logo
The Guardian view on Israel's aid blockade of Gaza: hunger as a weapon of war

The Guardian view on Israel's aid blockade of Gaza: hunger as a weapon of war

Business Mayor05-05-2025

S hameful. That was the word that Gideon Sa'ar, Israel's foreign minister, used to describe proceedings at the international court of justice (ICJ) last Monday. The United Nations asked the court to determine whether Israel must allow aid to enter Gaza, two months after it cut it off again just before the ceasefire deal collapsed. Supplies are running out. Unicef says that thousands of children have already experienced acute malnutrition.
Mr Sa'ar's complaint is that Israel is unfairly targeted. The separate international criminal court case against Benjamin Netanyahu, the prime minister, and Yoav Gallant, the former defence minister, also focuses on the alleged starvation of civilians. It is true that withholding food is a common weapon in war, yet has rarely been the focus of international legal cases, in part because intent is hard to prove. It is the rhetoric of Israeli officials, suggests Dr Boyd van Dijk, an expert on the Geneva conventions, which has changed that.
Last summer, Bezalel Smotrich, the far-right finance minister, remarked that it might be 'justified and moral' to starve people if it brought home Israeli hostages seized in the Hamas atrocities of 7 October 2023, but that 'no one in the world will allow us'. Israel's defence minister, Israel Katz, said last month that its 'policy is clear: no humanitarian aid will enter Gaza'. The far-right national security minister, Itamar Ben-Gvir, insisted that 'there is no reason for a single gram of food or any aid to enter' until hostages were freed. An aid ship destined for Gaza was attacked by drones and disabled on Friday. More than 52,000 people, mostly civilians, have been killed in Gaza since the war began, according to its health authorities. Unicef says they include 15,000 children, with hundreds of deaths since the new Israeli offensive began in March. But withholding food kills just as bombs do. Farmland is devastated. Flour is said to cost 30 times more than before the war. Aid warehouses are empty. UN World Food Programme bakeries closed a month ago when supplies ran out; essential community kitchens are now following.
Israeli officials have said they need to stop Hamas getting their hands on aid. It's obvious that men with guns will secure food long after others have starved. Donald Trump says that he has told Mr Netanyahu to allow aid in. Yet the US told the ICJ that Israel's security needs override its obligation to do so. The strong legal consensus is that occupying powers have an absolute duty under the Geneva conventions to permit food to be given to a population in need.
Israel is reportedly planning to resume aid delivery 'in the coming weeks', but via a radically new mechanism. It claims the UN agency for Palestinian refugees, essential to humanitarian efforts, has been mass-infiltrated by Hamas – an allegation strongly disputed by the UN and others. The proposed alternative, of international organisations and private security contractors handing out food to individual families, looks both unworkable and dangerous for civilians.
As Israel and the US attack international courts, other nations – including the UK – must do all they can to defend and bolster them. They must also press harder for the immediate resumption of aid. What is shameful about this ICJ case is the need to bring it. What is shameful is that almost half the children in Gaza questioned in a study said that they wished to die. What is shameful is that so many civilians have been killed, and so many more pushed to the brink of starvation. What is shameful is that this has, indeed, been allowed to happen.
Read More Credit hire boom powers firm's 62% profit surge

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Netanyahu Under Pressure as Ultra-Orthodox Parties Threaten to Dissolve Parliament
Netanyahu Under Pressure as Ultra-Orthodox Parties Threaten to Dissolve Parliament

New York Times

time22 minutes ago

  • New York Times

Netanyahu Under Pressure as Ultra-Orthodox Parties Threaten to Dissolve Parliament

