squat buildings along Ford Parkway, each of them no more than 12 to 18 feet tall, on parcels of land where city zoning calls for a minimum of 40 feet. Variance requests for building height and floor area ratio were denied in January by the city's Board of Zoning Appeals after some members likened the proposal to a strip mall, thrusting the issue before the city council.
Council Member Saura Jost, who represents Highland Park, urged her fellow council members on Wednesday to vote in favor of the Ryan Cos. two appeals of the BZA decision, noting that 'almost all projects at Highland Bridge have approved variances from the zoning code.'
The council then voted on Jost's motions, deadlocking 3-3 on each of the company's requests for zoning variances on the two land parcels. Council Members Anika Bowie and Cheniqua Johnson joined Jost in voting yes, and Council President Rebecca Noecker and HwaJeong Kim joined Nelsie Yang in voting no.
Given the tie, the motions did not pass. Council members noted that the vote could be reconsidered next week if a council member changed their vote.
Spanning more than 122 acres, the former home of the Ford Motor Company assembly plant in Highland Park has been developed into hundreds of housing units, commercial offices, multiple playgrounds and a Lunds & Byerlys grocery store, but residential construction has slowed.
Representatives of the Ryan Cos. have expressed concern that filling an additional series of sizable commercial or mixed-use buildings will be difficult given an economic climate marked by high interest rates, a difficult lending environment, sluggish city population growth, remote work and the city's rent control ordinance.
Just prior to the vote, Jost said the Board of Zoning Appeals had erred in identifying Ford Parkway at Cretin Avenue as a 'neighborhood node,' or a potential transit and development hotspot, when it's not listed as such in the city's Comprehensive Plan. She also noted the Ryan Cos. had expressed concern about navigating Ford Parkway's steep slope, shallow bedrock and perched water, as well as pedestrian easements that cut across the lot diagonally, which had been a city priority.
'Buildings ultimately bear on the soil below them,' Jost said. 'These are challenges not created by the landowner, but by the land. And as I mentioned before, they impact the entirety of the design.'
A Twin Cities developer unimpressed with the concept plans told the BZA — and the city council, during a public hearing last week — that construction challenges around slopes and bedrock are common and not insurmountable. While the Ryan Cos. had not provided a geo-technical analysis to prove their point, neither had he, Jost noted.
'I strongly disagree with a local developer being an expert when it comes to sub-surface soil conditions,' she said. 'They're not expert design professionals.'
Taking the opposite tack, Yang said the BZA had relied on credible testimony from a developer with experience in the field, and she could not support the company's appeals. 'I did not find an error in the decision-making,' she said.
Local News | Ryan Cos. appeals denial of Highland Bridge one-story storefronts
Local News | Ryan Cos. to appeal negative zoning decision at St. Paul's Highland Bridge
Local News | St. Paul Board of Zoning Appeals blocks Highland Bridge 'strip mall' proposal 4-2
Local News | St. Paul: At Highland Bridge, Ryan Cos. seeks less height, density along Ford Parkway
Local News | St. Paul free mental health clinic reached more than 100 visits since opening in October
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
12 hours ago
- Yahoo
Crawford County seeks community input for new growth plan
CRAWFORD CO., Mo. — Crawford County officials are asking for the community's help to create a new growth plan for the next 20 years. County commissioners and the county counselor held a public comprehensive plan and zoning meeting, Thursday evening. Nearly three dozen attended in-person and even more by livestream, to learn more about the process needed to create a new comprehensive plan. The county hasn't had a new plan since 2002, so they're asking for the community's help guiding commissioners and agencies for the next two decades. Those in attendance filled out a 12-page public input survey, focusing on land use, zoning, and wind and solar issues. There's also a survey to gather even more input. 'It's a good opportunity for them to learn about the process, encouraging people to get that survey taken, to get the results back into the commissioners, have the input they need to start the comprehensive plan process. This is our first step as the survey to gauge public opinion,' said Jim Emerson, Crawford County Counselor. Crawford County seeks community input for new growth plan New data center coming to southeast Kansas PSU's Center for Reading hosting educational summer camp for kids KDOT hosting Hwy 69 improvement meetings this week for Crawford County resident input Southeast Kansas sheriff quips, 'We saved the 4th of July' Jim Emerson says they have more than 1,000 completed surveys but are aiming for 4,000 in total. They hope to wrap up the survey process by July 1. You can find a link to that survey, here. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Yahoo
