Board of trade wants to tackle Toronto's congestion crisis with these 5 solutions
More than five kilometres of the Gardiner Expressway suffer from severe congestion that doubles travel times in Toronto during rush hour periods.
The highway is one of a dozen major downtown corridors facing at least a kilometre's worth of congestion that's bad enough to make a trip take one and a half to two times longer at peak times, according to a travel time analysis commissioned by the Toronto Region Board of Trade.
The new traffic data, billed as the most comprehensive portrait to date of the city's gridlock, serves as the backbone to the board's congestion action plan, which it released this morning.
For more than a year, the board's task force has been digging into the problem of congestion, which it considers a top regional and economic challenge that could be costing the Greater Toronto and Hamilton Area (GTHA) $44.7 billion a year in economic and social value.
"Despite years of conversation and well-intended short-term fixes, we remain gridlocked," Giles Gherson, the board's president, said in a statement.
"In the face of unprecedented economic uncertainty, it is more important than ever to tackle a crisis that is holding us back."
Today's report both quantifies parts of the problem — like travel time and the cost of lane closures — and offers five areas of action the task force argues can help alleviate congestion.
CBC Toronto explored many of the potential solutions highlighted by the task force in a three-part series, Gridlocked: The Way Out, last month.
Here's a look at the five key areas of action the task force is suggesting for Toronto.
1. Reduce lane closures
This year, roughly 10 per cent of all Toronto streets, or 550 kilometres of roadway, will be occupied by construction work zones at some point, according to the report.
Given existing demands on the road, the task force argues there needs to be a higher bar for lane closures and the city needs to actively manage how long they last.
The board hired infrastructure consultant Steer to assess the cost of lane closures in the city. Toronto charges a maximum of $37,000 per month to close a lane of traffic for construction, and determines the price based on lost revenue from nearby parking meters, according to the report.
But the report argues that pricing scheme grossly underestimates the actual cost. Steer's analysis found the social and economic costs (like increased travel times, vehicle operating costs and pollution from congestion) of closing a major arterial lane amount to $1.7 million per month.
Those social and economic costs should be part of the decision making process for granting lane closures, the report argues. And closures with the greatest impact should have limits — like not allowing closures on major arterial roads during peak travel hours.
Other major cities like Singapore, Sydney and Chicago don't allow lane closures on major streets during peak hours, and New York doesn't allow lane closures on major streets during the day.
"By implementing dynamic pricing for closures and encouraging off-peak construction, we can strike a better balance between necessary construction and the flow of traffic," said Alex Avery, CEO of Primaris REIT and a member of the task force's governing council.
As CBC Toronto previously reported, the city is working to improve its construction management. Council passed a congestion management plan last fall that includes a levy for builders who block lanes of traffic for construction. The fee would increase based on the size and duration of the closure.
The action report also supports 24/7 construction where possible, as was adopted to accelerate the timeline for construction on the Gardiner.
2. Enforce the rules of the road
The next piece of the puzzle for the task force is enforcement to correct driver behaviour.
Police officers and traffic agents can't be everywhere. So the report suggests adopting automated enforcement, with cameras catching drivers blocking intersections, double-parking and stopping in bike lanes and at bus stops.
WATCH | CBC Toronto gets demo of automated enforcement in Seattle:
Why Toronto is looking to Seattle to help solve gridlock
24 days ago
Duration 10:38
On a quest to figure out how to fix traffic, CBC Toronto travels to Seattle to get a behind-the-scenes look at how cameras seem to be deterring drivers from blocking intersections and driving in bus lanes.
CBC Toronto got a first-hand look at what that kind of enforcement looks like in Seattle, where they use it for blocking intersections and bus lanes — and it appears to be changing driver behaviour.
Toronto is working on an automated enforcement pilot but it isn't likely to start issuing tickets for blocking the box until sometime in 2026 at the earliest, and aspects of the program still require provincial approval.
3. Unclog the arteries
The task force commissioned an in-depth analysis of traffic in the downtown core from Parsons engineering firm.
It found that most of the worst-congested corridors downtown are east-west arterials like the Gardiner, Bloor Street and Lakeshore Boulevard, which "no longer serve their purpose to keep traffic flowing."
Overall, the analysis identified a dozen corridors where travel times during peak periods took at least one and a half times longer (than in free flowing traffic) across at least a kilometre of the roadway.