Israel's opposition parties said they would bring a motion to dissolve Parliament to a vote on Wednesday, presenting the most serious challenge yet to Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's right-wing government and raising the specter of early elections. If the motion passes, it is unlikely that the government will fall immediately. The parliamentary process before any final vote could take months, giving the prime minister time to shore up his increasingly fractious governing coalition or set his own agenda for a return to the ballot box. But it would deal a heavy blow to his political credibility. The opposition parties are exploiting a crisis within the governing coalition over the contentious, decades-old policy that exempts ultra-Orthodox men who are studying religion in seminaries from compulsory military service. Mr. Netanyahu's ultra-Orthodox coalition partners, the United Torah Judaism and Shas parties, have been locked in dispute with other members of the government over proposals to limit exemptions. The issue has taken on more urgency, and spurred growing public anger and scrutiny, since the Hamas-led attack on Oct. 7, 2023, ignited Israel's war in Gaza. United Torah Judaism has threatened to vote with the opposition, saying that it cannot accept the principle of drafting seminary students. If Shas also votes with the opposition, it could provide the majority needed to dissolve Parliament. Mr. Netanyahu's coalition commands a majority of 68 seats in the 120-seat Knesset. Shas and United Torah Judaism hold 18 seats between them, giving them strong leverage. The split inside the coalition has given the main opposition parties a political opportunity to challenge the government. While they support the move to enlist ultra-Orthodox religious students, they say their priority is to bring down Mr. Netanyahu's government and force new elections. The government, which was formed in late 2022, is the most right-wing and religiously conservative in Israel's history. The next election would take place in October 2026 if it were to reach full term. If the motion is passed on Wednesday, the bill would need to go to a parliamentary committee for review before returning to the assembly for further votes, and Mr. Netanyahu and his political allies could stall that process for months. But analysts say that even preliminary approval to dissolve Parliament could further destabilize his government. 'The whole system would go into a different mode — election mode,' said Aviv Bushinsky, a political analyst and a former media adviser to Mr. Netanyahu. Losing a vote would indicate a lack of leadership on Mr. Netanyahu's part, he added, and an inability to control his coalition. Gabby Sobelman contributed reporting from Rehovot, Israel.

US House speaker Johnson will travel to Israel June 22
US House speaker Johnson will travel to Israel June 22

Yahoo

time36 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

US House speaker Johnson will travel to Israel June 22

(Reuters) -U.S. House Speaker Mike Johnson will travel to Israel to address the parliament on June 22, he said on Wednesday. "Our ties run deeper than military partnerships and trade agreements," Johnson said in an emailed statement. Punchbowl News, which first reported Johnson's plan, said the House Speaker was expected to meet Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu in Jerusalem during the trip. Johnson did not provide further details on the planned trip. Johnson announced the visit as Israel presses on with its military campaign in the Gaza Strip, more than 20 months after it launched its offensive there in response to a deadly incursion into Israel led by Palestinian militant group Hamas. On Tuesday, Australia, Britain, Canada, New Zealand and Norway imposed sanctions on far-right Israeli cabinet ministers Itamar Ben-Gvir and Bezalel Smotrich, accusing them of repeatedly inciting violence against Palestinians in the West Bank. Israel called the action "outrageous" and said the Israeli government would hold a meeting early next week to decide how to respond.

Best of The Babylon Bee: Hamas agrees to surrender if Europe takes back Greta Thunberg
Best of The Babylon Bee: Hamas agrees to surrender if Europe takes back Greta Thunberg

New York Post

timean hour ago

  • New York Post

Best of The Babylon Bee: Hamas agrees to surrender if Europe takes back Greta Thunberg

Every week, The Post will bring you our picks of the best one-liners and stories from satirical site the Babylon Bee to take the edge off Hump Day. Want more of a chuckle? Be sure to click the links. Advertisement Thunberg was known to be en route to Gaza by boat, leaving Hamas leaders scrambling to stave off her arrival. READ MORE Advertisement The rowdy group was filmed torching cop cars, looting stores, and waving Mexican flags, providing some 'killer' footage for the 2028 race. READ MORE After the dustup in which the two exchanged numerous insults towards each other on social media, Trump found himself missing Musk. READ MORE Advertisement Bass stated her leaving was completely involuntary, reporting that she simply saw her city burning and, next thing she knew, she was on a plane to Antigua. READ MORE

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store