logo
Judge weighs text evidence after Brett Howden's emotional testimony

Judge weighs text evidence after Brett Howden's emotional testimony

New York Times22-05-2025

LONDON, Ont. – The judge in the Hockey Canada sexual assault trial will decide whether text messages Brett Howden sent to a teammate describing Dillion Dubé smacking the complainant's buttocks are admissible as evidence.
'Dude, I'm so happy I left when all that sh– went down. Ha, ha,' Howden wrote to Taylor Raddysh, also adding: 'Man, when I was leaving, Duber was smacking this girl's ass so hard. It looked like it hurt so bad.'
Advertisement
On Thursday, Justice Maria Carroccia heard arguments from both the Crown and defense as to whether the text exchange between Howden and Raddysh could be submitted as evidence as 'past recollections recorded.' Court ended early, as Carroccia said she needed time to make a ruling on the key piece of the prosecution's evidence.
Carroccia is expected to deliver her ruling on Friday morning.
Howden sent the text message to Raddysh on June 26, 2018, as the former 2018 Canadian World Junior teammates learned that Hockey Canada was opening an investigation into allegations that a woman had been sexually assaulted by several members of that team a week earlier in a London, Ont., hotel room.
Howden and Raddysh were roommates at the hotel, where they stayed during a Hockey Canada gala and golf tournament. Neither Howden nor Raddysh are accused of wrongdoing.
On Thursday morning, Howden — now a member of the Vegas Golden Knights — appeared in court via video feed from Las Vegas, where he resides.
As he was questioned by Lisa Carnelos, counsel for Dubé, Howden grew visibly emotional as he recalled learning about the Hockey Canada investigation and having to tell his father about the incidents. Carnelos later pressed Howden about his state of mind at the time.
'You're scared of a number of things,' she said. 'You're scared of your dad.'
Howden paused, and appeared to choke up.
'It was one of the hardest things to go through,' he said.
Carnelos pressed further, asking about his girlfriend at the time.
'That girlfriend was very important to you right?'
'Yes,' Howden said. 'She's my wife.'
'You've just had your second child with her, correct?'
Howden's face grew red.
'Yeah,' he said.
'Congratulations,' Carnelos said.
At that, Howden began to cry.
'I'm sorry, I'm sorry,' he said, composing himself after Carroccia asked him if he needed a moment.
Advertisement
The exchange underscored a second day of testimony from Howden. In his first appearance on the stand Wednesday, he repeatedly said he couldn't recall details about the alleged incident, prompting Crown attorney Meaghan Cunningham to accuse him of being dishonest about his lack of memory. Howden continued to insist he didn't remember specifics even when given access to transcripts from past statements he made to Hockey Canada investigators and police.
During a voir dire hearing on Wednesday over a Canada Evidence Act application by the Crown seeking to cross-examine Howden, prosecutors and the defense argued over Howden's truthfulness on the stand.
After a day of deliberations, Carroccia found that she didn't believe Howden was feigning memory loss, but agreed that there were elements of his testimony that were inconsistent with his past statements. Carroccia ruled that four areas out of the 18 Cunningham presented could be further questioned.
During arguments on Wednesday, Megan Savard — attorney for Carter Hart — said that Howden was an unsophisticated, inarticulate witness who didn't even dress properly for court. Howden appeared in a hoodie during his first day on the stand.
When Howden returned to the stand on Thursday, he wore a white polo shirt and appeared more forthright in his answers. He is the fourth member of the 2018 World Junior team called as a Crown witness. Raddysh, Boris Katchouk and Tyler Steenbergen have already testified.
Howden's former World Junior teammates — Dubé, Michael McLeod, Carter Hart, Alex Formenton and Cal Foote — looked on from the courtroom. They are each accused of sexually assaulting a woman in the early hours of June 19, 2018, after a Hockey Canada gala in London, Ont. All five players pleaded not guilty in the trial, which is now in its fifth week.
Advertisement
The Crown says that McLeod, Hart and Dubé all obtained oral sex from E.M. without her consent, and that Formenton had vaginal sex with E.M. without her consent. The Crown has also told the jury that Dubé slapped E.M.'s naked buttocks while she was engaged in a sexual act with another person, and that Foote did the splits and grazed his genitals over her face as she laid on the ground.
Howden recalled being shocked when he read the contents of his text exchange with Raddysh during a later Hockey Canada investigation. He said he could not recall sending those messages.
But he told Cunningham that he had 'no reason to lie' at the time.
Later, Carnelos pressed Howden about his state of mind and the casual nature of the text messages he exchanged about the incident in 2018. He said it was hard to remember details, but recalled being stressed and scared at the time.
'For so long, I've been trying to move on past this and forget about it,' Howden said. 'I remember the gist of what happened that night, but it's hard for me to go back in that time and remember it.'
Carnelos and other members of the defense argued that the text messages should be dismissed because Howden was not attempting to be accurate when he wrote them and did not expect them to be used as evidence seven years later.
Later, when Cunningham re-examined Howden, she again asked him whether — even if he doesn't recall the events described — he believed he was being truthful when he wrote the text message.
'I believe what I said back then,' he said. 'I was being honest.'
(Photo of Brett Howden of the Vegas Golden Knights by Steph Chambers / Getty Images)