3 days ago
- Yahoo
Veteran mechanic making a ground-up revival of Larned shop
Jun. 4—Larned City Council meeting at a glance Here is a brief look at what the Larned City Council did Monday evening: —In the consent agenda, approved minutes of May's regular meeting and also minutes of the Planning Commission and Board of Zoning Appeals. Also approved was a single audit to be performed by Adams Brown, for review at the July council meeting. —Approved Appropriations Ordinance No. 5 in the amount of $1,116,181.43. —In old business, approved revisions to the city's newly-drafted Water Conservation Plan by Ranson Fianancial, after review by the Kansas Department of Heath and Environment. Key to the plan are plans for water use conservation and practices; education, management and regulation, with drought response goals, triggers, management and regulatory actions. —In new business, approved a zoning change of the north 35 feet of 402 W. 13th St. from R-2 residential to C-1 commercial, to allow resident Jim Haynes to construct a fenced lot for business applications that include commercial vehicle parking and operation. The change was approved by the Zoning Commission at its May 14 meeting. —Approved the city street department's 2025 chip and seal plan as presented by Street Superintendent Adam Perez, utilizing the $150,000 bid contract approved in May with Circle C Paving concerning approximately 44 blocks in Wards 1 and 2 as well as Second Street from Morris to Santa Fe Streets. —Approved the purchase of a used 2018 Sullair air compressor from United Rentals in Hays at a cost of $13,000 for use by the city's street and parks departments. —After discussion, failed a motion to approve amending a city ordinance allowing non-local state-licensed vendors intending to sell liquor at approved events in the community such as the annual Santa Fe Trail Days celebration. —After discussion, approved the purchase of 10 concrete planters at a cost of approximately $560 each to be placed at strategic locations in the city, utilizing a $2,500 grant from Golden Belt Community Foundation with a 50/50 city match. The grant was intended to be utilized in tandem with the city's Broadway streetscape project. —Discussed moving forward with a project to repaint the interior of the Larned Community Center along with other needed maintenance and repair issues. The building's sound system, lighting and HVAC were also discussed. —Approved City Mechanic Joe Schartz's request to purchase a used 16,000-pound capacity Symmetric truck lift at a cost of $20,436 as a replacement to the City Shop's decades-old lift to improve service levels in city vehicle maintenance. Funding would be split between departments and general fund. —Heard a staff presentation by City Mechanic Joe Schartz on the progress being made in reviving the city's vehicle and equipment maintenance department after a 12-year hiatus. LARNED — Reviving a department after a 12-year layoff can be a daunting task for any city operation, but once in a while, things just fall into place. Larned City Manager Brad Eilts noted that for some time, he and the city council had realized not having a department for regular repair and maintenance of city vehicles and equipment was a drawback. Twelve years ago, City Mechanic Terry Taylor announced that after 32 years running the vehicle maintenance program for the City of Larned, he desired to take early retirement, but wasn't ready to retire, so he bought Don Hanken Motors and transformed it into his auto body shop. That left a hole in city operations that took a while for the city to realize, Eilts said. "A few years ago, the council put it back in the budget," Eilts said. "We were trying to figure it out, but we'd hit a wall and shelved it again. We were trying to find the right man for the job." This year, however, the right man appeared in the person of Joe Schartz, who was looking for a career change that would put his 40 years of automotive repair experience to use. For the past three months, he's been going over the building that the city shop shares with the street department on Santa Fe Street, taking stock of what the