The report suggests identifying "major connector roads" to plan which ones will absorb traffic when another connector road is disrupted, and moving bike lanes off of those roads to keep traffic moving.
It also recommends incentivizing off-peak deliveries. One way to do that, it says, would be to reduce permit fees for night or early morning operations for businesses that receive those deliveries.
4. Clear the bottlenecks
The action plan also identifies specific problem areas for traffic flow in the city that it says could be fixed by re-engineering the road design.
Those changes include restricting turning movements on Harbour and York Streets to prevent weaving between lane conflicts and restricting lane changes on the Gardiner between York Street and Spadina Avenue for the same reason.
The task force also supports implementing traffic signals for Gardiner on-ramps at York and Spadina as a pilot project to maintain traffic flow by controlling the pace of vehicles merging onto the highway.
WATCH | The difference between a smart highway and existing highways:
How using AI on highway ramps could keep traffic moving
23 days ago
Duration 0:57
Baher Abdulhai, an engineering professor at the University of Toronto, demonstrates the difference between a smart highway and existing highways using funnels to represent the highways and rice kernels to represent cars.
Last month, the city's director of traffic management, Roger Browne, told CBC Toronto it doesn't have any plans to implement traffic signals on on-ramps because there isn't much space for queuing vehicles off highways.
He also said it might not be within Toronto's control, given the city uploaded oversight of the Gardiner Expressway and Don Valley Parkway to the province in 2023.
5. Implement accountability mechanisms
The report advocates for a new reporting structure at the city when it comes to congestion, which would include a cross-departmental czar who would review all city business through a congestion lens.
But the action plan argues fixing congestion can't all be up to Toronto. It impacts the entire GTHA, and so there needs to be regional coordination to fix things. The solution for that, the report says, is creating an intergovernmental table for congestion management, chaired by the province.
The task force hopes the city and provincial governments act on those five action areas immediately.
But in the future, the report emphasized the need for increasing transit ridership, building even more rapid transit lines than those already planned and expanding water-based transportation.
Finally, the report advocated taking a look at ways to implement targeted congestion pricing once more transit alternatives, like the Ontario Line, are operational. That's a strategy that has been deeply unpopular in Ontario despite helping ease traffic in other major cities.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Winnipeg Free Press
20-05-2025
- Winnipeg Free Press
As regulators abandon ‘bare minimum' corporate climate reporting, a backstop lurks
TORONTO – In the future, seeing the carbon emissions of a company may not be much harder than finding out how many calories are in a chocolate bar, but that day looks further out than it did just a few months ago. Last year saw big steps toward better corporate climate transparency: a U.S. regulator required it, the Trudeau government committed to follow through on more, and a Canadian task force released guidelines on what those disclosures should look like. But the election of U.S. President Donald Trump has changed all that. Since Trump's return to the White House, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission effectively dropped its requirement on disclosures in late March, which led the Canadian Securities Administrators (CSA) to ditch its own plans a few weeks later. The moves come despite the rising impacts of climate change, making it all the more important that companies are mandated to release emissions data, as well as to say what risks they face from the crisis and how they plan to deal with them, said Pamela Steer, head of CPA Canada. 'The world is burning up in many cases,' she said. 'It's become more acute, more urgent than ever.' The CSA's decision not to require disclosures is 'incredibly disappointing,' she said, especially as dozens of other countries including Australia, the European Union, and even fellow United States-neighbour Mexico move forward with the requirement. Growing expectations for the information will make it harder for companies to raise money internationally without the rules, especially as Canada looks to diversify away from the U.S., said Steer. As it stands, companies have been reporting a hodgepodge of data and analysis, and some not at all, making it hard for investors to make informed decisions, she said. 