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Canada summer transfer primer: Latest on David, Buchanan, Larin and more
Canada summer transfer primer: Latest on David, Buchanan, Larin and more

New York Times

timean hour ago

  • New York Times

Canada summer transfer primer: Latest on David, Buchanan, Larin and more

TORONTO – This summer is shaping up to be one of the most important in recent memory for the Canadian men's national team. It's about to enter the Gold Cup as one of the tournament favorites. With a near-full strength squad, which sets itself apart from the U.S. men's national team, Canada has one of its best opportunities to win its first trophy since 2000. Doing so would fill this team with confidence ahead of the 2026 World Cup on home soil. Advertisement And for many of Canada's players, the World Cup presents both a challenge and an opportunity this summer. They know Canada head coach Jesse Marsch wants his players logging heavy minutes on their club sides heading into the World Cup. How they approach this upcoming season could be crucial to where they land on the World Cup roster. For the likes of, say, Alphonso Davies and Moïse Bombito, this summer might not be a priority. They know they're in terrific standing with their clubs in top leagues and will use that to propel them towards the World Cup. But for others, this summer represents a potentially pivotal moment to move to a new club – and possibly secure the playing time and the World Cup spot they're after. After a week spent around Canada's men's national team in Halifax and Toronto, here's what we're hearing about the future of a number of key players. This status of this summer's most discussed transfer option – not just in Canada, but across the soccer world – remains the same: David has options across Europe's top leagues vying for his services. As things stand, he's waiting for the right combination to emerge from an interested club: an attractive project (Champions League participation is justifiably high on his list of interests) and a financial package that makes sense. 'I want a club with ambition that wants to do something,' David told The Athletic last week. 'Obviously, I would love to fight for titles, to win titles. A team that's competitive, that has ambition, really, with a good sporting project.' Don't be surprised if David, linked heavily to Napoli and Juventus, stays true to himself and exercises patience throughout the summer. Participation in the Gold Cup feels more and more likely. Koné's high-profile transfer to Ligue 1's Marseille last summer did not unfold as hoped: he made just nine appearances, drew the ire of manager Roberto de Zerbi and was loaned mid-season to Rennes. Advertisement Despite being under contract, Koné is unlikely to return to Marseille, with another loan or permanent transfer on the table. The sticking point could be finding a club that wants to pony up the cash for Marseille after the Ligue 1 side paid in the region of £15 million for Koné last summer. A return to Rennes is still possible, but only if the club is willing to find the kind of money to turn Koné's loan deal into a permanent buy option. Could he be on his way to another new club, his fourth in just over a year? 'In football, there's a lot of changes. So, I'd be OK with that,' he told The Athletic. The experience in France was a humbling and eye-opening one for the prodigious No. 8. From the benefits of private physios to adding extra hours to his training regimen, Koné learned how vast the gap is between newcomers and those who compete regularly in Europe's top leagues. For his part, Koné seems to have a better understanding of how to be successful in Europe. He told The Athletic that in his next club, he wants 'an environment where I can showcase my skills, my talent and I could just grow and learn, because that's what I want to do: grow and progress and be the best player I can be. You're never going find an organization that's going guarantee (playing time), that just comes with work. For me it's the most important is to find an environment where I could be myself and learn and grow.' Whenever a forward bursts onto the scene by averaging a goal every 126 minutes en route to winning the Belgian Pro League, there's going to be questions about that player's future. Despite interest from clubs in France and England, though, the safe bet is for Promise David to stay in Belgium next season. He still has plenty to learn about the training demands of a European club. David will play more regularly next season as well, including in the Champions League. Advertisement The honesty David shared with The Athletic about a possible move should should speak for itself: 'I've never been in a position where I have options to move,' David said. 