operation needs in terms of tools and equipment. Three months into the process, Schartz requested his first big ticket item from the Larned City Council, and the council agreed with the request — a 16,000-pound, 2 post Symmetric vehicle lift, to replace the worn-out and leaking lift that has been in place since the 1980s. Modern times, modern measures, as it were. "My first day in the building, I wasn't sure exactly what I'd be up against," the veteran mechanic said. While he was impressed that the adjacent street department employees cleaned up his two bays and swept it top to bottom for his arrival, he cast a critical eye toward what he had to work with. "When I did my walkaround, things would go through my mind on what needs replaced, what needs updated, what needs fixed," he said. A lot of things — including the lift and its eight-foot pit in the concrete floor — were tagged for replacement or repair. "It's been about 12 years since we've had a city mechanic," he told the council. "Twelve years is a long time when you're talking about equipment. Terry Taylor did a very good job when he was there, but with nothing being there for 12 years, we're starting from the ground up with everything. Even small tools, like battery chargers and jumper cables, air conditioning equipment. We've been purchasing every day a little bit at a time; it seems like every day I go into work, I need a tool, so we're gradually updating our equipment in that manner." Getting a modern, safer, more efficient lift topped the list. "That's gonna be a big improvement," he said. "When I first started, the first two weeks was nothing but oil changes every day. We got caught up on that, so then the guys would bring something in and say that their window wasn't working or some other small thing. Now we're into the mower stuff, like transmission problems." Getting connected Schartz has been busy lining up wholesale vendors for parts and supplies. "We are now buying oil in bulk in 55-gallon drums instead of a quart at a time and getting wholesale pricing on that," he said. "On things like oil filters, air filters, other suppliers and dealers are giving us 10% discounts. He noted that vendor Jasper Engine and Transmissions gave him a quote on an engine with a $1,000 discount. "We've already started to save a lot of money." Heading into summer, he's been working on mower repair, as well as small item requests from various departments. "The parks department has a Yawnmar tractor from 1984 that Josh Kraisinger has been having troubles with for quite a while. I found a place we could get parts for it and I've got the alternator working on it now. There are a lot of older vehicles that are coming in but we'll be able to get parts for them to keep them running. "Things like that the city has lost out on by not having a mechanic," he said. "Not everyone is mechanically inclined, so if they think they've got a bad engine, they'll just sideline it. But it usually doesn't take long to fix and then they're back in service. "I knew it was going to be a challenge and it has been a challenge," he said. "The employees from the other departments are there anytime I need help. They have no issues coming over to help, whether it's holding a wrench or lifting something. That's impressive; to come into an organization with different departments and everybody wants to help." Some of Schartz's immediate goals are keeping maintenance logs on every fleet vehicle. "When a new vehicle comes in, there's a file started on it. Some departments have their own maintenance records, but I've started files of my own," he noted. "I will be making checklists going through every vehicle in the fleet and evaluating them; tires, brakes, hoses, engines and conditions of every vehicle so that we can get a handle on what kind of shape our equipment is really in. It will take a little while to do that, but that's one of the projects I've gotten started. "I would like to invest in flush equipment in the shop, transmissions, coolant, power steering. I'd say probably 90% of our fleet needs a transmission flush. If we keep up on those kinds of things, the longevity of our vehicles is going to go up, too." After securing his lift request, Schartz noted he was a little nervous about making his first staff report to the council. "I could do regular reports if that's what the city council wants me to do," he said. "I don't have a problem with that. With the shop being empty for 12 years, and starting from the ground up, a report every once in a while would be nice because the city and the community needs to know what the tax dollars are going for. "They listened to me and I got what I wanted, so I must be doing something right so far."