'There are many risks and opportunities that need to be disclosed, and investors are demanding the information, and I think companies are demanding a level playing field.' Many companies are, however, also being less public about climate generally given the Trump administration's hostility to efforts, such as Canada's big banks all leaving the Net-Zero Banking Alliance. Rising economic concerns have also put pressure on companies to cut back where they can. Recent anti-greenwashing rules from the Competition Bureau have added to the pressure, making it all the more important to have clear standards in place, said Steer. The rules, which require companies to be able to back up environmental claims or face potentially severe penalties, has led many to say even less about climate change. Steer said it is important to hold companies to account on what they say, but that companies need a bit of grace as whole new reporting standards are established. 'Having safe harbour, having a more pragmatic commentary and guidelines is actually what is needed.' The Canadian Sustainability Standards Board was created specifically to adapt international standards to the Canadian context, and it put out guidance in December that included several years of added time for companies to report on some measures. Ten of Canada's biggest public pension funds, representing more than $2.2 trillion in assets under management, voiced their support for the proposed guidance. 'Alignment with a global baseline is important for the competitiveness of Canadian companies in global capital markets,' the public pension group said, though Alberta's pension fund was notably absent despite endorsing the premise less than two years earlier. Provincial securities regulators were expected to take those guidelines and make them mandatory, but instead, the CSA announced on April 23 that it had indefinitely paused the work. CSA chair Stan Magidson, who is also CEO of the Alberta Securities Commission, said in a release that the regulator was focusing on making Canadian markets more competitive, efficient, and resilient. Work on climate disclosure would be revisited in 'future years,' the CSA said. But as the pension funds noted, disclosure efforts are part of staying competitive, said Wendy Berman, chair of the CSSB. 'There is going to be a lot of capital movement over the next 10 years as we transition to a low-carbon economy, and we certainly don't want Canada to miss that opportunity,' she said. 'What we're starting to see is a huge global shift,' said Berman. 'Would it be better if the U.S. was lockstep with the rest of the world? Of course. But that should not hold back Canadian companies.' Both Canada and the U.S. have moved backwards on disclosure, even though the rules were the 'bare minimum' to help investors, said Gary Gensler, then chair of the U.S. SEC when he passed them last year. In ending the requirements, current acting chair Mark Uyeda called them 'costly and unnecessarily intrusive climate change disclosure rules.' With both the U.S. and Canadian regulators abandoning efforts, it's unclear how well Prime Minister Mark Carney can make good on his campaign promise to establish 'broad climate risk disclosure for companies across Canada,' or to follow through on Trudeau's promise to mandate disclosures for large, federally incorporated private companies. The Finance Department said that with Cabinet only sworn in last week, the government will have more to say in due course. But even as high-profile debates rage on about broader disclosures, rules established in 2023 by Canada's banking regulator help provide a backstop. Winnipeg Jets Game Days On Winnipeg Jets game days, hockey writers Mike McIntyre and Ken Wiebe send news, notes and quotes from the morning skate, as well as injury updates and lineup decisions. Arrives a few hours prior to puck drop. The rules that kicked in this year from the Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions broadly align with what the Canadian Sustainability Standards Board had called for — requiring banks to report how their finances might be affected by climate change, as well as their own emissions contributions. Given their scale, and involvement in so many other companies, the reporting requirements should help put pressure and clear the way for others to follow, said Berman. 'When OSFI endorses it, and the banks must now comply with it going forward, that starts to create momentum,' she said. That momentum could help make climate disclosures an established part of assessing the health of a company, just as food labelling rules a few decades ago have since made it hard to imagine a chocolate bar not listing the calories, fat and other key details to know to stay healthy. This report by The Canadian Press was first published May 20, 2025.