'People were telling me in January, a bunch of options started popping up. People were like, 'Are you going to take off?' And I was like, 'The grass is f—ing green here.' You can go somewhere else and maybe the grass isn't as green as you thought. I mean technically you can say, 'Yeah, I did conquer Belgium.' And I didn't play a full season but then – I didn't even play a whole season. So maybe I should sit there and soak up as much training as possible. If my team decides to sell me, because they damn well can, I'm ready to go, but I'm happy with where I'm at. I'm not pressuring myself to go for it. If there's a better option that suits both parties, and everybody's happy with that, sure, why not? Pack up my bags and move. But I just extended my lease, it'd be a damn shame.' Expect the up-and-coming central midfielder to make a move this summer to Europe, with Belgium's Anderlecht the frontrunner to sign him. 'If the project is good for me, I would open to (a summer transfer), because I think for my future I would love to be able to get to play in Europe and experience that,' Saliba said. Canada's coaches have come to adore how well Saliba owns the space in the middle of the park with his ball-winning ability, dribbling and size. They see what others around MLS have seen, as Saliba has stepped into a more regular starting position. Saliba needs to be pushed at a higher level to have a chance of winning starts at the World Cup, though. Of the many positive takeaways from Canada's 4-2 friendly win over Ukraine, Buchanan's resurgence has to be at the top. Canada's best player at the 2022 World Cup has fallen on trying times: a move to Inter Milan didn't lead to consistent minutes, and a horrific injury at Copa América cut into his playing time and development. He only looked to be finding his footing toward the end of a mid-season loan to La Liga's Villarreal. But Buchanan's goal and two assists on Saturday had him turning a corner. 'I feel like my old self,' Buchanan said postgame. Advertisement Canada's coaches like how Buchanan played in more of a right midfield role with Villarreal as opposed to the right wingback role he occupied with Inter Milan. They want him to occupy more central areas of the pitch and be more connected to the team's forwards. That way, Canada believes he can be more effective in transition. So what does that mean for Buchanan's immediate club future? It's worth wondering if the positional versatility he'll gain from a strong Gold Cup this summer could make him more valuable to Inter. Could newly-appointed Inter manager Cristian Chivu sense Buchanan's versatility and try him in different positions as opposed to right wingback to make him fit? Chivu's recent history working with and developing younger players in Italy could help Buchanan's case in Milan. 'When the time comes at the end of the season, I guess that's when I'll reflect,' Buchanan told The Athletic in March of his club future. That time is now, and it certainly feels like the hyper-determined Buchanan could return to Inter to fight for his place next season. After a remarkable second start for Canada in which De Fougerolles commanded play in the back against Ukraine, things could soon turn at the club level for the uber-intelligent teenager. De Fougerolles is out of contract with Fulham come July 1. It's believed Fulham has expressed genuine interest in re-signing him. But is a return to Fulham – and possibly the Under-21 side – the best path for a player who looks more than ready for regular first-team minutes? That's the priority for De Fougerolles right now: Getting into a senior environment ahead of the World Cup. 'I need first-team football,' De Fougerolles said declaratively. 