Yahoo
5 days ago
- Yahoo
Ground is broken for next phase projects at St. Paul's Highland Bridge
With a ceremonial toss of a shovel of dirt, St. Paul Mayor Melvin Carter joined developers with the Ryan Cos. along Ford Parkway this week to break ground on a long-stalled, $68 million phase of construction within Highland Bridge, which will include the first retail additions since Lunds and Byerlys relocated a nearby store there in September 2022. Highland Bridge, which is about 50% developed, was once the site of the Ford Motor Co.'s Twin Cities assembly plant, which closed in December 2011, leading into more than 13 years of planning, soil remediation and building construction. That construction has slowed, though not entirely stopped, in the era of high interest rates, softer urban housing demand and rent control, which the city of St. Paul permanently rolled back last month for new construction. Work on the five new additions — spanning four single-level retail buildings, a 97-unit mixed-use apartment building with ground-level retail, and a two-level parking structure — is expected to get underway in earnest this summer and continue into October or November 2026. Given the current state of interest rates, financing and urban housing demand, 'it is challenging right now to do market-rate, multi-family,' said Maureen Michalski, a senior vice president of development with the Minneapolis-based Ryan Cos., 'but we're committed to the site. Weidner Apartment Homes is committed to the site. We're willing to advance the site based on this being a legacy project for us.' One of the single-story structures to be erected closest to Lunds and Byerlys already has a tenant lined up — Tierra Encantada, a Spanish-immersion daycare that plans to make Highland Bridge its 10th Minnesota location. The three other single-story structures, which will front Ford Parkway, will be built on more of an 'if you build it, they will come' model, with hopes of attracting retail to one of the more affluent corners of the city. Together with the ground-level of the future mixed-use building, they'll total 35,000 square feet of retail, Michalski said. The 133-acre Highland Bridge development also houses a two-story medical office building anchored by M Health Fairview, though most of the other construction to date has been residential, and until now, hundreds of units of planned market-rate housing have been on pause for years. That pause is over, according to the Ryan Cos. 'We have a variety of actions taken at the (city) council level that helped,' Michalski said, noting recent changes to tax increment financing agreements and other site controls. 'We essentially looked at the existing redevelopment agreement and minimum assessment agreement, and made some reallocations and rebalancing there … basically changing some timing of things.' The latest buildings, to be developed by the Ryan Cos. and located between Cretin Avenue and Mount Curve Boulevard, will be bisected by a new pedestrian promenade that will emerge at an angle from a small plaza to be located near Lunds at Ford Parkway and Cretin Ave. The future promenade will extend to an existing plaza located near Marvella 2190, the senior independent living apartment complex at 2190 Hillcrest Ave. 'It's a very desirable location,' Michalski said. 'Marvella 2190, which just opened in the spring, was fully leased when it opened in March.' Roads and infrastructure along the far southern end of the site are being completed south of Montreal Avenue and east of Cretin Avenue. Throughout Highland Bridge, four parks have opened to the public. Michalski said Weidner Apartment Homes plans to begin work next year on a roughly 170-unit apartment building south of the site, toward Bohland and Cretin avenues, and Presbyterian Homes plans additional senior housing. Elsewhere within the 133-acre development, six of 20 single-family lots have been sold, Michalski said, and about 150 upscale Pulte rowhomes have been completed to date. Overall, Highland Bridge currently spans about 1,000 units of residential housing, much of it located within multi-family developments and senior apartments built close to Ford Parkway. Of that total, about 200 units would qualify as affordable housing, much of it assembled with the help of tax incentives known as tax increment financing, using market-rate development to subsidize the affordable units. The Lumin, affordable senior apartments developed by CommonBond Communities, and Project for Pride in Living's Restoring Waters, which caters to families that have experienced homelessness, were constructed with funding derived in part from the two market-rate Marvella senior housing projects. Restoring Waters is now the headquarters for Emma Norton Services. St. Paul: At Highland Bridge, Weidner Homes, Ryan Cos. win concessions St. Paul City Council ends rent control for housing built after 2004 St. Paul: Ryan Cos. plan for four one-story buildings along Ford Parkway inch closer to approval by default