CBC
19-04-2025
- CBC
Vegemite can stay on Ontario cafe chain's shelves for now, Canadian food regulators say
Social Sharing An Ontario café chain has scored a win in its fight with Canadian food regulators to keep selling Vegemite at its stores. Earlier this year, the Canadian Food Inspection Agency (CFIA) told Leighton Walters, an Australian-Canadian dual citizen who owns the Found Coffee chain located in Toronto and Guelph, that the batch of Vegemite he'd imported to sell at his stores was non-compliant with Health Canada regulations. That put roughly $8,000 worth of Vegemite, which Walters has already paid for, in jeopardy. But in an email to CBC News sent late Friday, the federal agency says a health risk assessment from Health Canada has since determined that the level of risk to human health from the added vitamins in Vegemite is low when consumed in suggested serving sizes. "As such, the CFIA will work with the importer to allow the product to be sold in the short-term, including revised labeling, while we collaborate with Health Canada, the manufacturer, and the importer, to find a longer-term plan for Vegemite sales across Canada." Ordered to take Vegemite off shelves Walters had been importing jars of the Australian staple for five years to offer at his Australian-inspired cafes. "It's an iconic Australian product ... we've been so proud to serve it to thousands and tens of thousands of Australians, Canadians, travelers and tourists," he told CBC Toronto last week. WATCH | Toronto café owner fights to keep Vegemite on his shelves: Australian owner of Toronto café chain fighting Ottawa to save $8K of Vegemite 5 days ago Duration 2:13 But he recently stopped selling the product after Canadian regulators flagged his latest shipment of Vegemite from Australia because the spread is enriched with Vitamin B, which is only permitted in certain products in Canada. Walters also told CBC Toronto that CFIA has also ordered him to destroy the Vegemite he removed from his shelves, but an agency spokesperson denied that in an email, saying Walter was only ordered to remove it from his shelves. After going public with his story last week, and contacting the Australian Trade and Investment Commission for help, he gained the support of Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese. In a post to X Friday, Albanese said his government had discussed the issue with Canadian officials and thanked them for allowing Walters to have Vegemite back on the menu. "This is a win for Australian industry, but it's also a win for those people in Canada who get to enjoy this wonderful product that is so much a part of Australian culture and indeed, Australian pride as well," he said.
CBC
16-04-2025
- CBC
As Toronto enters a new era of ferries, council hopes oversight shift leads to smooth sailing
Social Sharing As the Toronto carries out a complex and costly plan to welcome a new electric ferry next year with another to follow in 2027, oversight of the popular summer amenity is moving to a new department. At the city's last council meeting in March, councillors voted to take the service away from the parks department and give it to its fleet services division. The move stems from an operational review the city and a consultancy conducted beginning in the fall, after a summer of frustration and long lines on the waterfront. Coun. Paula Fletcher is welcoming the change — especially after she said the parks department initially "forgot" to figure out where the new electric ferries would be parked and charged, leaving staff scrambling to prepare for the new vessels. The city decided to go electric in 2019, but an estimated cost on charging and docking infrastructure wasn't brought forward until 2024. "It's a marine fleet. It really doesn't have a lot to do with parks," Fletcher told CBC Toronto in an interview. "So it's moved out from folks that forgot [the ferries] needed to be plugged in, to people that do that every day. And I think it will be in good hands." The shift in responsibility comes as the city works its way through a costly plan to replace its aging ferries, which allow an average 1.4 million annual visitors enjoy the city's island. WATCH | Long ferry lines frustrated many in the city last summer: Torontonians frustrated at long lines for island ferry 9 months ago Duration 2:54 There are renewed calls for the city to work toward building a bridge to the Toronto Islands following a weekend of long lines at the ferry terminal. As CBC's Britnei Bilhete reports, some Torontonias said wait times were up to an hour and a half. The city's current fleet of boats is beyond the average industry lifespan. A staff report from March says the first ferry should arrive in late 2026 and the second in mid-2027. It does not say when they're expected to be operational. The ferries will be constructed at Damen Shipyards Galati in Romania. The motion to transfer oversight of the ferries received a yes vote from 22 councillors. Councillors Mike Colle and Anthony Perruzza voted against it, while Jennifer McKelvie and Michael Thompson were absent. Fleet services will take over the ferries by the fall. The report recommending the move says it makes sense because the department "is strategically oriented towards enhancing the reliability, efficiency and sustainability of the city's entire fleet." Cost of new ferries has jumped from $25M to $92M The change in authority comes after after councillors learned last summer that the price of electric ferries is significantly more expensive than anticipated. During the March council meeting, Coun. Stephen Holyday was critical of that rising cost. "It's frustrating because it's gone from buying a new vessel, which I think most people understood needed to be replaced, to getting a really fancy one and tens and tens of millions of dollars later," Holyday said. In July, councillors on the general government committee heard the price of the two ferries had gone from $25 million in 2020 to $92 million, due to design changes. City staff have said the savings of going electric will cover the cost of the vessels within two decades. On top of that cost, comes the work needed to prepare the docking infrastructure for ferries that need to be plugged in. In September, a staff report said the shoreside infrastructure project to include charging would cost about $42 million. But a more recent report pegs it at about $50.2 million. The required infrastructure changes include the installation of charging towers in two locations, electric houses to store battery energy and electrical equipment, modified docks and locking systems, plus new in-water stabilization.