'I'd like a loan. I think I can obviously push for it to play first-team minutes. Obviously if Fulham want me around, I'll gladly stay and be around the team. But a loan would be amazing. So just to play 40 professional games a season, I feel like that's part of the game that maybe I'm missing. With the Under-21s, it's less competitive. So if I were to go to a League One or a Championship team, I think every game would be competitive and that would give me something that I haven't had much of, and I think that experience would really put me in a good space.' Advertisement While De Fougerolles mentioned two English leagues, don't be surprised if he considers top-tier options outside of Europe's biggest leagues. A move to a team that develops young players is starting to feel more likely, with options in Belgium, the Netherlands or Austria as possibilities. After becoming a frequent starter in a variety of positions for Hajduk Split at just 21, it sounds like Sigur and his camp are pushing more than ever for opportunities outside of Croatia. A team in the Netherlands or Belgium that plays in European competitions makes sense. Increasing his understanding of how different European teams play ahead of the World Cup is a priority. 'Honestly, I think it's more down to what the club wants,' Sigur said of a possible move. 'I have a contract (through) 2028, so there's been a little bit of communication, but I think it was clear that when I come back from the Gold Cup, we're going to come to a decision. And obviously there needs to be concrete offers and offers that make sense for me to go. Obviously, with World Cup coming up, I want to be playing. And I've been in Hajduk three years now. So I know I am well respected there. I'm going to be one of the more senior players, if that's even possible. I'm only 21, but a lot of guys are going to move on, and it's a really young team.' After a strong first half to the season in La Liga, the longtime Canadian forward cooled. Larin scored just two goals in his final 16 La Liga appearances this season. Despite having a contract until 2028, Larin sounds ready for a different opportunity. 'I would love to stay in Spain and play at the top level. I've done well there. I played well with Valladolid. It's just about finding a team that fits my style. When I played with Valladolid (on loan in 2023), we created chances. When I get chances, I can score. But when you don't get chances, it's harder to score,' Larin told The Athletic. As things stand, Larin's spot as a starter at the 2026 World Cup doesn't feel assured. He knows from experience that he needs regular playing time to be at his most effective. 'Leading up to (the 2022 World Cup), I wasn't playing so much. It was very difficult. I had to put in more work to play and my fitness wasn't there. I played a big role when I played in the World Cup 2022 in Qatar, but I could feel my fitness a little bit,' he said. Advertisement While Larin wants to stay in Spain, would he consider a mid-season move to MLS? The Brampton-born striker, who starred at Orlando City before bolting for Europe, might not be at that stage just yet, but he would consider it. 'If the option was there and the time was right, I would have to evaluate it,' he said. Oluwaseyi is in the middle of his best professional season: he has eight goals in just 16 MLS appearances. Marsch and the Canada coaching staff remain high on Oluwaseyi and his ability to execute their pressing demands while still creating opportunities. Others are seeing Oluwaseyi elevate his play, too: it's believed there are clubs in France, Belgium and the English Championship currently monitoring him. Still, the probability of a move this summer feels low, at least for now. 'There's enough to think about at Minnesota. There's a lot to do at Minnesota, so I think my focus is just there for the most part,' Oluwaseyi said. Oluwaseyi is instead a candidate to turn a few memorable performances at the World Cup into a move in 2026. 'I'd be lying if I said as a player I didn't want to challenge myself,' Oluwaseyi said. 'I feel like Minnesota or MLS has been a pretty good challenge. And another challenge comes along that, that is the right one for me, and I'll definitely be up for it.' The emerging defender is under contract with Bristol City until 2027. After spending last season on loan with Crewe Alexandra in England's fourth tier, Knight-Lebel will not look for another loan this summer. Expect him to push for a regular spot with Bristol City and try to play as many Championship games as possible. Knight-Lebel's inclusion in every Canada squad since October suggests he's in the mix for a World Cup spot. Not just fighting for, but getting games at Bristol City could fortify that spot.

Judge in Hockey Canada sexual assault trial sets verdict date for July 24
Judge in Hockey Canada sexual assault trial sets verdict date for July 24

New York Times

timean hour ago

  • New York Times

Judge in Hockey Canada sexual assault trial sets verdict date for July 24

LONDON, Ont. – Justice Maria Carroccia set July 24 as the decision date in the Hockey Canada sexual assault trial. During Tuesday's proceedings, in which the defense continued closing arguments, Carroccia said verdicts would be delivered in person on that date. Michael McLeod, Carter Hart, Alex Formenton, Dillon Dubé and Cal Foote are all charged with sexual assault after an alleged incident in June 2018. The complainant — a woman known as E.M., whose identity is protected by a publication ban — has said she was sexually assaulted over the span of several hours in a London, Ont., hotel room. The players were in town for a Hockey Canada event celebrating their gold medal at the 2018 World Junior Championship. Advertisement McLeod is also facing a second charge for 'being a party to the offense' for what the Crown has asserted was his role 'assisting and encouraging his teammates to engage sexually' with E.M. All five players have pleaded not guilty at the commencement of the trial, which is in its eighth and final week. — The Athletic's Kamila Hinkson contributed reporting remotely from Montreal. (Photo by Andy Devlin / Getty Images)

Property owner fined $60,000 for destroying vital fish habitat on Vancouver Island, B.C.
Property owner fined $60,000 for destroying vital fish habitat on Vancouver Island, B.C.

Yahoo

timean hour ago

  • Yahoo

Property owner fined $60,000 for destroying vital fish habitat on Vancouver Island, B.C.

COURTENAY, BC, June 10, 2025 /CNW/ - Protecting fish and fish habit is vital to help sustain and support Canada's precious marine species. Under Canada's Fisheries Act, measures must be taken to avoid causing the death of fish and any harmful alteration, disruption or destruction of fish habitat when conducting any work or activities in or near water. On January 23, 2025, in Courtenay Provincial Court, area resident David Tingley was found guilty of failing to correct work that he had done illegally on his property, that affected fish and fish habitat on the Trent River. Mr. Tingley was fined $60,000, which was directed to the Environmental Damages Fund for the conservation and protection of salmon and salmon habitat in the Vancouver Island region. The case stems from work carried out without Fisheries Act authorization over successive years on one of Mr. Tingley's properties, which is bisected by the Trent River, an important fish bearing watercourse. DFO protects and conserves marine resources, and enforces the Fisheries Act. As part of DFO's work to disrupt and prevent illegal activity, the Department asks the public for information on activities of this nature or any contravention of the Fisheries Act and regulations. Anyone with information can call DFO Pacific Region's toll-free violation reporting line at 1-800-465-4336, or email the details to Quick Facts: Mr. Tingley made habitat alterations to the riverbank without appropriate authorizations. On May 15, 2020, Mr. Tingley was ordered to remediate the damage to the riverbank on his property by June 15 2020. Failure to comply with the order resulted in charges of failing to follow the direction of a fishery officer. Fishery officers work closely with biologists from DFO's Fish and Fish Habitat Protection Program to ensure any work undertaken near water complies with the fish and fish habitat protection provisions of the Fisheries Act. There are serious consequences for non-compliance with the fish and fish habitat protection provisions of the Fisheries Act - Fish and fish habitat protection policy statement, August 2019 ( Associated Link: Projects near water ( Stay Connected Follow Fisheries and Oceans Canada on X, Facebook, Instagram and YouTube. Follow the Canadian Coast Guard on X, Facebook, Instagram and YouTube. SOURCE Fisheries and Oceans Canada, Pacific Region View original content to download multimedia:

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store